69 million page views

No to nuclear armed Iran

Reader comment on item: Israeli Jets vs. Iranian Nukes

Submitted by Pritam (United States), Jun 28, 2008 at 02:57

Iran, if allowed to build nuclear weapons, will not only threaten Israel but can blackmail already neutral Europe. So the US government should put strong pressure on Iran.

Russia should be asked to give up its petty support for Iran's bomb program. Iranians can build ICBMs too with these kind of technology in the black market aka Abdul Qader Khan episode. So Europe too should never accept Iranian nuclear bomb.

If it is genuinely a power project, which seems very unlikely, it should be fully open to IAEA and other international inspectors. Iran does not have the rationale to seek nuclear parity with Israel. Iranian leaders are digging their own graves with their quest for weapons for armageddon.

Dislike
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (188) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Iranian defence? [175 words]PhilipJul 18, 2015 21:01224316
Iran Nuclear Coercion [111 words]Paul JefferyJul 16, 2015 19:01224275
Airplanes--Yes, but what about [36 words]Dave ALLANJul 16, 2015 15:05224266
Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu Says No Way Will Iran Get Nuclear Weapons [8 words]Tom SkylarkNov 25, 2013 14:05211801
1Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu's Interesting Message [1 words]Tom SkylarkNov 24, 2013 18:07211753
2Another Most Important Requirement for Israel in addition to Fighter jets! [35 words]IndianJun 1, 2010 08:52173646
1Israel needs us to help them live, we should sell/give Israel long range missiles that are able to defend against nuclear iran. [87 words]Phil GreendMay 30, 2010 18:05173553
3Long Live ISRAEL! [65 words]J. WoodardMar 27, 2009 14:19152860
1Israel forever strong and a free society [27 words]Bruce Mark WeissOct 16, 2011 14:44152860
No to nuclear armed Iran [118 words]PritamJun 28, 2008 02:57133656
Do SOMETHING! [45 words]Iran CitizenJun 16, 2008 03:18132255
Finally, a voice of reason! [61 words]Larry B.Jun 28, 2008 20:19132255
1Uranium Enrichment [51 words]ParvezOct 5, 2008 16:12132255
EMP [191 words]AdeimusJun 15, 2008 03:56132181
THE MISSING TARGET IN THE HIT LIST: [68 words]IamJosephJun 12, 2008 03:10131850
Turkey has no nukes [65 words]Evren İşbilenJun 12, 2008 13:28131850
israeils don"t play [59 words]don kellyMar 17, 2009 17:21131850
TURKEY DOES NOT NEED NUKES - ISRAEL DOES. [78 words]IamJosephMar 17, 2009 22:22131850
I enjoyed (if that is the phrase) Dan's comments of June 18th re going to war with Iran [141 words]DanSep 29, 2007 06:37109891
Attack on Natanz [62 words]WIM hohageJul 10, 2007 10:52103345
so sad! [6 words]chekad saramiAug 20, 2007 13:08103345
VICTORY in Egypt for Women and Girls .......... GO EGYPT [62 words]KatJun 28, 2007 15:08101875
1iran said it will kill Israel [73 words]Phil GreendJun 25, 2007 21:46101165
prophetic b.s. [34 words]johnJul 8, 2007 06:51101165
attack israel [59 words]don kellyMar 17, 2009 17:33101165
Bush a disaster waiting to happen !! [126 words]dfwhite19438Jun 22, 2007 21:50100415
and then what ? [87 words]yuriyJun 22, 2007 17:54100402
What is this supposed to mean? [113 words]MosheJun 23, 2007 17:56100402
Facts and attitudes about Iran [325 words]YuriyJun 25, 2007 00:43100402
