| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
Wrong on Harvey
Reader comment on item: CAIR's Assault on Paul Harvey
Submitted by Aaron S. Field (United States), Dec 24, 2003 at 08:07
Dear Dr. Pipes,I usually find myself in agreement with you and I echo your concerns about the CAIR, but you've got it wrong on Paul Harvey. By failing to distinguish Islam from Islamism, as you are always careful to do, Mr. Harvey's "religion that encourages killing" comment was offensive and his apology was appropriate, notwithstanding the CAIR's objectionable tactics.
Best,
Aaron S. Field, M.D., Ph.D.
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (126) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | of course C.A.I.R. and the other islamists hate free speech, ...it may lead to truth. . . . Feb 2010. [96 words] | Phil Greend | Feb 28, 2010 17:09 | 169504 | |
| 1 | GESTAPO tactic of CAIR [59 words] | Charles V. Scott | Oct 30, 2006 15:27 | 64818 | |
| 1 | cair [65 words] | billy miniaci | Oct 24, 2006 20:07 | 64398 | |
| 1 | It's about time!!! [64 words] | Rick Green | Oct 13, 2006 14:04 | 60242 | |
| 1 | I support Paul Harvey !!!!! [30 words] | Elmer Flemmer | Sep 1, 2006 13:55 | 54614 | |
| Paul Harvey [88 words] | Rebekah | Feb 3, 2006 00:17 | 33588 | ||
| 1 | answering to muslims [10 words] | thomas kj daniel | Jan 29, 2006 15:08 | 33025 | |
| GE sponsoring Paul Harvey again [250 words] | Liliane Stern | Apr 27, 2005 16:02 | 21860 | ||
| Late in the game, I also wrote to GE (in case they think we forgot) [192 words] | Huge Fann | Mar 27, 2004 04:16 | 14383 | ||
| What did Paul Harvey Actually do Wrong? [22 words] | Me | Jan 21, 2004 13:55 | 13469 | ||
| Islamic Debate [118 words] | Ray W. | Jan 19, 2004 21:58 | 13413 | ||
 DONT COME TO CONCLUSIONS WITHOUT FACTS !!! [234 words] | MAK | Jul 28, 2011 18:20 | 13413 | ||
| Your comments on Islam [75 words] | Linus M Brewer DDS | Jan 4, 2004 10:55 | 13080 | ||
| 1 | The True Meaning of Islam [41 words] | Abbas | Aug 22, 2006 15:09 | 13080 | |
| 14 | Allah is Light (Energy) [692 words] | Nisar Ahmed | Dec 12, 2007 04:07 | 13080 | |
| 3 | the most hypocritical religion: [58 words] | ahmadwes | May 17, 2008 16:54 | 13080 | |
| 1 | Islam and quran [62 words] | awais kazmi | Feb 19, 2009 16:25 | 13080 | |
| christians [7 words] | raven mcdonald | Apr 27, 2009 10:05 | 13080 | ||
| islam [171 words] | caroline gatt | Nov 20, 2009 05:21 | 13080 | ||
| islam the buetifuln and peaceful religion!!!!!!! [96 words] | aya | Nov 27, 2009 07:22 | 13080 | ||
| Islam and Free Will [196 words] | Rich | Nov 29, 2009 13:19 | 13080 | ||
| So, islam is just misunderstood? I don't think so - except by idiots like you.... [145 words] | Rich | Nov 30, 2009 22:31 | 13080 | ||
| Islam Exposed---what is it all about? [200 words] | Ahmed | Aug 28, 2010 22:02 | 13080 | ||
| islam [27 words] | slim.syni | Sep 4, 2010 08:21 | 13080 | ||
| Countering of Islam [54 words] | Muhammed | Nov 12, 2010 13:19 | 13080 | ||
