69 million page views
Home Articles Blog Reviews Spoken Books Other Languages Biographical Middle East Forum About this site Mailing List

read

Reader comment on item: Conversions in Israel
in response to reader comment: Is leaving islam punishable by death in the koran or other Muslim books?

Submitted by sara (Australia), Sep 26, 2007 at 01:34

i can not answer that question as i have not read the quran, but i have heard that punishment is left best from god.

Dislike
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (184) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
85converted to hinduism. [128 words]rahul.Jan 5, 2012 11:07192314
29congrats on your right decision [20 words]pujaJan 12, 2012 10:09192314
16example of miracle of hinduism [33 words]aakashMar 8, 2012 10:47192314
9bold [61 words]komalApr 25, 2012 01:54192314
4congratulations on this right dission [5 words]jawaharAug 25, 2012 15:44192314
3Respect every religion [98 words]HareemDec 11, 2012 09:36192314
3Congrats to embrace hindusim [18 words]crispyMar 7, 2013 23:57192314
7Rahul retrns to Hinduism. [78 words]ProloyApr 2, 2013 07:15192314
1Welcome to the open sky of vedic sanatan dharm and true freedom to worship God. [116 words]krishna kumar tiwariApr 18, 2013 04:16192314
4Your Change to Hinduism [58 words]A Proud HinduSep 25, 2013 10:26192314
welcome [7 words]kallyanSep 27, 2013 01:23192314
yahoo [11 words]pujonOct 9, 2013 01:23192314
5A respectful reply to Hareem Saheb [1060 words]gtmOct 21, 2013 18:34192314
1wow [8 words]dhirajMar 6, 2014 11:36192314
2Great Escape [31 words]BrownJun 26, 2014 02:19192314
1Respect for other Religion [64 words]BrownJun 26, 2014 02:29192314
1Hnd Dripped in Blood [192 words]NaliniJun 26, 2014 04:18192314
Welcome [4 words]AmatyaAug 9, 2014 16:24192314
42Hindus gave peace and prosperity for Muslim [426 words]Islamic AhimsaSep 11, 2011 00:51189249
1The problem with beliefs today [180 words]RamanhoodSep 3, 2010 04:28177620
2respect all religions [131 words]peaceDec 12, 2009 16:21165743
2respect all religions [41 words]SteadyfriendDec 29, 2009 14:42165743
23Nobody can convert you to Hinduism [238 words]Martin LutherNov 21, 2007 01:45114196
Good article [5 words]DipankarSep 26, 2008 06:19114196
1conversion [238 words]sekarApr 20, 2009 05:02114196
2Thats true! [76 words]SANDEEPOct 26, 2009 00:07114196
6response to FRANKLIN MUMBAI [346 words]Rachit PandeyApr 16, 2010 03:06114196
1thats true [20 words]ashishApr 14, 2011 11:45114196
3Great for future of mankind [50 words]VikramMay 6, 2011 08:33114196
1Yes [19 words]debashisSep 11, 2011 11:10114196
Dalit, Christianity and "Caste" [667 words]gtmOct 21, 2013 17:38114196
if more black muslims studied judaism they would see more in common.. [203 words]david pittsSep 30, 2007 01:23109933
2Deport them. [19 words]Anand NairJan 19, 2007 10:5973636
1One possible answer for the difference in conversion rates ... [60 words]SeanJul 21, 2006 17:0050485
Difficulties in converting to Judaism [206 words]Fred SchlomkaJul 25, 2006 08:5850485
What information do you have of Muslims and Jews converting to Christianity? [78 words]William WatsonJul 18, 2006 16:1850079
2Conversions in India [21 words]MahendraJul 17, 2006 07:5249898
to Mahendra on Muslims converting ot Hinduism [33 words]Anubhav SinghJul 24, 2006 02:5549898
1Reverts to Islam [154 words]Chandrajeet PadhyNov 24, 2006 11:1849898
Life of Converts in Israel [59 words]Amir Ali TayyabNov 29, 2006 18:2649898
119i am now Usha Kumari, formerly known as Salma Noor [248 words]Salma NoorJan 21, 2007 08:2349898
