69 million page views

A muslim is as a muslim does..

Reader comment on item: Muslim Soldiers in the West, Criticized by their Communities
in response to reader comment: A real Muslim, a real American Soldier

Submitted by donvan (United States), May 31, 2007 at 14:23

So you are a closet Muslim. Forced by circumstances to hide your true belief, yet you go to such lengths to inform us how you stand for truth, justice and the American way. Just don't sound right. Honesty, you see, also means integrity. It sounds like your Islamism is a " Muhammedism lite".

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (126) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Pakistani Vision : Destruction of West by Pakistani Islamic Nukes [80 words]Birju AmitNov 8, 2009 13:56164207
Surely this is another case of 'Sudden Jihad Syndrome'? [11 words]J SchamrothNov 8, 2009 10:25164199
A Demonstration of Loyalty to Islam, Normal Actions of a Shaheed, But Not A Syndrome [862 words]Doc TaterNov 27, 2009 16:07164199
The threat to America from radical Islam [201 words]Bob JackNov 8, 2009 10:24164198
Homicide Bomber Or Martyr Questions [73 words]infosifterNov 8, 2009 10:19164197
redemption [95 words]yuval Brandstetter MDNov 8, 2009 07:44164191
PC correctness [133 words]dfwhite19438Nov 9, 2009 15:17164191
Do muslims fight secular wars? [46 words]GeorgePJul 11, 2009 02:48158742
What about the Muslims they're fighting for? [70 words]Malcolm (Australia)Jul 18, 2009 07:20158742
War for religion [335 words]RafiNov 8, 2009 09:54158742
British Muslim, British Hero [56 words]Javed JavedFeb 18, 2008 08:03120452
Follow 120000 Prophets, Is that practcale? [52 words]miriamFeb 14, 2008 08:49120202
A real Muslim, a real American Soldier [4809 words]Al AmreekeeJan 21, 2007 22:4374007
Great Man [172 words]Philip SaenzFeb 10, 2007 20:5774007
You Deserve Respect Not Disrespect Forgive The Ignorance Of The Sleep [124 words]Deshawn AddisonMar 22, 2007 22:1574007
A muslim is as a muslim does.. [53 words]donvanMay 31, 2007 14:2374007
Well-said! [185 words]deborah majzoubJun 18, 2007 13:5174007
Get a life [174 words]Doug CorriganApr 17, 2008 13:4874007
Amreeke: Excellent Points [152 words]Viking WomanApr 21, 2008 05:1874007
To Doug Corrigan [317 words]sayitlikeitisMay 7, 2008 20:3374007
Hatred destroys. Not a relilgion. [23 words]Anne ZieglerSep 23, 2008 15:1674007
A Muslim is a muslim [148 words]arianaOct 4, 2008 05:3574007
quite true.. [92 words]donvanOct 6, 2008 08:2974007
1Do research before you refer any references [634 words]Rektivianto YoewonoApr 18, 2009 19:1874007
dont be ingulfed by flame of the bewilderment you are in and make research to get away from the personal stress [223 words]faisalJul 8, 2009 02:1474007
Opposites [151 words]IllaryJul 13, 2009 00:3674007
Misquoting the Quran [15 words]Mike FontaneNov 8, 2009 13:3874007
PRECISELY CORRECT [212 words]DANIEL REDMONDNov 26, 2009 13:3974007
@ Anne Ziegler [12 words]ChrisFeb 1, 2010 03:4674007
Oh really...... [138 words]ChrisFeb 1, 2010 04:0674007
On the subject ( Kill the Jews and Christians ) [1093 words]SayitlikeitisFeb 2, 2010 08:5874007
12I am a muslim soldier in US Army [572 words]'Al Amreeke'Dec 24, 2006 16:4270425
A 'good Muslim' cannot be American... [320 words]Warren RaymondDec 25, 2006 03:1270425
Dubious veracity of 'Al Amreeke' [22 words]Abu NudnikJan 2, 2007 10:3970425
You're not alone [157 words]Frank MascaroJan 6, 2007 14:4370425