Dear Yuriy, don't change the subject! [134 words]MosheJun 26, 2007 04:47100402
Facts and speculations apart [160 words]YuriyJun 27, 2007 21:52100402
Israeli attack potential [84 words]gisellaFeb 21, 2012 11:14100402
would love to see Iran get hit. [63 words]Thomas FieldsJun 22, 2007 16:24100395
The most idiotic move imaginable at this point in history [331 words]DanJun 18, 2007 21:5099332
Iran and their need for nukes [70 words]InfidelJun 19, 2007 19:4699332
So what would be the wise move Dan? [67 words]MosheJun 20, 2007 09:5199332
Make some sense please [280 words]DanJun 20, 2007 18:3499332
Yes Dan, some sense please. [119 words]MosheJun 23, 2007 17:2299332
Re: Iranian irrationality [164 words]DanJun 24, 2007 22:0799332
some thoughts for Dan re his comments. [579 words]bosDec 13, 2007 07:3199332
Mutually assured destruction?? [264 words]Larry B.Jun 28, 2008 20:4499332
Israel Jets vs Iranian Missles [205 words]JayJun 17, 2007 22:2498932
Could Be an Interesting Summer [121 words]BlackspeareJun 18, 2007 17:4898932
2Islam the Religion of Peace [157 words]InfidelJun 17, 2007 16:3898897
Infidel [8 words]Samson BellJun 19, 2007 13:3898897
Islam=peace [25 words]muslimApr 29, 2009 22:0898897
Israel striking Iran is pointless [117 words]freemanJun 17, 2007 12:1498869
angels [54 words]Gary GoldsmithJun 17, 2007 01:2598839
NEVER MIND [32 words]Gary K GoldsmithJun 17, 2007 18:2198839
This is the Final Straw [144 words]lindaJun 16, 2007 02:4098564
New appointment announced [32 words]G.VishvasJun 18, 2007 17:0798564
ISRAELI JET IS USELESS [86 words]MAMAMIA TONTERIYAJun 15, 2007 14:5598412
Oh, One More Thing [29 words]BlackspeareJun 15, 2007 10:5498312
Either stop Iran or at least allow Israel to do the job. [23 words]GeorgeJun 16, 2007 05:0798312
Striking Iran [14 words]Bruce Alan NilesJun 15, 2007 09:1098308
Full support to Israel to help world get rid of Nuclear Ayatullahs . [40 words]AbrahamJun 16, 2007 05:1098308
throw this possibility into the mix... [54 words]fyiJun 15, 2007 08:2298305
Security of Israel and US troops in Middle East is in jeopardy due to Iranians and Hizbullah both. [62 words]TomJun 16, 2007 05:1598305
Right to Self Defense [240 words]John R. PeacherJun 15, 2007 07:0398301
John, unfortunately Israel is standing alone! [51 words]MosheJun 17, 2007 06:0298301
Targetted Annihilation or How Does One Stop the Chanting: Zulu, Zulu, Zulu... [340 words]Jack Ryan, IIIJun 15, 2007 06:5898300
Iran is buying time to prepare for the coming war [114 words]DorrisJun 16, 2007 05:4198300
You just want to kill, to feel powerful... [31 words]Gary K GoldsmithJun 17, 2007 01:4598300
Attacking Nukes not a Good Idea [271 words]Wesley ClarkJun 15, 2007 04:0698299
Putting The Cat Among The Pigeons. [136 words]marianaJun 18, 2007 13:0798299
Jets face to Nuclear missiles [81 words]HarrakJun 18, 2007 17:4698299
Dont forge the ground forces! [18 words]MattJun 13, 2007 23:1298209
No Chance [20 words]JeffreyJun 13, 2007 20:4798076
to jeff [79 words]garyJun 15, 2007 22:3498076
Le beau risque [32 words]Olivença-BretagneJun 13, 2007 17:5298057
"First we take Manhattan, then…" (To "free bee") [399 words]Leonid Kaplun - LeonovJun 13, 2007 17:4798056
"First we take Manhattan, then..." [107 words]Another AmericanJun 14, 2007 23:2898056
Only acting alone Israel can survive [167 words]BenzionJun 13, 2007 16:4798055
