69 million page views

The Incredible Shrinking Baker

Reader comment on item: James Baker's Terrible Iraq Report

Submitted by Peter J. Herz (United States), Dec 12, 2006 at 20:18

I now see a pattern with James Baker: sound wise and pretend that everyone's operating in good faith.

I once heard Mr. Baker declare that America's One China policy was designed to give Beijing and Taipei time to work things out peacefully. In fact, it seems to tempt Beijing to bellicosity and military adventurism every four years. Now, he says Iran under Ah-madness-inedjad can be a bonafide peace partner. When, O when, will America's elite see that there really are people who hate liberty?

Dislike
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (114) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Bush the "conservative" [213 words]freemanJun 17, 2007 12:1098867
Baker has the view? [41 words]Robert G. DeardorffJan 28, 2007 19:1874884
Bush Administration Experts? [74 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
MalachyJan 17, 2007 09:1173272
Two Choices; Stay or Leave [94 words]Jersey GuyJan 10, 2007 00:2372239
Just when I thought it couldn't be done any dumber. [15 words]Reality CheckDec 21, 2006 21:1070189
BAKER'S OBJECTIVITY, TAKE II [38 words]orange yonasonDec 20, 2006 22:5570109
Joel Rosenberg political thriller-chiller novels [177 words]Lucy ChambersDec 20, 2006 18:3170098
Bush war [74 words]G.VishvasDec 20, 2006 10:2170076
RANDOM SPECULATIONS ON THE... [115 words]orange yonasonDec 19, 2006 23:4170055
CAN MISTER BAKER SAY, "CONFLICT OF INTEREST"? [116 words]orange yonasonDec 19, 2006 23:2070054
The prepaid ISG drivel [117 words]A. RamyDec 19, 2006 21:1170048
Marriage and Divorce Iraqi style [275 words]JayDec 19, 2006 01:4769940
It's still about FREEDOM - its presence or absence [161 words]Jay ConneDec 18, 2006 16:3469903
Brain Damage [23 words]MiriamDec 18, 2006 15:0869889
Iraq Study Group and the Arab-Israeli Conflict [113 words]Isaac MoubazbazDec 18, 2006 14:5169883
Just desserts for this shameful hustle. [471 words]marianaDec 17, 2006 16:2569792
Where were the "experts"? [93 words]JoelDec 16, 2006 19:4169713
I don't know... [114 words]Frank ShipleyDec 16, 2006 23:0869713
To be expected [136 words]John GiannascaDec 14, 2006 18:5969568
US Iraq Study Report [603 words]Stephen E hughesDec 14, 2006 12:4269527
But What If [23 words]Richard WittrupDec 14, 2006 11:2669524
Richard Wittrup: There must be a paradigm shift in thinking [67 words]gellin and infidellinDec 16, 2006 17:5869524
Islam is the problem [158 words]Romesh ChanderDec 16, 2006 21:1469524
Al Qaeda training 'English brothers' in Pakistan : Our best Non NATO Ally Pakistan is training Terrorists to murder innocent Americans [675 words]Proud CalifornianDec 18, 2006 23:0269524
Bush - Go For It!!!!!! [60 words]NirGuiDec 20, 2006 10:3569524
1The Archeology of The Middle East [694 words]Gellin and InfidellinDec 20, 2006 17:5169524
Islam is problem [191 words]Imdad AliMar 16, 2007 02:1069524
All Christians , Jews , Catholics , Hindus , Sikhs , Orthodox , Buddhists , Parsees , Bahais ,etc must send e-mail to US President Bush to take out Iran Nuclear facilities [77 words]AyodhyaDec 14, 2006 10:5669521
Dumbest request [152 words]Romesh ChanderDec 15, 2006 13:5069521
Romesh Chander ! Stop US bashing [139 words]TholiaDec 16, 2006 03:5969521
I agree - Bush should not bomb Iran's nuclear sites [74 words]jim.eDec 16, 2006 19:1869521