| 2 | Muslims, not the media or the terrorists, tells us about Islam [300 words] | Rajeev | Nov 17, 2010 03:03 | 13080 | |
| Response to : the most hypocritical religion: by ahmadwes [108 words] | Alex | Apr 19, 2011 13:28 | 13080 | ||
| Understanding Of Idea [82 words] | ishmail | Feb 12, 2015 18:32 | 13080 | ||
| ... Honestly [237 words] | Robi | Aug 12, 2015 23:50 | 13080 | ||
| 1 | GE is a coward [120 words] | Sam I. | Jan 2, 2004 17:45 | 13057 | |
| 2 | Islam not only religion encouraging killing [154 words] | Charles R.L. Power | Jan 2, 2004 15:30 | 13055 | |
| knowledge is part of what you believe [56 words] | Sara | Feb 21, 2007 17:29 | 13055 | ||
| Islam still profess murder, others do not... [27 words] | charmie | Feb 25, 2011 05:52 | 13055 | ||
| I agree but.... [145 words] | Ray | Jun 11, 2013 00:46 | 13055 | ||
| What will eventually transpire [91 words] | Paul D | Jan 2, 2004 08:53 | 13048 | ||
| GE/Paul Harvey [65 words] | Sherman Frager | Jan 1, 2004 20:51 | 13042 | ||
| Discredit Islam to End Terrorism [258 words] | John E. Matheny | Jan 1, 2004 05:03 | 13034 | ||
| CAIR's Assalault on Paul Harvey Art.1374 [112 words] | S.C.Panda | Dec 31, 2003 05:09 | 13020 | ||
| The abuse of the boycott weapon [255 words] | Ken Besig | Dec 30, 2003 19:33 | 13014 | ||
| A source of wonder [96 words] | Jeannt Zanger | Dec 29, 2003 18:06 | 12989 | ||
| reaction to cair [32 words] | george h solot | Dec 29, 2003 15:34 | 12986 | ||
| Political Correctness [9 words] | J Vincent | Dec 29, 2003 13:02 | 12984 | ||
| My E-Mail to GE [96 words] | Howard N. Singer | Dec 28, 2003 16:58 | 12975 | ||
| GE & Corporate Cowardice [139 words] | Ray Quigley | Dec 28, 2003 15:31 | 12973 | ||
| Boycotting GE [28 words] | Larry George | Dec 28, 2003 12:14 | 12967 | ||
| left-wing [17 words] | Octavio Johanson | Dec 28, 2003 09:46 | 12965 | ||
| Paul Harvey/GE [35 words] | Michael Appel | Dec 27, 2003 19:47 | 12959 | ||
| 1 | Nonsense [53 words] | Marvin Kravetsky | Dec 27, 2003 18:37 | 12958 | |
| CAIR's attack on Paul Harvey [53 words] | Evelyn Sepin | Dec 27, 2003 14:14 | 12956 | ||
| GE caves in for the CAIR Hate-Mongers [118 words] | mae | Dec 27, 2003 13:54 | 12955 | ||
| Yes and no [126 words] | john mcginley | Dec 27, 2003 13:35 | 12954 | ||
| Comparable Tactics [87 words] | Guy W. Kleinert | Dec 27, 2003 01:47 | 12946 | ||
| Paul Harvey [44 words] | Shirley | Dec 26, 2003 22:13 | 12943 | ||
| Both Sides [40 words] | Dr. Randall Feld | Dec 26, 2003 22:04 | 12942 | ||
| In defense of Paul Harvey & Free Speech [83 words] | LEE | Dec 26, 2003 16:32 | 12940 | ||
| Errosion of Freedom of Speech [76 words] | Pat English | May 17, 2009 21:16 | 12940 | ||
| The reality of Israeli-Palestinian political relations [66 words] | G. Wood | Dec 26, 2003 16:05 | 12939 | ||
| Copy of e-mail sent to GE [61 words] | John Katon | Dec 26, 2003 15:37 | 12938 | ||
| 1 | My Letter to Mr. Sheffer [377 words] | Dennis Murphy | Dec 26, 2003 15:31 | 12937 | |
