"Proof" - ??

Submitted by kman (United States), Nov 17, 2008 at 18:01

"Masood", I will congratulate you on one thing. You are only the second Muslim to ever even respond to me. That's as good as it gets.

You claim some generalizations from the Quran about its being "truth" and "never changed". So does Buddism, Hindu, witchcraft, Christianity, Confucianism, and all the rest. You have made no claim whatsoever that is different from any other religion or belief and you have generalized it hugely.

Your greatest accomplishment is to say that thus and so followed some alphabetic order. I have never even bothered to go there with Christianity. There are people out there that can come up with an astounding number of far greater facts about the Bible. Again, this is so low on the totem pole of value that, I won't bother stooping to go there.

You completely blow off every statement of value I give you of Christianity and its proven histrory.

You blow off every single year of Muslim History since your "prophet" came into being. In the past decade alone, the list of Islamic atrocities is absolutely endless. You blow all that off.

You never make any mention of any of the value of every piece of proof I've already given you.

You strain out a gnat to deliver an elephant instead of a God. When you can show me evidence of an "Allah" of any integrity, moral love for humanity, and truth from Muslim factual history then, please feel free to deliver.

Explain to me why Great Britain has now caved in to the Muslim demand that they no longer teach the "FACT" of the World War II atrocity that goes unmatched in mankind's history. That atrocity being the ugly slaughter in every heinous way imaginable of not only six million Jews but, ten thousand Christians and priests and, twenty million civilians. Tha "FACT" that Islam now wants to bury the "FACT" of their aliiance with Hitler and the number of Jews they gleefully shipped off to be buried in all those isanely heinous concentration camps.

We have come the full circle of Islamic history. Get the world far enough removed from a bit of history they were complicitly involved in, and then you can force them through distortions of their their own laws and, through intimidation, into believing it.

You can't give me ten seconds worth of even common sense and you repeat a demand of proof that has been proved here over and over. You repeatedly ignore every evidence delivered to your doorstep and then pointedly ignore it. You then ask for it to be proved yet again. When you show any scrap of reasoning skills or evidence that you have even "reasoned" through anything that has been presented to you - then, I will deliver, again, any proof you want.

You have been buried in proof and refuse to acknowledge it. You present no proofs of your own for your own claims.

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".