US is the last bastion of defense! [153 words]Syed KasimDec 17, 2006 22:2569521
Get real! [135 words]Noah WilkDec 21, 2006 21:0069521
Amen, Jim! [313 words]Noah WilkDec 21, 2006 21:1169521
blue-ribbon commissions should be analytic, not political [743 words]Stuart FaginDec 13, 2006 23:4869479
A war you say? Yes, it's Civil War, Stupid! [93 words]Martin KesslerDec 13, 2006 22:5869471
Why End the Muslim on Muslim Fighting, be it Baghdad or Gaza City? [206 words]Jeff BurkeDec 17, 2006 21:4469471
Baker's Other Forgotten Major Failure [61 words]Douglas BoggsDec 13, 2006 21:5269467
James "Big Oil" Baker Report [173 words]John R. PeacherDec 13, 2006 18:1569442
The slippery oil [46 words]Martin KesslerDec 18, 2006 02:4969442
Let's just hope and pray ... [10 words]Josh GDec 13, 2006 16:3469417
ERROR! [19 words]Mickey ObermanDec 13, 2006 16:3269416
Don't forget ... [3 words]Josh GDec 14, 2006 03:3669416
Baker and Carter [66 words]Gary CantorDec 13, 2006 15:3669407
People Mr Baker is advising to negotiate with ? [195 words]AlexanderZDec 13, 2006 12:2869391
suggestions for America's Policy with respect to the Iraq war [18 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
R. LaGambaDec 13, 2006 08:2969379
Unfortunately, many foreign-policy failures since Truman [133 words]SadhasivDec 13, 2006 08:1569378
US failure based on denial of Iraq's sectarian facts on the ground [378 words]Michael GreenDec 13, 2006 05:4869370
Paying for it - in more ways than one [111 words]David W. LincolnDec 13, 2006 05:4769369
Mr. Bush, reject it as a whole [57 words]Vic CoffeyDec 13, 2006 05:3669368
If it sounds like Saudi ploy... [23 words]Michael GreenDec 13, 2006 03:3369362
COULD WORK [88 words]JOHN MANITTADec 13, 2006 02:3869355
While we're stuck in Iraq, look at jihadi progress--according to Douglas Farah--a nice summary. [96 words]MelMDec 13, 2006 02:0369352
James Baker's Terrible Iraq Report [27 words]BenDec 13, 2006 01:5769351
Our vision is dangerously stuck in Iraq trying to avoid a catastrophic failure. [330 words]MelMDec 13, 2006 01:1269347
The Baker's team [15 words]steven LDec 13, 2006 00:2769345
Is Baker aware what iranian president said today? [41 words]Hari IyerDec 12, 2006 23:4269343
No Nothing Iraq Study Report [150 words]andria spindelDec 12, 2006 23:1769342
The Edelman PR Connection [252 words]Alan M. KaplanDec 12, 2006 21:5769335
How do we do it? [17 words]gellin and infidellinDec 12, 2006 21:5469334
Language, culture and the intelligence failure [324 words]James ArchibaldDec 12, 2006 21:5469333
Your 12/5 article, "Moderate Islam May Be Key To Winning War on Terror" [38 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Richard ShulmanDec 12, 2006 21:2769331
How can we trust "Moderate Muslims"...for anything? [349 words]RPaineDec 19, 2006 19:2569331
The Incredible Shrinking Baker [84 words]Peter J. HerzDec 12, 2006 20:1869326
Best I've read so far... my anger went down a notch, thanks! [189 words]Kay ScottDec 12, 2006 20:0669323
1Baker's Law Firm represents the Arabs [36 words]DaveDec 12, 2006 17:4169308
Yes, Dave, Baker is the lawyer for the Saudis against American citizens! [49 words]Kay ScottDec 13, 2006 16:5669308
1/2 withdrawal [35 words]John JasnochDec 19, 2006 12:0669308
"SALAD, ANYONE" [109 words]MARTIN KESSLERDec 12, 2006 17:4069306
I'm in total agreement... [89 words]Rick HouseDec 12, 2006 16:1669293
Republican, Democrat or Bi-Partisan all are in varying degrees of fantasy land [463 words]rickDec 12, 2006 16:0069291