| Stand up for truth in journalism [54 words] | Harriett Porch | Dec 26, 2003 13:30 | 12935 | ||
| GE threat to one is a threat to all [68 words] | A. Lee Stewart | Dec 26, 2003 13:12 | 12933 | ||
| Long live free speech! [68 words] | kevin | Dec 26, 2003 11:28 | 12932 | ||
| Boycott G.E. [16 words] | Myint Aung | Dec 26, 2003 10:59 | 12931 | ||
| My Email to Gary Sheffer at GE [94 words] | RPaine | Dec 26, 2003 02:58 | 12925 | ||
| Animal Rights in Islam? [197 words] | Mike Ramirez | Dec 25, 2003 19:33 | 12922 | ||
| How to contact GE and others? [29 words] | Steve Kobrin | Dec 25, 2003 19:26 | 12921 | ||
| CAIR---Displaying the Nature of Islamic Politics [216 words] | John Borgman, Jr. | Dec 25, 2003 12:21 | 12914 | ||
| Why don't we boycott GE? [31 words] | Amos B. Israel | Dec 25, 2003 10:30 | 12910 | ||
| Counter-boycott [126 words] | Hugh Fitzgerald | Dec 25, 2003 01:33 | 12904 | ||
| CAIR offensive on Paul Harvey [35 words] | harold fox | Dec 24, 2003 22:19 | 12901 | ||
| PAUL HARVEY [48 words] | milt welsh | Dec 24, 2003 22:03 | 12899 | ||
| no surprise [52 words] | forrest shalom | Dec 24, 2003 21:24 | 12897 | ||
| CAIR'S assault on Paul Harvey [11 words] | Fred Schwartz | Dec 24, 2003 19:06 | 12896 | ||
| Paul Harvey and CAIR [66 words] | carol barnett | Dec 24, 2003 18:28 | 12895 | ||
| Cockfighting and CAIR [25 words] | Peter J. Herz | Dec 24, 2003 18:27 | 12894 | ||
| Freedom of speech [206 words] | abraham lonzo | Dec 24, 2003 18:23 | 12893 | ||
| Paul Harvey/CAIR [29 words] | Elizabeth Marks | Dec 24, 2003 18:20 | 12892 | ||
| 2 | Paul Harvey's remark about Islam [136 words] | shirley majors | Dec 24, 2003 18:11 | 12891 | |
| Paul Harvey [25 words] | D. M. Miller | Dec 24, 2003 18:02 | 12890 | ||
| Is CAIR violating US Law? [28 words] | Bernard Ross | Dec 24, 2003 17:04 | 12888 | ||
| CAIR tries to silence free speech!!! [85 words] | tabingins911 | Jan 31, 2008 11:03 | 12888 | ||
| SHARON'S SPEECH [1212 words] | Michael Green | Dec 24, 2003 16:37 | 12886 | ||
| millions for paul harvey not a penny for tribute [32 words] | william f wyman | Dec 24, 2003 15:54 | 12885 | ||
| Compromising Principles for peace [194 words] | Darwin Barrett | Dec 24, 2003 15:27 | 12882 | ||
| SUPPORT PAUL HARVEY, BOYCOTT GE [53 words] | Sheri Whalen | Dec 24, 2003 13:58 | 12877 | ||
| hot heads [53 words] | martin | Dec 24, 2003 13:54 | 12876 | ||
| Religion of destruction [45 words] | S. Tunali | Dec 24, 2003 13:50 | 12875 | ||
| Support Paul Harvey [76 words] | Muriel Efron | Dec 24, 2003 13:50 | 12874 | ||
| Re CAIR's attempt to silence Paul Harvey [65 words] | Ruth Yancey | Dec 24, 2003 13:22 | 12870 | ||
| Paul Harvey [39 words] | Rosemary Reyes | Dec 24, 2003 13:18 | 12869 | ||
| U.S. right wing also rejects free speech [131 words] | Lawrence Rosler | Dec 24, 2003 13:03 | 12868 | ||
| Religionists Fall Prey Also [150 words] | John Voisey | Dec 24, 2003 12:45 | 12867 | ||
| Paul Harvey and the Islamofacists [139 words] | Frederick Remington | Dec 24, 2003 12:41 | 12866 | ||
