| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
I agree with this article 100% but what are the alternatives?
Reader comment on item: Mr. Olmert Visits Washington
Submitted by roslyn esther (Canada), May 16, 2006 at 14:24
The article lists all the dangers of unilateral withdrawal and I agree with all of them. But what should Israel do with the West Bank? Should it police and control it forever? Should it negotiate and with whom? What should be the goals of negotiation if any?
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
Daniel Pipes replies:
I addressed this question, giving my thoughts about Israel's necessary course in two recent articles, How Israel Can Win and Israel Shuns Victory.
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (73) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Upholding a Sensible Approach [140 words] | Susan H. Somerville | May 31, 2006 02:11 | 46754 | ||
| American pressure on its allies [136 words] | Amitabh tripathi | May 26, 2006 02:50 | 46434 | ||
| Israels new 2008 vulnerable border [304 words] | Jay | May 23, 2006 01:30 | 46167 | ||
| The expiation of Jews [167 words] | Yuval Brandstetter MD | May 22, 2006 16:19 | 46151 | ||
| Dr. Pipes is right.. [223 words] | M. Saleem Akhtar | May 21, 2006 10:33 | 46074 | ||
| WASHINGTON RALLY 05/23/2005 12 noon [64 words] | odeleya jacobs | May 21, 2006 08:44 | 46070 | ||
| Mr. Olmert Visits Washington [84 words] | steven L | May 19, 2006 16:19 | 45975 | ||
| Cowardice [72 words] | obilic | May 19, 2006 15:55 | 45973 | ||
 Ayaan Hirsi Ali [73 words] | Sidda | May 20, 2006 09:54 | 45973 | ||
| Sidda [25 words] | Octavio Johanson | May 20, 2006 17:06 | 45973 | ||
| Octavio, I don't know [147 words] | Sidda | May 21, 2006 21:26 | 45973 | ||
| Arabs are not a threat. [188 words] | Charles Smyth | May 19, 2006 09:21 | 45948 | ||
| 1 | Israel and Koran, Bible and Torah - Save the whole world! [236 words] | Ayran Khan | May 19, 2006 03:09 | 45936 | |
| ayran khan [43 words] | ahmad zafire | May 20, 2006 08:47 | 45936 | ||
| check your sources [26 words] | anonymous | Dec 9, 2007 19:03 | 45936 | ||
| torah and koran are like wheels in a gear whose cogs are finely and properly engaged... [181 words] | grant newman | Jan 24, 2011 00:41 | 45936 | ||
| Israel must decide what is good for Israel - and the US must decide what is good for the US [342 words] | Sully | May 19, 2006 02:41 | 45933 | ||
| AND STILL NO PEACE why not? [269 words] | rench | May 18, 2006 17:36 | 45903 | ||
| Why the dismantlement show ??? [113 words] | Marlon Moser | May 18, 2006 14:15 | 45897 | ||
| Build the wall! [129 words] | Harrak | May 19, 2006 20:32 | 45897 | ||
| common sense [289 words] | true believer | May 23, 2006 07:19 | 45897 | ||
| reply for true believer [119 words] | Harrak | May 23, 2006 15:42 | 45897 | ||
| Facts and updates for Harrak [860 words] | true believer | May 25, 2006 10:17 | 45897 | ||
| and another thing for Harrak [37 words] | another believer | May 26, 2006 00:48 | 45897 | ||
| true believer...... [176 words] | ahmad zafire | May 27, 2006 22:20 | 45897 | ||
| from true believer to ahmed zafire [494 words] | true believer | May 29, 2006 03:33 | 45897 | ||
| true believer [420 words] | ahmad zafire | May 30, 2006 12:35 | 45897 | ||
| Ahmed Zafire [425 words] | true believer | Jun 16, 2006 08:37 | 45897 | ||
| true believer!!! [77 words] | ahmad zafire | Jun 17, 2006 02:31 | 45897 | ||
| not quite [35 words] | true believer | Jun 26, 2006 09:35 | 45897 | ||
| true believer [23 words] | ahmad zafire | Jun 26, 2006 21:54 | 45897 | ||
| not so [31 words] | true believer | Jun 28, 2006 07:10 | 45897 | ||
