| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
False claims
Reader comment on item: Muslim Europe
Submitted by A Gill (United Kingdom), May 24, 2004 at 05:27
I have to comment on S C Panda's truly ridiculous comments.The assertion that India has a Muslim immigration problem is completely false. India has come until recently had a right wing Hindu supremacist government. Muslim immigration to Pakistan has actually increased.
Muslims in Gujarat certainly do not find India freer mainly because in 2002, 2500 Muslims were killed in pogroms with the complicity of the then government. So this wild assertion has no basis in fact.
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (184) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Population changes are coming [129 words] | steven | May 21, 2012 22:01 | 195741 | ||
| 6 | Case study India [112 words] | Hitesh | Dec 19, 2010 03:10 | 181113 | |
 islam [129 words] | jon | Jan 28, 2013 09:12 | 181113 | ||
| 2 | Why? [88 words] | Luis | Jul 13, 2010 00:04 | 175484 | |
| Well Said [5 words] | True | Jul 22, 2010 13:11 | 175484 | ||
| 2 | And the effects of the years of the 35 hour week in France show the cause of low birth rates is long work hours and cut benefits - not religious fervour or the lack of it [130 words] | Duncan McFarlane | Jun 7, 2010 17:16 | 174000 | |
| 3 | Immigrants don't outbreed or convert the host society to their religion by force - whether Irish catholics or Pakistani Muslims [228 words] | Duncan McFarlane | Jun 7, 2010 16:38 | 173998 | |
| europeans wake up now or sleep forever [294 words] | marin | Mar 17, 2010 11:28 | 170286 | ||
| 1 | Unexpected Consequences of Islamic Europe [438 words] | Alfred London | Mar 8, 2010 12:56 | 169850 | |
| 2 | lessons from india [184 words] | unmesh shukla | Dec 25, 2009 11:25 | 166266 | |
| 7 | Taqqia [201 words] | Michael | Oct 27, 2010 09:12 | 166266 | |
| Islamization - Gods' punishment for Holocaust [29 words] | Peter Canada | Oct 19, 2008 23:09 | 140488 | ||
| Respose to Islamization [67 words] | Hertha V | Oct 25, 2010 18:54 | 140488 | ||
| My opinion [120 words] | Michael | Oct 28, 2010 04:44 | 140488 | ||
| 1 | A Muslim Europe? [91 words] | Mitt Karbit | Sep 16, 2008 21:12 | 138700 | |
| never underestimate [207 words] | the croatian | Sep 26, 2008 14:28 | 138700 | ||
| 1 | All we need is a spark [539 words] | steve | Sep 4, 2008 02:03 | 137902 | |
| hoo well, europe goes to hell :D [44 words] | muhi | Dec 23, 2008 06:57 | 137902 | ||
| Revival of Europe [122 words] | Nikolas | Jul 20, 2010 19:31 | 137902 | ||
| 4 | Buried by political correctness [128 words] | Etienne | Jun 9, 2008 19:54 | 131601 | |
| The painful end of Europe [254 words] | LZ | Feb 19, 2009 07:56 | 131601 | ||
| Very interesting [43 words] | Ravi | Jun 5, 2008 16:26 | 131218 | ||
| West will decline [200 words] | A dude | Jun 1, 2008 14:03 | 130794 | ||
| re: West will decline [448 words] | sean | Jun 5, 2008 01:24 | 130794 | ||
| 1 | Response to west will decline [263 words] | Fara | Jul 12, 2008 20:46 | 130794 | |
| we are all the reflection of the{ one and only} [115 words] | centre in unity | Mar 28, 2011 08:55 | 130794 | ||
| 1 | Islamic Europe inevitable [50 words] | resigned realist | Apr 16, 2008 17:12 | 125861 | |
| Europe will remain christian [106 words] | Gleb Feigstein | Apr 16, 2008 03:42 | 125793 | ||
| Religion is a by-product of a lack of education [214 words] | Peter | Feb 16, 2008 06:38 | 120326 | ||
