69 million page views

Convicts to the past

Reader comment on item: Away with Crusaders, Crucifixes, Crosses, and Christmas
in response to reader comment: The changing of the Medal

Submitted by Dr Albert Schadenfreude (United Kingdom), Jun 22, 2009 at 18:35

Dear Tess,

By what you say, it appears Australia is a British colonial outpost on the edge of Asia, your nation state which you call 'Australia' is a concept, not a culturally unique country. You yearn for a British past from the other side of the world. How ironic

Was this the same Australia built on Aboriginal land, populated by convicts, operated the one-bob policy in the 1960's and 1970's to attract British immigrants (mainly poor working class) in fear of the 'Yellow-peril' (the term used at the time to describe the fear of Australia being overun by the Chinese and Japanese)? The same country that gave the world nothing more then Marmite?

Australians are no more then modern-day colonialists. That is their mentality. That is also why they have attracted a huge number of white South Africans following the end of apartide and continue to attract white Zimbabweans.

By the way, the Commonwealth in not a Christian or whites-only club, it is made up of a diverse range of countries and people from across Asia and Africa (infact and not coincidently, most countries that were part of the British Empire). The Head of the Commonwealth doesn't have anything to do with the Anglican Church per se. It is a 'Commonwealth' of nations, equal in status (as opposed to the Empire, run from Blighty) Given how 'British' you claim to be, surprised you didn't know that!

And with you daft nostalgia about Churchill, he didn't fight the war by himself, millions of Africans and Indians of all religious background fought in both the World Wars in the misguided belief that they would also win their freedom from Imperial Britain. ..

