69 million page views
Home Articles Blog Reviews Spoken Books Other Languages Biographical Middle East Forum About this site Mailing List

No Hope

Reader comment on item: [The Road Map:] Learning from Oslo

Submitted by Paul M. Neville (United States), Jun 11, 2003 at 18:39

I don't believe there are enough Palestinians who want peace with Israel to reach critical mass. Should the new PM seek to enforce the road map he would be killed. He will probably resign soon.

Israel with US support must clean out the PA leadership and then wall off the West Bank and Gaza, letting the Arabs and Europeans support them. Arafat should be arrested and tried in the US for the killing of a US diplomat in Africa. The undefensable settlements must be withdrawn and settlers relocated.

This basically is a let them stew in their own juices plan.
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (80) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
There will never be peace until the "Prince of Peace" returns [19 words]Tommy MooreFeb 1, 2005 22:5020055
LOOK AT NORTH KOREA [298 words]HARRYOct 21, 2003 00:4111861
Sword of Islam [263 words]Matthew CoxJun 24, 2003 23:329727
"Learning from Oslo" - New York Post - 10th June 2003 [637 words]James ConnollyJun 15, 2003 16:309560
Diplomacy [328 words]Don CanhamJun 15, 2003 01:129554
Is it hopeless? [95 words]AlexanderJun 14, 2003 10:359553
Just Ridiculous [61 words]MarkJun 13, 2003 18:339549
Behind the roadmap [262 words]Ilona MelstradsJun 13, 2003 13:509542
It's Obvious [65 words]MikeJun 13, 2003 09:009538
Zero Tolerance? [20 words]adrian winterfieldJun 12, 2003 07:499526
Myth of "occupation" [134 words]ObserverJun 12, 2003 01:189521
Move the Palistinians to the east bank---Jordan. [49 words]Phil WhittenbergJun 11, 2003 21:169518
'All of the other endeavors to achieve 'peace' are stillborn...' [230 words]Keith AckermannNov 10, 2006 05:509518
PLO [11 words]DonJun 11, 2003 19:419516
Zero Tolerance [116 words]LlamaJun 11, 2003 19:309514
Of course, peace! [44 words]JasonJun 11, 2003 19:069513
..and Israel's provocations? [134 words]HichamJun 11, 2003 18:479512
No Hope [99 words]Paul M. NevilleJun 11, 2003 18:399511
Thank you! [43 words]Daniel HahnJun 11, 2003 18:399510
1Road map to Civil War [237 words]M. Von RohrJun 11, 2003 17:249508
I hope Bush has learned from Oslo [47 words]Bill ReevesJun 11, 2003 16:009506
"Negotiations" [356 words]Joseph GrossmanJun 11, 2003 13:519504
Responsibility [28 words]Terry MillerJun 11, 2003 13:459503
Flexibility does not mean weakness [243 words]Aaron MarshJun 11, 2003 13:069502
Bush's hypocrisy [179 words]Kathy SanfordJun 11, 2003 12:169501
Bush response to Israeli response to killings [79 words]Seth KaufmanJun 11, 2003 12:059500
Even-Handedness [163 words]J SchonmanJun 11, 2003 11:549499
Israeli response to terrorist acts [221 words]Ed HirschJun 11, 2003 10:569497
When will the administration learn? [113 words]GregJun 11, 2003 10:569496
Repeating Oslo? [161 words]Barry RabJun 11, 2003 10:179495
The Road Map to Treblinka [70 words]JoelJun 11, 2003 09:369494
Way to go, Daniel! [5 words]Joe SpivackJun 11, 2003 08:559493
A proper Palestinian state [46 words]John GinsburyJun 11, 2003 08:099492
President Bush's word is genuine. [67 words]Kylen HasenoehrlJun 11, 2003 07:529491
Zero tolerance policy [21 words]LRJun 11, 2003 05:159490
