69 million page views

Zakir Naik

Reader comment on item: Free Muslims March against Terror
in response to reader comment: Yazeedi Zakir Nalaik or say Dr. Zakir Naik

Submitted by R Chowdhury (United Kingdom), Jan 24, 2008 at 09:01

Assalamu alaykum

Brother, i understand that you are "very very upset over Zakir Naik comments", so are the rest of us, but we must not start giving fatwas of Kufr on other muslims unless they explicitly indulge in Kufr by words, actions or belief.
I am not a supporter of Zakir Naik, nor a fan and i agree that his views on karbala as a political war are very disturbing indeed..

There are "so" many ahadith in addition to the quranic verses on the pure household that shouldnt leave us even to doubt the family of the prophet sallalahu alaihi wa alihi wassalam , one little bit.

The prophet sallalahu alaihi wa alihi wasalam said very clearly, that "fatima is a peice of me, if fatima is happy, then i am happy, if she is sad then i am sad". Mr Zakir Naik, do you really think that Fatima radiallahu anha and the rest of the household would be pleased with you calling it a "political war" ?
Do you really think that Fatima radiallahu anha's blessed soul will be pleased to know that you are doubting her son and calling him an "opportunist" ?

The prophet sallalalahu alaihi wa alihi wassalam also clearly said "i love hassan and husyan, and whoever loves them loves me and whoever hates them hates me, whoever is at war with them, then i am at war with them".

Do you really think that the Imaan of Yazid is safe if the prophet sallalahu alaihi wa alihi wassalam is at war with him? Dont you think that ALLAH will NOT BE AT war with the one who the prophet is at war with ?

Mr Zakir Naik, instead of honouring the ahlul bayt, you chose to give the benefit of the doubt to Yazid whose character is mentioned by Ibn Kathir as a "playboy, alcoholic, abandaner of the salah, an entertainer , deep lover of music". It is also reported that Yazid saw permissible to "do nikkah with your own mother".

These are clear violations of the Sunnah and the QUran and this is what Imam Husayn stood up for , not for politiics.

Do you really think you should give the benefit of the doubt to a man like Yazid who ruled for 3 years and in the first year he killed the sons and daughters of the prophet, in the 2nd year he conquered Madinah Al Munawarra, and made it open for his army to do whatever they wish. He sent from Shaam a rep who was given the authority to kill anyone in Madinah who opposes Yazid.

Ibn Hajar and others mention that "more than 1000 daughters of the Sahaba (Radiallahu Ta'ala Anhum)" were raped. More than 10,000 people of the Sahaba (Radiallahu Ta'ala Anhum) were tortured and beaten by the army of Yazid (La'natullahi alaihi). All the children of the Sahaba (Radiallahu Ta'ala Anhum) were taken and banged against the walls , if the parents (SAHABIS) didn't give bayah to Yazid. The horses of this tryrant urinated near the Mimbar of the prophet (Sallalahu alaihi wa alihi wassalam).In his third year he went to the kaba and destroyed and levelled and burnt it.

It is only "reasonable" that you Mr Naik apologise for your "sick" outburst and in future be careful about what you say.

May allah guide us all

RC

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (28) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Worst man on the planet [137 words]FARIS CHAMOCHIJun 19, 2009 01:11157629
FARIS CHAMOCHI has no knowledge about ISLAM! [22 words]AlmaJan 26, 2010 08:36157629
Everyone must support Kamal Nawash and the Free Muslims [82 words]YigalAug 18, 2006 14:3953376
Mr.Zakir Naik [49 words]samuelMay 4, 2006 18:1144867
Imam Khomeni [82 words]HassanSep 5, 2006 12:0744867
Regarding Dr. Zakir Naik [63 words]suhanNov 18, 2007 03:3144867
2Yazeedi Zakir Nalaik or say Dr. Zakir Naik [156 words]Vilayath AliDec 21, 2007 12:5844867
Zakir Naik [559 words]R ChowdhuryJan 24, 2008 09:0144867
Sunnis and Shias [69 words]tariq khanApr 16, 2008 08:1644867
1zakir Naik The Hero [101 words]Shakeel Ahmad ( yeshkay)May 5, 2008 14:4544867
Fatwa Against Naik (l.a) [162 words]Bilal H. KazmiMay 26, 2008 07:1244867
one thing that realizes that yazid's children are still alive [81 words]shakil shahJul 2, 2008 05:2244867
Let us unite as Muslims and stop divisions........ [193 words]Nazir AliAug 3, 2008 07:3744867
Don't abuse any one [159 words]sarfaraz rafiNov 20, 2008 09:1844867
1he should be boycotted [163 words]Mohammad KAshif KhanDec 2, 2008 22:2644867
truth [66 words]awais hamidDec 6, 2008 02:4344867
Islam Aik-Insan Aik [23 words]shoaib cheemaDec 13, 2008 02:3344867
NAIK IS ALIVE [84 words]syed farhan haider naqviJan 3, 2009 17:3344867
WHO WANTS TO READ, BOYCOTT NAIK [58 words]syed farhan haider naqviJan 3, 2009 18:1144867
request [75 words]sania subhan qureshiFeb 13, 2009 08:3444867
MISCONCEPT ZAKIR [124 words]SHAMSHEERJun 20, 2009 03:3144867
I ACCEPT UNITY WITHOUT ZAKIR [127 words]SHAMSHEERJun 20, 2009 03:4944867
Zakir Naik !!! - The Truth about Him [21 words]IbrahimMar 23, 2010 15:2344867
Ahlebait [210 words]SIRAJ/ChennaApr 12, 2010 13:1444867
Holy Quran & Ahadees [41 words]Siraj, ChennaiApr 15, 2010 12:2044867
Siblings of Ali(RA) [67 words]Siraj, ChennaiApr 22, 2010 10:1244867
Kamal Nawash and Free Muslims Against Terrorism [79 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
M.KoanMar 13, 2006 11:5939951
Kamal Nawash [32 words]AdamJun 20, 2006 15:4739951

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)