| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
"Irredentist" ?
Reader comment on item: Why Oslo's Hopes Turned to Dust
Submitted by Virginia Thogersen (United States), Sep 10, 2003 at 10:32
"Palestinians have irredentist dreams... "irredenta \n : a territory historically or ethnically related to one political unit but presently subject to another (Webster's)
irredentism \ n : a political principle or policy directed toward the incorporation of irredentas within the boundaries of their historically or ethnically related political unit (Webster's)
I had to look it up. I couldn't imagine any kind of dream about dentists that would not be a nightmare.
Dislike
Submitting....
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (99) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Hashimites- Gershon [85 words] | Eddie kiswani | Nov 13, 2005 04:45 | 28308 | ||
| Why Oslo Hopes Turned to dust 09 Sep 2003 [36 words] | S.C.Panda | Oct 16, 2003 04:02 | 11801 | ||
| Let Pres. Bush know... [154 words] | Judith L. Schechter | Oct 2, 2003 10:03 | 11653 | ||
 Weapons of Mass Distruction [64 words] | M.Bambridge | May 1, 2006 13:26 | 11653 | ||
| Weapons of Mass Destruction. [35 words] | Maxine Bambridge | May 1, 2006 20:31 | 11653 | ||
| Coptic Pharaonic Republic represented 18 Million Coptic in Egypt [10 words] | C.P.R. Government in exile | Oct 1, 2003 13:03 | 11617 | ||
| Mr. Pipes zeros in on the *real* problem [214 words] | ramo | Sep 26, 2003 09:59 | 11512 | ||
| If only Mr. Pipes completed the picture... [284 words] | Patrick Friel | Sep 25, 2003 14:35 | 11503 | ||
| Don't stereotype the multi-sided parties to the conflict [264 words] | Gary Newman | Sep 21, 2003 07:03 | 11380 | ||
| 2 | Muslim Israeli? [149 words] | Yk | Sep 19, 2003 15:48 | 11344 | |
| serb hater [15 words] | serb hater | Feb 4, 2007 10:54 | 11344 | ||
| "Basic Premise" [195 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | G. Wood | Sep 18, 2003 23:20 | 11324 | ||
| See: it got a few takers [186 words] | Alain Jean-Mairet | May 2, 2006 07:42 | 11324 | ||
| Hypocrites [83 words] | Jack Higgins | Sep 17, 2003 21:08 | 11286 | ||
| Never Forget [25 words] | Robert Stamos | Sep 17, 2003 16:55 | 11284 | ||
| There is only one test for the PA, deal with terrorism [401 words] | Jonathan Pfeffer | Sep 17, 2003 03:05 | 11275 | ||
| I don't understand [104 words] | Richard Ellis | Sep 16, 2003 21:49 | 11271 | ||
| A VERY SIMPLE SOLUTION TO END THE VIOLENCE [111 words] | Jenny | Sep 16, 2003 15:55 | 11266 | ||
| Israeli government must share some culpability. [202 words] | Tim Das | Sep 15, 2003 09:28 | 11257 | ||
| Wrong assumptions. [409 words] | Motty Perel | Sep 15, 2003 00:22 | 11253 | ||
| ...[T]he right policies.... [162 words] | Charles T. G. Pickett | Sep 13, 2003 04:32 | 11243 | ||
| Hamas Covenant [68 words] | Jukian Wasserman | Sep 13, 2003 01:48 | 11241 | ||
| After the dust clears [19 words] | Mark | Sep 13, 2003 01:27 | 11237 | ||
| Do the Palestinians Really Want a State as More than Just a Means for Defeating Israel? [232 words] | Avi Sharabi | Sep 12, 2003 18:20 | 11232 | ||
| Why Oslo's Hopes Turned to Dust [235 words] | Roger Norman | Sep 12, 2003 15:50 | 11230 | ||