| It's time to make GREAT ISRAEL AND COMPLETE PALESTINE COUNTRIES [100 words] | Aryan Khan | May 18, 2006 10:09 | 45889 | ||
| In a perfect world [392 words] | Robert Arbetman | May 18, 2006 09:43 | 45885 | ||
| Olmert to D.C [416 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Al Ramey | May 17, 2006 20:18 | 45838 | ||
| Mr. Olmert Visits Washington [128 words] | quebecoise | May 17, 2006 17:11 | 45821 | ||
| Israel: Secular Vs Torah [841 words] | Yoven | May 17, 2006 16:52 | 45820 | ||
| Zilzal 1X ATTN: Yoven [295 words] | Harrak | May 18, 2006 18:56 | 45820 | ||
| to yoven [147 words] | tariq | May 20, 2006 05:40 | 45820 | ||
| To yoven Immigration of jews to Israel [371 words] | Faisal | May 24, 2006 08:50 | 45820 | ||
| One can always hope... [131 words] | J.S. | May 17, 2006 15:55 | 45816 | ||
| Many Israeli policies make no sense [256 words] | Kenneth S. Besig | May 17, 2006 12:40 | 45808 | ||
| why Israel may be making these withdrawals [81 words] | lee brock | May 17, 2006 12:31 | 45807 | ||
| Jews and muslims [85 words] | G.Bisvas | May 17, 2006 06:36 | 45790 | ||
| the unfortunate quislings [76 words] | Donald O | May 17, 2006 20:08 | 45790 | ||
| hoping for a G-d willing peace between jews and muslims [40 words] | ahmad zafire | May 17, 2006 22:38 | 45790 | ||
| Olmert Goes to Washington [273 words] | Ed Gordon | May 17, 2006 04:13 | 45786 | ||
| Gush Etzion [67 words] | Israel Pickholtz | May 17, 2006 01:43 | 45783 | ||
| The devil is in the details [164 words] | Moshe Even-Shoshan | May 16, 2006 23:56 | 45780 | ||
| Garrison State [122 words] | Blackspeare | May 16, 2006 22:57 | 45774 | ||
| END WITHDRAWAL FROM TERRITORY; DO NOT GIVE UP LAND [177 words] | Carmen Waggoner, Ph.D. | May 16, 2006 22:20 | 45771 | ||
| Let Israel Do It [738 words] | John R | May 18, 2006 18:55 | 45771 | ||
| Israeli Strategy [109 words] | John R | May 19, 2006 16:01 | 45771 | ||
| Olmert, the terrorist's ally [222 words] | Dr-RJP | May 16, 2006 20:56 | 45763 | ||
| The fall [197 words] | Harrak | May 19, 2006 00:25 | 45763 | ||
| Israeli retreat [192 words] | Daniel M | May 16, 2006 17:39 | 45753 | ||
| why so glum [362 words] | john w. mcginley | May 16, 2006 16:04 | 45737 | ||
| Olmert's U.S. visit [71 words] | David BenShem | May 16, 2006 15:44 | 45736 | ||
| What we learn from history is, we do not learn from history [100 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 16, 2006 15:34 | 45735 | ||
| history for our country [38 words] | adeel | Oct 13, 2010 01:45 | 45735 | ||
| Olmerts convergence plan. [37 words] | Monty Pogoda | May 16, 2006 15:01 | 45733 | ||
| Israeli Withdrawals [37 words] | Jack Bremer | May 16, 2006 14:49 | 45731 | ||
| Israel and Palestine [51 words] | Kerry Winn | May 16, 2006 19:31 | 45731 | ||
 I agree with this article 100% but what are the alternatives? [47 words]w/response from Daniel Pipes | roslyn esther | May 16, 2006 14:24 | 45728 | ||
| The alternative [254 words] | Yuval Brandstetter MD | May 17, 2006 15:45 | 45728 | ||
| a reply to Dr. Pipes Reply [100 words] | roslyn esther | May 17, 2006 17:49 | 45728 | ||
| Compared to Iraq, Gaza is going GREAT! [148 words] | Steve | May 16, 2006 13:37 | 45723 | ||
| JEWISH RETREAT [100 words] | Ken Zimmerman | May 16, 2006 12:55 | 45722 | ||
| Kadima plus Olmert [253 words] | true believer | May 17, 2006 10:14 | 45722 | ||
| Appeasement continues [64 words] | Ralph C Whaley MD | May 16, 2006 12:37 | 45720 | ||
| There she goes again [153 words] | yonatan silverman | May 16, 2006 12:06 | 45718 | ||
| Recent Remarks by Former IDF Chief Ya'alon [1016 words] | Ken Mann | May 16, 2006 11:20 | 45712 | ||
| And Lest We Forget... [103 words] | Robert | May 16, 2006 18:27 | 45712 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)