69 million page views

"Islamic civilization" = the Skull Tower of Nis and the Skull Cathedral of Otranto

Reader comment on item: Kastelorizo - Mediterranean Flashpoint?
in response to reader comment: Islamic civilisation

Submitted by Ianus (Poland), Mar 13, 2012 at 19:26

Mozere wrote :

> 1 In my posts I have expressed my opinions as distilled through readings of a vast number of historians such as E. Zurcher,B.Lewis H.Inalcik et. al. Any historian with a modicum of sympathy for the ottoman cause is labelled,by you, as in the pay of the Turks.

B. Lewis and H. Inalcik are, of course, Turkish court historians and so interesting only inasmuch as they confirm and elaborate on a priori Turkish propaganda. E. Zurcher seems to be following them faithfully too, hence his popularity in Turkey. Critical books on Turkey are not printed but confiscated and banned in Turkey. It was so under Abdul Hamid II and under Kemal, the so called Ataturk, and it remains so under imam Erdogan too. So don't try to fool us by quoting the names.

> This is the age of internet,anybody who needs to read the relevant sources can doso easily,we are not in the 1980s.<

You don't understand the difference between "source" and "interpretation", do you? You're just a Turk and so not much is to be expected or demanded from you in terms of thinking.

What "source" on the Ottoman history can a man writing in our time be? NONE!!! Treitschke instead is a source in double sense. He lived at the time of the Ottoman empire and he voiced what such eyewitnesses as Moltke and others had seen and written about Turkey. Zurcher, Lewis -or Maccarthy whom you failed to mention - can at best express their own opportunist opinions and get paid, published and popularized in Turkey for doing it. They are NO sources at all and when confronted with real sources they fail dismally to fulfill any rigorous scientific criteria! What e.g. Lewis writes about janissaries or Jews in the Ottoman empire is at best incomplete and at worse a caricature.

> 2 I take exception when you quote Heinrich von Treitschke as an outstanding historian, to me he was a demagogue,a proto nazi,an opinionated anti semitic anti slav warmonger.A man to your heart I guess.Had he lived through WW2 he would probably been tried as a war criminal and hung.<

Is it all you know about him? Can you accumulate a few more politically correct phrases and un-words about him?Feel free to continue! After all glib propaganda and trite generalities is all you are able to do, isn't it ?

Imagine that Treitschke hated Turkish barbarity because like any of his contemporaries he saw its horrors in Bulgaria. Remember Batak ? If you don't ,then it is time to refresh your holey memory and then and only then to ask why Turks have always been so much hated and rightly resented as barbarians always are by the civilized nations ?

Anyway, imagine that the Ottoman Turks made an alliance with people like Treitschke and people like him wrote the first-hand , documented and probably the most complete account of the Armenian genocide you Turks committed starting in 1915 "Deutschland und Armenien". So instead of blaming him for imaginary thought crimes you should better take a closer look at your own Ottoman and Kemalsit record of genocides, massacres and jihad and start puttng to the pillory and hanging your own real war criminals instead of inventing and persecuting imagined ones and thus adding nonsense to dishonesty.

> 4 Treitschke accuses the Ottomans of being a nomadic empire having no civilisation and thus no moral authority to rule.<

It is not just Treitschke - an author contemporary to the Ottoman empire- it is first of all his sources that do that. So when you have all sources showing and saying something you'd draw the conclusion that the opposite was the case? In Turkey for not following this "logic" you will be jailed for 3-4 years for denigrating Turkishness, won't you ? (This is my answer to your remark on "freedom of speech" in your nasty Turkish police state).

> Nomadic empires do not last for 500 years,do your own google search on this ie Mongols.<

The mechanism by which the Satanic Turkish primitivism imposed and upheld its yoke upon higher civilization is to my knowledge best explained by Treitschke. Any google search (What substitute is it to reading real contemporary source? ;) won't undermine its depth and obscure its sad veracity.