| Correction to Number of Casualties [86 words] | Michael Gruda | Sep 12, 2003 09:19 | 11224 | ||
| We are privileged to have you! [24 words] | Ed Kaplan | Sep 11, 2003 20:56 | 11217 | ||
| The unspoken additional price for peace [130 words] | Haym L. Rabinovitz | Sep 11, 2003 19:07 | 11216 | ||
| Many thanks [101 words] | Steven Schipper | Sep 11, 2003 17:52 | 11214 | ||
| Amen [39 words] | henry m rosenbaum | Sep 11, 2003 14:42 | 11211 | ||
| YOU DA MAN [11 words] | Shimon Lobel | Sep 11, 2003 13:32 | 11208 | ||
| Peace with Terrorists [108 words] | Arlinda DeAngelis | Sep 11, 2003 04:44 | 11206 | ||
| Failure of a 'two state solution' [94 words] | Fred S | Sep 11, 2003 03:13 | 11205 | ||
| How do you? [133 words] | robert fusfeld | Sep 10, 2003 22:14 | 11198 | ||
| Turn Israel loose [78 words] | Rev. George Guillory | Sep 10, 2003 21:17 | 11196 | ||
| Isn't it obvious? [218 words] | Thomas Sheehan | Sep 10, 2003 21:03 | 11195 | ||
| response [104 words] | Gershon Y. Perry, M.D., F.A.C.C. | Sep 10, 2003 19:52 | 11194 | ||
| sensible and logical approach [24 words] | Dr. Matania Ginosar | Sep 10, 2003 19:47 | 11193 | ||
| First you need a PR campaign [622 words] | Byron | Sep 10, 2003 19:31 | 11192 | ||
| Oslo, The Road Map and other mistakes [60 words] | Lindsey Binnie | Sep 10, 2003 18:05 | 11191 | ||
| Thank You [49 words] | Denise Clark | Sep 10, 2003 17:21 | 11188 | ||
| Clarify the message and win the hearts and minds of the Plestinians. [125 words] | RPaine | Sep 10, 2003 16:06 | 11186 | ||
| 2 state solution to the 'Palestinian' problem. [130 words] | Robert Dietrich | Sep 10, 2003 15:35 | 11185 | ||
| An oversimplification, but true [191 words] | andrew freedman | Sep 10, 2003 13:55 | 11184 | ||
| why oslo was doomed [140 words] | Neil Abramson | Sep 10, 2003 12:47 | 11180 | ||
| Agreed [164 words] | Tom | Sep 10, 2003 10:55 | 11177 | ||
 "Irredentist" ? [69 words] | Virginia Thogersen | Sep 10, 2003 10:32 | 11174 | ||
| Why Oslo's Hopes Turned to Dust: Amen [47 words] | Daniel Wildman | Sep 10, 2003 10:09 | 11173 | ||
| You Speak The Truth [141 words] | M. | Sep 10, 2003 09:44 | 11172 | ||
| YOUR VISION BRINGS HOPE [65 words] | Sheri | Sep 10, 2003 09:29 | 11171 | ||
| Great agenda to pursue in the next decade. However . . . [266 words] | Mark from Missouri | Sep 10, 2003 08:35 | 11168 | ||
| No substitute for Victory [92 words] | Glenn Klotz | Sep 10, 2003 08:30 | 11167 | ||
| The Main Point [31 words] | David Shoup | Sep 10, 2003 07:43 | 11163 | ||
| The Arab curse of having no decent leadership [234 words] | David Hersch | Sep 10, 2003 06:35 | 11162 | ||
| not going far enough [150 words] | yuval brandstetter MD | Sep 10, 2003 06:15 | 11161 | ||
| Why Oslo's Hopes Turned to Dust [340 words] | Beverly Ryan | Sep 10, 2003 03:22 | 11158 | ||
| Comment on -why Oslo's hopes turned to dust [194 words] | yigal koltin | Sep 10, 2003 02:42 | 11157 | ||
| bravo [16 words] | JOSEPH HADDAD | Sep 10, 2003 02:41 | 11156 | ||
| You are right - This is first priority [239 words] | Mary | Sep 10, 2003 02:10 | 11154 | ||
| oslo [22 words] | muhammad Siddiqui | Sep 10, 2003 02:06 | 11153 | ||