| Religion is a by-product of a lack of education - EPIC FAIL [160 words] | Mike | Mar 27, 2008 01:41 | 120326 | ||
| Against the all odds [181 words] | LNPBR_limp | Dec 3, 2007 12:02 | 115623 | ||
| conversion [13 words] | amit | Dec 10, 2007 11:35 | 115623 | ||
| 2 | muslims deprived in India ( kashmir region ) -- really? [101 words] | An Indian | Jun 5, 2008 16:17 | 115623 | |
| Untrue [25 words] | Number 11 | Jun 9, 2008 19:47 | 115623 | ||
| Obviously.. [366 words] | Foha | Jul 22, 2010 13:36 | 115623 | ||
| it's coming-while europe slept [11 words] | john b | Oct 15, 2007 16:32 | 111530 | ||
| A foretaste [11 words] | Mike | Jul 20, 2007 22:45 | 104180 | ||
| 1 | US UK to blame [209 words] | steve bakmore | Jun 19, 2007 13:30 | 99507 | |
| why are muslims leaving to come to the west [85 words] | Phil Greend | Jun 2, 2007 13:37 | 95790 | ||
| The Eu/Arab dialogue is why! [377 words] | Veronica | Jun 22, 2007 15:44 | 95790 | ||
| this isn't something new [98 words] | pstyx | Jan 7, 2007 13:58 | 71981 | ||
| Muslim Europe [145 words] | Krishna R. Kumar | Nov 22, 2006 09:03 | 66955 | ||
| the salvation of europe [101 words] | michaelc | Nov 16, 2006 15:19 | 66341 | ||
| 2 | Italy is fighting against Islam! [140 words] | Liam Millan | Feb 6, 2007 04:33 | 66341 | |
| Re: Muslim Europe [158 words] | Octavio Johanson | Nov 16, 2006 04:15 | 66289 | ||
| Potential [205 words] | James Jones | Aug 27, 2007 00:47 | 66289 | ||
| To your thoughts i reply [107 words] | Lz | Feb 19, 2009 07:31 | 66289 | ||
| Peak oil will solve the problem [26 words] | David | Sep 15, 2006 19:04 | 56089 | ||
| REPLY Daniel Pipes [78 words] | DANY | Sep 14, 2006 15:26 | 55951 | ||
| ...I'm all for building bridges [325 words] | Right of Center Filipino | Nov 16, 2006 00:23 | 55951 | ||
| Building bridges? [429 words] | Scott | Dec 17, 2006 08:36 | 55951 | ||
| What are you like? [389 words] | Malachy | Jan 18, 2007 14:04 | 55951 | ||
| compromise leds to defeat [88 words] | Phil Greend | May 13, 2007 20:32 | 55951 | ||
| distorted figures. [276 words] | Veronica | Jun 22, 2007 16:07 | 55951 | ||
| Distorted Ideas [682 words] | Malachy | Jun 23, 2007 10:56 | 55951 | ||
| to apppease what next, Paris or London? [872 words] | Veronica | Jun 24, 2007 11:19 | 55951 | ||
| Do you really think that europe has been that generous to muslims? [164 words] | freddy shark | Sep 22, 2007 12:41 | 55951 | ||
| 1 | read the Koran---here is a very short list [1861 words] | Don | Jul 11, 2008 05:17 | 55951 | |
| Christians,Muslims,Buddhists,Hindus= 4 wheels of a Car [102 words] | Adnan zia | Sep 17, 2008 15:57 | 55951 | ||
| How Europe and the Americas do the world a disservice with liberal immigration laws [180 words] | Reuben Horne | Sep 3, 2006 19:50 | 54802 | ||
| 1 | imperialism causes migration [22 words] | fike2308 | Jun 5, 2010 10:03 | 54802 | |
| It is by chance [133 words] | Kaaf adam | Jul 14, 2006 19:19 | 49687 | ||
| Not True [185 words] | A Re-Convert | Nov 14, 2006 15:52 | 49687 | ||
| European happy to be outside of europe! [47 words] | Swede without a home | Jun 2, 2006 15:26 | 46938 | ||
| Not so bad [146 words] | Miriam | May 22, 2006 00:53 | 46111 | ||
| its not the Muslims fault [33 words] | donvan | Dec 25, 2006 07:35 | 46111 | ||
| 1 | Opinion from Moscow [264 words] | Daria | Mar 28, 2006 16:26 | 41677 | |
| United States not much better [257 words] | Brad | Aug 8, 2006 13:39 | 41677 | ||
