| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
legal status of gaza and west bank residents
Reader comment on item: "[Symposium] On the Strip: Where To Go from Gaza?"
Submitted by terence silber (United Kingdom), Jul 4, 2006 at 10:29
As the residents of Gaza and the West bank voted democratically for a known established terrorist group to rule them, Is their protection under UN laws about targetting civilians no longer available to them?
Can the IDF now target anyone and collateral damage of civilians is now legitimate and not a war crime because they are clearly aiding and abetting hamas?
Dislike
Submitting....
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (123) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| osama bin laden [78 words] | gary | Jul 17, 2006 05:37 | 49887 | ||
| Islamist Call for Turkey & Pakistan to launch an invasion on State of Israel [458 words] | Bheekobhai | Jul 17, 2006 00:56 | 49865 | ||
 What is true? [155 words] | Gautam Bhudhkumar | Aug 20, 2006 07:35 | 49865 | ||
| Acknowledge Israel's Right To Exist [69 words] | Frederick Bainhauer | Jul 15, 2006 12:07 | 49740 | ||
| Moslems & Jews equal blame 2 go around. [82 words] | Kevin USA | Jul 13, 2006 01:47 | 49544 | ||
| 4 | Israel belongs to the Jews [463 words] | Infidel | Jul 17, 2006 02:22 | 49544 | |
| correction [103 words] | fawzi | Jul 17, 2006 16:55 | 49544 | ||
| 1 | Fawzi's apogee [119 words] | Infidel | Aug 21, 2006 22:44 | 49544 | |
| 1 | fawzi: Wrong Correction [161 words] | Moshe | Sep 2, 2006 16:35 | 49544 | |
| Apogee also means "highest point" [3 words] | Moshe | Sep 2, 2006 16:39 | 49544 | ||
| what about displacing palestinians? [85 words] | logic | Nov 4, 2008 16:14 | 49544 | ||
| 3 | NO PALESTINIAN STATE – No land concessions R4. [781 words] | Jay Draiman | Aug 16, 2009 15:55 | 49544 | |
| Crisis in Israel and only solution [299 words] | Amit Kumar | Jul 12, 2006 14:13 | 49512 | ||
| Deport 100,000 Palestinian Muslims to every Muslim Country by Saudi Arabian Airlines [145 words] | Magnoba Ganchi | Jul 9, 2006 05:11 | 49261 | ||
| The beginning of the end of Islamic fascism [120 words] | Rich | Jul 6, 2006 10:49 | 49051 | ||
| Not just the violence... [201 words] | J.S. | Jul 4, 2006 14:44 | 48866 | ||
| "O" please people.... [383 words] | ahmad zafire | Jul 4, 2006 19:20 | 48866 | ||
| The Seen Christian Cross A Reminder To Christians Of The Redeeming Work Of Christ On The Cross [251 words] | AnneM | Jul 6, 2006 08:29 | 48866 | ||
| Speaking of fantasies... [86 words] | tch, tch, tch...You assume far too much... | Jul 6, 2006 14:06 | 48866 | ||
| i understand [165 words] | ahmad zafire | Jul 7, 2006 06:39 | 48866 | ||
| What do Muslims pray? [96 words] | barbara | Jul 9, 2006 04:58 | 48866 | ||
| yes!! [115 words] | ahmad zafire | Jul 10, 2006 23:40 | 48866 | ||
| God and WC [423 words] | Harrak | Jul 11, 2006 00:35 | 48866 | ||
| translation of one prayer [69 words] | khairandaish | Jul 16, 2006 00:32 | 48866 | ||
| Harrak [11 words] | barbara | Jul 17, 2006 04:45 | 48866 | ||
| 10 Commandments [43 words] | Infidel | Aug 23, 2006 02:10 | 48866 | ||
 legal status of gaza and west bank residents [61 words] | terence silber | Jul 4, 2006 10:29 | 48853 | ||
| Death wish [153 words] | G.Bisvas | Jul 3, 2006 10:35 | 48781 | ||
| in my opinion [83 words] | terence silber | Jul 3, 2006 02:18 | 48761 | ||
| In A Nutshell [244 words] | orange yonason | Jul 2, 2006 18:29 | 48745 | ||
| Arab propaganda. [30 words] | Moshe | Jul 4, 2006 12:20 | 48745 | ||
| Moshe, Thanks For The Link To Israel_WAT [275 words] | orange yonason | Jul 7, 2006 03:13 | 48745 | ||
| After Gaza? [615 words] | Ed Gordon | Jul 2, 2006 14:43 | 48738 | ||
| They ALREADY HAVE TWO STATES [149 words] | Yuval Brandstetter MD | Jul 4, 2006 10:14 | 48738 | ||
| The Israeli "Seinfeld strategy" [144 words] | Kenneth S. Besig | Jul 2, 2006 03:49 | 48709 | ||
| Only Solution to Arab - Israel Problem [287 words] | Kajol Sinha | Jul 2, 2006 00:27 | 48701 | ||
