69 million page views

Who has broken the enigma for real

Reader comment on item: Europeans: From Venus?
in response to reader comment: Why Europe cant compare

Submitted by vMAXv (Poland), Jan 7, 2006 at 14:32

I was reading Walt's comment saying "British didn't capture enigma, American did so in 1943", in real Enigma wasn't captured by British, or American. Polish had the codes already in the late 1920's/very early 1930's. Germans were so sure of those codes that they weren't changing it a lot, and if did so - Poles were quickly sorting it out as they had their own copy of Enigma. When Poland has entered the allied forces they passed it to the British, so they could also read the German messages.

That's the whole story, Walt - read before you say something, i know that America hasn't got a good education system but you should try to confirm your informations.
Dislike
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (193) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
God Bless America [14 words]Frank PilsenFeb 21, 2016 20:49228179
A preview of coming attractions [70 words]BernieNov 19, 2009 15:54164758
One way Europe could stand up and be noticed [64 words]There is NO Santa ClausNov 18, 2009 10:14164720
Will the EU, by feeeling much less appreciated by Obama, open even more doors to Islamism? [323 words]SvetNov 18, 2009 02:18164701
The EU's Mixed Relationship with America the Result of European Diffidence Towards America [361 words]M. ToveyNov 24, 2009 12:02164701
2Europa super omnia!!! [133 words]Regnum_LusitanicumAug 9, 2009 15:08159900
Europe will die.. [40 words]MichaelNov 17, 2009 22:04159900
Really? Habitator Caeli Ridebit DOMINUS Subsannabit Eos [693 words]M. ToveyNov 18, 2009 12:32159900
Europa Super Omnia? [161 words]Peter HerzNov 23, 2009 17:33159900
China as America's Mistress [53 words]Peter HerzNov 23, 2009 17:38159900
China's Emergence as a World Power Moves in China's Inscrutability [594 words]M. ToveyNov 23, 2009 18:48159900
To Mr. Tovey [158 words]Peter HerzNov 24, 2009 19:41159900
RESPONSE TO REGNUM LUCITANICUM [417 words]DANIEL REDMONDNov 26, 2009 14:23159900
European Superiority Complex [95 words]Straight_Talk_LuigiDec 15, 2009 15:08159900
no one is innocent [597 words]ronJul 2, 2009 08:55158379
A young persons view - Human-beings twisted minds [1068 words]Matilde AndersenApr 15, 2009 12:01153921
Have you read de Tocqueville? [447 words]M BranscombeFeb 19, 2008 14:50120542
Europeans Imitating Americans for THEIR "Blue Card". [494 words]YnnatchkahJan 20, 2008 14:18118631
2Americans and Europeans equality [289 words]TylerJan 7, 2008 20:24117692
Pride comes before the fall [165 words]ChristianSep 1, 2007 11:27107443
Standing Up for America [381 words]ZeroAug 28, 2007 23:28107151
Attempting an unbiased comment... [750 words]WillAug 20, 2007 10:50106562
What about Great Britain? [404 words]Squire TomMay 20, 2007 08:0393686
Agreed [189 words]MikeJan 11, 2009 09:5893686
Segun yo [314 words]DanFeb 11, 2007 03:0476769
Young european (Swede) [371 words]JohanJan 30, 2007 16:4175181
For Johan [46 words]Peter HerzNov 23, 2009 17:4675181
A better world [855 words]TimJan 9, 2007 02:2372127
1US defeated Germany? [436 words]AnneMay 7, 2006 08:3144979
2Nazi Germany was defeated primarily by the Soviet Union [61 words]Oliver L.Jun 17, 2010 21:3244979
Europe vs.America? [655 words]NielsFeb 28, 2006 11:5438352
tooth fairy [187 words]donvanFeb 9, 2007 15:2738352
Early US Settlers [213 words]CathyDec 25, 2005 20:2730559
The Lost Continent [63 words]Steve LuckDec 15, 2005 16:3930033
The only thing the rest of the... [15 words]Christian F.Jan 20, 2007 11:1430033
5American arrogance and other observations. [940 words]JosephNov 18, 2005 14:3028594
