69 million page views

Who are Christian Zionists and who is attacking them?

Reader comment on item: [Christian Zionism:] Israel's Best Weapon?

Submitted by Ami Isseroff (Israel), Jun 13, 2006 at 05:38

Dear Daniel,

The article raises important points, but we need to understand (or find out?) who exactly are Christian Zionists and who is attacking them, and why. They are not a uniform group and the support that Bush's policies enjoy in the USA is not due primarily to the most vociferous and extreme proponents of Christian support for Israel. I am sure that Condoleezza Rice is a Christian and that she supports Israel's right to exist. I doubt if she subscribes to all the ideas of Pat Robertson.

"Christian Zionism" may denote three different things:

1. Support of any Christian for the existence of Israel as a state, and for giving Israel a fair hearing in attacks such as the divestment campaigns. This is due to rational and theological considerations, including recognized guilt for the Holocaust and Christian anti-Semitism, for which "replacement theology"* was a doctrinal underpinning.

2. Support for restoration of the Jews, a movement that began in the 16th and 17th centuries and was inspired by the reformation and the vulgate translation of the bible, which discredited replacement theology.

3. Belief in 'dispensationalism' rapture and armageddon, and the desire to bring about about armageddon in order to see the second coming of Christ. (The doctrine of Darby, adopted and adapted in the USA by various evangelist groups and caricatured by people like Stephen Sizer).

Opponents of Christian Zionism are trying to paint all Christian support for Israel as #3- dangerous fundamentalist fanatics, and to discredit it in this way. Their approach is that there are only two choices - either be an anti-Zionist or support dangerous extremists. In fact, most Christian support for Zionism is not based on #3 but on #1 and #2. The people who are trying to overturn the Presbyterian divestment decision are not believers in Armageddon and rapture, but rather people who believe in fairness and common sense, and this is true of groups like Anglicans for Israel and others.

See http://www.zionism-israel.com/Christian_Zionism for some additional background.

* Replacement theology is the doctrine that all the promises that God made to "Israel" in the old testament were transferred to the Christian Church because the Jews sinned and denied Jesus as the Messiah.

