69 million page views

Columbia U. and Muslim community

Reader comment on item: Columbia University vs. America

Submitted by Gene Lambson (United States), Apr 3, 2003 at 12:26

Interesting comments coming out of C.U. and other parts of the world that you mention in this article. They fit very well with the pattern one would expect when a culture is faced with extinction, but hasn't yet become conciously aware of that fact yet. The late Prof. Harris ("Cannibals and Kings" - did you ever get a chance to read it? ) would have recognized what's happening and what will happen over the next 20 or 30 years.

I've read a few glimmers of recognition from some people in the press recently, but I don't get a feeling that there's widespread realization that the culture that births the kind of violence and terror that we've seen is doomed.
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (136) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
45 Communist Goals for America [176 words]Frank P.Nov 9, 2005 16:1828103
"Joseph Massad" is but a tool of the enemy [52 words]Lance K.Feb 7, 2005 18:5920151
Is DeGenova still on staff? [17 words]Doug DawsonJan 28, 2005 20:5719955
Anti American remarks [90 words]C. RosselMay 29, 2007 22:5019955
Comments like these by the "professor" [128 words]Paul in OklahomaJan 8, 2005 21:2119533
Reply to Chris Adams: This kind of indoctornation makes me ashamed to go to any university [254 words]LaurenJul 9, 2003 18:559964
Orwellian definition of Israel as a "racist" state [295 words]Leonard ApplebaumJun 2, 2003 05:349320
COLUMBIA VS AMERICA [85 words]CAESAR M. WARRINGTONApr 17, 2003 18:088437
Well said Mr. Warrington [242 words]yolanda s. cabreraJan 6, 2007 09:328437
Deeply Irrelevant [66 words]Bill HadneyApr 15, 2003 17:508379
In reply to Chris Adams. [199 words]Mike MacConnellApr 14, 2003 08:458342
To DeGenova: You ought to be ashamed!!! [62 words]Bruce SmithApr 10, 2003 21:238253
United...States? [403 words]Justin KleinApr 10, 2003 18:088249
Equal opportunity [175 words]DuckApr 9, 2003 20:068226
Get rid of them. [7 words]Walter MontgomeryApr 9, 2003 13:258218
Letter to Dept of Education [417 words]Pam MorganApr 9, 2003 04:128200
Fire De Genova [189 words]BeruskaApr 9, 2003 01:478194
Thank God schools like Columbia still exists! [230 words]Chris AdamsApr 8, 2003 00:068131
Shame [58 words]John Bruce CiarrierApr 7, 2003 20:588129
Congratulations [25 words]Edwina KhedouriApr 7, 2003 10:118110
[213 words]Mike RicottaApr 7, 2003 07:528107
Another interesting fact [22 words]AlphaApr 7, 2003 02:398101
The Columbia School of Hate [496 words]Arlinda DeAngelisApr 6, 2003 11:598096
Columbia: Do the Right Thing...Fire Degenova [60 words]Andrew J. PadillaApr 6, 2003 09:268094
Freedom of Speech [304 words]Yaakov ElefantApr 6, 2003 05:038090
Expelling professors [37 words]Dan in Southlake, TXApr 5, 2003 23:558087
Columbia vs America [55 words]Gary RiceApr 5, 2003 23:128086
American Parents [57 words]Vivian E. WolfeApr 5, 2003 18:538077
DeGenova and Sadam Hussein [104 words]sheila miyoshi jagerApr 5, 2003 18:518076
Frustration [89 words]Ken BesigApr 5, 2003 16:348073
appointment [48 words]Marvin JohnsonApr 5, 2003 14:548070
Shame on Columbia [27 words]William ThomasApr 5, 2003 10:238065
A Shame and a Travesty [39 words]E SiegmundApr 5, 2003 10:088064
sad state of affairs [29 words]Tim HolteApr 5, 2003 09:288063
Disgraceful [37 words]john pappasApr 5, 2003 00:358056
Congratulations...and everyone back him up! [43 words]MWhittonApr 4, 2003 23:048053
Conservative Values Fair Game [185 words]Bob ClockApr 4, 2003 22:538052
Context is everthing [50 words]Jon HennesseeApr 4, 2003 22:158050