Pride!! [343 words]TickerJan 23, 2006 05:3628594
wow [43 words]Christina NguyenJan 17, 2007 11:1228594
You can't generalize Europe [32 words]T.BNov 29, 2008 06:3728594
American opinion [453 words]BRAD VALENTINEOct 26, 2005 06:1627361
America Insecure? [308 words]DavidDec 28, 2005 09:3927361
Brad i agree with much of what you say [763 words]sonsamSep 13, 2006 22:2727361
AMERICANS [50 words]JayOct 19, 2005 00:5727084
response to Jay: please, this is stupid. [295 words]FredOct 26, 2005 22:1927084
thanks for all the INTELLIGENT comments. [266 words]LukeNov 19, 2005 22:4427084
Europeans want to be American [21 words]MikeOct 15, 2006 20:4327084
Judgemental [32 words]SamSpadeNov 15, 2006 11:4727084
Is it really true [100 words]TimFeb 8, 2007 12:0327084
Bless you... [62 words]American PatriotMar 14, 2011 19:0227084
6The US didn't save France from Germany, they saved it from USSR [304 words]Jacques LemaOct 3, 2005 06:2526555
USA is not a free country [61 words]Jesse MattsonApr 16, 2007 07:1326555
Better late than never [5 words]AnitaNov 6, 2011 14:4326555
Why Europe cant compare [321 words]WaltSep 20, 2005 04:1926038
Who has broken the enigma for real [118 words]vMAXvJan 7, 2006 14:3226038
American? Europe Invention [254 words]KemMar 6, 2006 19:4826038
yes [142 words]sonsamSep 13, 2006 22:5926038
World War 2 [1150 words]SharunasNov 1, 2006 15:3226038
Good answer [43 words]JakeJan 19, 2008 17:1726038
european reply [581 words]GrizeldaSep 15, 2008 15:3426038
Time to stick up for the Brits!! [376 words]TomJul 21, 2005 14:2523683
A Few QUICK thoughts [63 words]P SnydeJun 24, 2006 13:0923683
Respect for the British. [128 words]SDudeNov 1, 2006 15:5023683
Not quite [66 words]jakeJan 19, 2008 17:0823683
A little jealous? [123 words]MoserJun 5, 2005 20:4122573
America: Land of the Free, Home of the Brave [210 words]BrodyApr 29, 2005 23:4821895
Brody is inaccurate and blinded by patriotism [319 words]LukeMay 2, 2005 19:3621895
America: Land of the Hopeless, Home of the Stupid [99 words]FranFeb 24, 2006 10:0621895
Not our fault [141 words]unknownMay 19, 2006 09:3621895
GET OVER YOURSELF [329 words]Come off it ...Aug 8, 2006 03:3921895
RIGHT ! [32 words]ironOct 10, 2006 12:5521895
Europe can't handle what the U.S can [49 words]mikeOct 15, 2006 20:5921895
Hmmmm [409 words]SharunasNov 1, 2006 16:3921895
stop bickering about past differenes and look whats lying ahead [639 words]ASNov 2, 2006 08:1421895
Why we in Europe dislike America [112 words]MarianoAug 25, 2007 21:1221895
The last bastion of democracy! [204 words]MichaelNov 17, 2009 21:5521895
Lesson from the past [163 words]SebastianMar 21, 2005 15:3021093
Thoughts of a Young American [242 words]KTFeb 26, 2005 01:4720532
Europe is healing give her time!! [433 words]RudolphJan 25, 2005 17:3619867
America is awesome [101 words]TDec 14, 2004 22:4318999
America is Awesome? [355 words]Dave PrinceJan 3, 2005 19:3918999
A reason to leave [15 words]Joshua CorkernOct 28, 2004 22:3518026
1It's not just the Europeans [217 words]M.Oct 28, 2004 11:4518014
Europe DOESN'T get it [68 words]MaxSep 27, 2004 13:0417404
Please stop. [186 words]Carsten BoghSep 22, 2004 21:0317109
Europe a shining example of a continent that learned from its mistakes! [348 words]Melvias Dreyfus HarkenSep 11, 2004 22:0016907
Americans knowledge of Europe and respect for other cultures [287 words]DebbieFeb 10, 2009 18:3416907
Reasons for disliking the US [650 words]NRDec 6, 2003 14:3012507
Ignorant and arrogant America [107 words]Miquel (Catalonia)Jan 23, 2008 04:0612507
US and Israel vs the world!! [66 words]American PatriotDec 6, 2003 11:3512505
Literary confusion... [14 words]jimJul 21, 2006 15:2512505
