A state of all its citizens -- what about the Palestinian state?

Submitted by manny (Canada), Apr 27, 2009 at 10:58

She says Israel must be turned into a "state of all its citizens."

This reminds me of my pet peeve. I am disturbed every time I hear someone decry the Jewish settlements on Palestinian land. What they are saying is that the future State of Palestine cannot be formed as long as Jews live on that land -- Palestine must be "judenrein"

Palestine will not be "a state for all its citizens". Why should Israel be?

Like (1) Dislike

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>

Reader comments (44) on this item

	Title	Commenter	Date	Thread
	Hortific terror-pusher: Huwaida Arraf [134 words]	Donny	Nov 29, 2021 23:55	276937
	Racist Arab former MK Haneen Zoabi: inventor of fake quote about Naftali Bennett [997 words]	Hananya	Jun 16, 2021 19:23	268312
	When Dissenting Voices Become Treasonous [136 words]	M Tovey	Apr 12, 2021 20:29	265596
	Note that for Zoebi, having an Arab 'right of return' isn't racist. [63 words]	Anon	Oct 13, 2017 12:30	241058
	On the contrary, let her continue to talk as a knesset member [44 words]	anon	Jul 11, 2016 17:01	230356
	Israel Too Democratic [61 words]	Dave	Jun 17, 2014 21:46	215455
1	What is wrong in her statements? [145 words]	Abdulkarim Al-habsi	Jan 23, 2013 02:06	202743
1	Haneen Zuabi [47 words]	Nick	Dec 27, 2012 13:30	201987
	Let's send Zoabi to ride the bus in India! [9 words]	Arnie	Dec 27, 2012 09:02	201976
4	Muslims are the biggest beneficiary of democracy [252 words]	Prashant	Feb 23, 2012 01:13	193578
1	Hostile members of government [72 words]	daniela	Feb 20, 2012 09:38	193514
	Arab MK's [46 words]	stan	Feb 18, 2012 21:52	193455
1	Tolerance in other countries [44 words]	missha	Feb 16, 2012 10:57	193408
	The truth in reverse [158 words]	yuval Brandstettewr MD	Dec 21, 2012 11:19	193408
1	Treasonous of Thought [197 words]	Jay1	Jan 29, 2012 19:06	192890
	Dear Dr. Pipes [49 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes	Debanjan Banerjee	Jan 26, 2012 03:53	192830
	This clearly shows the extreme goodness of Israel and the Jews ! [25 words]	Phil Greend	Jul 13, 2010 23:25	175558
	settlements [31 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes	gerson Jacobs;	Jun 9, 2009 20:02	157088
	A challenge to Iranian voters [149 words]	abhi	May 31, 2009 14:32	156474
1	A state of all its citizens -- what about the Palestinian state? [76 words]	manny	Apr 27, 2009 10:58	154541
	MUSLIMS IN ISRAEL [769 words]	MOHAMAD NOZZI	Apr 28, 2009 05:57	154541
	utter selfishness [40 words]	Ted	Jul 21, 2010 03:30	154541
	You ... read Koran [128 words]	spa	Aug 5, 2010 01:36	154541
	VICTORY OVER ISRAEL MIGHT NOT NECESSARILY BE BY PHYSICAL VIOLENCE &/OR ETC. [373 words]	MOHAMAD NOZZI	Apr 24, 2009 20:50	154407
1	really? [20 words]	Russian Bear 1987	Nov 8, 2014 17:09	154407
	MUSLIMS FIGHT AGAINST MUSLIMS [79 words]	MOHAMAD NOZZI	Apr 23, 2009 00:45	154325
	NOT A SMART MOVE -2 [74 words]	MOHAMAD NOZZI	Apr 22, 2009 23:28	154321
	Haneen Zuabi [10 words]	outspoken2	Apr 20, 2009 18:17	154170
	Who said that Haneen Zuabi is Iranian and representing an Arab Party? [34 words]	Insha Marri	Apr 13, 2009 01:01	153796
1	Another Arab enemy [133 words]	Ken Besig	Apr 7, 2009 10:53	153497
2	The Very Concept [76 words]	Nesivos	Apr 5, 2009 15:34	153357
2	Hypocrisy of Islamic leaders [146 words]	Sunil Sarang	Apr 7, 2009 23:22	153357
2	She is not a traitor [63 words]	Yuval Brandstetter MD	Apr 5, 2009 05:14	153337
1	Well yes and no [151 words]	Ken Besig	Apr 8, 2009 03:59	153337
2	Wrong again [136 words]	Yuval Brandstetter MD	Apr 10, 2009 11:27	153337
	She is a traitor [8 words]	Robert	Apr 2, 2009 22:02	153231
2	Israel must be called a Jewish state, period. [129 words]	Proud_Kafir7908	Apr 2, 2009 01:27	153157
1	THE PRICE OF HAVING A DEMOCRACY- IF SHE WAS IN IRAN, ADVOCATING ISRAEL.... [75 words]	JKF	Apr 1, 2009 13:40	153113
	Everyone has a right to express his/her opinion in Israel [52 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes	Debanjan Banerjee	Apr 1, 2009 07:16	153089
2	There is no such thing as democracy without limits. [131 words]	Isaac Haskiya	Apr 2, 2009 05:19	153089
	The US precedent [33 words]	PezDispenser	Jun 18, 2014 16:52	153089
	Enemies of the State Of Israel should be barred from any PUBLIC POSITION!!!! [35 words]	Italiano	Apr 1, 2009 06:47	153086
1	I find her presence in the Knesset, or on this planet distasteful [97 words]	james burke	Apr 1, 2009 06:45	153085
	What kind of circus is the presence of this ? [16 words]	Svet	Apr 1, 2009 03:05	153081