8Hinduism [7 words]AmirJan 31, 2007 05:5049898
15Welcome to Hinduism, and wishing you all the very best [249 words]Gopal KamatJan 31, 2007 09:5249898
19You have done the best decision [102 words]s.azizMar 3, 2007 18:4749898
1Don't forget, the origins of your faith [76 words]EfraimMar 9, 2007 03:2249898
6to Salma Noor [123 words]MohamedApr 8, 2007 14:2149898
9Usha Kumari - Have a blissful life!!! [59 words]JaladhiApr 9, 2007 15:1349898
12to mohamed's reply to salma [129 words]doodleMay 4, 2007 19:4649898
3Salma- please refrain from such comments. [11 words]ABHILASH PILLAIMay 21, 2007 06:1949898
12USHA KUMARI IS AN EXAMPLE ONLY [359 words]kishor kumarMay 23, 2007 09:0749898
12HINDUISM [416 words]surferJun 12, 2007 10:5749898
6Thanks Miss Usha Kumari [238 words]rudraJul 16, 2007 09:5049898
4funny [43 words]saraJul 20, 2007 12:4649898
5Please Know Hindu Religion Properly... [357 words]Thanks! A good writing...Jul 21, 2007 20:4349898
Is leaving islam punishable by death in the koran or other Muslim books? [14 words]JosephSep 25, 2007 00:3849898
read [24 words]saraSep 26, 2007 01:3449898
1Yes, muslim apostates from Islam are often killed, beaten, or receive death threats [193 words]saraSep 26, 2007 17:2149898
Is leaving the faith of Islam punishable by death. [101 words]JosephSep 28, 2007 10:4349898
8ISLAM AND LAST PROPHET [198 words]AJAY RATHORENov 12, 2007 04:1749898
8Usha Kumari [123 words]SubrataJan 18, 2008 11:2849898
1to usha [58 words]Scenic1Jan 23, 2008 07:1649898
5Usha [34 words]shreyaJan 30, 2008 22:5049898
3You are loved [178 words]ShaviFeb 19, 2008 15:1749898
3to mohamed [65 words]ayushApr 17, 2008 08:3849898
8Congratulations SISTER! [99 words]Bharat SinhaAug 1, 2008 20:3949898
9Future [210 words]vijaySep 16, 2008 09:4649898
34Muslim Conversions in India [234 words]GauravSep 24, 2008 16:0749898
15Muslims converting to Hinduism [156 words]MahendraSep 24, 2008 19:0249898
13to mohammed [189 words]RiddhimaSep 25, 2008 15:0849898
2surfer [28 words]RiddhimaSep 25, 2008 15:1749898
Then where is the problem? [86 words]DipSep 26, 2008 06:1749898
1@ mohammed [29 words]kumarSep 27, 2008 06:3749898
Welcome [22 words]VinSep 27, 2008 20:2949898
4Fastest growing religion in which parameter? [39 words]AshishSep 28, 2008 11:5049898
2Please Became Muslim Usha Kumari, formerly known as Salma Noor [20 words]Fahad QadriOct 10, 2008 02:0549898
ayush [23 words]Fahad QadriOct 11, 2008 04:5149898
6Why convert out of islam? [237 words]dudeaspOct 15, 2008 09:3549898
5hinduism [21 words]suhailOct 24, 2008 08:3649898
Converting or becoming ex-Muslims! [240 words]Mahendra MathurNov 6, 2008 20:0849898
4conversion [18 words]suhailNov 20, 2008 02:1449898
There is no compulsion in religion [75 words]ArshadFeb 19, 2009 05:0149898
5Certain bad verses in Quran are not the problem [563 words]AbhiMay 15, 2009 00:3149898
1A forlorn hope [155 words]Mahendra MathurMay 15, 2009 23:1249898
2wow!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [8 words]RugvedMay 27, 2009 09:5149898
2HOW CAN U CRITISIZE A RELIGION [60 words]MESSENGER OF HINDUISMJun 27, 2009 02:4449898
On Islam & Other Faiths [225 words]SteadyfriendSep 21, 2009 16:5349898
4Becoming Ex-muslims [179 words]Mahendra MathurSep 23, 2009 12:3849898
1Islam and last prophet [164 words]Mohd Imtiyaz KhanNov 15, 2009 07:2849898
1Bless on you [326 words]FasihDec 14, 2009 10:5349898
Fasih's waffle [257 words]MahendraDec 16, 2009 15:1349898
Treason [143 words]FareedJan 5, 2010 08:2649898