1Conservative scholars need to work together, counter the ideology of the left [253 words]Paul R. HuardApr 4, 2003 22:088049
Thank You!!!! [24 words]Richard SchmitzApr 4, 2003 17:398042
Why is dissent so problematic? [193 words]Brian AndersonApr 4, 2003 15:408039
Ignorance TEACHING Ignorance [235 words]Kathryn BrownApr 4, 2003 11:518032
Looking at islam [111 words]Godbole, VasudevApr 4, 2003 10:528030
Columbia comments [48 words]JimApr 4, 2003 08:148027
Far Left Professors [71 words]Jerene1820Apr 4, 2003 07:248026
1With freedoms come responsibility & consequences [173 words]T AndersonApr 3, 2003 22:198020
Shame- What if they were racial slurs? [64 words]MichaelApr 3, 2003 21:518018
Comments like these by the "professor" [127 words]Paul in OklahomaApr 3, 2003 21:248014
Columbia no longer the "Gem of the Ocean" [85 words]paul e. schwabApr 3, 2003 20:338011
Nichilas DeGenova [95 words]Charles ChristineApr 3, 2003 18:238009
Insanity [76 words]Joseph RothmanApr 3, 2003 17:528008
Re: Send Your Kid to Columbia? [46 words]Green WallaceApr 3, 2003 16:508006
Genova Info here [260 words]jennApr 3, 2003 16:458005
Ivory Towers [98 words]Greg GardnerApr 3, 2003 15:598004
Terminate him [220 words]G. FrederickApr 3, 2003 15:498002
Slouching Toward Irrelevance [177 words]Bill HadneyApr 3, 2003 13:408000
Maybe we ought to go back [178 words]Bob LamoreauxApr 3, 2003 12:577997
Columbia U. and Muslim community [119 words]Gene LambsonApr 3, 2003 12:267996
Some students surpass their instructors [50 words]MorkApr 3, 2003 11:177995
Why is anyone surprised? [304 words]joe harrisonApr 3, 2003 10:217991
Withdraw Support of Enemies of Reason and America [35 words]Ralph C.Whaley MDApr 3, 2003 07:257990
To Susan-Freedom To Speak Our Minds [58 words]William D. CookApr 3, 2003 06:437987
Academic mentally unstable. [107 words]Tracy BoudreauxApr 2, 2003 22:517973
Freedom of speech [50 words]Shawn O'nealyApr 2, 2003 22:107970
Columbia Not the Gem of America [131 words]Joan ArchibaldApr 2, 2003 21:577969
Money talks [202 words]Andrew TowneApr 2, 2003 21:357968
Not All Lost At Columbia [83 words]Ron LewenbergApr 2, 2003 21:317967
Columbia U ? [178 words]GeorgeApr 2, 2003 20:407966
Academic hatemonging nothing new [367 words]Michael McCanlesApr 2, 2003 20:097965
Columbia...One of the best? [54 words]Susan A.FishmanApr 2, 2003 18:467963
What if? [48 words]David R. BridgeApr 2, 2003 17:417961
Double-Standards and the danger therein [109 words]Rube LongfellowApr 2, 2003 17:417960
Farewell Columbia! [55 words]Noreen JacksonApr 2, 2003 17:397959
Think about this too [386 words]TobyApr 2, 2003 16:387958
Brave Words From Base Cowards [182 words]Kevin RichardsonApr 2, 2003 13:507955
Gutless mishmosh [99 words]Dolores FigulyApr 2, 2003 13:257954
America bashing [309 words]Sir Daniel TobinApr 2, 2003 13:137951
Columbia University IS Responsible [94 words]Douglas MerzApr 2, 2003 12:397949
Public schools? Or socialist indoctrination? [169 words]Chris ThompsonApr 2, 2003 11:077942
The crowded academic space of 'Understanding Islamic Militancy' [222 words]Jonathan PfefferApr 2, 2003 10:597941
DeGenova's Remarks About Iraq and the American Military [99 words]Robert ObenshainApr 2, 2003 10:567940
Columbia is ok with this [95 words]Frank ShannonApr 2, 2003 10:557939
Ahh. Now I'm Enlightened. [123 words]Mike HessApr 2, 2003 10:497938
Colleges, Universities, Children, and Money [207 words]S. BlackardApr 2, 2003 10:207937
Second comment on professors at Columbia [162 words]Judy SchechterApr 2, 2003 09:517936
How do we respond? [93 words]Judy SchechterApr 2, 2003 09:387935
Against Columbia [93 words]Prof Wm ClaytonApr 2, 2003 08:147932
See Article on Iraqi-Americans [88 words]James W. S imsApr 2, 2003 07:567931