Benzion's thoughts [55 words]Scott MyersJun 13, 2007 18:2498055
go for it [127 words]truth seekerJun 14, 2007 00:5998055
Frustration and Desperation. [204 words]Tom SchmittJun 14, 2007 11:4298055
Who Will Defend Israel's Rights [375 words]M. ToveyJun 14, 2007 15:3198055
Go it alone? [195 words]freemanJun 17, 2007 12:2298055
Israel will go alone [114 words]BenzionJun 17, 2007 21:0598055
No sense [49 words]RamidJun 18, 2007 22:1298055
What is your goal? [160 words]BenzionJun 19, 2007 18:4798055
Irony of How Much Certain Things Change (Like Heads of Multiple States); the More They Stay the Same. [155 words]M ToveyMar 16, 2021 12:2198055
tit for tat [51 words]Ben PerryJun 13, 2007 16:4098054
1Fulfilment of Ezekiel 38 & 39 ? [185 words]clarence paul puckettJun 13, 2007 22:4798054
Watch Israel, Watch. [721 words]M. ToveyJun 15, 2007 13:3298054
Attacking Iran's Nuclear facilities [63 words]Charles D. GelfandJun 13, 2007 16:1298052
permission [125 words]truth seekerJun 14, 2007 01:1098052
Israel must destroy Iran's nuclear threat [201 words]Mel LarawayJun 13, 2007 13:0598044
We need to eliminate Islamist Ahmedinejad and other fanatic ayatullahs of Iran . [32 words]GoraJun 16, 2007 11:3298044
What about the response? [425 words]PatJun 13, 2007 11:3197978
Pat, don't expect too much! [182 words]MosheJun 17, 2007 10:4997978
Shhh----It's Suppose to be a Secret! [72 words]BlackspeareJun 13, 2007 11:2797977
No ground incursion , Only Aerial Attacks and Tactical Nukes should be used to target Iran [94 words]VernonJun 16, 2007 12:1297977
And all of that fallout? [79 words]BryantJun 13, 2007 10:3997975
All that possible fallout [102 words]BenzionJun 13, 2007 16:2297975
This giant is not going to go away - ever - without a stone in the forehead [109 words]Anthony RoseJun 13, 2007 08:5497968
Why such an article ? [131 words]JonJun 13, 2007 08:0297934
1If Iran wants nukes...give them some [75 words]ScottJun 13, 2007 01:5197904
Iran's Islamic Government Must be Decapitated [39 words]Domenic PepeJun 13, 2007 01:2097897
Pre-emption Cannot Predict the Future [611 words]M. ToveyJun 12, 2007 23:5897892
Once again [74 words]David W. LincolnJun 12, 2007 22:4897886
Forgot Russian surface to air missiles [35 words]Gamaliel IsaacJun 12, 2007 21:2797880
Wonder may not happen, but the job needs to be done. To Moshe etc. [174 words]Leonid Kaplun - LeonovJun 12, 2007 19:2997866
Four negative scenarios in future . [909 words]RanetJun 12, 2007 19:2197864
WORLD WAR THREE IS UNDERWAY [356 words]Support our TroopsJun 12, 2007 19:1097860
how to support them [33 words]ASJun 14, 2007 13:5197860
The Mind Of G-D [204 words]Seamus MacNemiNov 27, 2007 08:5497860
RAFSANJANI SAYS MUSLIMS SHOULD USE NUCLEAR WEAPON AGAINST ISRAEL [1010 words]Kaffir SoldierJun 12, 2007 19:0597857
A CASE FOR PREEMPTIVE NUCLEAR STRIKE AGAINST IRAN? [600 words]marianaJun 18, 2007 11:2297857
Jehad inspired Pakistani Agencies are helping Palestinian Terror Groups against Israel. [238 words]Sword of TruthJun 12, 2007 19:0397856
The Peace of Islam or "Devilishly Clever, these Islamists!" [241 words]marianaJun 17, 2007 14:0597856
Long live American-Iranian friendship ! [449 words]IanusJun 12, 2007 18:4397849
Pakistan bigger threat than Iran , Hizballah and Hamas ! [463 words]FriendJun 12, 2007 18:4197848