2Muslims and koran [75 words]JitendraFeb 28, 2010 11:2649898
1Hinduism [88 words]Good FriendMar 1, 2010 02:0349898
Quran's call to kill non-muslims [71 words]MahendraMar 1, 2010 07:5649898
Fithna [64 words]FareedMar 1, 2010 13:1449898
thanks [7 words]nikanthaMar 3, 2010 11:2149898
Changes [21 words]Tom DundeeMar 3, 2010 12:5849898
Fitnah - your own interpretation of Koran [27 words]MahendraMar 3, 2010 14:0749898
Origin of the Qur'an [52 words]FareedMar 4, 2010 13:4549898
Quran's exhortion to kill non-muslims [262 words]MahendraMar 5, 2010 13:5649898
Submitted by Mahendra [283 words]FareedMar 6, 2010 14:0049898
YOU ARE WRONG [61 words]AmeenMar 7, 2010 03:0049898
Advice [197 words]Kamala RamApr 13, 2010 06:1349898
1HINDUS DO NOT believe in CONVERSION [83 words]C PAUL SApr 19, 2010 06:0149898
3i feel sorry for usha but her decision is great in reality. [45 words]meghna rajApr 21, 2010 19:1449898
thank u very much sister [17 words]AMIT B PATELApr 25, 2010 05:4749898
1War against non-believers by Muslims [368 words]MahendraApr 29, 2010 22:0149898
Fighting the unbelievers [165 words]fFareedMay 2, 2010 02:4049898
Violence and Koran [87 words]MahendraMay 4, 2010 22:0449898
obsolete [153 words]FareedMay 15, 2010 14:4049898
War against non-believers [137 words]MahendraMay 24, 2010 08:4249898
1misconception on islam [92 words]parvez abdullahMay 26, 2010 09:1149898
2Violence and Islam [147 words]MahendraMay 28, 2010 17:1249898
Kaaba is not an Idol, its Qibla which means direction [86 words]Mighty WindowsJun 2, 2010 21:3649898
3Kaaba - idol or not [75 words]Mahendra MathurJun 5, 2010 22:3049898
Myth [139 words]fareedJun 11, 2010 15:2849898
Jehad [863 words]MahendraJun 12, 2010 10:5249898
1@qadri... [275 words]almightyJul 18, 2010 01:5049898
Hindus are Victim of Islamic terror from ancient time [160 words]debashisSep 11, 2011 11:0649898
10I consider myself a hindu as i have full belief on it. [76 words]rahulDec 29, 2011 10:2149898
may goddess bless you [54 words]kumarMar 13, 2012 09:4049898
210mumnai pathan girl, tired of islamic hypocrisy of hindu hatred, embraced hinduism [792 words]ayesha khan to asha chattopadhyayMay 13, 2012 02:4849898
1Another miracle of hinduism.i love it [12 words]Samrat mauryaJul 23, 2012 10:3549898
1not muslim [18 words]mohammadAug 8, 2012 17:4849898
1People judge a religion based on the general conduct of its practioners. [261 words]GunalNov 5, 2012 06:2449898
1misconception that she has become a sanatani hindu [26 words]nakhanDec 6, 2012 03:0149898
3Comments on Fahad's posting [43 words]benDec 11, 2012 11:3249898
Conversion [196 words]Nasir KhanDec 12, 2012 13:2149898
Ben's Comment [25 words]benDec 13, 2012 11:1949898
well done! welcome to hinduism [22 words]JaiHindDec 24, 2012 23:4949898
1Complete made-up rubbish ! [145 words]NadiaJan 26, 2013 17:1749898
conversion in hinduism [16 words]iam now usha kumariFeb 8, 2013 04:1149898
2Muslim invaders [133 words]RajFeb 27, 2013 15:0849898
comments to imtyaz khan [5 words]fasihMar 12, 2013 05:1149898
LET SEE [7 words]aramMar 25, 2013 03:2049898
Welcome to open sky of universe i.e. Sanatan Vedic Dharm of universal law and true God - braham & your self [77 words]kkTiwariMar 29, 2013 09:4549898
2Welcome to your open sky of vedic dharma with universal law and truth of univers the God & YOU. [207 words]krishna kumar tiwariApr 18, 2013 05:2949898
Ghengis Khan [28 words]A human beingJun 7, 2013 14:2249898
8Thanks. ASHA , Very Proud that you left "ISLAM" [125 words]Ex-Muslim ABDULLAH MAHMUDJun 15, 2013 02:3849898