Dislike
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (151) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
1Secular Democracy in the entire Islamic World [199 words]PrashantNov 20, 2016 00:56234176
try to imagine [106 words]y Brandstetter MDFeb 3, 2014 03:25212919
1the devils work [156 words]IanFeb 19, 2011 10:57182828
My spin [168 words]Daniel F. WhiteAug 10, 2009 21:19160020
7muslims are offended by everything, . . except islamic terror .! [350 words]Phil GreendAug 8, 2009 20:23159857
WHAT OFFENDS ME [92 words]alanAug 16, 2014 12:14159857
2No sense of humor [175 words]YosefAug 7, 2009 10:55159793
commenting yosef: rhyme religion and the pope in german football [151 words]arnoAug 10, 2009 10:01159793
2Muslims take offense to any religious sysmbols not their own [276 words]RRWestJun 21, 2009 15:04157730
Jews and Muslims [19 words]DaveJun 5, 2009 14:59156846
1Changing historic place names & symbols not about citizenship or tolerance [281 words]Non-CatholicJun 10, 2009 15:29156846
8Removal of Christian symbols from public [72 words]One-eyed eagleMay 26, 2009 17:54156201
Trinity Cross obviously named for Trinidad itself [241 words]Non-Catholic outraged by this sort of thingMay 21, 2009 14:39155927
5hail britainistan [78 words]kafirnproudMay 15, 2009 11:52155474
2pampering the child [55 words]mriitunjayMay 15, 2009 04:50155456
1Having done away with the Jews [23 words]yuval Brandstetter MDMay 14, 2009 00:35155391
1Changing the Trinity Cross [93 words]catholic pastor netherlandsMay 13, 2009 03:33155335
1Our failure? [217 words]Larry B.May 17, 2009 12:02155335
Expect jealousy and desparation from fundamentalists [229 words]AbhiMay 13, 2009 02:30155328
1The Islamic republic of England [32 words]AB from GermanyMay 17, 2009 06:55155328
Londestan [60 words]Doug CharackyMay 25, 2009 20:37155328
1Change the Union Jack fjst like The Trinity Cross of the Order of Trinity [50 words]Ronald ParkerJun 16, 2009 12:34155328
5Let's be honest, Islam breeds hate. [150 words]Happy Non-MuslimMay 12, 2009 10:56155288
A very well said comment [3 words]TakeNoteMay 13, 2009 01:46155288
2Strange twist... [193 words]KathyMay 15, 2009 09:39155288
1The changing of the Medal [119 words]Tess McNamara Australian and Pro Israel ZionistMay 12, 2009 09:06155281
Convicts to the past [280 words]Dr Albert SchadenfreudeJun 22, 2009 18:35155281
Our hearts are our symbol. [234 words]LynnApr 13, 2009 08:00153810
Domination [99 words]TomMay 10, 2009 23:37153810
1Thank You Mr Pipes for opening eyes to the truth. [416 words]Terry J RogersOct 10, 2008 02:25139861
Crucifix [184 words]YnnatchkahMar 21, 2008 21:21123196
In Brazil, these Islamic Opressors will have to dance. [216 words]YnnatchkahMar 21, 2008 15:41123182
5Islam is a very immature religion [305 words]TonyJul 31, 2007 23:50105206
1like adolescents [357 words]dfwhite19438Apr 9, 2008 02:27105206
1Banning Christmas [284 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Kuranda SeyitJul 11, 2007 02:46103406
Be Cautious [277 words]SebastianSep 30, 2006 01:0058287
1people of islam [327 words]Muhammad AriefJul 7, 2006 02:5849125
Well said! [11 words]TomMay 10, 2009 19:3249125
confused [152 words]LilMay 8, 2006 15:3645030
1Muslims don't want to care.... [319 words]SoundocApr 15, 2006 21:1143264
It's not new [156 words]Noelle PerryMar 12, 2006 19:3639877
Giving in to wrongs is also wrong [58 words]Fed UpMar 24, 2006 16:2839877
2A cuckoo's egg in the nest. [511 words]Paul BastierOct 25, 2006 23:4039877
Reply to Paul Bastier [79 words]Frahad NavkhodaApr 2, 2007 10:2839877
1Why? [374 words]Patrick LauMar 3, 2006 12:5738781
1Away with crosses,crucifixes and christmas [134 words]TomFeb 27, 2006 18:0738246
5Not in Hispanic America [344 words]JoseApr 8, 2006 21:0638246
6Comment on Jose's Not in Hispanic America [131 words]JoyceJul 17, 2007 23:0838246