Please read the above comment; other comments are just random noise [243 words]Lonely in KabulJun 14, 2007 00:1297848
Suspicious [70 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Barry MillerJun 12, 2007 16:0997827
Israeli Jets vs. Iranian Nukes [22 words]1bigtzionistJun 12, 2007 19:3197827
Expecting the Unexpected [168 words]MosheJun 12, 2007 15:4097823
Be ready to fight on five fronts before attacking Iran ! [154 words]RomiJun 12, 2007 18:1797823
Be ready to fight on five fronts before attacking Iran ! [170 words]Another AmericanJun 13, 2007 22:2197823
AA, can you be serious? [41 words]MosheJun 17, 2007 05:0097823
Be ready to fight on five fronts before attacking Iran ! [85 words]Another AmericanJun 18, 2007 01:3497823
Israeli Jets vs Iranian Nukes [66 words]Another AmericanJun 12, 2007 13:1597814
Nuclear Iran is in interest of none ! [34 words]BobJun 12, 2007 18:1097814
Iran problem [91 words]Hessel MeilechJun 12, 2007 12:2497809
Attack on Iran is most difficult but Its not impossible . [52 words]VanuJun 12, 2007 18:0897809
Haste makes Waste. [122 words]Bob SanockiJun 12, 2007 12:1097807
Disarm Iran before US chooses its next president in 2008 [67 words]DonJun 12, 2007 18:0597807
Iran is not Iraq, and Israel is not United States. [42 words]andy thompsonJun 13, 2007 14:3497807
good luck [35 words]John TheermanJun 12, 2007 11:5897805
WW III already started with Islam's attack on USA on Sept 11 . We have to fire final bullet to finish it with decisive victory. [128 words]CinisJun 12, 2007 17:5997805
Watch the fifth Column in USA before attacking Iran [229 words]PeterJun 16, 2007 15:3997805
Next: Rome via Jerusalem? [259 words]free beeJun 12, 2007 11:5397804
Ready-to-use , 100% elastic prophecies [266 words]IanusJun 15, 2007 17:5097804
What Will Iran Do In Response To An Israeli Attack? [138 words]yonatan silvermanJun 12, 2007 11:3197802
What will Pakistan , Al Qaida , Hamas , Hizballah , Syria, Mullahs do when Israel will take out Iranian Nuclear Facilities ? [699 words]BoskyJun 12, 2007 17:5097802
The Battle Is The Lords ! [63 words]clarence paul puckettJun 12, 2007 23:0097802
Israeli Jets vs. Iranian Nukes [1637 words]Ed Melik, Esq.Jun 13, 2007 03:1497802
Israel vs Iranian nukes [548 words]Moshe LevyJun 13, 2007 08:5297802
Slave mentality [228 words]BenzionJun 13, 2007 12:0797802
What can be done to protect Israel from Iranian retaliation ? [622 words]GovindJun 16, 2007 12:0297802
Al Qaida planning to attack US and Israeli Embassies in India [2570 words]RohitJun 16, 2007 15:2897802
Hamas says , Kill the Infidels : So its best to finish them before invading Iran. [327 words]BrunoJun 16, 2007 15:4397802
We make the strike, knowing we have to, and don't worry about retaliation. [1056 words]James VesceJun 18, 2007 12:2997802
"We make the strike we know we have to and don't worry about the retaliation" by Mr. James Vesce [3022 words]Ed Melik, Esq.Jul 2, 2007 23:0597802
And there's always the "Turkey versus Iranian Nukes" option [872 words]James VesceJul 13, 2007 10:3197802
Turkey/Nukes/Revelation [23 words]TMSep 20, 2007 01:4497802
Not Easy without US [140 words]Constant HeadJun 12, 2007 11:1197800
read the article thoroughly [215 words]yuval Brandstetter MDJun 14, 2007 03:5597800
Better Europeans support Israel and US war against Terror , Islamism and Iran , otherwise .. [399 words]Proud FrenchJun 18, 2007 12:1997800
