69 million page views

Soraia's Culpability (?)

Reader comment on item: Guarding the Secrets: Palestinian Terrorism and a Father's Murder of His Too-American Daughter

Submitted by Kathy R. (United States), Apr 6, 2022 at 12:37

My name is Kathy and I am a school teacher in Ohio. While I do not practice Islam, I taught at Dayton Islamic School in Beavercreek in 1995-1999. It was there that I met many wonderful people from all over the world. One parent I met and became rather friendly with was Sister Soraia (her son was in my class - Adil, if I recall correctly). Soraia was welcoming and friendly, encouraging me to learn a few Arabic phrases such as as-salamu alaikum and to participate in community pot lucks at the school. We talked to each other almost daily.

After working at the school for two years, in early 1999, while I was preparing to move to a new county and leave Dayton Islamic, Soraia and another family from the school were planning their move back to Palestine. I distinctly remember standing outsided at parent pick-up asking Soraia if she was afraid to move back overseas due to the strife and instability of the Middle East. I especially remember this conversation because it was a few days after a young girl named Erica Baker from Kettering went missing while walking her dog. Soraia told me she was not afraid for her children in Palestine because at least there, if they died, she'd know why. Unlike in the US where kids get kidnapped and never seen again. I could see the logic in her thinking and wished her the best of luck. That summer I moved away from Beavercreerk and her family moved back to Palestine.

As the summer progressed, Soraia and I kept in touch, writing letters back and forth. She even mailed me packages with trinkets from Palestine.

It was that fall in 1999 when I found Guarding the Secrets on my local library bookshelf. I was a voracious reader of true crime at that point in my life, and this was one of the few books I had yet to read. In order to give faces to names, I normally would peruse through the photo insert pages of a crime book before starting to read. This time I didn't do that. For some reason, I was about 4 chapters in before I looked over the pictures. It was then I saw the trial picture of Soraia with her arms wrapped around a woman, and I realized that the sister of the victim was the mother of my student.

When finished with the book, my feeling was that Soraia egged her parents on; she was culpable in Tina's murder. However, I also knew the book was a biased, one-side-of-the-story telling, but I still felt it could have been reasonable that her sisters behaved that way. I especially felt this because I'd had a personal experience at Dayton Islamic myself that supported an underling feeling of a controling male influence upon and social inequality for the women in that community.

My experience was this: As a teacher in that building, I developed a friendly relationship with the bus driver of the school, Mohammed. We would talk in the hallway, in plain sight of all, often discussing photography - something we both enjoyed. One day he approached me and told me people in the community were not happy with us talking and we had to stop. I was confused and apparently Mohammed anticipated that for before he walked away, he handed me a book to read, telling me it would help me understand. I cannot recall the title, but it was a true story about an Islamic princess who developed breast cancer and how she choose to flee her husband in lieu of being locked up.

After finishing the book, I was uncertain how to handle my coorespondancing with Soraia, so I just stopped responding and she stopped writing as well. I've often wondered now why her family moved back to Palestine and if they ever came back to the US or Ohio? (I know the other family returned to the US because I ran into the other mother at the Dayton Mall Burger King).

I've also wondered just how culpable Soraia was? Did the author Harris get it right? I read on here that Th was at the trial and heard the tape - saying you could hear a sister in the background encouraging the parents. Is this true? Why does Th not give a real name?

Another person posting on here knew Soraia as a teen and said how nice she was. I, too, found Soraia very kind and caring, so I do struggle to understand how and if she could have been an influence.

Any insights or comments would be greatly appreciated,
Kathy

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Daniel Pipes replies:

Thank you for this valuable first-hand testimony.