| 1 | Russia is multireligious country [73 words] | Konstantin | Jun 17, 2007 21:19 | 41677 | |
| Europe invited Muslim Immigrants to construct Europe .Not your Love?? [75 words] | Adnan zia | Sep 17, 2008 14:39 | 41677 | ||
| It's all true [644 words] | Elaine Lennon | Feb 26, 2006 08:33 | 38070 | ||
| EU deal with Arabs in 1973 [658 words] | Guy Leven-Torres | Mar 1, 2007 14:06 | 38070 | ||
| Lets get it Over with [78 words] | British Patriot | Nov 28, 2007 19:06 | 38070 | ||
| equal response [57 words] | Adnan zia | Sep 17, 2008 14:56 | 38070 | ||
| I didn't believe it until... [104 words] | Dan | Jan 27, 2006 20:19 | 32860 | ||
| Hey Dan [36 words] | Ali Habibi | Feb 5, 2006 19:12 | 32860 | ||
| Beware Europeans [31 words] | Hanif malaysia | Jun 6, 2007 20:12 | 32860 | ||
| Live Free or Die [108 words] | Johnny_Freedom | Dec 26, 2005 22:52 | 30604 | ||
| The Examples of Living Islam can be seen everyday in Iraq. [135 words] | Bramha | Oct 12, 2006 08:11 | 30604 | ||
| a modest proposal [445 words] | Tristan | Dec 18, 2005 03:39 | 30126 | ||
| How to beat it [418 words] | Michael F | Dec 12, 2005 16:42 | 29829 | ||
| 1 | Religion and its appeal to modern day. [462 words] | jamal | Mar 16, 2007 13:45 | 29829 | |
| Where is your God? [55 words] | the messenger | Feb 3, 2009 19:31 | 29829 | ||
| The way I see Europe being saved [236 words] | Johnny Carpati | Nov 13, 2005 19:02 | 28335 | ||
| The Roots of Discontent [164 words] | C.B. Ko | Nov 13, 2005 03:41 | 28304 | ||
| I have seen it coming [106 words] | D M Street | Nov 5, 2005 15:44 | 27828 | ||
| How I pity those who continue to be in denial! [40 words] | Li Bai | Oct 31, 2005 02:33 | 27538 | ||
| Too true! [30 words] | Ossy | Mar 23, 2006 05:05 | 27538 | ||
| truth of Islam [41 words] | amer | May 27, 2008 20:59 | 27538 | ||
| Islam is Secular [471 words] | Syed Kasim | Oct 3, 2005 00:48 | 26550 | ||
| Islam is a political philosophy not a secular one [561 words] | Reuben Horne | Sep 1, 2006 03:45 | 26550 | ||
| And you contradict yourself [197 words] | Reuben Horne | Sep 2, 2006 23:21 | 26550 | ||
| 1 | Jizya was less than Zakat [24 words] | Syed Kasim | Dec 17, 2006 21:13 | 26550 | |
| Judeo-Christian-Muslim is possible [268 words] | Syed Kasim | Dec 18, 2006 23:39 | 26550 | ||
| Islamic Government is not secular [1061 words] | Monte Gardner | Jun 15, 2007 21:58 | 26550 | ||
| Follow-up Comment on The Demographic Jihad [249 words] | Aidan Maconachy | Sep 22, 2005 16:13 | 26176 | ||
| The Demographic Jihad [667 words] | Aidan Maconachy | Sep 11, 2005 12:19 | 25644 | ||
| False Truths [246 words] | Harish Duggirala | Aug 9, 2005 12:50 | 24481 | ||
| forbidden cultural practices [187 words] | Ralph Deans | Feb 23, 2006 14:44 | 24481 | ||
| Decline of Christianity = Rise of Islam? [246 words] | David Fee | Jun 10, 2005 05:11 | 22623 | ||
| The Mission and The Ghost [165 words] | Khan | Feb 20, 2005 00:58 | 20435 | ||
| So what? [159 words] | Fr. Martin | Jan 11, 2005 17:58 | 19613 | ||
| SIDE EFFECTS... [154 words] | DONVAN | Nov 21, 2006 15:33 | 19613 | ||
| Our glorious Western civilization is based on astronomical debt of future Muslims of Europe. [394 words] | Syed Kasim | Dec 21, 2006 00:47 | 19613 | ||
| Double Standards .........No veto power for muslims [56 words] | Adnan zia | Sep 17, 2008 16:09 | 19613 | ||
| Your numbers seem too high [392 words] | J.R. Ortiz | Jan 2, 2005 18:57 | 19313 | ||
