| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
History not always a good teacher
Reader comment on item: The Roots of Iraq's Rebellion
Submitted by Fan of Dr. Pipes (United States), Apr 13, 2004 at 14:44
What's the deal? If the US pulls out now there will be a civil war that kills millions. We can bring democracy to Iraq, especially if it is the Iraqi's who are governing and not us. To abandon the silent majority that supports liberation would be criminal. I also disagree with the belief that past precedent is an accurate predictor of the future. People like to believe that knowing history allows you to make accurate judgements about policy, but that belief is overrated.
Dislike
Submitting....
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (91) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Peace among all the people [125 words] | Ashley Ansara, DVM, PhD | Oct 12, 2005 00:23 | 26833 | ||
| missing facts... [270 words] | linz | Apr 27, 2004 22:12 | 14910 | ||
| What Strongman. [64 words] | Sheldon Lazarowtz | Apr 27, 2004 16:43 | 14899 | ||
| The Roots of Iraq's Rebellion [8 words] | emil steinberger, m.d. | Apr 25, 2004 23:20 | 14867 | ||
| New Romans Bearing Gifts [160 words] | Toby Petzold | Apr 24, 2004 23:37 | 14859 | ||
| 2 | The American 'weakness' [248 words] | Raymond T. Kyle | Apr 23, 2004 19:03 | 14849 | |
| British rule in Egypt [62 words] | Paul Savitz | Apr 22, 2004 15:52 | 14839 | ||
| Yes, but... [177 words] | Brian | Apr 20, 2004 22:47 | 14810 | ||
| Excellent, and the implications for Israel? [91 words] | Y Brandstetter MD | Apr 20, 2004 05:50 | 14783 | ||
| Rebellion? [297 words] | Tom | Apr 19, 2004 11:40 | 14773 | ||
| What about Iran? [58 words] | Joe | Apr 18, 2004 15:53 | 14770 | ||
| It won't work [181 words] | Darwin Barrett | Apr 18, 2004 13:56 | 14769 | ||
| Isn't this different? [202 words] | David | Apr 18, 2004 12:50 | 14768 | ||
| we need to use more force [53 words] | G singh | Apr 18, 2004 03:43 | 14761 | ||
| I disagree with Mr Pipes [77 words] | Raminder Gill | Apr 17, 2004 20:19 | 14755 | ||
| The US Obstacles in Iraq [867 words] | Shimon Z. Klein | Apr 17, 2004 12:55 | 14752 | ||
| Iraq's Rebellion [274 words] | Lisette Murad | Apr 17, 2004 09:22 | 14748 | ||
| 1 | Islam [104 words] | Dr. Ashley Ansara | Apr 16, 2004 22:59 | 14746 | |
| Iraqi enterprise [132 words] | Ilya Zwieback | Apr 16, 2004 21:44 | 14745 | ||
| 1 | There was an American strongman in Iraq... [3 words] | Ahmed Ali | Apr 16, 2004 19:52 | 14744 | |
| To Val Shkolnikov... [61 words] | gjs | Apr 16, 2004 19:22 | 14741 | ||
| Find a "Democratically minded Iraqi" [167 words] | Tom Loper | Apr 16, 2004 16:14 | 14739 | ||
| Regarding Muslim rule by Muslims only. [64 words] | Arthur S. Goldberg | Apr 16, 2004 16:05 | 14738 | ||
| Much Debatable History Lesson [93 words] | Matthew Scribner | Apr 16, 2004 12:10 | 14732 | ||
| The RootsofIraqi Rebellion art.1723 [37 words] | S.C.Panda | Apr 16, 2004 06:34 | 14729 | ||
| Aesop and Daniel [59 words] | Reality Check | Apr 15, 2004 15:48 | 14727 | ||