Europe will stand strong [122 words]KevinSep 5, 2003 19:5811055
what? [219 words]sonsamSep 9, 2006 04:1811055
reactions about Europe [188 words]Quentin HAug 10, 2003 01:0610490
not your enemy [273 words]sonsamSep 9, 2006 05:0010490
Pipes got it wrong about Venus... [212 words]Olivier ZimmermannJul 7, 2003 18:209908
Zimmerman i agree with you on this one [310 words]sonsamSep 13, 2006 23:479908
I'm scared of Americans [400 words]Farin UrlaubApr 15, 2003 06:368368
My theory on why Europe hates US [800 words]LindenApr 9, 2003 03:228199
My thoughts [912 words]sonsamSep 9, 2006 02:158199
1Royal europe [129 words]JohnJan 14, 2007 21:148199
WOW!!! [3 words]AGAApr 17, 2007 14:288199
Now the Eur-os want the US taxpayer to bail them out [144 words]Not Bill ClintonMar 3, 2009 02:098199
Delusional Americans [299 words]Ruairi KavanaghFeb 11, 2003 09:496539
1european superiority ? ! [484 words]Tyrone JacksonFeb 1, 2003 18:226241
35Europe is superior to everything on Earth [146 words]NitramónDec 29, 2006 13:216241
Euros [79 words]jeremyOct 1, 2007 03:236241
USA [27 words]AsathruJun 4, 2011 15:236241
how uneducated is this guy? [101 words]pridedefilerDec 9, 2012 08:026241
European superiority [85 words]Lee PaxtonJun 21, 2016 10:106241
US and Iraq Petrol [232 words]QazaQJan 25, 2003 11:115973
Reply to QazaQ [37 words]amiexpatFeb 10, 2003 10:215973
To commenter QazaQ [118 words]FaveJul 24, 2003 13:065973
Spelling [38 words]Jerry SoupdogMar 26, 2008 22:085973
Tarzan English? [108 words]Peter HerzDec 25, 2009 23:075973
superficial and predicatble [3 words]dannyMar 14, 2013 23:245973
Polls [133 words]Jhonny McdougleJan 23, 2003 03:435903
UK and U.S will stand together [60 words]Mike A WJan 22, 2003 15:055890
Brits disagree [13 words]danielAug 25, 2007 21:225890
Islamic strongholds? [92 words]JeffJan 19, 2003 17:325859
No [21 words]TillAug 25, 2007 21:255859
Europe Vs. America: response to Mr. Firzli [125 words]Leah BankelJan 13, 2003 19:575704
EUROPE'S JEALOUSY [127 words]JUAN ARAUJODec 17, 2002 14:094701
don't hate US because u ain't US...europeans r just jealous [46 words]jennipher l.Apr 3, 2007 15:054701
How sad... [258 words]CatherineJun 22, 2007 11:194701
Democratic perspective of US [266 words]BourscheidtAug 27, 2007 14:294701
European countries top the democracy index. The US does not. [198 words]AndersOct 20, 2009 05:184701
The EIU assessment of Swedish democracy i manifestly an outright fraud - we have the proof [115 words]GrundlagDec 2, 2009 10:554701
Germany [39 words]jim lovingtonDec 8, 2002 21:054487
What can Europe learn from America? [47 words]Carmen SmithNov 19, 2002 22:564059
Do the ends justify the means? [384 words]Kieron DanielsNov 8, 2002 11:503725
America vs Europe [119 words]J.AreggerSep 18, 2002 19:492554
Reasons [155 words]MichaelJan 1, 2007 01:372554
Europe: Land of appeasers [83 words]An American PatriotAug 29, 2002 17:202199
re Europe: Land of appeasers An American Patriot [354 words]anonFeb 10, 2003 16:582199
Re: An American Patriot [199 words]Norsk!Apr 3, 2006 14:512199
Norsk [225 words]sonsamSep 14, 2006 00:472199
Venus IS the issue between US and Europe [429 words]j steinkeAug 24, 2002 19:452090
1The European World View [280 words]Gary VinebergJul 29, 2002 02:501464
Europeans seem quite Masochistic [187 words]Ryan NeidlingerJul 26, 2002 21:561446
The true cause of US-EU rift [119 words]Greg OfieshJul 25, 2002 04:591432
Sad about the current drift [122 words]Ka SheiJul 23, 2002 13:451400
The Historical Facts [323 words]Brendan JamesJul 21, 2002 08:581382
i agree [273 words]sonsamSep 12, 2006 03:501382
Are you sure? [33 words]Romeu LourencaoJul 20, 2002 22:471378
