| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
Comments on the left
Reader comment on item: Why the Left Loves Osama [and Saddam]
Submitted by Sharna Fetman (United States), Mar 19, 2003 at 16:19
Dear Dr. Pipes:I believe this article simplifies and automatically villifies as"left" everyone who does not agree with the war.
I am no lover of Saddam. I am also a student of history and understand well the lesson of World War II and the problems of appeasement. However, the sheer lack of diplomacy and respect shown by everyone--including Rumsfeld, Cheney, and Bush--for our backers and detractors in Europe and around the world is shortsighted and appalling.
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (134) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Moral equivalence [38 words] | guy | Jul 13, 2011 19:42 | 187333 | ||
| churchill got it right [59 words] | rabbi allen podet | Aug 18, 2010 11:22 | 176892 | ||
| Pathetic Loony Left [74 words] | Godfrey deBouillon | Feb 15, 2010 21:09 | 168943 | ||
| It is easy to get published if you are politically correct [93 words] | Abhishek | May 5, 2009 21:51 | 154990 | ||
| 1 | Gullible left and opportunist Islamists [213 words] | Sunil | Apr 25, 2009 22:39 | 154473 | |
| how low the ideals of the left [80 words] | rodney allsworth | Apr 20, 2009 23:26 | 154177 | ||
 How Low the Ideals of the Left- Low as you can go, Response to Rodney Allsworth [117 words] | Anne- USA | May 9, 2009 11:32 | 154177 | ||
| Thank You Mr. Pipes [63 words] | Fred | Sep 19, 2006 12:28 | 56467 | ||
| The Left that exists only in weak, ignorant sheep minds. [92 words] | Billy | Jan 22, 2007 20:58 | 56467 | ||
| Know neither left nor right [129 words] | Joshua | Feb 16, 2007 22:40 | 56467 | ||
| The right wing fantasy-believers... [15 words] | tom | Dec 14, 2008 17:42 | 56467 | ||
| Please Explain [213 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Infidel | Sep 12, 2006 17:34 | 55735 | ||
| Liberals vs. Fringe Conspiracy Theorists [540 words] | Justin H. | Jan 13, 2006 12:49 | 31575 | ||
| 1 | enemy of my enemy is my friend [30 words] | Dean | Nov 13, 2005 01:59 | 28302 | |
| Nobody's Poodle [299 words] | Nicole Chaplain-Pearman | Jul 29, 2005 11:27 | 24040 | ||
| sacred cow? [71 words] | charlie | Sep 12, 2006 22:47 | 24040 | ||
| The left [32 words] | sgtmac_46 | Jul 22, 2005 22:53 | 23721 | ||
| Wonderful article [57 words] | P Sing | Jul 11, 2005 19:15 | 23362 | ||
| Marxists [78 words] | Twin Ruler | Sep 28, 2004 14:27 | 17433 | ||
| one of the elements driving the left [75 words] | colin | Feb 29, 2004 14:56 | 14024 | ||
| How Charming. Uneducated children spewing words... [277 words] | Jen | Sep 9, 2003 09:30 | 11097 | ||
| You are uneducated [95 words] | Jaren Sanders | Feb 2, 2006 11:18 | 11097 | ||
| its spelled 'Gandhi' and not 'Ghandi' [21 words] | Anubhav Singh | Sep 13, 2006 01:03 | 11097 | ||
| human nature [554 words] | frank | Mar 5, 2007 23:59 | 11097 | ||
| Response to traditionalists "Leftist response..." [250 words] | Ricardo Ben-Safed | Sep 6, 2003 15:52 | 11062 | ||
| Income redistribution [65 words] | Bruce | Aug 23, 2003 00:20 | 10733 | ||
| In response to Leftist response [106 words] | foxyact | Jun 4, 2003 14:45 | 9387 | ||