| clearing some points of view [72 words] | E. Darwish | Apr 15, 2004 14:13 | 14725 | ||
| Interpretation of the patterns of colonialism [104 words] | Pete | Apr 15, 2004 12:42 | 14724 | ||
| The Roots of Iraq's Rebellion [138 words] | Moin Ansari: American Jewish Muslim Alliance | Apr 15, 2004 12:31 | 14723 | ||
| It's only a clash of perceptions, not of cultures [274 words] | Michael Elvin | Apr 15, 2004 12:18 | 14722 | ||
| Declare Victory and bring back our kids: Not be scared of "shariyaa" [1031 words] | Moin Ansari: AMERICAN JEWISH MUSLIM ALLIANCE | Apr 15, 2004 11:41 | 14721 | ||
| On Muslim Theology [211 words] | Fay Voshell | Apr 15, 2004 08:47 | 14720 | ||
| MUCH NEEDED HISTORY LESSON [86 words] | Tova Mattero | Apr 15, 2004 02:25 | 14716 | ||
| Your solution to bringing peace to Iraq [226 words] | Yolanda Canfield | Apr 15, 2004 02:11 | 14715 | ||
| The Growth of Democracy [251 words] | Val Shkolnikov | Apr 15, 2004 00:31 | 14713 | ||
| Complete agreement [19 words] | Jacqui | Apr 15, 2004 00:15 | 14710 | ||
| Freedom Not Intuitive [117 words] | Rick Heller | Apr 14, 2004 23:26 | 14709 | ||
| "Democratically-minded"? [63 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Melvin A. Fechter | Apr 14, 2004 22:56 | 14708 | ||
| A Combination of Roots of Rebellion [28 words] | Timothy B. Roberts | Apr 14, 2004 22:03 | 14707 | ||
| Agreement [48 words] | Roger Davis | Apr 14, 2004 21:01 | 14706 | ||
| Sistani=Strongman? [14 words] | Fred | Apr 14, 2004 19:30 | 14704 | ||
| Who? [33 words] | Ann Charney Colmo | Apr 14, 2004 14:26 | 14700 | ||
| Islam and democracy, like oil and water. [159 words] | Bill Sweeney | Apr 14, 2004 12:42 | 14696 | ||
| But then there are the Utopians..... [326 words] | Diane Alden | Apr 14, 2004 12:35 | 14695 | ||
| I agree mostly: [127 words] | William Oliver | Apr 14, 2004 12:21 | 14693 | ||
| Brilliant as usual! [6 words] | Walter D'Ull | Apr 14, 2004 11:11 | 14692 | ||
| recipe unworkable for lack of key ingredient [72 words] | H.C. Klingman | Apr 14, 2004 10:35 | 14691 | ||
| Two Questions [98 words] | JG | Apr 14, 2004 10:34 | 14690 | ||
| Superb article [29 words] | Charles DICKINSON | Apr 14, 2004 10:05 | 14688 | ||
| How can Muslim ambitions be confined to their own? [356 words] | Chana Givon | Apr 14, 2004 10:01 | 14687 | ||
| Sure this plan will work? [35 words] | John Philips | Apr 14, 2004 06:45 | 14685 | ||
| Deadline is for Iran, not Iraq [117 words] | Barry | Apr 14, 2004 05:27 | 14682 | ||
| Idealism [343 words] | Robert Vaughn | Apr 14, 2004 01:42 | 14681 | ||
| Highly Imformative [259 words] | Avraham | Apr 14, 2004 01:36 | 14680 | ||
| Hope springs eternal [187 words] | gjs | Apr 14, 2004 00:14 | 14676 | ||
| I agree [47 words] | Joanne Postelmans | Apr 13, 2004 23:51 | 14675 | ||
| disagree on failure [128 words] | George Tomkin | Apr 13, 2004 23:32 | 14674 | ||
| Rule by non-Muslims is an abomination [208 words] | Jonathan Usher | Apr 13, 2004 22:52 | 14672 | ||
| I Have a question [149 words] | Arthur Bay | Apr 13, 2004 21:46 | 14670 | ||
| There are Muslims and there are Muslims. [288 words] | Malvina | Apr 13, 2004 21:27 | 14669 | ||