| Fight back [23 words] | Tom Pensyl | Dec 24, 2003 12:33 | 12864 | ||
| how to fight this version of organized crime [199 words] | michael fisher | Dec 24, 2003 12:32 | 12863 | ||
| Thanks for information on Paul Harvey and CaIR [28 words] | Vivian Bernstein | Dec 24, 2003 12:17 | 12861 | ||
| Let GE be the first whose products and services we no longer purchase [178 words] | Peter Jessen | Dec 24, 2003 12:05 | 12858 | ||
| Paul Harvey--GE, etc. [41 words] | Herman Fleisher | Dec 24, 2003 11:47 | 12855 | ||
| THE PROFF IS IN THE READING [168 words] | Fred Keller | Dec 24, 2003 11:46 | 12854 | ||
| Boycotts are an American tradition too [49 words] | George P. Wood | Dec 24, 2003 11:45 | 12853 | ||
| sent your commments to GE [117 words] | Maryallene Otis | Dec 24, 2003 11:03 | 12850 | ||
| Re: Paul Harvey and CAIR [114 words] | Dan Katcher | Dec 24, 2003 10:53 | 12849 | ||
| Countering CAIR's Influence [170 words] | m. Bean | Dec 24, 2003 10:46 | 12848 | ||
| Similarities among the three Monotheistic Religions [207 words] | Joseph PEREA | Dec 24, 2003 10:33 | 12847 | ||
| 1 | Difference between Christians and Muslims [97 words] | Rebekah | Feb 2, 2006 23:24 | 12847 | |
| Pretty sad really [353 words] | Whildcat | Sep 17, 2006 01:44 | 12847 | ||
| why people go to makkah [54 words] | adel | Nov 27, 2006 18:38 | 12847 | ||
| i am a christian dating a muslim man [49 words] | diane | Aug 31, 2008 19:34 | 12847 | ||
| religion which encourages killing? [19 words] | Nathan Lindenbaum | Dec 24, 2003 10:22 | 12845 | ||
| CAIR & Harvey [101 words] | ed marsh | Dec 24, 2003 10:21 | 12844 | ||
| Paul Harvey is not the only one.......... [21 words] | Ian Azizollahoff | Dec 24, 2003 10:20 | 12842 | ||
| Paul Harvey [205 words] | Doug Anderson | Dec 24, 2003 10:17 | 12841 | ||
| Fear for Civilisation [175 words] | Stephen Jones | Dec 24, 2003 10:12 | 12840 | ||
| CAIR's apparent strength an illusion [322 words] | Ronald Proby | Dec 24, 2003 10:00 | 12839 | ||
| RE: CAIR's Assault on Paul Harvey [100 words] | Anne | Dec 24, 2003 09:42 | 12838 | ||
| on second thought [77 words] | marty schneer | Dec 24, 2003 09:33 | 12836 | ||
| GE Succumbs to CAIR [425 words] | Arlinda DeAngelis | Dec 24, 2003 09:21 | 12835 | ||
| Paul Harvey sponsors [95 words] | Marc Segan | Dec 24, 2003 08:49 | 12833 | ||
| CAIR's Assault on Paul Harvey [35 words] | Murray Kupersmith | Dec 24, 2003 08:48 | 12832 | ||
| Who do I write, [14 words] | L. Bendett | Dec 24, 2003 08:48 | 12831 | ||
| Paul Harvey [224 words] | Michael Kelemen | Dec 24, 2003 08:39 | 12829 | ||
| re Paul Harvey [56 words] | Richard Belson | Dec 24, 2003 08:36 | 12828 | ||
| It's not the first time [95 words] | Sheryl | Dec 24, 2003 08:29 | 12827 | ||
 Wrong on Harvey [63 words] | Aaron S. Field | Dec 24, 2003 08:07 | 12826 | ||
| HARVEY VS CAIR [93 words] | Lee Rudder | Dec 24, 2003 07:54 | 12825 | ||
| Cair not alone in tactics [235 words] | Yocheved Miriam | Dec 24, 2003 07:45 | 12823 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)