Dr Tawfik, some tips to help you ask the right question

Submitted by Harrak (Canada), Mar 11, 2006 at 18:45

"1- Killing Muslims who convert from Islam to other religions (Redda Law which is part of Shariia System in Saudi Arabia)"`

..they should denounce it as a law. But denouncing it as a Saudi Law will be agaist international law that prevents UN member states to interfere in other states internal affairs. Other words No here, be it there who cares. Or if we apply international morality, than we start with Israel and Saudi Wahabia in the top of the List.


"2- Declaring war on Non-Muslims to give them a choice between Islam-Jizia (Humiliating tax)- and Killing (this was the way to spread Islam and is approved till now in the current Islamic books)

..they should reject this totally..

"3- Stoning women for having "illegal" sex (i.e. outside marriage or the Islamic slavery system as practiced in Saudi Arabia till now)"`

refer to the comment on number 1

"4- Killing homosexuals (as described in the current Islamic books and practiced in Iran and other Islamic countries)"
`
Proof and source needed about killing homos in Iran. Yes known to have happened in Wahabia but lashes is the law in Iran now. No to killing, but yes to fining them if they break a social law adopted by the Majority where applicable.

"5- Beating women or wives to discipline them"`

NO NO Ali never beat fatima nor did Muhamad..

"6- Slavery (As practiced by Prophet Mohammed his followers in the history of Islam)
`
No No No to that, and slavery was not practiced by Muhamad, it was practiced by Belgium in the Congo, by the whites in Africa and by the Dick Cheney`s friends in the appartheid system of South Africa..

"7- Enslaving female war prisoners and raping them (Ma Malakat Aimanikum) as justified in the traditional Islamic teaching"`

refer to 7.

"8- Accepting Dhimmi status for Non-Muslims - the correct word in Arabic is "Zhimmi"- (this is a form of second class citizen who do not have the same rights as Muslims do) under an Islamic system"

No to that openly and no to that in Kuwait, Emirates and Soudi Wahabia where foreigners (citizens of other sovereign states) are low class persons. No to that in Israel where Palestenian are lower status people.

"9- Is marrying and having sex with a 7-9 years old female child to follow in the foot steps of Prophet Mohammed (as described in Hadith Sahih in Sahih Al-Buchary) "Halal" (acceptable) or WRONG? ""

First that is you Sahih and the Sahih of the Wahabis (are u Wahabi!) , may be halal in 1400 years ago and Haram now. But you should ask the Quebec government -Canadian province - to change their laws that allows 12 years old girls to marry with parents approval. Age of consent to have sex in many western countries is higher than Arab countries any ways. So the west should make it 18 and Arabs will follow..(recommand you watch a movie called Karla Homolka).

"10- Calling Jews "pigs and monkeys" in the current Islamic teaching."

That is actually your teaching. That does not exist and you can existantize it if you want..


Later doctor,

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".