To dhimmi no more

Submitted by Hassan (United States), Mar 4, 2011 at 23:46

"Our dear Hassan" Are you plural.

"who lives among big time kuffar and whose anecetors the Hindus were brutalized by Islam right our dear Hassan?" Yes I live in America, and I wish that this website doesn't show this info. It is the only true thing that you know about me beside my religion and you used in every message you wrote. I get it . . . I live in America . . . but I don't consider Americans kuffar. Many Americans are my friends and we hang out together. Kuffar has a very bad connotation to it. No one use this word these days, except extremests.

"whose ancetors the Hindus were brutalized by Islam right our dear Hassan?" No, I told you before, my ancestors were not Hindus.

"Limited time"? you could have fooled me our dear hassan! You posted four messages in one day and they all were long and talking about everything I wrote. I won't read four messages and answer them in one day. If I have time, I would read more of Pipe's articles.

"all I'm saying is that islam is the religion of the Arabs only and you ain't no Araba" I did not mention my origin. I think this website shouldn't show the country of commenters.

"3A'isha was 9 years old when Muhammad had sex with her! How disgusting! So which one is it?" The issue of marrying a 9 year old girl is a big deal this time but it wasn't 1500 years ago. People who were against Islam 1500 year ago did not use this issue to fight the new religion. No one talked about it for hundreds of years. If it was a problem for Muslims, they would just erase it from their books.

People 6000 years ago in Rome and Egypt used to marry their siblings and mothers. But no one was against it at that time. You should talk about the people of the whole era around the world, not just one man in one place. Many idols around the world in history used to think that women are not equivalent to men and they don't have the same rights. They also used to buy them. There are many moral issues that are introduced by civilization and people adopted them.

"Oh let me see 90M Hindus were killed by your masters the Arabs right?" This is my first time hearing this. All I know is that Muslims tried to conquer the world long time ago. I searched online for some info, and I found some resources saying that Muslims killed 80 million Hindus between 1300s and 1400s but this is nonsense. People were not that many at that time. Our history was saying that the biggest Muslim's army was around one hundred thousand solders no more. People were fighting in thousands not millions. Moreover, who counted them?!!! There was not any good technique of counting 80 million people at that time. Finally, not only muslims who killed people in history. Romans killed a lot of middle eastern people, Jewish people killed Jesus, Englishmen killed Indians and Arabs, and Americans killed native americans and Iraqis.

* I have nothing against any of those people, just saying that these things happened.

"So what is your native tongue? Let me guess Urdu right?"

No, my language is not Urdu . . . good try though.

"You do not know any Arabic why the delusions?" I didn't mention my origin or my native language.

"Ah the Muslim ego!" No comment.

"I urge you to leave islam and be free again". What "free again" . . . You still don't know my origin. This is not what I am here for. I am here to talk, not to have anyone converted to any religion.

* Define any concept you use in the future . . . It might means something else for me; so, I want to be sure that we all on the same page.

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".