fish nor fowl.. [142 words]donvanJan 9, 2007 16:5570425
Safety [206 words]Yaakov WatkinsJan 11, 2007 22:2270425
I salute you, Al Amreeke [214 words]Michel C. ZalaJan 17, 2007 15:5370425
Muslim Soldier in US Army [1169 words]Another AmericanJan 18, 2007 02:5370425
I'm Your Friend [75 words]Philip SaenzFeb 7, 2007 20:0170425
don't believe your story...Sarg..! [366 words]fatchabruteMar 19, 2007 04:0970425
To "Soldier W...Al Amreeke:" Label me "Unconvinced." [255 words]marianaMay 14, 2007 12:5270425
Sad [64 words]KatJun 11, 2007 22:2470425
1thank you for your service [71 words]gary fouseJun 18, 2007 00:1570425
i dont understand why american government allow muslims to build mosques in such a huge numbers [65 words]anilAug 15, 2007 15:0270425
To Al Amreeke & all Muslim-American Soldiers [55 words]SusanSep 17, 2007 10:4670425
That is wrong!!! [136 words]AllahAkbar!Sep 17, 2007 20:4970425
You can't have it both ways [174 words]JOE KAFFIRJan 14, 2008 15:3870425
salaam brother [119 words]Yasser Al ShararaJan 21, 2008 07:0770425
And we rely on guys like this to obtain important intelligence? [48 words]Doc TaterFeb 6, 2008 17:5770425
God save your country [81 words]tjMar 3, 2008 05:0870425
Life is tough all over - welcome to the real world. [206 words]Jon WhiteApr 4, 2008 09:5470425
MY STORY:Muslim Marine Everyday [82 words]muslim marineJun 30, 2008 04:3470425
Joe Kaffir, you are now enlightend [77 words]Muslim MarineJun 30, 2008 04:4970425
To donvan [74 words]Muslim MarineJun 30, 2008 17:2870425
Semper Fidelis [192 words]donvanJul 1, 2008 11:0670425
NO ONE IS PERFECT brother! [47 words]TIPO ZOLTAN {HOLLAND}Aug 19, 2008 13:2270425
to Al Amreeke [63 words]LilianaSep 20, 2008 10:4070425
Thank you Buddy. [80 words]John CerkezNov 3, 2008 21:4470425
TENTH VERSE "...Same As The First... A Little Bit Louder, A Little Bit Worse...." [50 words]marianaMar 5, 2009 12:4370425
comments on a story [59 words]AlexApr 8, 2009 10:2370425
"New" Muslim [527 words]DJMMay 21, 2009 15:3370425
Nor do I believe you [25 words]PippaNov 8, 2009 19:4770425
Our dear DMJ and his imaginary friend [420 words]dhimmi no moreNov 9, 2009 07:5370425
Nice try, Al! [56 words]Guy MacherNov 9, 2009 14:1470425
Another Muslim American soldier [81 words]BeqarorJan 2, 2010 15:1170425
@ AllahAkbar! [86 words]ChrisFeb 2, 2010 00:0770425
American Muslim soldier [137 words]fredApr 3, 2014 05:0670425
i love these brave soldiers [56 words]danicaAug 12, 2006 05:1452481
2PROUD TO BE AMERICAN MUSLIM IN THE ARMY!! [369 words]ahmadzafireDec 24, 2006 18:5052481
... follow the same Prophets? [103 words]W. A. TomlinsonJan 2, 2007 17:5852481
I ain't buying ... [324 words]Mark MajorJan 4, 2007 09:0152481
W. A. Tomlinson yes the same prophets... [261 words]ahmadzafireJan 4, 2007 23:3652481
easy answer [489 words]ahmadzafireJan 6, 2007 02:3752481
More baloney [121 words]Mark MajorJan 6, 2007 14:3852481
more from what you dont know.... [132 words]ahmadzafireJan 6, 2007 21:2452481
Still ain't buying it [316 words]Mark MajorJan 8, 2007 05:2752481
I don't think so [317 words]Mark MajorJan 8, 2007 06:2152481
So Elison cannot say if our constitution comes before Quran--- and he swore alligience to USA?? [175 words]JaladhiJan 8, 2007 15:5652481
ahmadzafire - the clerics and Iraqis won't agree with you!! [128 words]JaladhiJan 8, 2007 17:1652481
Mark Major [262 words]ahmadzafireJan 8, 2007 21:2052481
not really.... [59 words]donvanJan 9, 2007 17:1852481
