69 million page views

No, They Cannot

Reader comment on item: Can Hezbollah and Hamas Be Democratic?

Submitted by Srini Varadarajan (United States), Mar 23, 2005 at 08:09

One need only look at the record of attempts at democracy: between 1945 and 1990, it was THREE attempts yielding FOUR failures.

While Afghanistan and Iraq are "pending judgement", even if BOTH of them succeed it leaves a failure rate of 80% (one of them succeed, cent-percent).

For success, I'll use 10 years completion with actual elections, no coups, etc.
Dislike
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (56) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
It is now Feb 2010, 5 yrs. after the question was asked "Can hamas be democratic?" it is still , NO ! ! ! [100 words]Phil GreendFeb 11, 2010 02:00168777
When democracy becomes inconvenient [91 words]Joshua IssacAug 9, 2012 14:56168777
Hitler & Allende [104 words]Frank K. BelloJan 28, 2006 06:0932903
Compare with Communists [394 words]Tara MayaMay 31, 2005 01:0322485
Thanks to Arlinda De Angelis ,Mr Octavio Johanson and to Rachel [124 words]Haddad AlfredApr 2, 2005 10:0621304
Additional Terrorist Examples [82 words]Abraham IrwinMar 30, 2005 10:4121245
In answer to Ms Arlinda DeAngelis [51 words]RachelleMar 29, 2005 12:4521201
Some questions [181 words]RachelleMar 28, 2005 04:5721187
For Rachelle [8 words]stuart opotowskyJan 18, 2008 18:5021187
In response to Haddad [36 words]Arlinda DeAngelisMar 26, 2005 20:4621179
Bravo ! [42 words]HaddadMar 26, 2005 14:3221174
1Democracy vs. Autocracy [48 words]Ben LeitnerMar 26, 2005 03:0221170
Reality [156 words]BobMar 25, 2005 15:3321169
What price democracy without LAW ? [211 words]JonMar 24, 2005 11:1421159
Examples of democratically elected totalitarians. [80 words]John Vander VoortMar 24, 2005 10:0421158
Hindu suffering [61 words]S.C.PandaMar 24, 2005 07:0221157
Who is behind Hamas? [218 words]WernerMar 23, 2005 18:5221152
Were the American colonists the exception? [174 words]PatMar 23, 2005 17:1921150
Critical Points [39 words]Matania GinosarMar 23, 2005 16:2921148
Explaining American Presidents - The Legacy Issue [399 words]Boris CelserMar 23, 2005 11:4921144
How soon we forget [155 words]Darwin BarrettMar 23, 2005 11:4521143
I need more sleep! [86 words]VashtiMar 23, 2005 11:0721142
Democratic suicide [21 words]Aaron RosloffMar 23, 2005 10:1321141
Response to Mr Ruben Holsteinburg [70 words]Jacob CarmielMar 23, 2005 10:0921140
No, They Cannot [58 words]Srini VaradarajanMar 23, 2005 08:0921138
Unfortunately, those who share Daniel Pipes's views are in a minority [152 words]Octavio JohansonMar 23, 2005 07:0121137
Democracy and Totalitarianism [318 words]Arlinda DeAngelisMar 23, 2005 01:1321130
Democratic Hamas, etal? [51 words]Carole BolotinMar 22, 2005 20:5321127
Conservatives can't come to grips with the problem. [138 words]Jason PappasMar 22, 2005 20:3421126
Why are our 'Leaders' so clueless? [26 words]Father of 2 boys in Army, 3rd joining Air Force soonMar 22, 2005 20:2721125
Controversial Issue: Hezbollah as a terrorist organisation? [69 words]A. AtraschMar 22, 2005 18:3821124
Is banning Hezbollah and Hamas realistic? [199 words]Emmanuel PMar 22, 2005 18:3321122
Justice Jackson's Dissent [758 words]Daniel W. WeilMar 22, 2005 18:0821121
Can Hezbullah be democratic? [234 words]Anthony LetayfMar 22, 2005 18:0421120
The Iranian/Syrian backed Islamist Hezbollah Monster [706 words]FreeNov 27, 2006 14:1021120
1Muslims must embrace democracy [145 words]Ruben HolsteinburgMar 22, 2005 17:3921119
Islamists can't be democratic [471 words]Quennel GaleMar 22, 2005 17:2621118
How true [56 words]StasJul 27, 2012 18:1921118
But Democracy gives Legitimacy to those who would crush Terrorists [79 words]ScottMar 22, 2005 17:2521117
Remember Oslo [188 words]Dave M. O'NeillMar 22, 2005 16:4721116
An open question to all readers [161 words]Octavio JohansonMar 22, 2005 16:2221115
What about Fatah? [81 words]WernerMar 22, 2005 14:5621113
Being Skeptical may not be enough [264 words]Nick WiesenfeldMar 22, 2005 14:3121112
Transformation possible or not [167 words]WernerMar 22, 2005 14:1021111
Can Hezbollah and Hamas Be Democratic? [112 words]Rachelle AssoulineMar 22, 2005 14:0521110
There can be no peace [138 words]W.Mar 22, 2005 13:3321109
If Hezbollah and Hamas were violent white groups, there would be a stronger reaction [103 words]Octavio JohansonMar 22, 2005 13:3321108
Educate them and give them a chance [136 words]Thani Al-ShirawiMar 22, 2005 12:0021105
Look deeper [55 words]George ValdshteinMar 22, 2005 11:5321104
A question [75 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
David JonesMar 22, 2005 11:4321103
Limits [86 words]Lyle SykoraMar 22, 2005 11:3921102
Confirmation [73 words]DeirdreMar 22, 2005 10:5721100
Skeptical also [152 words]AMar 22, 2005 10:2821099
Terrorists do not believe in democracy [27 words]B. AlotaibiMar 22, 2005 09:5521098
Can terrrorist organizations become "democratic"? [45 words]Donald W. BalesMar 22, 2005 09:3821097
Unpleasant facts of life [134 words]Peter J. HerzMar 22, 2005 09:1121095

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)