| liberals been melted down [45 words] | bradley w. east | Apr 22, 2003 19:10 | 8577 | ||
| Leftist response... [339 words] | vcrs | Apr 12, 2003 16:06 | 8288 | ||
| Saddam's choice. [126 words] | Maureen Neilson | Apr 12, 2003 08:32 | 8280 | ||
| Ulla Sandbaek promulgates a myth [172 words] | David | Apr 11, 2003 17:18 | 8274 | ||
| Enlightening article [34 words] | Donna Ragan | Apr 11, 2003 03:54 | 8259 | ||
| To commenter Sharna Fetman [75 words] | Beruska | Apr 9, 2003 02:23 | 8197 | ||
| Liberation... [103 words] | Jean-Sébastien Duquette | Apr 8, 2003 11:36 | 8151 | ||
| This argument is past its pull date [238 words] | Mike Elvin | Apr 7, 2003 17:40 | 8125 | ||
| In Response To Jan Gustin's letter ‘Left Or Far Left [341 words] | Jonathan Pfeffer | Apr 7, 2003 13:37 | 8117 | ||
| Demonization of the left...the RIGHT thing to do. [241 words] | Larry Mendoza | Apr 7, 2003 12:04 | 8115 | ||
| Left or Far Left? [126 words] | Jan Gustin | Apr 7, 2003 10:40 | 8112 | ||
| Formal complaint filed against teacher [233 words] | Abigail Browning | Apr 5, 2003 13:20 | 8068 | ||
| Arab Intellectuals [33 words] | Monica Harris | Apr 5, 2003 02:55 | 8059 | ||
| The left, and the perfect incomplete model of our human condition [630 words] | Jonathan Pfeffer | Apr 1, 2003 22:54 | 7916 | |
| The Arab intellectual view is even more bizarre [830 words] | Jonathan Pfeffer | Mar 31, 2003 23:17 | 7831 | ||
| Which way would secure real democracy? [268 words] | Ulla Sandbaek. Member of the European Parliament | Mar 31, 2003 11:06 | 7808 | ||
| to Ulla [206 words] | Anubhav Singh | Sep 13, 2006 02:24 | 7808 | ||
| secular humanism versus benovelent dictatorship vs what? [212 words] | frank | Mar 6, 2007 20:23 | 7808 | ||
| real democracy [63 words] | shakoor ahmad | Apr 23, 2008 08:01 | 7808 | ||
| Two heads- one body [326 words] | Lawrence Ricci | Mar 30, 2003 22:13 | 7795 | ||
| Independent article, same conclusion [39 words] | Joel Pollak | Mar 30, 2003 17:03 | 7786 | ||
| Its Easy to Say No to War When They Don't Have a Job. [42 words] | ICalledIt.com | Mar 30, 2003 10:53 | 7780 | ||
| How long? [654 words] | Jblazso | Mar 29, 2003 16:37 | 7772 | ||
| Socialism: the fantasy of slothocracy [459 words] | D.R. | Mar 28, 2003 16:37 | 7750 | ||
| Modernism - double standards - Hypocrisy [123 words] | Paul Wakeford | Mar 26, 2003 18:45 | 7697 | ||
| Ijtihad or death [125 words] | Orson Olson | Mar 26, 2003 03:31 | 7658 | ||
| The workers and the street marches [87 words] | Peter Edgar | Mar 25, 2003 22:52 | 7647 | ||
| The Oportunist Left [150 words] | Paul Wakeford | Mar 25, 2003 05:29 | 7569 | ||
| The foundation [295 words] | Michael | Mar 25, 2003 00:28 | 7564 | ||
| Islam and the Left - both death worshippers? [138 words] | Garry Mallett | Mar 24, 2003 04:44 | 7550 | ||
| Response to Abdullah Al Osama [70 words] | D | Mar 24, 2003 02:39 | 7549 | ||
| Response to Sharna Fetman [184 words] | Daniel Bairey | Mar 24, 2003 02:16 | 7548 | ||
| lack of insight [191 words] | Sarah Karpman | Mar 23, 2003 21:08 | 7542 | ||
| The Left [74 words] | Matthew Fountain | Mar 23, 2003 11:26 | 7530 | ||
| Being Number 1 has its consequences [131 words] | David J. Buckner | Mar 22, 2003 22:48 | 7526 | ||
| The Left [309 words] | Brad Sprague | Mar 22, 2003 02:53 | 7511 | ||