Dislike
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (62) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
How about Hindu Zionism? [120 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
PrashantJul 24, 2022 02:08284103
Christian Zionist Importance [8 words]Leonard CohenJul 23, 2022 10:33284077
Christians Need Not Be Zionists to Support Israel's Return to Zion [180 words]M ToveyDec 15, 2021 10:26277281
1891 3-5 Palestine for the Jews; a Copy of the Memorial [Petition] Presented to President Harrison (Signed) by Wm. E. Blackstone [33 words]RobertDec 12, 2021 19:15277240
Zionists and The Invisible Hand [491 words]Michael SAug 31, 2015 09:26224878
Christian Zionism [61 words]Lujack SkylarkNov 3, 2012 23:44200291
1Time for an update after Obama throwing Israel under the bus on May 19, 2011 [141 words]Dan SchwartzMay 21, 2011 15:19185444
3Christian duty to protect the Jews and Israel [33 words]Phil GreendJun 8, 2007 03:1196696
1Who are the rebellious generation [111 words]DeWayneJan 9, 2008 20:0796696
Christian Zionists, Jews, and Israel [1 words]David Ben-ArielSep 6, 2006 16:0655093
Who are Christian Zionists and who is attacking them? [367 words]Ami IsseroffJun 13, 2006 05:3847558
Christian Zionism as Christians who reject the New Testament for their own version of Old Testament [186 words]DeWayneFeb 16, 2007 22:4947558
1Replacement Theology as Anti-Semitism [357 words]Ami IsseroffFeb 25, 2007 22:2047558
Replacement Theology [753 words]DeWayneFeb 26, 2007 20:2347558
Bishop Eusebius ? [186 words]DeWayneFeb 26, 2007 20:4247558
Besides Replacement, Restoration, and Reformation Theology, There is Regeneration [1099 words]Bryan RunnelsAug 5, 2009 06:4147558
Why we Christians (Bible believing evangelicals) support Jews [392 words]Sharon BeardAug 24, 2011 10:4347558
Supersessionism [21 words]Jonathan RickJan 20, 2006 00:4532040
It is Mind Boggling [157 words]www.jperspective.comSep 30, 2004 15:3817484
Bush's wmd [91 words]Brenda LachanceFeb 11, 2004 20:4113849
Christian Zionism [112 words]RICHARD CHAIMBERLINNov 1, 2003 20:5412040
Thank you [67 words]VladikOct 18, 2003 05:3511832
Writing campaign? [46 words]Dee Dee NadlerAug 5, 2003 01:2810445
Nice job [36 words]MostakAug 1, 2003 11:2710381
Christian Zionist [81 words]Linda REbohJul 28, 2003 12:4710277
What is the point of all the arguments??? [208 words]Perplexed!Jul 25, 2003 02:3310233
Steve Wells has hit the target! [60 words]Gary MaggioJul 22, 2003 00:3610103
Sorry, you failed to cite Mr Henry Dunant [59 words]thomas n. laszloJul 17, 2003 08:4310056
Another Reason for Christian Zionism [149 words]Joan HellerJul 17, 2003 02:5610054
Prophecy about the re-gathering when and where [188 words]DeWayneFeb 16, 2007 23:1210054
UK CHRISTIANS [160 words]Nigel FreemanJul 16, 2003 18:3610049
Israel's Only Real Ally [237 words]FrankJul 16, 2003 14:5510045
Christian Zionism [208 words]Arlinda DeAngelisJul 16, 2003 14:0610044
Christian Zionism (Judeo/Christian) Talmudic? [212 words]DeWayneFeb 26, 2007 02:5010044
Christian Zionism [122 words]Jim O'DeaJul 16, 2003 10:1910038
Christian Zionism [30 words]Terry MillerJul 16, 2003 08:2510036
General praise [15 words]Walter D'UllJul 16, 2003 07:0910034
1Israel's Best Weapon? [135 words]Tatiana PahlenJul 16, 2003 03:4510032
Swamp and Desert... [59 words]Bev HeippJul 16, 2003 01:1510031
Christian Zionists Support may be a two-edged sword [385 words]robert fusfeldJul 15, 2003 22:2110027
Questioning the Motivation of Christian Zionists [58 words]Tillie and Norman MutterperlJul 15, 2003 22:0810026
Irony of Christian Zionism [206 words]Horace Jeffery Hodges, Ph.D.Jul 15, 2003 19:2110025
DeWitt Talmage, the celebrated preacher [59 words]P. LubinJul 15, 2003 15:4210021
Christian Zionists, ok; antisemites, no! [62 words]Hersh AdlersteinJul 15, 2003 15:0810020
Easy does it -- but do it [195 words]John W. McGinleyJul 15, 2003 14:5210019
Christian Zionists [66 words]Lisa MichelsonJul 15, 2003 14:4510018
Excellent! [17 words]Denice Gary PandolJul 15, 2003 13:3510017
Christian Zionists [98 words]Marvin PetalJul 15, 2003 12:4010016
best weapon and ally [271 words]Carmen Waggoner, Ph.D.Jul 15, 2003 11:3210014
1The Darkside of Christian Zionism [162 words]Glenn KlotzJul 15, 2003 11:2910013
1There Is No 'Dark side' to Christian Zionism [304 words]Paul BatesFeb 13, 2007 22:5510013
The Dark Side of Christian Zionism [248 words]DeWayneFeb 26, 2007 02:2110013
No Dark Side to Christian Zionism [145 words]DeWayneFeb 26, 2007 03:1310013
Persecutions only rainbow [38 words]Marvin DiamondJul 15, 2003 11:0910011
Motivations of early Christian Zionists [204 words]Robert B. ArbetmanJul 15, 2003 09:2710007
Amen [1 words]Jill NeilyJul 15, 2003 08:4010005
Christian Zionists [42 words]Steve WellsJul 15, 2003 07:5310004
Thank you. [8 words]Robert G. MogullJul 15, 2003 07:4210003
1extremism isn't necessarily zionist [95 words]larry derfnerJul 15, 2003 07:1010002
Well said!! [71 words]NicholasNov 16, 2021 19:5510002
Not All Supporters of Zion are Extremists As Enemies of Zion Would Have Any to Believe [52 words]M ToveyNov 17, 2021 19:0110002
Just sent the following to Bill O'Reilly [176 words]Steve KleinJul 15, 2003 06:4310001

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)