| Excellent [14 words] | Peter Kelly | Apr 13, 2004 20:22 | 14667 | ||
| This last article-about pulling out and leaving behind a strongman [163 words] | Gary (2nd generation American/ Indiana-born) | Apr 13, 2004 20:15 | 14666 | ||
| Ah, history! [197 words] | Peter J. Herz | Apr 13, 2004 20:03 | 14665 | ||
| roots of conflict in Iraq [166 words] | donvan | Apr 13, 2004 19:47 | 14664 | ||
| Telling the Truth but with one problem [1487 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Seth J. Frantzman | Apr 13, 2004 19:21 | 14663 | |
| Question [234 words] | Dan Reid | Apr 13, 2004 18:35 | 14661 | ||
| Another Ataturk or regional wars [168 words] | Ilona Melstrads | Apr 13, 2004 17:49 | 14659 | ||
| Additional Actions we can Take [228 words] | Gary kardon | Apr 13, 2004 17:44 | 14658 | ||
| There are two fallacies in Pipes' analysis: [432 words] | Tanru | Apr 13, 2004 17:43 | 14657 | ||
| Agreed, but ... [15 words] | Ira Weiner | Apr 13, 2004 17:39 | 14656 | ||
| Roots of Iraq's Rebellion [46 words] | NENETTE GRUNBERG | Apr 13, 2004 17:20 | 14655 | ||
| Did the Bush Administration know? [62 words] | Edward Goodman, MD | Apr 13, 2004 17:02 | 14654 | ||
| Iraq religion will not accept the West [27 words] | Robert Keats | Apr 13, 2004 16:43 | 14653 | ||
| Can Muslims ever secularize? [153 words] | Pat Kunz | Apr 13, 2004 15:48 | 14652 | ||
| At last somebody with intellectual cred speaks the obvious [32 words] | Howard Veit | Apr 13, 2004 15:23 | 14651 | ||
| The Root's of Iraq's Rebellion [96 words] | Bill Trebing | Apr 13, 2004 15:19 | 14650 | ||
| On the other hand.. [280 words] | Scott | Apr 13, 2004 15:13 | 14649 | ||
| Tantamount to re-establishing Hussein. [448 words] | Kirk Bertino | Apr 13, 2004 14:48 | 14646 | ||
 History not always a good teacher [83 words] | Fan of Dr. Pipes | Apr 13, 2004 14:44 | 14645 | ||
| on "The Roots of Iraq's Rebellion" [146 words] | Vlad | Apr 13, 2004 14:38 | 14644 | ||
| A new and more terrible future Iraqi uprising. [152 words] | Thomas C. Nixon--Ph. D. | Apr 13, 2004 14:32 | 14643 | ||
| Send this Article to the President [63 words] | Rae Spengler | Apr 13, 2004 14:24 | 14642 | ||
| Finding a strong-man to rule Iraq - come on! [309 words] | Lloyd Lionel Klein | Apr 13, 2004 14:16 | 14641 | ||
| "The Roots of Iraq's Rebellion" What about turkey? [105 words] | Rich McMahon | Apr 13, 2004 14:06 | 14640 | ||
| Missing the point [106 words] | Joaquim | Apr 13, 2004 13:38 | 14638 | ||
| Quite insighful [327 words] | Barak Queija | Apr 13, 2004 13:37 | 14637 | ||
| is hope disappearing [228 words] | john W. mcginley | Apr 13, 2004 13:26 | 14636 | ||
| Which strong man? [120 words] | Howard Mirkin | Apr 13, 2004 13:20 | 14635 | ||
| How about Britain in Iraq and transJordan and etc etc?? [27 words] | Henry Krieger | Apr 13, 2004 13:08 | 14634 | ||
| Missing the Point [19 words] | Bob Greenberg | Apr 13, 2004 12:52 | 14633 | ||
| Iraq was never united as a country, it was coerced [112 words] | Ken Besig | Apr 13, 2004 12:45 | 14632 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)