Road Map [110 words]Ely SilkJun 11, 2003 01:589487
Bush is now ignoring Palestinian terrorism [57 words]Jacob SlabiakJun 11, 2003 01:249486
Lessons from Oslo: A recipe for Israel's destruction [414 words]Lisette MuradJun 11, 2003 00:289484
Your prescience [276 words]Sondra TuckfeltJun 11, 2003 00:049483
This is The End Of The Road Map Unless... [36 words]Ben CreechJun 10, 2003 23:489481
Washington Follies [207 words]Henry ThorndikeJun 10, 2003 23:049479
The Oslo sham. [226 words]Alexander M. BerlinJun 10, 2003 22:079477
Road map [278 words]Michael LichtJun 10, 2003 21:519476
The Road Map to Hell [167 words]Arlinda DeAngelisJun 10, 2003 20:399475
Road map to Peace [31 words]Wendy GriffinJun 10, 2003 20:009474
Arafat's speech [28 words]Dr.Donald FrommerJun 10, 2003 19:499473
Pipes as Pollyanna [272 words]Edward AlexanderJun 10, 2003 19:109472
NO PEACE FROM THE WICKED [155 words]GRAHAM RAEL-BROOKJun 10, 2003 19:049471
Learning from Oslo; not likely! [274 words]Steven ChaimbergJun 10, 2003 18:579470
Bush already screwing up [62 words]GaryJun 10, 2003 18:399469
i love bush [3 words]paul martinezJul 18, 2006 20:359469
Is President Bush and his administration ignoring the violence ? [107 words]Josef ZorskiJun 10, 2003 17:069466
Road Map needs the Security Fence [274 words]Ivan BarnaJun 10, 2003 16:399465
DAN PIPES IS RIGHT ON TARGET [92 words]JERRY BORISJun 10, 2003 16:199464
Brilliant article [13 words]Hillary MarkowtizJun 10, 2003 15:519463
last artice [14 words]WJun 10, 2003 15:239461
The Abbas chimera [207 words]Vijay DandapaniJun 10, 2003 15:209460
Hard to be optimistic [118 words]D. MendesJun 10, 2003 15:169459
Pot hole in the road map [60 words]Alan M. KohnJun 10, 2003 15:129458
Palestinians not partners for peace [195 words]YosephJun 10, 2003 14:509456
sol'n to Israeli problem [89 words]p mannesJun 10, 2003 14:429455
Some other questions: [168 words]Alain Jean-MairetJun 10, 2003 14:359454
Agreement [8 words]Marilou HodgkinJun 10, 2003 14:309453
The Road Map [93 words]Edward PurizhanskyJun 10, 2003 14:209452
Plus ca change [155 words]Ruth Morton FazioJun 10, 2003 14:049451
One war - one enemy [115 words]Edmund JamesJun 10, 2003 13:569450
US Reaction To Israel's Attcak on Hamas Leader [187 words]Lindsey BinnieJun 10, 2003 13:479449
Never Oslo again [24 words]Joe EshkeriJun 10, 2003 13:399448
Ha'aretz predicts "Clintonization" of Road Map -- Say It Ain't So, Daniel [683 words]David GoldmanJun 10, 2003 13:379447
Oslo redux??? [150 words]fred bailinJun 10, 2003 13:339445
Comments and an angry reaction on today's news [675 words]John RudolphJun 10, 2003 13:309444
Peace is impossible. [85 words]Jay VailJun 10, 2003 13:289442
Peace??? [147 words]Glenn KlotzJun 10, 2003 13:209441
Ah vos commentaires! [124 words]dominique HunterJun 10, 2003 13:009440
The Road Map [379 words]Ken BesigJun 10, 2003 12:579439
Here we go again [76 words]sandanJun 10, 2003 12:399438
The "road map" versus War on Terrorism [225 words]ibrodskyJun 10, 2003 12:359437
Why two perpetually hostile states? [138 words]Brad CoxJun 10, 2003 11:409436
Agreement [6 words]Yvonne M. SchackJun 10, 2003 11:269435
"RoadMap" already violated by Palestinians [56 words]TerryJun 10, 2003 11:169434

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

Most Viewed

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)