> Ottoman empire brought the Islamic civilisation tothe Balkans,you may not like it the way some Balkan peoples liked it and it was not pushed down their throats,but it was nevertheless a civilisation.

Barbarity and nomadism which the Turks brought with them is no civilization but its very opposite!!! We Europeans do know your Turkish "Islamic civilization" quite well. The Skull Tower of Nis and the Skull Cathedral of Otranto where the wretched Italians were massacred by the savage Islamic Turkish horde in 1480 are its typical landmarks and everlasting monuments.

I'd even say that Turkey is in more than a metaphorical sense a huge Skull Tower stretching from the Evros to Alexandrette. It has been literally built upon skulls and bones of our ancestors and Treitschke rightly said that the wounds which your mentally sterile Asiatic Turkish horde inflicted upon us still bleed after 500 years.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (70) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
10Kastelorizo is just a sign [583 words]AlexandrosFeb 27, 2012 11:47193708
3Florida of Europe [292 words]MozereFeb 28, 2012 10:26193708
6other benchmarks [45 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanFeb 28, 2012 20:27193708
4Not exactly [724 words]AlexandrosFeb 29, 2012 06:19193708
14"Wounds which a mentally sterile Asiatic horde inflicted on Christian civilization still bleed after 500 years " [2725 words]IanusFeb 29, 2012 16:47193708
4A question or two [417 words]IanusFeb 29, 2012 17:47193708
3Answers to Ianus, hope to hear more opinions and from others [1445 words]AlexandrosMar 1, 2012 11:41193708
2regional cooperation [322 words]MozereMar 1, 2012 12:22193708
9Additional reply to Mozere comments [1856 words]AlexandrosMar 2, 2012 08:05193708
6Wrong side repenting and apologizing [902 words]IanusMar 11, 2012 12:07193708
1Islamic civilisation [635 words]MozereMar 13, 2012 11:57193708
3The so salled "Islamic civilisation" [59 words]Young MCMar 13, 2012 18:39193708
7"Islamic civilization" = the Skull Tower of Nis and the Skull Cathedral of Otranto [864 words]IanusMar 13, 2012 19:26193708
1Answers to both Ianus and Mozere. [444 words]AlexandrosMar 15, 2012 10:51193708
3Sackcloth and ashes while the hungry wolves are howling around [749 words]IanusMar 16, 2012 18:38193708
1Ianus [350 words]AlexandrosMar 18, 2012 07:28193708
4A prominent former board member of the American Turkish Council [2050 words]IanusMar 21, 2012 16:37193708
"Moved" was describing the action [14 words]AlexandrosMar 23, 2012 18:43193708
7Those who didn't manage to "move" [538 words]IanusMar 24, 2012 11:15193708
2Not what i meant [298 words]AlexandrosMar 25, 2012 05:13193708
6The Turkish massacres of Phocea 12.06.1914 [763 words]IanusMar 28, 2012 17:16193708
1I would suggest another book [70 words]AlexandrosMar 29, 2012 03:46193708
Thanks [99 words]IanusApr 1, 2012 16:30193708
2Not so easy! [209 words]Pantelis GiannopoulosJun 25, 2012 14:00193708
6EU Turkish Arranged Marriage Plans [263 words]RebeccaFeb 25, 2012 23:24193650
Give them blank cheques [69 words]MozereFeb 27, 2012 00:39193650
4Camp Bondsteel in Kosovo - a strategic bridgehead for the Second Ottoman Invasion of Europe ? [564 words]IanusFeb 27, 2012 18:23193650
3a shame [69 words]mythFeb 23, 2012 16:35193593
steady on [203 words]MozereFeb 25, 2012 05:24193593
4Washington and the Turkish octopus there [1584 words]IanusFeb 25, 2012 11:09193593