| the difference.... [136 words] | donvan | Dec 5, 2006 16:23 | 19313 | ||
| Acquired Jihad Syndrome [74 words] | Syed Kasim | Dec 17, 2006 21:32 | 19313 | ||
| English translation any time soon? [12 words] | Ken Keane | Dec 21, 2004 20:27 | 19097 | ||
| Justice. [132 words] | Imran | Jul 25, 2004 21:15 | 16071 | ||
| Muslim Europe [225 words] | tgs | Feb 23, 2006 00:05 | 16071 | ||
| wake up christians [63 words] | row | Apr 7, 2007 19:33 | 16071 | ||
| We are Muslims not Mongols [94 words] | adnan zia | Sep 17, 2008 15:21 | 16071 | ||
| We will not leave quietly in the night! [176 words] | F Eriksen | Jul 21, 2004 08:31 | 16022 | ||
| penalty [59 words] | George Aksan | Jun 7, 2004 13:36 | 15563 | ||
| Drastic changes will occur in European society later [8 words] | Abdullah | May 31, 2004 07:51 | 15446 | ||
| The End of Christian Europe [63 words] | Mike Zeldis | May 29, 2004 18:21 | 15416 | ||
| One way to curb growth. [88 words] | M. Levi | May 27, 2004 19:46 | 15394 | ||
| My recent visit to Germany confirmed Daniel Pipes' "Muslim Europe" [63 words] | Carmen | May 27, 2004 18:09 | 15389 | ||
| Re: Muslim Europe [363 words] | Major Gordon Smith | May 25, 2004 09:23 | 15333 | ||
| A grim but realistic warning [170 words] | Abhay Sapru | May 25, 2004 00:41 | 15329 | ||
| Islam Teaches Tolerance? [58 words] | N. Khan | May 24, 2004 15:09 | 15326 | ||
| RE TO N .KHAN [37 words] | DANY | Sep 14, 2006 15:10 | 15326 | ||
| Mohamad & Islam [136 words] | Charles Meckna | Dec 25, 2006 23:28 | 15326 | ||
 False claims [76 words] | A Gill | May 24, 2004 05:27 | 15323 | ||
| Paranoia [87 words] | David Cohen | May 24, 2004 05:19 | 15322 | ||
| Response to Seelai [45 words] | Ibn Warraq | May 22, 2004 17:24 | 15318 | ||
| A tragedy [216 words] | S.C.Panda | May 19, 2004 06:18 | 15289 | ||
| Europeans' free choice [46 words] | Seelai | May 18, 2004 18:22 | 15280 | ||
| Islam and the once-Christian West. [377 words] | Stewart Davies | May 18, 2004 03:09 | 15264 | ||
| "The Fall and Decline of Europe?" [310 words] | Carool Kersten | May 17, 2004 21:59 | 15261 | ||
| enter Eastern Europe [153 words] | Yuval brandstetter MD | May 17, 2004 14:17 | 15254 | ||
| An important distinction [159 words] | David McDuff | May 17, 2004 09:42 | 15251 | ||
| Prophecies of doom [155 words] | Bernard Gilland | May 17, 2004 05:34 | 15249 | ||
| Thought-Provoking Article [208 words] | Avraham | May 17, 2004 00:29 | 15245 | ||
| A future too horrible to contemplate [24 words] | jaime | May 16, 2004 14:12 | 15243 | ||
| Brilliant article [57 words] | Dillicia Gill | May 16, 2004 04:17 | 15240 | ||
| England [226 words] | Stuart Lee | May 15, 2004 22:26 | 15235 | ||
| time to count noses and take sides [272 words] | Maurice Cohen | May 15, 2004 12:47 | 15230 | ||
| what freedom? [20 words] | Mohammed Amin | May 15, 2004 11:50 | 15228 | ||
| You seem to have overlooked another, dire, possibility [77 words] | Michael Selzer | May 14, 2004 16:47 | 15223 | ||
| Comedy indeed.. [100 words] | Petter Nikula | May 14, 2004 09:16 | 15213 | ||
| Congratulations ! [53 words] | Hilare | May 13, 2004 13:08 | 15202 | ||
| 2 | Chinese immigration to Europe [66 words] | José Josephs | May 12, 2004 21:23 | 15195 | |
| The punishment of hatred [130 words] | josef zuares | May 12, 2004 17:25 | 15192 | ||
| Fan [17 words] | Gerald Wilkerson | May 12, 2004 16:28 | 15190 | ||
| islam vs postfascism [87 words] | Tom Holbrook | May 12, 2004 13:41 | 15186 | ||