| Good suggestions, but... [182 words] | Charles Martell | Jul 8, 2006 14:01 | 48701 | ||
| We are in World War III & We have to .......... [781 words] | Rohan Tilakratne | Jul 1, 2006 23:43 | 48698 | ||
| what to do [12 words] | terence silber | Jul 3, 2006 02:33 | 48698 | ||
| Staring in the headlights [79 words] | Jaladhi | Jul 5, 2006 22:02 | 48698 | ||
| It must start with Israel [220 words] | gmack | Jul 1, 2006 20:36 | 48687 | ||
| Deplorable insularity [121 words] | Saikat Biswas | Jul 1, 2006 12:31 | 48664 | ||
| 1 | Truth is not Politically Correct [101 words] | Michael | Jul 1, 2006 12:29 | 48663 | |
| Violence Indicates Islam's On Its Last Legs [70 words] | AnneM | Jul 3, 2006 17:45 | 48663 | ||
| I agree: going to war WW2 style. [139 words] | John Berg | Jul 1, 2006 12:14 | 48661 | ||
| Where to go from Gaza? [178 words] | kim segar | Jul 1, 2006 10:29 | 48654 | ||
| The Government You Deserve? [235 words] | maura collins | Jul 1, 2006 07:19 | 48648 | ||
| In this Jew Hating World, nothing could surprise me but... [87 words] | Jeff Burke | Jul 9, 2006 12:50 | 48648 | ||
| History should be Repeated [116 words] | Shahin S. | Jun 30, 2006 23:21 | 48629 | ||
| You want to repeat mistake once again. [199 words] | Proud Arab | Jul 3, 2006 01:28 | 48629 | ||
| Europe made the mistake of Appeasing Hitler [73 words] | Shahin S. | Jul 3, 2006 20:58 | 48629 | ||
| Full Force [872 words] | John R | Jun 30, 2006 22:44 | 48625 | ||
| Enormous force [340 words] | Yuval Brandstetter MD | Jul 2, 2006 08:25 | 48625 | ||
| To John R./ Full Force [102 words] | joe | Jul 3, 2006 03:35 | 48625 | ||
| No Such Thing As A "Moderate Islam" [48 words] | AnneM | Jul 3, 2006 17:55 | 48625 | ||
| Dr. Pipes Forgets [81 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Stuart | Jun 30, 2006 19:52 | 48612 | ||
| Unfortunately not quite true [213 words] | Morten Nielsen | Jul 6, 2006 16:06 | 48612 | ||
| Has the time come...? [15 words] | Melvin A. Fechter | Jun 30, 2006 19:52 | 48611 | ||
| just another brick in the wall [138 words] | gary | Jun 30, 2006 19:38 | 48610 | ||
| Israel may at last be doing the right thing [41 words] | Judith Sinclair | Jun 30, 2006 18:10 | 48600 | ||
| More on Washington's mistaken approach... [211 words] | J.S. | Jun 30, 2006 15:25 | 48586 | ||
| Its Islam versus Peace [509 words] | Kumar Gaurav | Jun 30, 2006 14:28 | 48581 | ||
| Please think [145 words] | James | Jul 3, 2007 11:55 | 48581 | ||
| Please open your eyes now [124 words] | Truth follower | Jul 10, 2007 06:45 | 48581 | ||
| how to inflict a sense of defeat? [77 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Shepard Barbash | Jun 30, 2006 14:17 | 48577 | ||
| Is bombing Gaza civillians justified? [43 words] | Charles Martell | Jul 1, 2006 06:51 | 48577 | ||
| Apollo [544 words] | Harrak | Jul 1, 2006 23:06 | 48577 | ||
| Here We Go Again [647 words] | Blackspeare | Jul 2, 2006 14:55 | 48577 | ||
| Not A Good Idea [340 words] | Blackspeare | Jul 2, 2006 15:05 | 48577 | ||
| Dr Pipes is being an American [116 words] | Yuval Brandstetter MD | Jul 3, 2006 15:56 | 48577 | ||
| Blackspeare, Hanging the Black Flag [413 words] | Infidel | Jul 3, 2006 22:45 | 48577 | ||
| Over The Top [161 words] | Blackspeare | Jul 4, 2006 22:04 | 48577 | ||
| WOW!!! Infidel, I loved your comment! [10 words] | Moshe | Jul 5, 2006 11:18 | 48577 | ||
| Gaza-Where to go now [502 words] | Paul | Jun 30, 2006 13:53 | 48574 | ||
| دمعة غدر ..تفشل السلام [264 words] | mohamed.m | Jun 30, 2006 13:00 | 48568 | ||
| respect this forum please [27 words] | ahmad zafire | Jun 30, 2006 23:21 | 48568 | ||
| mutual terror [229 words] | Harrak | Jul 1, 2006 12:23 | 48568 | ||
| Dan , Please translate this letter [43 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Jangaldhar Badshah | Jul 1, 2006 23:59 | 48568 | ||
| Restraint for Israel [66 words] | Margaret Young | Jun 30, 2006 12:58 | 48567 | ||
| Where To Go from Gaza?" [78 words] | Mike | Jun 30, 2006 12:24 | 48565 | ||
