69 million page views

SELF RESTRAINT IS FATAL

Reader comment on item: Thoughts on the Israeli Incursion into Gaza

Submitted by FERN SIDMAN (United States), Jul 13, 2006 at 14:43

As a young person growing up in New York City, I was a member of Brit Trumpeldor of America, better known as the Zionist Youth Movement Betar, founded by the great Zionist leader, Ze"ev Jabotinsky. When I joined Betar at the age of 12, every potential member was required to enroll in the Tironut program. Tironut, or basic training, as it were, was an intensive series of lectures and seminars covering a wide range of topics including Jewish history, the history of the Zionist movement and the glorious legacy of Betar and the Jewish underground that valiantly battled the British during the mandatory regime, prior to the creation of the State of Israel.

I learned about a young Jew from Poland named Shalom Tabachnik, a/k/a Shlomo Ben Yosef, a member of Betar who came to live in the land of Israel and who settled on the northern settlement of Rosh Pina. On Thursday, April 21, 1938, the 20th day of Nissan 5698, Ben Yosef and two Betar colleagues attempted to defend the settlement of Rosh Pina from an impending Arab attack, emanating from the neighboring Arab village of Djani. An automobile carrying Arabs approached Rosh Pina. Ben Yosef and his two fellow Betarim stepped out on the road and tried to stop the automobile. A single shot was fired and the Arabs fled in panic.

A few hours after the incident the three young men were arrested by the British police. They gave themselves up without any struggle. "Despite the fact that not a single drop of blood was shed at Rosh Pina and despite the fact that the police knew very well that the three young men had only fired into the air in order to discourage the Arabs from passing through the settlement, the British decided to create a big "terrorist" incident out of the Rosh Pina affair. The very fact that Jews had resolved to withstand an Arab attack made them feel afraid. Their plan to frighten Jews from coming to Palestine would be endangered if Jews were to fight back. They knew very well that the Jews could put an end to the Arab "revolts" in a few days." (Triumph on the Gallows, Itzhak Gurion, 1950)

On June 29, 1938 Ben Yosef was hanged on the gallows by the British authorities. His last words in a conversation with friends were, "Havlagah" (self-restraint) is fatal."

Today I also thought of the brave and courageous defender of the settlement Tel Chai. I thought of Yosef Trumpeldor, for whom Betar is named. I thought of his efforts to defend Tel Chai against Arab attacks. No stranger to military conflicts, Trumpeldor was the highest ranking Jewish officer in the Czar's army during the Russo-Japanese war of 1905. I thought of him and of his last words when he was gunned down by an Arab bullet while defending the settlement in 1920.

Today, I thought of the last words of Shlomo Ben Yosef and Yosef Trumpeldor when I read of Katyusha rocket attacks on cities in northern Israel. Besides Nahariya, it was reported that Rosh Pina and Tel Chai had been hit by rocket fire and that the airport in Rosh Pina was shut down. I thought of Shlomo Ben Yosef and Yosef Trumpeldor when I heard Ehud Olmert's response to the rocket attacks by the Syrian backed Hizbollah militia in Lebanon. According to a news report from Arutz Sheva, "Olmert was clear that the multi-pronged attack, which involved ground forces as well as Katyusha rockets, was not an act of terror, but "an act of war" and said the Israeli response would be "very restrained but very, very painful."

Seems like the word restraint keeps rearing its head. The Associated Press reported that, "U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan called for restraint. "We would not want to see an expansion, an escalation, of conflict in the region," he said. Mr. Annan was joined by US Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice, who was quoted by Associated Press as saying, "All sides must act with restraint to resolve this incident peacefully and to protect innocent civilians and civilian infrastructure." If we've learned anything from this two front war that threatens to explode like a powder keg, we've learned that the calls for restraint from world leaders only apply to Israel. Seems like the age old double standard concerning the actions of Israel are in full swing.

While the State of Israel engages Hizbollah terrorists on its northern border and Hamas terrorists on its southern border, let us remember the words of the young Betari from Rosh Pina. Let us remember the words of this simple Jew whose courage and bravery move us to tears. Let us remember the actions and examples that Yosef Trumpeldor set for his people and his beloved nation of Israel, so many years ago.

It is these axioms that must shape our destiny in the current military conflict. We must address the world clearly and unequivocally. We must shout from the rooftops, the words of Shlomo Ben Yosef. Yes, it is true. Self restraint is fatal. We know that self restraint only emboldens our enemies. We know that the Arab enemy mocks and ridicules Israel when self restraint is elevated to the level of a religious commandment. We know that only swift action without trepidation or hesitation can ensure our preservation.

The facts are clear and cannot be debated. Three Israeli soldiers are being held captive by our Arab enemy and eight Israeli soldiers lay dead as a result from the brazen attacks from Hizbollah. Jewish settlements, towns and cities are being barraged by Katyusha rocket attacks on our northern front and continued Kassam rocket attacks are being staged by our Arab enemy In Gaza. This is the time to throw off the yoke of "restraint". Our survival and preservation as a people and nation are at stake. Now is the time conquer our proverbial nemesis, better known as fear of world opinion. Now is the time to reach out to the Almighty G-d of Israel.