| Offensive [42 words] | jazz | Mar 22, 2003 00:16 | 7510 | ||
| Thank You! [15 words] | Russell | Mar 21, 2003 22:17 | 7508 | ||
| There are horrors ... [229 words] | Craig Goodrich | Mar 21, 2003 20:27 | 7507 | ||
| MARX GOT IT VERY WRONG [81 words] | Neil Abramson | Mar 21, 2003 19:27 | 7504 | ||
| Re Abdullah's comments [19 words] | hari iyer | Mar 21, 2003 17:02 | 7499 | ||
| Sadaam's horrors are not the focus of this war [177 words] | Andrew Tolstoy | Mar 21, 2003 16:55 | 7498 | ||
| The real motive behind the Liberal [152 words] | Les Jordan | Mar 21, 2003 15:35 | 7495 | ||
| Amazing for the Post [220 words] | Brad Bretzin | Mar 21, 2003 13:58 | 7491 | ||
| You've painted with too broad a brush [112 words] | Alyn Wambeke | Mar 21, 2003 10:55 | 7485 | ||
| Karl Marx [105 words] | Mark Hancock | Mar 21, 2003 08:55 | 7481 | ||
| I don't know on which planet you live, but it can't be earth [405 words] | Carsten | Mar 21, 2003 08:28 | 7480 | ||
| Cool article [43 words] | Diogo Chiuso | Mar 21, 2003 08:14 | 7479 | ||
| About time!!! Well done! [11 words] | Ant | Mar 20, 2003 23:02 | 7469 | ||
| Diplomacy of a VETO [71 words] | Jim Reichel | Mar 20, 2003 22:21 | 7468 | ||
| Why the Left Loves Osama [7 words] | Ron Blum | Mar 20, 2003 20:14 | 7465 | ||
| Conservative Re-Education in Western Universities Needed [85 words] | Rutherford Wallace Snipes | Mar 20, 2003 19:47 | 7464 | ||
| The Leftovers [114 words] | Arlinda DeAngelis | Mar 20, 2003 19:46 | 7463 | ||
| Why The Left... [95 words] | Jim Paizis | Mar 20, 2003 19:40 | 7461 | ||
| to Abdullah Al Osama [200 words] | Paul Martin | Mar 20, 2003 19:27 | 7459 | ||
| Response to Sharna [464 words] | Monica | Mar 20, 2003 18:58 | 7457 | ||
| Peace Love Hate....its all mixed up [35 words] | Jason Bradley | Mar 20, 2003 17:58 | 7455 | ||
| We are the world, we are the children... all together now, leftists and islamists! [614 words] | Monica | Mar 20, 2003 16:39 | 7452 | ||
| Not left, not right [194 words] | Bettina Camcigil | Mar 20, 2003 15:31 | 7450 | ||
| Response to Abdullah Al Osama [285 words] | Phil Berry | Mar 20, 2003 13:52 | 7449 | ||
| You Left Out One Important Point [283 words] | Edward M. | Mar 20, 2003 12:52 | 7445 | ||
| Captialism? Maybe. Faux-Racial Equality? Definitely! [212 words] | Dan D. | Apr 19, 2006 21:04 | 7445 | ||
| Not quite on the mark [253 words] | Alexander Kizuk | Mar 20, 2003 12:16 | 7442 | ||
| Re Abdullah al Osama's comment: [46 words] | Charles Coury | Mar 20, 2003 10:57 | 7441 | ||
| All Critics of the War Are not Socialists [382 words] | Susan Bradford | Mar 20, 2003 10:31 | 7440 | ||
| The Extreme left vs the "not-right" [165 words] | Frank Burkett | Mar 20, 2003 09:31 | 7437 | ||
| Liberals are by definition terrorists, and the troops need to take out this garbage [52 words] | John Forsyth | Sep 24, 2007 12:48 | 7437 | ||
| Ummm [129 words] | Ral | Mar 20, 2003 08:42 | 7435 | ||
| Karlheinz Stockhausen quote may not be accurate [282 words] | J.S. Frentzen | Mar 20, 2003 07:40 | 7434 | |
| Peace [66 words] | Marlene Karadza | Mar 20, 2003 05:38 | 7432 | ||
| The Nihilist Left [129 words] | James Solbakken | Mar 20, 2003 04:35 | 7431 | ||
| Yes, but... [276 words] | Barbara Runkel | Mar 20, 2003 04:25 | 7430 | ||
