69 million page views

to William McGarroch: America's Rude Islamists and BNP supporters

Reader comment on item: America's Rude Islamists
in response to reader comment: Reply - Tim Burton

Submitted by Anubhav Singh (India), May 5, 2006 at 08:56

"..Anyway it would be impossible to kick all the Islamic people out the country because it would basicly destroy the economic system and we would have massive unemployment...."

what laws of economics did you apply William? they run banks for you? or they make aircrafts? or they are responsible for the health system of UK?

Even I, a Hindu living in India, supports BNP. The west with its thoughtless/mindless liberalism and immigration is digging its grave. any society/country will do itself a favor if it kicks out muslims.

"..This is just a few Islamic extremists acting like hooligans and obviously nobody knows how many people are supporters of these people but the whole of the Islamic comunity shouldn't be labelled for the minority..."

you are using the wrong metrics. this is like using concept of celsius to measure quantity of cotton. you should not judge the no. of extremists with no. of normal people (that they are just a small percentage of all muslims, we all know). you should measure ratio of extremists to normal people across religions. there are devious people in all religions and societies. but if you compare this ratio in Islam it overwhelmingly beats other people and religions.

this misplaced consdescending attitude that an average liberal, secular westerner shows towards Islam gives courage to Islamists. they dont think like you. think about why you ar eliberal and secular. you cannot be secular to a religion which clearly calls for your own destruction. and please dont give tripe about economic effects if govts act hard on islamists.

we in India have been tortured by Islam for centuries (and please dont give me the nonsense of cultural contributions by Muslims in India). and they are encouraged by our secular, tolerant mindset. their actions are changing an average secular hindu towards religious fanaticism.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (44) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Is "Islamism" the right term? [142 words]tomkowJun 13, 2006 15:4047590
America's Rude Islamists Welog 23Apr2006 [56 words]S.C.PandaJun 13, 2006 04:1647550
The Islamic Thinkers Society? [136 words]Lamar CarnesMay 25, 2006 17:5546409
As if Muslims have a monopoly on rudeness [96 words]FrenchKissMay 7, 2006 12:5844988
#reply:As if Muslims have a monopoly on rudeness [227 words]Obnoxious guyMay 9, 2006 02:5144988
totally agree [65 words]RichardNov 17, 2006 22:1344988
We are at war. This is the enemy. [130 words]rickApr 28, 2006 15:0144441
America's Rude Islamists [35 words]Anubhav SInghMay 5, 2006 07:2444441
Dumb infidels [210 words]surinder singhMay 8, 2006 08:4144441
hate-crime [16 words]ArkansasApr 26, 2006 02:1944200
America's Rude Islamists [113 words]steven LApr 25, 2006 22:1344179
America's Enemies Within [146 words]JaladhiApr 25, 2006 14:4644128
The Truth Hurts... [492 words]ErikApr 25, 2006 13:1044115
Islamic Rally in New York-Insight into the Heart of Islam! [148 words]MJApr 25, 2006 05:3844090
deportation to the land of the not so free [104 words]AnneApr 24, 2006 22:0744062
British step [43 words]VijayApr 24, 2006 06:3943977
Being Destroyed from Within [209 words]van der LeyApr 24, 2006 02:0243965
To Van der Ley [49 words]AnubhavMay 6, 2006 12:0843965
WHY ARE SUCH RADICAL ISLAMISTS BEING ALLOWED INTO OUR COUNTRY [335 words]JennJun 2, 2006 10:0043965
Understanding Islam [857 words]KamekishApr 24, 2006 01:0143962
Rude Doesn't Quite Get It [284 words]peter g jonesApr 23, 2006 18:3143937
out in the open [88 words]bndApr 23, 2006 16:3043930
New York Demonstration [74 words]Bill WaldronApr 23, 2006 15:1143919
Islamic Thinkers Society aka Al Muhajiroun work with ICNA and MAS [472 words]Ben van de PolderApr 23, 2006 20:4343919
missing the point .... [449 words]jamilMay 17, 2006 07:4843919
Al Muhajiroun UK [138 words]Ben CunninghamApr 23, 2008 19:2943919
Right on the money... [265 words]Tim BurtonApr 23, 2006 14:5543917
Reply - Tim Burton [169 words]WilliamApr 23, 2006 17:3643917
to William McGarroch: America's Rude Islamists and BNP supporters [304 words]Anubhav SinghMay 5, 2006 08:5643917
I agree. [63 words]concernedApr 23, 2006 14:2643912
Tim....Not the BNP [82 words]PCMadnessApr 23, 2006 16:1643912
Reply to PCMadness [258 words]Tim BurtonApr 25, 2006 17:5343912
NO TO ISLAM [37 words]howlin freedomApr 23, 2006 14:2643911
If only they would listen [213 words]caroleApr 23, 2006 13:2843904
Only One Way Out [292 words]BarbaraApr 23, 2006 13:1043903
Islamists confidence is a bad sign [97 words]Gideon ReichApr 23, 2006 13:0843902
How can there be peace? [160 words]David DaoudApr 23, 2006 12:4543897
vile [34 words]yonatan silvermanApr 23, 2006 12:2443895
Sickening [33 words]David BrotskyApr 23, 2006 11:1443880
Counter-Terror mandated. [608 words]Jim WrightApr 23, 2006 11:0043878
Islam Rules The World - Not if we can help it! [79 words]ColeApr 23, 2006 10:0843875
nothing has really changed [138 words]dr. richard tombackApr 23, 2006 08:5743867
See the video of the rally: [1 words]ajmApr 23, 2006 01:5843839
Shame on us all [506 words]Kevin AbbasiApr 23, 2006 19:0443839

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)