69 million page views

It's not on the fringe

Reader comment on item: How Central Is Muslim Anti-Semitism?

Submitted by Irfan Khawaja (United States), Jul 7, 2002 at 13:52

I have written a short memoir-essay that deals with Islamic anti-Semitism in a forthcoming book edited by Ibn Warraq. Suffice it to say this: I grew up in a Pakistani American Muslim household in northern New Jersey in the 1970s and 1990s. Anti-Semitism was part of the very air we breathed as we grew up. There was NO escaping it. Every reference to Jews was pejorative. Everything said about them denigrated them. We were taught to hate them. We were punished for befriending them. This remains the status quo in many, many households here and abroad.

The same is true of my cousins in Pakistan. One of them explicitly admires Hitler--an admiration he nourished at school where he was taught that Hitler was a freedom-loving nationalist. Two cousins, members of the former Nawaz Sharif government, are raving anti-Semites who once tried to convince me that the "Jews were the worst of all people ('kawm') on earth" because it says so in the Quran. These are standard-issue views among the Muslims of the present generation. They are not on the fringe, and it is about time that propagandists like Sarah Eltantawi emerge from their despicable state of denial and start to deal honestly with this fact.

There is no bigger lie than the claim that anti-Semitism is a "fringe" phenomenon among Muslims. It is part of the mainstream. Take it from someone who's been there and seen it from the inside. My brother and I used to call the Muslim American community "The Fourth Reich." It was supposed to be a sick joke, but we regarded it as a joke only because unlike the self-appointed Muslim spokespeople, we were never brazen enough to deny the fact of anti-Semitism in that community--we just had no other way of dealing with it but to make fun of it. It's no longer funny when prominent media personalities deny its existence on the air for public consumption. Then it becomes mere sickness.

What the Muslim spokespeople are denying are the experiences of those of us who had to endure this anti-Semitism all of our lives, who had to have friendships with Jewish friends on the sly, who had to watch in motification as our elders spouted anti-Semitic venom in front of our friends and in front of us. It is impossible to describe what torture it was to live through that. Imagine having to tell a friend that you can't go to his bar mitzvah because "Islam prohibits it." Why would Islam prohibit such a thing? Answer: because Jews are unclean, that's why, and we wouldn't want their uncleanliness to rub off onto us. What other reason could there be? No one had to state the reason out loud. Everyone knew what it was. Only a fool could fail to notice that that is exactly how bigotry works. Only a fool or a propagandist would try to pretend that it was a fringe phenomenon. This is what so many of us had to grow up with. It is also what some of us refuse to forgive or forget.

The question of whether anti-Semitism is intrinsic to Islamic theology is a separate issue. I'm only dealing here with the sociological issue of the prevalence of anti-Semitism among Muslims, especially Muslim Americans, and especially middle class Pakistanis. I would challenge Sarah Eltantawi to tell me that what I experienced for twenty years did not exist. I would like her to explain to me how it was all a fringe phenomenon, even though I never found a way to escape it except to escape the Muslim American community as such. I'd like her to explain why it is that every time I deal with that community, I'm forced to cringe at its anti-Semitism. I'd like her to explain to me why this never changes, whether I go to Pakistani communities or Arab ones, whether it's in the US or in Pakistan or Saudi Arabia. She can't explain it, because she hasn't had the courage to look the phenomenon straight in the face. To paraphrase Galileo: nevertheless, it exists!

Let me add in passing that we Muslims were the subject of a great deal of bigotry ourselves at the hands of Jews--no question about that. Those who deplore Muslim anti-Semitism would come across more credibly if they spent some time exploring this fact. But be that as it may, Muslims have a great deal to answer for on this subject, and it is about time they started with the task of doing so.