| great piece, but remember the cultural revolution was... [100 words] | Eugene Narrett | Mar 20, 2003 00:19 | 7426 | ||
| Leftism as Marxism [188 words] | Jim Ryan | Mar 19, 2003 23:17 | 7422 | ||
| Moral Authority and America's Promise [257 words] | Mike Gutowski | Mar 19, 2003 22:29 | 7419 | ||
| Point-blank! Does the far left hears you? [162 words] | Rachel Neuwirth | Mar 19, 2003 21:50 | 7417 | ||
| After throwing out orthodoxy, leftists MUST hate it. [189 words] | catherine johnson | Mar 19, 2003 21:49 | 7416 | ||
| Leftists love most tyrants [116 words] | catherine johnson | Mar 19, 2003 21:19 | 7415 | ||
| Rebels without a cause [97 words] | Brenda Smith | Mar 19, 2003 21:18 | 7414 | ||
| Fails the logical sniff test [239 words] | Daryl Kennedy | Mar 19, 2003 21:05 | 7411 | ||
| what clarity [30 words] | leah averick | Mar 19, 2003 21:00 | 7410 | ||
| Moral Inversions [279 words] | Janice Sentara | Mar 19, 2003 19:39 | 7408 | ||
| The Left is sinking.. [55 words] | Harold Dodson | Mar 19, 2003 18:39 | 7405 | ||
| Arab "socialism" [110 words] | Carey E. Stronach, Ph.D. | Mar 19, 2003 16:48 | 7402 | ||
| Socialist commentary [134 words] | Frederick Miller | Mar 19, 2003 16:32 | 7400 | ||
| Policy Review article [59 words] | Dorothy White | Mar 19, 2003 16:21 | 7398 | ||
 Comments on the left [74 words] | Sharna Fetman | Mar 19, 2003 16:19 | 7397 | ||
| Bravo! you did it again. [39 words] | Rosejean T. Castriota | Mar 19, 2003 15:59 | 7396 | ||
| The Left Loves Osama [and Saddam] for Economic Reasons [78 words] | Jacob Slabiak | Mar 19, 2003 15:52 | 7394 | ||
| Why does the Right love Osama? [430 words] | Thomas Paine | Mar 19, 2003 15:24 | 7393 | ||
| The Left [42 words] | Jamie Gilcrest | Mar 19, 2003 14:53 | 7392 | ||
| Why the Left Supports Saddam [35 words] | Ethel C. Fenig | Mar 19, 2003 14:47 | 7391 | ||
| Good Timing for Your Latest Article [80 words] | Robert Guinaugh | Mar 19, 2003 14:39 | 7389 | ||
| 1 | The Leftist-Saddam Connection [59 words] | Nicholas Panos | Mar 19, 2003 14:22 | 7386 | |
| True that [65 words] | Mike Hanson | Mar 19, 2003 13:53 | 7382 | ||
| Enemy of my enemy [57 words] | S. Burns | Mar 19, 2003 13:33 | 7380 | ||
| Rush Limbaugh Reads Daniel Pipes [28 words] | Otavio Lima | Mar 19, 2003 13:22 | 7378 | ||
| Yes, still not all opponents are left [74 words] | Roy Terry | Mar 19, 2003 12:33 | 7376 | ||
| Hate of America [271 words] | Michael McCanles | Mar 19, 2003 10:55 | 7374 | ||
| Left Today Is Utilizing Old School Lennist Tactics [126 words] | Steven Stern | Mar 19, 2003 10:20 | 7371 | ||
| Brilliant distillation! [71 words] | Michael Joyce | Mar 19, 2003 09:49 | 7368 | ||
| Expose the Left's Irrational Agenda [204 words] | Michael Glass | Mar 19, 2003 09:27 | 7366 | ||
| Nihilism replaces Idealism [154 words] | Richard Zuma | Mar 19, 2003 09:07 | 7365 | ||
| Hate of America [56 words] | Paul M. Neville | Mar 19, 2003 08:32 | 7364 | ||
| The Inversion of Liberalism [278 words] | Jack Ajzenbreg | Mar 19, 2003 07:48 | 7363 | ||
| Islam , Left or Right.....or left right, left right, left right. [181 words] | Abdullah Al Osama | Mar 19, 2003 06:45 | 7361 | ||
| Abdullah's Desire [13 words] | Ken McPherson | Jan 6, 2006 18:27 | 7361 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)