teach what theyre interpretation of... [29 words]ahmadzafireJan 9, 2007 23:0652481
Personal Jihad Against Jihad [96 words]Noah FreitasJan 12, 2007 13:4652481
I disagree with you [270 words]Mark MajorJan 14, 2007 12:5052481
Individual moral imperative [123 words]Mark MajorJan 14, 2007 13:4052481
1more info on marriage and four wives [566 words]ahmadzafireJan 15, 2007 23:4252481
You can't justify Polygamy in the west [242 words]Mark MajorJan 17, 2007 09:3652481
Mark Major it's not polygamy if its not out of sexual content. [440 words]ahmadzafireJan 17, 2007 20:5852481
What I said [254 words]Mark MajorJan 19, 2007 09:3952481
what i said [787 words]ahmadzaffireJan 21, 2007 00:2052481
people are awakening. [180 words]surjitJan 22, 2007 19:3052481
sorry you feel that way!!! [28 words]ahmadzafireFeb 7, 2007 00:4552481
Polygamy [581 words]samFeb 12, 2007 23:5652481
You went off on a tangent [112 words]Mark MajorFeb 20, 2007 00:3552481
My Opinion [72 words]mark MajorFeb 20, 2007 00:4352481
Mark, with all respect... [1327 words]samFeb 21, 2007 21:0152481
I like your version of Islam Sam............. [265 words]TimothyFeb 22, 2007 12:5052481
Ahmed whom are you really fooling? [228 words]morousMar 2, 2007 12:0752481
wrong Sam [47 words]fatchaMar 19, 2007 04:3452481
ahmadzafire ... ? [218 words]fatcha bruteMar 19, 2007 05:3152481
Ahmadzafire [63 words]fatchabruteMar 20, 2007 02:5352481
fatchabrute [150 words]ahmadzafireMar 22, 2007 20:4452481
ELLISO NEEDS TO DROP THE FRONT... [18 words]verballisticMay 4, 2007 03:4452481
Bible or Country? [20 words]DonnaNov 7, 2007 23:5552481
Not true [428 words]cenniciaFeb 14, 2008 08:4152481
Mark Major I dont believe you [23 words]Muslim MarineJun 30, 2008 05:0252481
What point are you trying to make [97 words]mark majorJul 6, 2008 06:1052481
Believe what you will, I won't try to convert your way of thinking [278 words]Mark MajorJul 6, 2008 06:3352481
Lets look at this in context to the lives they lived and what is god like [279 words]Mark MajorJul 6, 2008 07:1352481
A lot of what you say is true though: [125 words]Mark MajorJul 6, 2008 07:3852481
listen!! [299 words]ahmadzafireJul 7, 2008 21:3952481
prove it [21 words]ahmadzafireJul 7, 2008 21:4452481
Mohammed was still different by the way he lived his life [162 words]mark MajorJul 10, 2008 05:3852481
you don't get the point [56 words]ahmadzafireJul 10, 2008 23:1752481
free speech Buddy [353 words]Mark MajorJul 19, 2008 05:3552481
Perception is what i call it [515 words]ahmadzafireJul 28, 2008 13:5952481
Hellfire Blazes over the heads of Kafirs [252 words]Still a KafirOct 6, 2008 23:3752481
Still a Kafir [124 words]ahmadzafireOct 8, 2008 15:0252481
if Support kafir against muslims you will be with them, not with muslims [60 words]MOHAMMED ABDUL MUJEEBApr 6, 2009 07:3852481
MOHAMMED ABDUL MUJEEB [145 words]ahmadzafireApr 7, 2009 03:1652481
You don't kill other muslims and that's not your intent...!? [164 words]MOHAMMED ABDUL MUJEEBApr 8, 2009 01:5252481
MOHAMMED ABDUL MUJEEB [94 words]ahmadzafireApr 8, 2009 22:1852481
The Lord will take away there crescents [210 words]ColinJul 21, 2009 12:1852481
People please!!! We are failing the test from Yahew,God,Allah,Jeavoah,Almightly etc... [798 words]ahmadzafireJul 22, 2009 19:5152481
Reply to ahmadzafire - Jesus Christ is born of Virgin Mary as a SINLESS BLOOD only can save this WORLD [148 words]A ChristianNov 20, 2009 17:4352481

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)