Columbia Univ. vs.America [170 words]S.C.PandaApr 2, 2003 06:397929
Barbarism lives [373 words]Andy TriggsApr 2, 2003 05:397927
Foner, De Genova, et al. [410 words]Michael E. SullivanApr 2, 2003 03:337924
How can we remedy the situation? [234 words]LarryApr 2, 2003 02:537923
Disgraceful Columbia University [50 words]Alan A. GrosserApr 2, 2003 01:337922
Nationalism as the root of all evil [101 words]Ben ArkinApr 2, 2003 00:267919
1How to protect freedom from itself? [450 words]Aaron UrisApr 1, 2003 22:397915
Hear a tirade, fear a whisper [191 words]Garry PriorApr 1, 2003 22:007913
There's more to the universe than just one's beliefs [84 words]Wayne Jerome RogersApr 1, 2003 21:587912
interesting fact [16 words]Howard GoldApr 1, 2003 21:097907
Send Your Kid to Columbia? [15 words]Jim O'BrienApr 1, 2003 20:497905
Columbia vs America (USA) [128 words]R.DavisApr 1, 2003 20:277904
Awareness [52 words]Lucy SilverApr 1, 2003 20:047903
Let them move! [25 words]Mickey PettyApr 1, 2003 19:567902
Time to expose the lies and propaganda of the America haters [249 words]Diana NielsenApr 1, 2003 19:107900
Shameful Columbia Comments [88 words]Dr O'KayApr 1, 2003 18:567897
No surprise [53 words]Sharon CarneyApr 1, 2003 17:517892
Non-Academicians [65 words]Jerry StolzenbergApr 1, 2003 17:307891
Columbia University and Their Wonderful Prof. Nicholas DeGenova [107 words]Gene BiegelApr 1, 2003 17:257888
FIRE DE GENOVA RIGHT NOW [43 words]vinceFeb 11, 2006 15:267888
I support Professor DeGenova's rights, will he support mine? [227 words]LarryFeb 12, 2006 11:107888
1I didn't know it was this bad. [159 words]Richard RheinerApr 1, 2003 17:127887
My letter to Columbia and its response [332 words]Ron GansApr 1, 2003 16:457886
for a million Mogadishus - The other side of the coin [42 words]Barry J. WimberlyApr 1, 2003 16:407885
Nothing new, but it bears repeating [56 words]Menahem DunskyApr 1, 2003 16:397884
Freedom to speak our minds [28 words]Susan BradfordApr 1, 2003 16:207881
So Much Hate, it is frightening! [167 words]Lily TobinApr 1, 2003 16:157880
And I Thought Columbia Was a Place of Education [63 words]Donald J RosenApr 1, 2003 16:077879
Columbia University's Views [93 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Arnie KramerApr 1, 2003 15:417875
THANKS TO DR. PIPES from a former liberal from NJ [71 words]JOE B.Apr 1, 2003 15:367874
Comments [6 words]Eber HaddadApr 1, 2003 15:207872
I was hoping someone would say this. [113 words]Richard ZumaApr 1, 2003 15:087871
Columbia's historical sympathy for fascism emerges again [75 words]Steven MillerApr 1, 2003 14:597870
Thanks for the list [26 words]Wayne SchmittApr 1, 2003 14:457869
All Correct! [62 words]AlexanderApr 1, 2003 14:007863
Hypocrisy of De Genova [85 words]Michael OberndorfApr 1, 2003 13:327862
anti-american academics [297 words]mark a jacobs mdApr 1, 2003 13:307861
degenova comments [106 words]jonathan turkelApr 1, 2003 13:027859
Columbia University's sponsorship of hate [198 words]anonymousApr 1, 2003 12:437857
Revolting! [25 words]David M. FrostApr 1, 2003 12:427856
Shame on my School [82 words]Steven HessApr 1, 2003 12:337854
DeGenova calls for the genocide of our enemies as well? [139 words]Michael JoyceApr 1, 2003 12:077853
Fundamentalism [152 words]Fay VoshellApr 1, 2003 11:527852
The Foner Connection [158 words]Fred FrishmanApr 1, 2003 11:447851
Liberal Ethnocentrism [198 words]AvrahamApr 1, 2003 11:357849
Columbia is the norm [198 words]Glenn KlotzApr 1, 2003 10:517848
Is it because today is April 1? [73 words]Wallace Edward BrandApr 1, 2003 10:267846
Yet another cuckoo with tenure. [92 words]Kevin M.Apr 1, 2003 09:247842

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)