10Recidivist Turkey [1225 words]IanusFeb 26, 2012 18:12193593
Who is a cheat? [344 words]MozereFeb 27, 2012 02:31193593
16The slave hunters' state of the Crimean Tatars and a second disciple of Ataturk [1422 words]IanusMar 1, 2012 15:09193593
1Slavery [279 words]MozereMar 2, 2012 07:37193593
5Adampol (aka Polonezkoy) an moribund ethnographic zoo in Turkey and Nazim Hikmet vs. Ataturk's police state [1142 words]IanusMar 3, 2012 08:10193593
17Tripolitsa or from Lord Byron to Mozere the Turk [2270 words]IanusMar 4, 2012 17:30193593
4Islamic slavery then and now [1588 words]IanusMar 16, 2012 14:54193593
1Kastelorizo an Italian name [31 words]MozereFeb 20, 2012 08:44193512
1Criminal Minded State Propaganda [17 words]Young MCFeb 21, 2012 14:17193512
1Continental shelf [199 words]MozereFeb 22, 2012 06:12193512
23An outpost against Turkish jihad [1265 words]IanusFeb 22, 2012 11:16193512
5Bellicosity and Misleading Propaganda [275 words]Young MCFeb 23, 2012 09:36193512
7Islands have a full right to continental shelf [1199 words]IanusFeb 24, 2012 08:18193512
3Islands do not have an automatic right to EEZ [278 words]MozereFeb 26, 2012 04:08193512
3Continental Shelf and Mozere's "Vikings" [430 words]Young MCFeb 27, 2012 12:15193512
7Tyrkjaránið - An Ottoman slave-hunting raid in Iceland 1627 [1574 words]IanusFeb 27, 2012 16:48193512
4more details [62 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanFeb 27, 2012 21:57193512
p.s. [18 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanFeb 27, 2012 22:25193512
Law applies to everybody equally [143 words]MozereFeb 28, 2012 06:49193512
1Islands and constructed EEZ claims [461 words]Young MCFeb 28, 2012 11:51193512
7Turkey has implicitly admited to be a thug. [805 words]IanusFeb 29, 2012 13:56193512
6The biggest mosque in Kosovo to be built by the (Islamic) Republic of Turkey [167 words]IanusFeb 29, 2012 17:13193512
1Turkey can't pick and choose the territory it claims as and when it discovers oil and gas [377 words]Francis WilsonDec 25, 2012 08:14193512
10Imia [1045 words]IanusFeb 17, 2012 15:28193427
1game of interests [98 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
athinagorasFeb 17, 2012 09:06193421
8Another Crusade? = ... damn the locals [378 words]Kali SimpsonFeb 10, 2012 09:40193269
7Turkification through extermination [580 words]IanusFeb 17, 2012 10:43193269
1Dear Ianus - you say tomato, I say potato. [416 words]KaliFeb 17, 2012 21:50193269
11Clarification on EEZ map [220 words]HamiltonAFeb 9, 2012 19:55193256
4eerily similar to the 1970s and 1980s [192 words]JohnFeb 9, 2012 04:56193244
15Just a remark! [67 words]Jim Pap.Feb 8, 2012 08:09193200
re transport info [36 words]annmarieJul 31, 2013 20:45193200
1Kastelorizo - Mediterranean Flashpoint [119 words]JudithFeb 7, 2012 21:40193186
1reason for war [116 words]havasFeb 12, 2012 08:31193186
2"Not too different..." - In Your Dreams! [51 words]Young MCFeb 12, 2012 19:08193186
2The Reasons Are Plenty - Which One is the Most Tempting [206 words]M. ToveyFeb 13, 2012 13:44193186
26Israel, Cyprus and Greece are natural friends and allies [179 words]Andrew M.Feb 7, 2012 19:36193175
1Greece [95 words]Lujack SkylarkFeb 8, 2012 19:30193175
Remember the Name Kastelorizo; You Heard It Here First- Kudos Dr. Pipes [43 words]M. ToveyFeb 7, 2012 18:18193172
3Diaspora [79 words]NickLlewellynJul 26, 2012 11:29193172

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)