Make Master Plan to destroy all Iranian Nuclear and Miltary Facilities . [340 words]Proud WarriorJun 12, 2007 10:4397798
The bush brand of feinting [58 words]John W McGinleyJun 12, 2007 17:5197798
Good action analysis but how about reaction! let us be reasonable [167 words]HarrakJun 12, 2007 09:5697796
Judeocide [52 words]Yuval brandstetter MDJun 13, 2007 05:3497796
You are grossly over-estimating Iran's capabilities, Harrak [336 words]Bryan JacksonJun 13, 2007 12:3897796
Harrak's scenario [202 words]VijayJun 13, 2007 14:3397796
fear, fear and fear- [48 words]free beeJun 13, 2007 18:3497796
wipe out Iranian Regime power centers [134 words]HopefulJun 14, 2007 14:0897796
Free Bee- The Sancho Panza with no Horse. [140 words]YnnatchkahJun 14, 2007 17:4497796
Isreal Is Like David Up Against Present Day Goliaths, The Muslims [115 words]AnneMJun 14, 2007 19:4597796
It Can Be Done, Like It Was In 1981 [76 words]AnneMJun 14, 2007 19:5397796
No Western Plot,The Jewish People Went Home To Their Homeland [44 words]AnneMJun 14, 2007 19:5997796
Harrak may be right in his analysis [133 words]Sindy ShmidthJun 14, 2007 20:4897796
Harrak , you missed potential threat from Pakistani Nuclear Bombs and Long Range Missiles [57 words]LikadJun 15, 2007 17:4497796
pakistan!! [92 words]Sindy ShmidthJun 16, 2007 15:1697796
Million Muslims studying Militant Islam in Pakistani Madrassas [165 words]SamirJun 16, 2007 16:0997796
Samir wake up , India has more than 120,000 madrassas involved in imparting Islamist Education. [191 words]NareshJun 18, 2007 12:1297796
Mr Ynnatchkah's arrogance, answered [71 words]free beeJun 18, 2007 16:2797796
question for AnneM [24 words]free beeJun 18, 2007 16:3097796
Over optimistic [66 words]true believerJun 19, 2007 08:3197796
Nobel for mollas [27 words]true believerJun 19, 2007 08:3797796
Mr. Free Bee [411 words]YnnatchkahJun 19, 2007 16:0897796
Israelis Visit America All The Time [97 words]AnneMJun 20, 2007 09:2897796
Jews are Jewels and Muslims ... [215 words]BambioJun 20, 2007 16:1997796
Oh and I have a question for you our dear freebee aka un drained [53 words]dhimmi no moreJun 20, 2007 20:4397796
Ms AnneM- Home is ... [70 words]free beeJun 21, 2007 10:5597796
out-dated data from true believer [75 words]Sindy ShmidthJun 21, 2007 12:5497796
Despite Daily Dangers, Most Israelis Staying Put [130 words]AnneMJun 21, 2007 17:5897796
To Bambio, about free bee [109 words]YnnatchkahJun 21, 2007 18:5897796
AnneM- Palestinians are NOT moving to Isreal. [61 words]free beeJun 22, 2007 13:1697796
There Have Been News Reports Of Some Palestinians Fleeing To Isreal, That Is The Truth [56 words]AnneMJun 22, 2007 21:3697796
Thanks , With love to Ynnatchkah [432 words]BambioJun 23, 2007 05:5797796
Thank you free bee for your "answer"! [45 words]MosheJun 23, 2007 15:4997796
Listen Moshe and Remember. [34 words]free beeJun 24, 2007 23:0197796
Wake up sameer : Naresh comments: [394 words]sikJun 25, 2007 06:1897796
Thank you again free bee, you are a real asset! [36 words]MosheJun 26, 2007 03:5597796
not outdated [149 words]true believerJul 9, 2007 09:5997796
bravo [72 words]surjJul 22, 2007 20:1997796
israels a looser! [55 words]nikeFeb 21, 2011 13:2597796

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)