| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
Internal discontinuity
Reader comment on item: Combating the Ideology of Radical Islam
Submitted by Zach Allen (United States), Apr 14, 2003 at 09:03
In one paragraph of the article you state: There is no such thing as a moderate Islamist.In the penultimate paragraph you state: The solution is to support moderate Islamists even if they do not explicitly renounce violence as a political tool.
That leaves me wondering what you really meant. Could you clarify, please.
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
Daniel Pipes replies:
The first statement is mine; the second is Graham Fuller's.DP
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (86) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| why not [41 words] | jack steenbarger | Apr 21, 2010 21:13 | 171548 | ||
| RADICAL ISLAM FROM A SOCIAL PERSPECTIVE [161 words] | R .WOOD | Dec 17, 2009 08:11 | 165962 | ||
| ignorenace is a harmful wapon [231 words] | Nora | Feb 18, 2009 20:04 | 150755 | ||
 Naivete [98 words] | Knave | Dec 19, 2009 16:12 | 150755 | ||
| jihad is a holy WAR [238 words] | waterguessen | Dec 19, 2008 22:47 | 145466 | ||
| 1 | 99.999999% muslims are islamics [67 words] | Mohd suhel | Aug 19, 2008 05:51 | 137005 | |
| Radical Islamists or Cultists? [239 words] | Maudi | Aug 6, 2008 07:31 | 136349 | ||
| 4 | Take the fight, on to the street. [40 words] | Matthew Haysom | May 28, 2008 10:57 | 130319 | |
| 2 | THE ONLY WAY TO WIN IS NOT TO PLAY (ATHEIST PERSPECTIVE) [109 words] | ATHEIST | Sep 1, 2008 04:37 | 130319 | |
| Wrong is wrong and right is right [295 words] | Antiworldly | Oct 18, 2009 17:32 | 130319 | ||
| Check your facts [237 words] | Confused | Nov 22, 2010 23:31 | 130319 | ||
| 7 | How do I fight back against radical Islam [105 words] | David H McLeish | Jan 6, 2008 17:48 | 117605 | |
| By searching for truth! [754 words] | PDM | Jan 6, 2008 20:18 | 117605 | ||
| Dear Sir David H McLeish [180 words] | Ynnatchkah | Jan 6, 2008 21:32 | 117605 | ||
| Semper Fidelis.... [153 words] | donvan | Jan 7, 2008 10:42 | 117605 | ||
| What can I do [413 words] | blackman | Apr 2, 2008 18:37 | 117605 | ||
| Speak out Against Radical Islam--Don't Bow to Terror [147 words] | 51 year old, 115-lb. woman who'd like to beat down a radical extremist before I die | Sep 10, 2014 20:31 | 117605 | ||
| "Islamist" vs. "Islam" [143 words] | Barry Wolfe | Apr 11, 2006 12:40 | 42927 | ||
| 1 | Combating Islamism [22 words] | Clifford Ishii | May 29, 2005 14:12 | 22467 | |
| A Nation of optimism [65 words] | Tom Kunzie | Jul 25, 2006 22:59 | 22467 | ||
| The failure of the American-Islamic discourse [268 words] | Ibn Filastin | Apr 30, 2005 22:35 | 21907 | ||
| What? [335 words] | Maudi | Aug 6, 2008 08:45 | 21907 | ||
| 1 | Islamic justification of violence [200 words] | Henry Rebello | Dec 4, 2004 05:25 | 18851 | |
| 2 | The real face of Islam [186 words] | John D'souza | Dec 4, 2004 05:12 | 18850 | |
| wrong conclusions about islam [96 words] | Marwan Tawashi | Feb 3, 2007 15:22 | 18850 | ||
| a challenge to muslims - stop deluding yourselves [121 words] | basil | Jun 27, 2009 15:35 | 18850 | ||
| Very true statements [34 words] | Too late to bicker | Oct 18, 2009 18:04 | 18850 | ||
| Two dangerous ideas [584 words] | David Isecke | Apr 19, 2003 01:49 | 8461 | ||
| Philosophy of Islam [94 words] | Don | Apr 18, 2003 17:03 | 8456 | ||
| Moderate Islamist [158 words] | dane | Apr 17, 2003 17:34 | 8436 | ||
| Clashes of Interest? [181 words] | Matt Murray | Apr 16, 2003 17:32 | 8408 | ||
| 3 | The reinventing of Islam [1147 words] | Daniel Kayes Thomson | Apr 16, 2003 11:42 | 8396 | |
| 2 | Brave and correct Rabbi Daniel Kayes Thomson [17 words] | ELIJAH HA NAVI | Jul 19, 2006 16:43 | 8396 | |
| Bismillah. Take a Look [222 words] | Faheem Munir | Dec 17, 2006 00:58 | 8396 | ||
| 1 | Moderate Islamists? [65 words] | Neil Lewis | Apr 15, 2003 22:52 | 8382 | |
| Islamism [66 words] | Muhammad Siddiqui | Apr 15, 2003 17:22 | 8378 | ||
| Vilification of Islamism [123 words] | Don Van SICKLE | Apr 15, 2003 12:29 | 8374 | ||
| Fighting Islamist Ideology (read Sayyid Qutb) [189 words] | Jon | Apr 15, 2003 10:55 | 8371 | ||