Comment on Comment on Jose's Not in Hispanic America [117 words]Billy FJul 25, 2007 17:4838246
religions again [42 words]G.BisvasFeb 24, 2006 07:5737895
Clothing recalled over mosque picture [379 words]SophieFeb 23, 2006 14:0737816
12deeply disturbing.. [415 words]MerrillFeb 11, 2006 08:2734915
8Demographic aggression by muslims [163 words]G.BisvasFeb 25, 2006 04:4934915
2India's pain [54 words]JoeJul 16, 2006 10:2534915
Hate agenda, borne from fear not ignorance [180 words]Frahad NavkhodaApr 20, 2007 05:4634915
it's all a question of faith [236 words]CFeb 11, 2006 04:2434886
2Partly agree [282 words]JoeFeb 13, 2006 15:1234886
90STOP THE APPEASEMENT. Muslims if you dont like it, LEAVE [218 words]JoeFeb 8, 2006 00:2534282
2Muslims will never change [65 words]ArunFeb 8, 2006 09:0934282
3Muslims globalizing their religion [24 words]A. PatriotFeb 14, 2006 19:3034282
1bravo,Joe. If they do not like our culture, leave as soon as possible [37 words]OskarApr 7, 2006 18:2534282
1How could Muslims change? [76 words]SoundocApr 8, 2006 22:3634282
1darn right [8 words]john benOct 25, 2006 17:1334282
4Boot them out [33 words]DaveJan 5, 2007 22:2134282
2Correct [7 words]OctavioJan 6, 2007 17:4734282
5Dar al-Harb [215 words]JohnApr 8, 2007 20:4534282
Another Dear John letter [145 words]Frahad NavkhodaApr 12, 2007 05:0334282
2let's treat muslims how muslims treat others in their own countries [101 words]susanJul 15, 2007 15:2234282
2Because they Hate!! [156 words]Jim LittleJul 15, 2007 20:3434282
1Dear Susie letter [117 words]Frahad NavkhodaJul 23, 2007 04:4934282
1You're right, your secular greed is to blame [74 words]Frahad NavkhodaJul 23, 2007 04:5734282
11frahad, logic not a strong point of muslims [372 words]susanJul 23, 2007 18:2834282
3there is nothing greedier and more imperialistic [316 words]susanJul 23, 2007 18:3834282
2Know your history [162 words]Jim LittleJul 24, 2007 19:3634282
1Insulting Tone [95 words]Frahad NavkhodaJul 25, 2007 08:3534282
1..Diatribe continues [24 words]Frahad NavkhodaJul 25, 2007 08:3834282
1Are you sure? [12 words]LilyJul 30, 2007 13:0534282
3Stop Islamafication of America [172 words]phil nolanDec 30, 2007 16:0234282
1Australians wont stand for them [165 words]aussieteenJan 16, 2008 08:5534282
1Muslims haven't seen Real America yet [61 words]Dewey PowersApr 9, 2008 11:4934282
11Europe wake up! Ban Islam in Europe now! [94 words]AlexJun 8, 2008 19:4834282
1Thank you Joe!! [193 words]PrivateNov 13, 2008 08:2534282
1ITS TIME [24 words]miamiJan 3, 2009 01:5434282
1Picayunish Muslims. [142 words]Alex F WysockiMar 8, 2009 18:5134282
Lead by Example Australia [38 words]Dr Albert SchadenfreudeJun 22, 2009 18:5134282
What's the difference between a patriot and a nationalist? [45 words]Dr Albert SchadenfreudeJun 22, 2009 19:0434282
1Be scared of muslim religion! [38 words]Ex muslimSep 22, 2009 09:2334282
1One way Ticket or Get out to where you Belong! [228 words]Anti UlianovNov 27, 2009 08:1634282
1Muslims do not let themselves to be appeased [267 words]DanApr 1, 2010 14:4434282
1I agree [59 words]M of TwoApr 26, 2010 05:2034282
1STOP ISLAMIC LAW BEFORE IT DESTROYS OUR CULTURE & FREEDOM [143 words]The DoctorOct 13, 2010 08:1134282
1say it like it is [4 words]marciaMar 29, 2011 13:1934282
I agree, luckily West has chance to learn from Mistakes of East, don't burn your finger to know .... [2070 words]Ravi Ranjan Singh Bharat PanthiMay 17, 2011 07:2134282
Appeasement [162 words]MichaelMar 26, 2014 14:5434282
4Hindu's Celebrate Christmas in the UK [288 words]David SmithFeb 6, 2006 11:2433937
Christmas ! [102 words]GinaSep 18, 2006 09:0233937
1The Star of David and The Cross [98 words]RhenaeJan 24, 2006 01:5132292
4Profit before prophet? [66 words]jakmanFeb 17, 2006 09:2432292