| Play the Requiem [154 words] | Johnson | Aug 29, 2006 22:41 | 15186 | ||
| Modernity [278 words] | Matthew Scribner | May 12, 2004 10:44 | 15180 | ||
| Great article [105 words] | Darlene Carroll | May 12, 2004 10:19 | 15178 | ||
| 1 | Orthodox Christians know [316 words] | Victor Karras | May 12, 2004 09:59 | 15176 | |
| A Peacable Transformation to Islamic Civilization?- Not Necessarily [556 words] | Uzi Amit-Kohn | May 12, 2004 02:45 | 15166 | ||
| Weep for Europe's future [212 words] | DAVE | May 12, 2004 02:36 | 15165 | ||
| one world government [142 words] | buzzkill | May 11, 2004 23:10 | 15159 | ||
| Points of Contestation [524 words] | Randy McDonald | May 11, 2004 21:33 | 15154 | ||
| Muslim Europe [238 words] | C.C. Courington | May 11, 2004 21:21 | 15152 | ||
| The Decline and Fall of Western Civilization [293 words] | Darwin Barrett | May 11, 2004 20:45 | 15148 | ||
| DECLINE AND FALL OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION [332 words] | Suresh Mittal | Jun 19, 2007 12:07 | 15148 | ||
| entropy is at work [222 words] | Maurice Cohen | May 11, 2004 20:43 | 15147 | ||
| Death Pact [29 words] | Tanru | May 11, 2004 20:05 | 15145 | ||
| Maybe Modernity is the Problem [348 words] | Peter J. Herz | May 11, 2004 20:00 | 15144 | ||
| muslim europe [145 words] | dante | May 11, 2004 17:42 | 15138 | ||
| Accusations and Islam [561 words] | Adnan zia | Sep 15, 2008 05:01 | 15138 | ||
| Islamization of Europe Predicted [441 words] | Mike Ramirez | May 11, 2004 17:30 | 15133 | ||
| what was that saying...curiosity wha? [123 words] | zoyeb | Nov 29, 2006 21:34 | 15133 | ||
| The law of sowing and reaping [223 words] | Calbert | Jul 30, 2008 21:33 | 15133 | ||
| Will Islam support decadent Europes' pension plan? [270 words] | William Sluis | May 11, 2004 16:10 | 15129 | ||
| Islam-Christian Battle [102 words] | Bassam | May 11, 2004 15:46 | 15127 | ||
| or European Islam? [387 words] | Alain Jean-Mairet | May 11, 2004 15:12 | 15125 | ||
| "Muslim Europe"...another powerful article by Daniel Pipes! [128 words] | Ray Barretto | May 11, 2004 13:04 | 15122 | ||
| 2 | Cultural Dilution [301 words] | Joe Nash | Aug 20, 2007 15:15 | 15122 | |
| Powell and immigration [80 words] | halldor | May 11, 2004 12:29 | 15121 | ||
| Thoughts [148 words] | saddened | Oct 8, 2006 23:21 | 15121 | ||
| another perspective [264 words] | Laurie Dinerstein-Kurs | May 11, 2004 12:21 | 15120 | ||
| Cultural Deterioration of Europe. [51 words] | Jeanne Zanger | May 11, 2004 11:52 | 15119 | ||
| Pipes is completely wrong [165 words] | Randy McDonald | May 11, 2004 11:13 | 15116 | ||
| hello [143 words] | ADRIAN | Apr 22, 2006 09:29 | 15116 | ||
| The answer to stopping islam... [220 words] | Saddened | Oct 8, 2006 23:10 | 15116 | ||
| The Problem of Islam in Europe [608 words] | Guy Leven-Torres | Feb 17, 2007 03:19 | 15116 | ||
| The EU and its totalitarian agenda-Recent laws about' Islamophobia' and 'Hate Crime' [486 words] | Guy Leven-Torres (Agricola) | May 7, 2007 06:37 | 15116 | ||
| Inundated! [166 words] | fred lapides | May 11, 2004 11:08 | 15115 | ||
| A wake up call for democracies [12 words] | Herbert Stone | May 11, 2004 10:52 | 15114 | ||
| Precedent [274 words] | Bob Carl | May 11, 2004 10:48 | 15113 | ||
| 4 wives and child brides - why they hate us? [152 words] | Sampson | May 11, 2004 10:36 | 15112 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)