A good place to start would be to start ignoring the Sarah Eltantawis of the world, who stand for nothing but official ignorance, official denial, and plain old official lies.
Dislike
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (60) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
2"prophet" mohammed hated Jews, now islamists hate Jews [149 words]Phil GreendMar 22, 2008 10:16123235
1If the Prophet Mohammed hated the Jews then how... [72 words]SaaraJan 15, 2009 17:29123235
1sara 2 [147 words]btillyJan 15, 2009 23:02123235
Peace [230 words]amer khanMay 23, 2009 20:08123235
If the Prophet Mohammed hated the Jews then how... [36 words]nassarJul 16, 2010 10:13123235
1Islam a peaceful religion [167 words]ShakeebMar 13, 2007 12:1586146
3the muslim faith is not a peaceful religion [74 words]john newmanFeb 21, 2008 16:5186146
1Islam is a peaceful religion [1351 words]ShakeebApr 4, 2008 15:0386146
shakeeb [97 words]btillyJan 15, 2009 23:0886146
1A Heartfelt Answer To Shakeep (Pakistan) [282 words]D.K. Milgrim-HeathJul 17, 2010 10:3786146
Shakeeb from Pakistan. [59 words]Z'dJan 21, 2011 02:3486146
Re Islam is a peaceful religion - Shakeeb, Apr 4, 2008 15:03 [160 words]Gibson BlockFeb 13, 2011 10:2086146
Anti-semitism? [78 words]Bo SmithOct 8, 2006 10:2959296
Daniel Pipes official position on Palestinian statehood [104 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Michael DevolinFeb 1, 2006 00:3733362
muslim anti israel [24 words]Mar 2, 2004 18:3714044
What long range scenarios could happen w/ Islamic radicalism? [161 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
John P.Dec 18, 2003 18:1412742
Try assimilating this! [265 words]see in postDec 14, 2003 20:4712657
Growing Up in a Pakistani/Muslim household [126 words]sophia bJun 20, 2003 17:599661
good [2 words]frankApr 4, 2006 17:529661
Misunderstood Religion [329 words]Ihsan RijalMay 30, 2003 11:409298
anti-Semitism is central to Islam [165 words]Michael DevolinMar 24, 2003 06:567554
Quote Something [311 words]Bilal AhmedAug 7, 2007 19:397554
Jews expelled from Arab Countries [104 words]Joseph Abdel WahedFeb 15, 2003 20:076677
It's true in Canada also...... [306 words]Kyle SimmersDec 8, 2002 17:394484
A question for Dr. Pipes [230 words]Isaac WebsterSep 25, 2002 13:242637
1Jews and Islam [66 words]A. AhmadoSep 13, 2002 22:552466
To agree with A. Ahmado... [239 words]John SiglerDec 4, 2002 15:132466
Go, Daniel! Astute as always [53 words]Susan CohenAug 30, 2002 17:212221
TV's important part in enforcing public opinions [137 words]Julia SAug 13, 2002 12:551820
ok [3 words]nounaNov 19, 2007 16:361820
MESAN - Middle East Studies Association [211 words]Yossi Ben-AharonJul 15, 2002 03:391274
4The aim of Islam is clear [366 words]W. ArmeniousJul 14, 2002 20:161271
Research before you jump to conclusions. [68 words]M.Cochrane.Jun 17, 2008 04:461271
Wrong [79 words]JojoJul 16, 2009 03:501271
where did you get this information [10 words]amirNov 10, 2013 10:511271
1Who is behind the Channel "Ekraa" [289 words]Wahid BoctorJul 14, 2002 13:561270
Turning away from the DARK SIDE of Islam [169 words]Jonathon MoseleyJul 14, 2002 13:191269
Dark side jonathan? [84 words]AliApr 19, 2003 03:311269
It's not on the fringe [783 words]Irfan KhawajaJul 7, 2002 13:521180
How long has the hatred existed? [435 words]Philip BillJul 2, 2002 06:251101
Daniel Pipes - A man amongst men [33 words]Jeff BercovitchJun 30, 2002 13:411091
No Two State solution [116 words]Daniel BoncaJun 30, 2002 02:061087
State Media [125 words]Mike SteinbergJun 30, 2002 02:051086
Baby Killers [59 words]Daniel BoncaJun 30, 2002 01:451085
Aggressive engagement necessary! [41 words]Robert K Novich MDJun 28, 2002 19:431076
The Arab World Has Taken The Mantle Of Anti Semitism [54 words]Danny BoncaJun 28, 2002 19:311075
"Right On!" [17 words]Randi T. VarroneJun 28, 2002 01:461069
No remorse [257 words]Sam LahiriJun 27, 2002 13:021062
Forever Dhimmi [100 words]Rusty RivetJun 26, 2002 22:181054
Fanatic that is not so fringe! [49 words]Tim MooreJun 26, 2002 21:111051
What is the fringe? [154 words]martin SchulbergJun 26, 2002 18:341044
A scapegoat is always needed [76 words]Glenn KlotzJun 26, 2002 16:081036
Discredit the message by attacking the messenger [260 words]Ethan CoreyJun 26, 2002 14:211027
Personal attacks on Pipes [98 words]Richard BurdJun 26, 2002 13:541025
Thick skin [51 words]Mark GoldsteinJun 26, 2002 13:401024
Debating lying Muslim "leaders" [93 words]James BarkerJun 26, 2002 10:591017
Saying "I'm not going to be attacked" doesn't accomplish much [165 words]Gamaliel IsaacJun 26, 2002 10:101011
You are OUR spokesmodel [182 words]Richard PolirerJun 26, 2002 09:551008
Muslim moderates [120 words]J. SeidenbergJun 26, 2002 09:531007
Hate starts with the kids. [36 words]Bruce BuntinJun 26, 2002 08:33998

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)