| REsponse to your article [22 words] | Kate Willner | Sep 10, 2003 01:52 | 11151 | ||
| intelligent person [12 words] | art stoller | Sep 10, 2003 01:27 | 11149 | ||
| Your false assumption. [224 words] | Sigmund Silber | Sep 10, 2003 01:02 | 11148 | ||
| The lessons of Oslo [122 words] | Jeffrey S. Sheff | Sep 10, 2003 00:56 | 11147 | ||
| Halleluya! [29 words] | sabareete | Sep 10, 2003 00:38 | 11144 | ||
| Thank you [19 words] | S. Weisberg | Sep 10, 2003 00:27 | 11143 | ||
| re: Failed Oslo [31 words] | lily Flacks | Sep 10, 2003 00:15 | 11142 | ||
| Amen! [17 words] | Jean Mallin | Sep 9, 2003 23:57 | 11139 | ||
| Re: Daniel Pipe's Comments on The failure of the Oslo accord. [1117 words] | Reuben Horne | Sep 9, 2003 23:17 | 11138 | ||
| So Simple [132 words] | Len Rossen | Sep 9, 2003 23:11 | 11136 | ||
| Reality [117 words] | Lance Silver | Sep 9, 2003 22:39 | 11135 | ||
| Only a miracle [35 words] | Marion Christiansen | Sep 9, 2003 22:35 | 11134 | ||
| Clinton's complicity [93 words] | Lucas J. Meyer | Sep 9, 2003 21:53 | 11131 | ||
| Absolutely correct. [218 words] | Joseph M. Grossman | Sep 9, 2003 21:47 | 11130 | ||
| How? [142 words] | Mike | Sep 9, 2003 20:35 | 11129 | ||
| It Ain't Gonna Happen [272 words] | Ken Leondar | Sep 9, 2003 18:54 | 11128 | ||
| Completely agree with you [115 words] | Jeffrey Vaks | Sep 9, 2003 17:45 | 11127 | ||
| Why Oslo's [8 words] | Andrei Morozov | Sep 9, 2003 17:28 | 11126 | ||
| Fair and sound suggestions [97 words] | shahin shadmer | Sep 9, 2003 15:14 | 11119 | ||
| A Thought On Dealing Rationally With Those Irrational [67 words] | Bruce L. Murray | Sep 9, 2003 15:07 | 11118 | ||
| Fantastic insight [92 words] | Walter Kopilow | Sep 9, 2003 14:37 | 11117 | ||
| Your proposed peace plans [335 words] | Catherine Logan | Sep 9, 2003 14:20 | 11116 | ||
| A voice from the past [25 words] | Marcia Kelly Illingworth | Jun 22, 2007 17:34 | 11116 | ||
| Approval [39 words] | Steve Mydanick | Sep 9, 2003 13:55 | 11115 | ||
| oslo's Hopes [41 words] | Marilyn Solomon | Sep 9, 2003 13:42 | 11114 | ||
| Root cause of hatred [125 words] | A.A. | Sep 9, 2003 13:24 | 11113 | ||
| Thoughts on Hamas [223 words] | Clintok | Sep 9, 2003 13:03 | 11111 | ||
| This article [35 words] | Ron | Sep 9, 2003 13:01 | 11110 | ||
| Approach for the Next Decade [65 words] | Flora Steinman | Sep 9, 2003 12:39 | 11109 | ||
| 1 | What's the rush? [147 words] | Arthur Cordell | Sep 9, 2003 12:39 | 11108 | |
| If only... [128 words] | Helen Bienstock | Sep 9, 2003 12:32 | 11107 | ||
| Forms of gov't [196 words] | Gene Lambson | Sep 9, 2003 12:17 | 11106 | ||
| Oslo-death toll [19 words] | Jack Rauber | Sep 9, 2003 11:58 | 11105 | ||
| Outstanding Oslo Analysis [121 words] | Adina Kutnicki | Sep 9, 2003 11:57 | 11104 | ||
| Thank you [130 words] | Chava Casper | Sep 9, 2003 11:44 | 11103 | ||
| The truth hurts [141 words] | AJ | Sep 9, 2003 11:41 | 11102 | ||
| Oslo and Road Map Failure [101 words] | Robert Abrams | Sep 9, 2003 11:22 | 11101 | ||
| Let Israel win one war [54 words] | Mike Cohen | Sep 9, 2003 11:12 | 11100 | ||
| Right On! [14 words] | Lynda Kramer | Sep 9, 2003 10:43 | 11099 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)