Woe to Europe [62 words]JohnJul 19, 2002 21:201371
Remember History's Lessons... [107 words]MarkJul 19, 2002 13:491362
A voice from Germany [351 words]Michael KleinerJul 19, 2002 12:471356
Hatred and fear in Europe [149 words]Leonard SokolicJul 19, 2002 08:291350
U.S. did not defeat Germany [315 words]Stephen HudsonJul 18, 2002 23:471348
A bit of perspective [954 words]Petter O. NikulaJul 18, 2002 21:451346
The Atlantic seems even wider these days [156 words]N LambertJul 18, 2002 18:581342
Have Another? [134 words]ClintonJul 18, 2002 15:551336
Multi-racial victimology [229 words]Michael WhiteJul 18, 2002 13:571332
We shouldn't still pay for Europe's defense [108 words]CatherineJul 18, 2002 13:331331
It would be great wouldn't it ? [194 words]SharunasNov 1, 2006 17:221331
Europe has returned to mentality of the '30's [122 words]Yossi Ben-AharonJul 18, 2002 10:111329
Reply to Yossi Ben-Aharon : reaction to zionist hatred towards europe [236 words]Quentin HAug 10, 2003 17:561329
reply to quentin [233 words]sonsamSep 14, 2006 01:301329
Subsidizing Europe [105 words]Francois KrodelJul 18, 2002 10:071328
Europe and Germany [97 words]Curtis KreutzbergJul 18, 2002 09:231327
Europeans need to follow America [57 words]Andrew YungerJul 18, 2002 08:121326
2European attitudes to the US [391 words]Ian BlackJul 18, 2002 07:161325
what do you expect? [101 words]FrankNov 28, 2013 14:571325
Towards a More Complete Reference [164 words]Dr Winston PickettJul 18, 2002 05:001323
No alliance with Turkey [207 words]Gerald GerjekianJul 17, 2002 21:141322
Europeans cannot resist violence [151 words]Dan McDowellJul 17, 2002 20:451321
reply to dan [169 words]sonsamSep 14, 2006 02:061321
America's New Center of Gravity [67 words]Paul M. NevilleJul 17, 2002 20:251319
Europe is on a downhill slide [42 words]Donna PillarJul 17, 2002 15:531317
Perfectability of man [253 words]Byron MurgatroydJul 17, 2002 13:381314
U.S. domestic shortcomings [327 words]Ron GoldsteinJul 17, 2002 13:131313
Europe is antagonistic to the U.S. [39 words]Prof. Richard MillmanJul 17, 2002 11:081312
Too much credibility given to EU and UN [124 words]Shirley DobryJul 17, 2002 10:351311
Americans should spend like the Europeans [28 words]Edward DubinJul 17, 2002 10:301310
Why is America so self-confident ? [103 words]SabrinaJul 17, 2002 09:191309
Sabrina, you're so wrong [164 words]sonsamSep 15, 2006 00:531309
Chaos and Order [188 words]D.R.Jul 17, 2002 03:281306
Great job! [77 words]Matt MathiasJul 17, 2002 03:151305
The Article is "Spot-On" as the Europeans Would Say! [112 words]Charles LouderJul 17, 2002 02:141304
Who will they call? [278 words]Arlene SwartzmanJul 16, 2002 17:161300
Too much credit to Europe [149 words]PGJul 16, 2002 14:441297
If the rest of the world could do the same... [31 words]Henry MorganJul 16, 2002 13:431295
The soft and yielding Euros [262 words]SheerahkahnJul 16, 2002 13:431294
NOT JUST INDIA [74 words]GRAHAM RAEL-BROOKJul 16, 2002 13:171293
The Left Wing is a Cult [137 words]Art AltmanJul 16, 2002 13:081291
The reason Europe has lost it's nerve [373 words]Ken BesigJul 16, 2002 13:041290
Sense quo vadis? [291 words]GrizeldaSep 15, 2008 15:581290
How Polarized are We? [77 words]Frank BlazeyJul 16, 2002 13:031289
Military defeat, not diplomacy [151 words]TimJul 16, 2002 12:281287
Could UK and Russia be exceptions? [81 words]Stephen FongJul 16, 2002 12:281286
Up in Smoke or Sweet Dreams [120 words]Glenn KlotzJul 16, 2002 11:511285
God Bless America - The last hope for the world [97 words]Jeff BercovitchJul 16, 2002 11:111282
Americans and Europeans: Martians & Venusians? [94 words]Michael A. CoffeyJul 16, 2002 09:401281

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)