4I KNOW, ISLAM ... Proud that Left ISLAM. [72 words]EX-MUSLIM ABDULLAH BODHIJun 15, 2013 02:4749898
Freedom [18 words]DaleJun 25, 2013 17:5149898
2islam is best [70 words]ZUBAIRJul 20, 2013 08:1149898
why [98 words]samAug 25, 2013 20:5649898
to mohamed [42 words]sundarSep 11, 2013 05:5649898
to pervez abdulla [62 words]sujoySep 11, 2013 09:2649898
to imtiaz khan [43 words]sujoySep 11, 2013 09:4849898
2I SALUTE YOU... [8 words]deepSep 22, 2013 12:2849898
2well done [8 words]akshaySep 30, 2013 00:4949898
1Namaste, Asha Chattopadhyaya [115 words]gtmOct 21, 2013 17:0749898
A matter of opinion only [1541 words]gttmOct 24, 2013 14:4249898
2Genuine Decision [38 words]narendraJan 1, 2014 07:1549898
realy i feel you are unfit to be a muslim [21 words]m.mohamme duvaissFeb 10, 2014 03:4549898
6muslim hypocrisy and hate of all non muslims. jews hindu and Christians. [44 words]fatimaApr 4, 2014 15:5249898
jai shri ram [12 words]ashok kumarJun 21, 2014 06:0549898
Regarding change of religion [72 words]imtiazJul 21, 2014 05:1949898
to my sister [3 words]joySep 2, 2014 14:5849898
16Hyderabadi Muslim Girls forced to Prostitution by Arab Agent Owaisi MIM [203 words]Khaleda Shaikh HyderabadiAug 16, 2015 02:4349898
is it tru [22 words]aramMar 21, 2016 07:3749898
1know about the mahabharata [26 words]ranvirNov 26, 2016 00:4949898
1advice to you [19 words]arjunJan 14, 2017 11:4949898
Hadith supports that mosques should be built where idols could be found. Does hadith belong to the words of Allah? [48 words]zumaJul 14, 2017 04:3649898
Why should a mosque be built at the place where idols were placed since it seemed to be idolatry? [290 words]Mahendra MathurJul 17, 2017 16:5049898
Quranic disaster? Read Q3:18 and laugh [79 words]dhimmi no moreJul 18, 2017 06:3349898
fake [8 words]AssamJun 28, 2018 04:3849898
Ayesha khan to ASHA chattopadhyay [35 words]SHUBHRAJIT CHAKRABORTYMay 20, 2021 03:2249898
3Muslims converting to Judaism in Israel!!! [97 words]Romesh ChanderJul 16, 2006 19:2649839
No Fatwas in Israel [216 words]Fred SchlomkaJul 17, 2006 01:0549839
Really? [78 words]David PittsSep 30, 2007 01:2749839
Fred Shlomka's comments re: conversion to Judaism in Israel [531 words]MikeSep 20, 2008 22:4249839
Islam, the religion of truth [62 words]The son of IslamFeb 15, 2009 14:2649839
Conversions in Israel - food for thought [246 words]Fred SchlomkaJul 16, 2006 04:3149780
conversion in israel? [33 words]Anubhav SinghJul 17, 2006 04:2749780
1a question for Anubhav Singh [122 words]concernedJul 22, 2006 09:2749780
response to concerned [237 words]Anubhav SinghJul 24, 2006 03:1649780
thanks, Anubhav [73 words]concernedJul 25, 2006 06:2749780
8how can a palestinian-muslim born in the united states convert to judaism [21 words]Hatem KJul 29, 2006 23:0049780
Conversuion to Judiasm! [35 words]SaifAug 3, 2008 12:4849780
Contact any orthodox synagogue in the United States and make an appointment with the rabbi [56 words]MalkielAug 15, 2008 12:5249780
She can convert. And her husband can convert with her [37 words]MalkielAug 15, 2008 12:5549780
Conversion [78 words]ADNov 11, 2009 18:0849780
Answer [72 words]DylanJun 28, 2010 20:3149780
11Our ancestor's land kashmir [261 words]debashisSep 12, 2011 00:0149780
Conspicuous absence of data on Muslim and Jewish conversions to Xianity [28 words]Mark JamesJul 15, 2006 18:3149755
Consipicuous absence indeed [8 words]l.d.Mar 15, 2007 10:2749755

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

Most Viewed

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)