1Shariah and Hindu/Sikh Cremations. [47 words]jakmanFeb 21, 2006 14:2432292
Inflatable dolls [40 words]jakmanFeb 22, 2006 02:4032292
4Latin America and Islam. [150 words]JoseMar 8, 2006 19:3132292
Blow Up [21 words]JoeJul 16, 2006 10:3332292
India and the Muslim perspective [468 words]Frahad NavkhodaMar 29, 2007 10:4832292
Multiculturalism is working fine in Canada. [65 words]Sundeep GillJun 16, 2007 01:2132292
6good and bad past of islam [512 words]G.VishvasApr 8, 2008 18:1532292
Nothing of substance [126 words]FrahadApr 14, 2008 11:3532292
1clarity of words [94 words]G.VishvasApr 18, 2008 02:4132292
1Navkhoda lives in the past [159 words]G.VishvasJun 16, 2009 11:2832292
Burning a dead cause on the funeral pyre [73 words]Frahad NavkhodaJun 22, 2009 18:0132292
7about hindutva fascism [109 words]G.VishvasJun 25, 2009 12:1632292
My opinion [37 words]Thiago SoaresSep 13, 2011 20:3932292
1Since when is the government responsible for how it makes us "feel" [86 words]Tom RoutheDec 21, 2005 10:3230345
Amen! [15 words]Jackie PierceDec 19, 2005 14:5730201
impact of the cross [117 words]Roslyn EstherDec 16, 2005 23:5830101
Re: Impact of the cross [158 words]RickDec 20, 2005 00:4330101
Rick you are right [190 words]JoeFeb 14, 2006 21:1630101
For the sake of symmetry [40 words]Sergio RubinsteinDec 16, 2005 20:4530097
1Don't come here, stay where you are, we don't want you. [168 words]RickDec 16, 2005 18:0230092
4Rick - Darn Fine! [107 words]Heather ClarkDec 16, 2005 23:4730092
2reply to Rick [33 words]JoyceJul 17, 2007 23:1830092
1Muslim wise to the ways of the West [264 words]david romeroDec 16, 2005 17:4230090
1I can't Believe What I am Reading [152 words]Lali PerFeb 16, 2006 10:0430090
Thanks to the Greco-Roman-Hebrew culture [157 words]frahad NavkhodaApr 15, 2008 06:0630090
1frahad Navkhoda [49 words]Daniel F. WhiteAug 7, 2009 18:4830090
Dog that barks the most seldom bites [59 words]Frahad NavkhodaAug 10, 2009 19:0730090
When Church Bells ring in Saudi Arabia [43 words]RickDec 16, 2005 15:1930082
COMMENT! [100 words]COMMENT!May 9, 2007 08:0130082
Away with Crucifixes, Crosses, and Christmas [451 words]Mary-Ann BarnesDec 16, 2005 13:1630075
"Sorry, mate ... [336 words]ddsDec 15, 2005 12:5730008
Like it or Leave it [125 words]MMMar 30, 2007 07:4330008
Australia is no shining example [339 words]Frahad NavkhodaApr 2, 2007 10:1230008
shining examples? [356 words]BosJul 17, 2007 09:4130008
1farhad [716 words]susanJul 23, 2007 18:5230008
Susan [148 words]Frahad NavkhodaJul 25, 2007 08:5230008
LOL [705 words]susanJul 25, 2007 16:4330008
Educating Susan [285 words]Frahad NavkhodaJul 27, 2007 05:2330008
reply [1058 words]susanJul 27, 2007 16:4730008
Rose Tinted view of History! [205 words]Frahad NavkhodaJul 30, 2007 05:0030008
Star of David and The Cross [351 words]Yehoshua ZellerDec 15, 2005 12:5030006
Foundations of our Societies [166 words]TrevorDec 13, 2005 17:0629900
They don't call us Dar al-Harb for nothing.... [99 words]LexEconDec 13, 2005 15:5029888
a story of The Cross [106 words]Ed BrophyDec 13, 2005 14:0429881
Warning - Politically Incorrect Post [237 words]Heather ClarkDec 12, 2005 11:1729800
Kudos to Heather Clark [25 words]Ed BrophyDec 13, 2005 14:1029800
1Re: Ed Brophy Comments & Kudos [273 words]Heather ClarkDec 14, 2005 00:2029800
to Heather Clark [482 words]DrewDec 15, 2005 15:5329800
1Drew and Heather- Everyone's a Racist for defending their lives and honor! [259 words]Yehoshua ZellerDec 16, 2005 13:2729800
For Drew [73 words]Heather ClarkDec 16, 2005 23:1029800
For Yehoshua Zeller - Politically Incorrect [119 words]Heather ClarkDec 16, 2005 23:2929800
are you kidding me [101 words]appledumplinhearneDec 11, 2005 21:4729785
Happy Big Bunny Day [126 words]P.O.D.Dec 10, 2005 06:1229732

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)