In 1840 Alexis deTocqueville agreed with your premise [207 words]rICHDec 19, 2006 11:4769291
Whose Fight is This? [218 words]Ben PerryDec 12, 2006 15:5669290
Daniel P. is dead on [125 words]M. BenjaminDec 12, 2006 23:5969290
Only solution to this crisis [240 words]TempleDec 14, 2006 10:5269290
Step up [39 words]wolfgangDec 14, 2006 11:2469290
Benjamin solution [115 words]Syed KasimDec 17, 2006 22:4669290
Bell Curve of Intelligence [71 words]LDCDec 12, 2006 15:4869289
Let Me Join the Warmonger Parade [306 words]BlackspeareDec 12, 2006 14:5369284
James A. Borat, DC permanent feature. [237 words]PavelDec 12, 2006 22:2869284
Secure the Kurds, Let the Rest Fight It Out [444 words]JoeDec 12, 2006 14:5369283
important and relevant history [11 words]Phyllis StraussDec 12, 2006 14:5169282
Baker&Botts (with Hamilton) [104 words]AlanDec 12, 2006 14:3169279
James Baker's Terrible Iraq Report [157 words]Marcel ZytoDec 12, 2006 13:3869275
Response to Daniel Pipes' article [26 words]mendelDec 12, 2006 13:2669271
Contact the White House. Mr. Mendel's idea [112 words]GeniDec 12, 2006 18:2069271
Dangerous Islam [153 words]DmytroJan 28, 2009 07:4469271
Baker Report and Bush War Plan [232 words]James WelshDec 12, 2006 13:0669270
Israel....alone. [105 words]PotatoeDec 12, 2006 13:0169269
The majority of Muslims [136 words]JeffDec 13, 2006 02:1069269
Baker Commission Iraq Report [341 words]MPicowDec 12, 2006 13:0069268
The gist of the Report [99 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDDec 12, 2006 12:4969267
Another disappointment.....Titles over substance [178 words]No DhimmiDec 12, 2006 12:0169263
Priceless [449 words]PatDec 12, 2006 11:5169261
ISG Report [53 words]Gary RosenDec 12, 2006 11:1369259
time to name names [98 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
cvtDec 12, 2006 10:5069257
ISG [69 words]Donald W. BalesDec 12, 2006 10:2569255
Who is to lead the Arab World-The Sunis or the Sheites [123 words]David GoshenDec 12, 2006 10:2569254
Civil War in Islam !!! [377 words]Romesh ChanderDec 12, 2006 09:5669251
Romesh - I agree with you.. No sudh thing as moderate Islam or moderate Muslim [82 words]JaladhiDec 12, 2006 15:4669251
Romesh Chander Truer words have never been said [51 words]gellin and infidellinDec 13, 2006 20:0669251
The west is the problem [52 words]Syed KasimDec 17, 2006 23:0269251
Syed Kasim back to the madrassa [70 words]gellin and infidellinDec 18, 2006 10:3469251
IGNORANCE IS THE CAUSE OF SO MUCH HATRED IN THE WORLD [160 words]GERARDO LARREA FRENCHDec 22, 2006 00:5269251
It's time to leave daddy's friends and find your own, George! [71 words]Abu NudnikDec 12, 2006 09:5569250
Bunch of Know-Nothing clowns on center stage? [150 words]JaladhiDec 12, 2006 09:2869247
You are too kind [16 words]jim.eDec 12, 2006 09:2469246
The Baker Report [33 words]Mildred MallekDec 12, 2006 09:0569243
ISG Membership [42 words]JuliaDec 13, 2006 07:0569243
Other Know-nothing figures and Baker report is nothing but a way out [192 words]HarrakDec 12, 2006 08:4469241
New Lipstick on a Very Old Piq. In this case, the old pig is James Baker III [195 words]Jeff BurkeDec 12, 2006 07:4269234
A suggestion that was never made by any bi-partisan group [274 words]rickDec 12, 2006 16:5569234
You forgot one [56 words]SadhasivDec 13, 2006 14:0069234
Handball is played every day just not with the right people [156 words]RickDec 13, 2006 18:5969234

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)