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (87) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Soraia's Culpability (?) [776 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Kathy R.Apr 6, 2022 12:37279655
1Muslim men can marry non-Muslim women [42 words]RobertJun 8, 2018 03:49243188
question [16 words]IanSep 17, 2017 18:02240845
2Hypocrite [39 words]DahliaMay 29, 2020 17:54240845
1sad thing [55 words]observerAug 25, 2020 03:52240845
Hate [31 words]AlbertE.Jun 5, 2014 14:23215260
3Colored [22 words]AlbertE.Jun 5, 2014 14:19215259
2Maria Isa Dead [8 words]JohnMay 2, 2014 00:36214682
3Maria Isa-Update from Prison from a Journalist/former guard [124 words]SteveApr 21, 2013 16:09205389
8Rest in peace Tina [173 words]TabathaApr 20, 2013 14:54205337
9friend of Tina's sister, Soraia [263 words]Cindi WhistlerDec 11, 2007 15:13116027
3i'm soraias and tina's niece [36 words]allieOct 2, 2008 13:22116027
9Classmate of Tina's [490 words]Cateena WadeNov 22, 2008 23:46116027
1Tina Isa is remembered by more than you few. [49 words]Katherine SerranoJul 25, 2011 22:35116027
2What else is there to say about your grand parents? [29 words]JRMay 2, 2014 23:45116027
1What happened to [18 words]KathySep 19, 2014 15:50116027
7Soraia Isa - Living the American Way too! [152 words]RoseMay 24, 2015 00:33116027
3Mother of Isa girls has died [102 words]NoraFeb 3, 2016 17:32116027
Trial [29 words]ThNov 16, 2016 18:29116027
2Excuse me while I laugh [21 words]sarahAug 30, 2019 19:31116027
response to allie [6 words]observerAug 25, 2020 03:55116027
did you watch documentaries [16 words]observerAug 27, 2020 04:07116027
Questionable Facebook address [26 words]Kathy R.Apr 6, 2022 12:42116027
I knew Soraia in late 1990's [97 words]Kathy R.Apr 6, 2022 15:31116027
Christianity [481 words]BeckaJan 22, 2007 19:0274158
1Islam/Christianity [173 words]CherylLynneJan 27, 2007 17:4474158
It's not about religion [45 words]David P. LaniganSep 22, 2007 21:5674158
2the secrets [148 words]clarice dallasMay 15, 2008 14:2774158
1Don't be so ignorant.... [208 words]JenOct 15, 2011 00:4974158
1Of course it's about religion! [47 words]Gerald BerryApr 19, 2022 01:1674158
1It is time that we stop entertaining this argument. [131 words]PrashantApr 20, 2022 10:1774158
1A Web of Evil [216 words]PJNov 21, 2006 03:0766791
5Tina [270 words]NicoleJul 21, 2006 01:0150406
5i hate to be the one to deal with this... [164 words]anonMay 3, 2007 00:4350406
4Response to anon [129 words]JamesMay 5, 2007 01:1150406
2response [288 words]allieMay 6, 2007 13:1550406
Respond to Allie and Anon [64 words]FriendMay 8, 2007 22:0750406
to respond [73 words]a viewerAug 29, 2007 15:1350406
picture of TIna anyone? [41 words]AllyNov 11, 2008 16:5150406
Any new updates? [38 words]AussieFeb 24, 2013 08:3850406
sad thing [33 words]dianaSep 23, 2020 06:5850406
1Deplorable [157 words]YDec 28, 2005 13:5630701
1Islam [50 words]Regan MacBannonDec 28, 2005 04:5430677
Correction [20 words]former christianJun 8, 2006 20:2130677
agreed [105 words]JenOct 15, 2011 00:5430677
1Palestinian terror and a father's murder of his too-American daughter [379 words]foreign devilDec 7, 2005 03:5229563
1FBI stepping in [149 words]JeremyOct 22, 2005 08:2727203
Tina Isa [143 words]Regan MacBannonOct 22, 2005 03:0227197
1To Regan MacBannon [291 words]SoraidaNov 18, 2005 14:2627197
3Sure thing [151 words]Denver JonesJul 30, 2006 09:4327197
2Re: Sure Thing [99 words]CarrilynnSep 29, 2015 10:0927197
1understanding the arab culture [117 words]InayaOct 12, 2005 14:4426873
1Inaya, it is your religion! [168 words]JustMeApr 30, 2006 10:0326873
2JustMe [100 words]AliJul 23, 2006 06:3526873
islam [250 words]friendsFeb 13, 2008 10:2026873
why? [32 words]azeri gurlSep 24, 2005 21:2726268
About the parents? [89 words]S.May 24, 2005 19:3722391
2A MESSAGE TO "D" [253 words]ch.Apr 29, 2006 17:4122391
Response to ch [120 words]"D"Jul 2, 2006 14:4022391
according to "Court TV" [71 words]JJMay 22, 2005 02:1922308
1Tina Isa Murder [130 words]SunnieApr 6, 2006 11:4822308
1A scary story indeed [262 words]JinanApr 17, 2006 21:3522308
I saw it on Cour tv [65 words]someguyinkcJan 20, 2007 02:1222308
1Forensic Files story response to Sunnie [58 words]KayJan 9, 2009 16:4522308
Forensic Files [79 words]DavidMar 3, 2009 22:1322308
So Sad [132 words]D.Mar 2, 2005 02:1920613
to "D" [82 words]CaroleneMay 24, 2005 13:1820613
1to "Carolene"... [378 words]DJun 27, 2005 03:4520613
Question regarding FBI response [67 words]Tomas GoryFeb 21, 2005 01:1320446
PARENT INFO [102 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
JaneFeb 18, 2005 21:0220426
5I'm an arab daughter but more an American [282 words]CaroleneFeb 10, 2005 19:4820258
21Palestina "Tina" Isa [371 words]Paula Walker (Smith)Nov 19, 2004 09:3918461
1Sad but true [190 words]Roz JonesJul 30, 2006 01:1318461
Tina's burial place, does anyone have info? [143 words]NoraJul 30, 2006 01:1818461
2Mortified [154 words]MJApr 3, 2007 11:0618461
1islam [65 words]deanne littrellSep 20, 2007 17:2318461
Sorry [66 words]Suzie Kanbara PiatigorskiOct 11, 2008 20:1018461
2I saw a facebook account too [108 words]NoraSep 21, 2015 16:1018461
Info on parents [170 words]D.Mar 31, 2004 01:5114433
1Response to "Info on Parents [123 words]GJan 16, 2005 01:3914433
1Info on Parents Reply [49 words]DMar 2, 2005 02:2514433
3RESPONSE TO D ABOUT INFO ON PARENTS [366 words]NorieOct 14, 2005 23:4314433
1there is a tape [48 words]xMay 28, 2017 16:0714433
No evidence that she struck at them with a knife first [78 words]Joseph JoestarDec 3, 2019 06:4214433
2A light once extinguished will find reason to shine again [89 words]Don Ramon de CordobaMar 19, 2004 10:1914260
Question [23 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Therese EliasOct 22, 2003 11:0011884
1To answer your question [57 words]ViewerJun 8, 2006 20:5411884

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)