| Rough road ahead fellows [178 words] | Peter Yorkoski | Feb 21, 2007 01:46 | 8371 | ||
| What about Muhammad and the Quran? [142 words] | Rick Flanders | Apr 15, 2003 02:26 | 8365 | ||
| Rethink "Moderates" [235 words] | Boycat | Apr 15, 2003 00:52 | 8364 | ||
| Stop thinking like westerners [285 words] | Peter Yorkoski | Feb 21, 2007 02:26 | 8364 | ||
| CAIR and the ACLU. Enough said. [127 words] | Keith | Apr 14, 2003 22:32 | 8363 | ||
| CAIR [146 words] | Marwan Tawashi | Feb 4, 2007 04:31 | 8363 | ||
| "Moderate?" [35 words] | p e | Apr 14, 2003 21:13 | 8362 | ||
| The real enemy is change [209 words] | Dennis Cashen | Apr 14, 2003 18:00 | 8358 | ||
| 1 | Democracy not always best solution [109 words] | Syd Veritask | Apr 14, 2003 15:06 | 8357 | |
| 3 | Democracy: Government with limited power [92 words] | Stephen Berman | Apr 14, 2003 14:00 | 8353 | |
| Islamists may "fail" but they don't willingly unelect themselves. [199 words] | Matthew Kennel | Apr 14, 2003 13:59 | 8352 | ||
| Islam is indeed the problem. [38 words] | Emmanuel Goldstein | Apr 14, 2003 13:35 | 8350 | ||
| You may fight but we will win [34 words] | Patz | Dec 4, 2007 23:38 | 8350 | ||
| MODERATE ISLAM [128 words] | WHIP | Sep 22, 2009 16:50 | 8350 | ||
| The moderates need to speak up a little louder! [170 words] | fenix | Apr 14, 2003 13:29 | 8348 | ||
| Democracy & Islamists [310 words] | Glenn Klotz | Apr 14, 2003 13:06 | 8347 | ||
| It'll never work... [124 words] | Mark | Apr 14, 2003 12:20 | 8346 | ||
| Democracy is the Key [94 words] | Susan Bradford | Apr 14, 2003 09:10 | 8344 | ||
 Internal discontinuity [52 words]w/response from Daniel Pipes | Zach Allen | Apr 14, 2003 09:03 | 8343 | ||
| Saudi Arabia self-described Islamist State [50 words] | Ron Fox | Apr 14, 2003 07:42 | 8341 | ||
| Democracy vs Liberty and Islamism [299 words] | Gordon Mullings | Apr 14, 2003 07:18 | 8340 | ||
| Co-authors disagree [186 words] | JMH | Apr 13, 2003 22:41 | 8334 | ||
| ISLAM IS NOT THE ENEMY? [246 words] | Mike Davis | Apr 13, 2003 22:36 | 8333 | ||
| Christian,Muslim? [103 words] | Amal | Jan 12, 2007 12:18 | 8333 | ||
| The gap between our interests [150 words] | Lenn Chow | Apr 13, 2003 18:51 | 8330 | ||
| In agreement with Pipes [56 words] | Etta Heller | Apr 13, 2003 14:29 | 8327 | ||
| Does Moderate Islam Really Exist? [130 words] | Richard Rheiner | Apr 13, 2003 13:47 | 8325 | ||
| Moderates have a big problem [88 words] | Paladin | Dec 22, 2009 22:58 | 8325 | ||
| Holes in arguments [937 words] | John Vander Voort | Apr 13, 2003 06:27 | 8315 | ||
| Staggering!!! [93 words] | Monty | Apr 13, 2003 03:50 | 8313 | ||
| Understanding Islamism, Effects on American Policy [725 words] | Yirmeyahu Ben-David | Apr 13, 2003 03:06 | 8309 | ||
| Illiberal Civil Society? [134 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Anthony Chase | Apr 13, 2003 01:42 | 8307 | ||
| Personal view [164 words] | E. J. Blumberg | Apr 13, 2003 01:04 | 8306 | ||
| The battle is between...? [77 words] | Stephan Dedalus | Apr 13, 2003 00:18 | 8305 | ||
| New Islam Movement [2596 words] | Zoya | Apr 13, 2003 00:09 | 8304 | ||
| re: New Islam Movement [67 words] | Mustafa McPherson | Sep 4, 2007 18:58 | 8304 | ||
| Need to be explicit [151 words] | Boris Frenkel | Apr 12, 2003 23:07 | 8300 | ||
| Source of the Problem [358 words] | Wiilliam James Bonnesar | Apr 12, 2003 21:54 | 8299 | ||
| Another Consideration [22 words] | Mack Payne | Dec 21, 2010 10:54 | 8299 | ||
| Refresh Your Thoughts [17 words] | Mack Pfayne | Feb 5, 2011 15:16 | 8299 | ||
| Two dangerous ideas [584 words] | David Isecke | Apr 12, 2003 21:47 | 8297 | ||
| elections [29 words] | Al Green | Apr 12, 2003 21:41 | 8296 | ||
| militant theology & militant theocrats [69 words] | MPaul Hansen | Apr 12, 2003 20:48 | 8295 | ||
| The Core of the Matter [404 words] | C.C. Courington | Apr 12, 2003 20:04 | 8294 | ||
| Moderate Islamists, an Oxymoron [188 words] | Jan David Romanoff | Apr 12, 2003 20:03 | 8293 | ||
| 1 | I'm with "Will of Allah" [171 words] | Clarky | May 16, 2008 10:51 | 8293 | |
| Radical or moderate Islamic Muslims? [158 words] | Helen | Jun 21, 2008 17:29 | 8293 | ||
| Will of Allah [563 words] | Charles Oren | Apr 12, 2003 17:39 | 8291 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)