Now is the time to know that Hashem marches into battle with us. As Jews, we are never alone. Hashem will be with us, if only we allow Him to be. If only we bend our collective necks to the yoke of Heaven and walk in His ways and remain faithful to His commandments. Hashem commands us to show no mercy on our enemies. We are commanded to fear only G-d and to treat our enemies accordingly. To engage in bold and decisive military actions that will permanently disable Hizbollah and Hamas. If we can summon up the strength to quash our own egos and accept Hashem's dominion, the battle will be fought for us.

On this 17th day of Tammuz, may our prayers reach the Almighty G-d of Israel and may He protect His nation Israel.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (41) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Canadians killed in Lebanon [77 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Michael McNaughtonJul 18, 2006 12:5850023
Gaza invasion [121 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Robert SolotJul 14, 2006 11:5249653
WHO is Israel fighting ? [92 words]Henry EfroymsonJul 14, 2006 10:3849645
SELF RESTRAINT IS FATAL [1143 words]FERN SIDMANJul 13, 2006 14:4349580
Again HUMANE & Super- restrained Israel only attacks terrorists after warning to civilians to evacuate [266 words]FreeNov 27, 2006 14:1449580
Agreement with most, but not all... [79 words]orange yonasonJul 2, 2006 19:0048747
One more thing Israel should do for every suicide bombing [49 words]EstherJul 1, 2006 19:4048686
no recognition of Palestinians, the stateless Arabs of the Levant [273 words]Jonathan UsherJul 1, 2006 10:4048656
comments in old testament [177 words]Jonathan UsherSep 4, 2007 06:5048656
1Palestine is mentioned in Genesis [135 words]mary sparrowdancerSep 4, 2007 17:4448656
Your first mistake is thinking that today's Palestinians have ANYTHING to do with Phillistines...! [171 words]sarahSep 5, 2007 23:4048656
mary sparrowdancer is dead wrong [30 words]KlewSep 6, 2007 02:1548656
And do you claim to be "American?" [66 words]mary sparrowdancerSep 14, 2007 17:5048656
Klew is wrong [40 words]mary sparrowdancerSep 14, 2007 17:5348656
Palestinians and Palestine [215 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
MusaAug 25, 2018 14:3448656
Re: #659: Pipes explains in NY Sun "How Israel Can Win"; and #657 [362 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Richard FinnJul 1, 2006 08:2248650
Can't rule Palestinians in 21st century the way the British ruled India in the 19th century [294 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Ian MordantJul 1, 2006 06:4448646
Can't rule palestine in the 21st century.......... [48 words]JoeJul 5, 2006 07:1348646
A Simpler Solution [129 words]PTJul 1, 2006 03:4748639
Thoughts on the Israeli Incursion into Gaza [36 words]steven lJun 30, 2006 21:3248623
End of two-state travesty [352 words]markJun 30, 2006 19:2148609
"Walls have only limited utility..." True, but... [140 words]ElaineJun 30, 2006 17:2148595
Points more relevant today than ever. [24 words]LouJun 30, 2006 15:5048587
Save Your Breath [150 words]DebbyJun 30, 2006 17:2148587
Debby I'm with you every word, and I live in Israel almost 60 years. [95 words]BruriaJul 1, 2006 11:0448587
Thankfully I never moved to Israel [124 words]Jeff BurkeJul 5, 2006 18:5948587
Gaza invasion [69 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Robert SolotJun 30, 2006 14:2548580
الغدر سبب فشل السلام [252 words]mohamed .mJun 30, 2006 14:1248576
The Limited Elasticity of Appeasement [470 words]AlexJun 29, 2006 14:1748438
Gaza invasion [59 words]Robert SolotJun 30, 2006 14:3248438
Exchange Rate [41 words]WolfJul 1, 2006 00:5748438
THIS NONSENSE HAS GOT TO STOP! [226 words]bobJun 29, 2006 13:1748437
Gaza re-entry [91 words]Steve GureJun 30, 2006 13:3948437
Good Idea [21 words]Mark RothJun 29, 2006 11:4848429
Excellent proposals, but how many more Jewish dead before the Israeli government implements them? [52 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
mhlJun 29, 2006 10:2348427
Thoughts on Gaza Incursion- not accurate [158 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Andy B.Jun 29, 2006 09:3948423
Why the death penalty will not work [293 words]Pro-Israeli DemocratJun 29, 2006 09:0548419
results of international funding for the PA [136 words]michael cJun 29, 2006 07:4848414
thoughts on the Israeli incursion into Gaza [134 words]joeJun 29, 2006 04:4748409
Wake Up World [109 words]MartynJul 14, 2006 17:3448409
The fence is good [146 words]Henrik R ClausenJun 29, 2006 03:5048407

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)