| Perfect. [13 words] | bunuel cela | Jun 30, 2006 12:01 | 48561 | ||
| Beware of wolf in sheep's clothing [410 words] | Jaladhi | Jun 30, 2006 11:37 | 48557 | ||
| Beware of Wolf in Sheep's clothing ... [110 words] | MurphX | Jul 3, 2006 20:08 | 48557 | ||
| On "Where to go from Gaza?" [207 words] | Robert Guinaugh | Jun 30, 2006 10:52 | 48551 | ||
| mistaken enemy [61 words] | Alan | Jun 30, 2006 10:41 | 48549 | ||
| A fouled up ambition [60 words] | Alan Goldstein | Jun 30, 2006 10:36 | 48547 | ||
| Who is Right [53 words] | Hoot Howell | Jun 30, 2006 10:15 | 48543 | ||
| Rather... [325 words] | SHmuel HaLevi | Jun 30, 2006 09:43 | 48536 | ||
| Could This Be It? [111 words] | Blackspeare | Jul 2, 2006 17:39 | 48536 | ||
| On the Strip [55 words] | Bahi Habib | Jun 30, 2006 09:33 | 48533 | ||
| Where to go? [129 words] | Jack Clifford | Jun 30, 2006 09:25 | 48532 | ||
| Short and to the point : What a pleasure [119 words] | Jon - a brit in Euroland | Jun 30, 2006 08:31 | 48527 | ||
| Where to Go [104 words] | Phllip | Jun 30, 2006 08:20 | 48525 | ||
| Why this double standard [229 words] | Amitabh tripathi | Jun 30, 2006 08:03 | 48524 | ||
| public action [111 words] | Karen Salina | Jun 30, 2006 06:57 | 48520 | ||
| The Palestinian issue is inseparable from the global war with Islamic radicalism. [119 words] | Moshe | Jun 30, 2006 05:53 | 48516 | ||
| Ten Existential Threats to State of Israel [357 words] | Uttam | Jul 1, 2006 00:06 | 48516 | ||
| conspiracy theory [125 words] | Harrak | Jul 2, 2006 13:03 | 48516 | ||
| The Jewish Israeli public voted for defeat [319 words] | Kenneth S. Besig | Jun 30, 2006 02:22 | 48504 | ||
| A mile in my brother's moccasins [121 words] | Martin H. Katchen | Jun 30, 2006 02:21 | 48503 | ||
| Concerning your "Symposium On the Strip" Here is a copy of a letter I sent to The Jerusalem Post recently [155 words] | Ted Kraminer | Jun 30, 2006 02:04 | 48502 | ||
| Bush's commitment to to Abdullah in Crawford in 2002 [118 words] | Arthur Cohn | Jun 30, 2006 00:40 | 48499 | ||
| Israel and USA agree among the grass roots [227 words] | Charles Cameron | Jun 29, 2006 23:02 | 48495 | ||
| You didn't see this one coming? [730 words] | Wyzoleowl | Jun 29, 2006 22:24 | 48493 | ||
| "Where To Go from Gaza?" [75 words] | steven L | Jun 29, 2006 21:45 | 48490 | ||
| Why are all people of Europe called are of Aryan descent? [58 words] | Bonginkosi Wellington Sikhakhane | Feb 5, 2007 13:54 | 48490 | ||
| C'mon People [31 words] | Zachary | Jul 31, 2012 22:02 | 48490 | ||
| They're All the Same [101 words] | Blackspeare | Jun 29, 2006 21:42 | 48489 | ||
| don't forget [80 words] | oblilic | Jun 29, 2006 21:38 | 48488 | ||
| Going upstream [127 words] | David W. Lincoln | Jun 29, 2006 20:59 | 48486 | ||
| Wake up George! [37 words] | Al Roth | Jun 29, 2006 20:57 | 48485 | ||
| 3 CHEERS FOR ISRAEL [138 words] | John Manitta | Jun 29, 2006 20:45 | 48483 | ||
| We are unfair with Israel... [179 words] | Marc Bellm | Jun 29, 2006 20:14 | 48480 | ||
| Where to Go From Gaza? [83 words] | Dan Rusen | Jun 29, 2006 20:14 | 48479 | ||
| From Realism to Idealism To Crack [482 words] | Harrak | Jun 29, 2006 20:11 | 48478 | ||
| Concise, Clear and... [17 words] | LDC | Jun 29, 2006 19:59 | 48477 | ||
| Agree [12 words] | Boris | Jun 29, 2006 19:49 | 48475 | ||
| Resignation By War or Persuation [127 words] | Melvyn I. Marquis | Jun 29, 2006 19:31 | 48473 | ||
| Not a sense of defeat, but an acceptance of Israel's permanence [160 words] | Moshe Even-Shoshan | Jun 29, 2006 19:29 | 48472 | ||
| Events of the last few days [182 words] | David | Jun 29, 2006 19:16 | 48469 | ||
| What Palestinian people?? [46 words] | Dennis Sellers | Jun 30, 2006 16:16 | 48469 | ||
| Restraint? [73 words] | Dennis Sellers | Jun 29, 2006 18:45 | 48468 | ||
| Do the right thing even at our own expense. [203 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Vinod Gulati | Jun 29, 2006 18:25 | 48466 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)