| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
Wahabi Imams
Reader comment on item: [Hasan Akbar and] Murder in the 101st Airborne
Submitted by Howard S. Smigel (United States), Mar 25, 2003 at 19:42
I heard your excellent comments on Fox News the night of the grenade incident. At that time you stated that of the seven Muslim imams serving as chaplains with the forces, five were of the Wahabbi sect.In your article in today's email (and in the NY Post) you make no mention of this. Are the facts as you stated them on Monday not true, or have you been asked to suppress them?
Did you see the item on DebkaFile concerning the Syrian bus that was struck when the bridge was blown up? According to DebkaFile, the bus carried Palestinian fedayeen going to fight for Saddam. I have not seen any news source carrying that other than DebkaFile. Do you know whether it is true and, if so, why no one else has picked it up?
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
Daniel Pipes replies:
It was the other speaker, Frank Gaffney, who made this point about the chaplains, not me.DP
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (146) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Wake up True Amerians [81 words] | AZH | Nov 23, 2009 06:03 | 164912 | |
| Heart Not in Right Place [77 words] | Cecil Berger | Jul 21, 2005 11:24 | 23678 | ||
| 1 |  He is not imbalanced. [42 words] | David Olds | Nov 11, 2009 17:26 | 23678 | |
| 1 | Wrong Cecil: read the diary entries [78 words] | Abu Nudnik | Nov 20, 2009 13:08 | 23678 | |
| 1 | Now that the verdict is in... [477 words] | D Mead | May 4, 2005 10:58 | 21988 | |
| Americans were defeated in Vietnam and so be in Iraq & Afghanistan too. [150 words] | Mohammad, CPA | Jan 21, 2010 23:31 | 21988 | ||
| 1 | Our dear CPA the wannabe Arab [329 words] | dhimmi no more | Jan 22, 2010 18:41 | 21988 | |
| i was one of the nurses that night.... when the grenade attack happen to the 101st [26 words] | Martha | May 2, 2005 22:03 | 21945 | ||
| Response to Martha [17 words] | Chuck | Sep 25, 2007 04:09 | 21945 | ||
| Collaboration and even treason abound now in the US... [91 words] | jim cyr | Apr 30, 2005 10:59 | 21903 | ||
| Muslims not the only group prone to 'terrorism' [199 words] | Annie | Apr 25, 2005 22:29 | 21815 | ||
| 3 | Response to Annie's comment from April 25, 2005 [495 words] | Roscoe | Jan 21, 2006 20:30 | 21815 | |
| Response to Annie [80 words] | chuck | Sep 23, 2007 00:17 | 21815 | ||
| Unveiling the hidden [68 words] | Xeron | Nov 24, 2007 19:16 | 21815 | ||
| Dear Annie... [402 words] | Matthew S. | Dec 27, 2011 22:56 | 21815 | ||
| HIS ACTIONS THRUOUGH MY EYES. [347 words] | Rodney French | Apr 23, 2005 01:17 | 21772 | ||
| Muslim Differences Only Go So Far [65 words] | Bonnie Arthur | May 12, 2004 09:44 | 15174 | ||
| A traitor, a disgrace...Should be given ultimate punishment... [106 words] | Nick | Sep 30, 2003 19:51 | 11605 | ||
| when will the murderer die? [33 words] | Irv Weinsoff | Jun 18, 2008 18:46 | 11605 | ||
| In response to Nadia K. on Muslims and US citizenship [361 words] | Chris B. | Jul 27, 2003 01:55 | 10261 | ||
| Nadia on hasan akbar [52 words] | btilly | Sep 1, 2008 17:30 | 10261 | ||
| We have the proof at hand [361 words] | Michael R. Gilmore | Jul 9, 2003 11:13 | 9956 | ||
| Response To Tammy Hall [316 words] | Mike Ramirez | Jun 30, 2003 17:19 | 9776 | ||
| My brother was Major Gregory Stone [49 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Tammy Hall | Jun 17, 2003 20:22 | 9591 | ||
| I also want to extend condolences and, Daniel, you're wrong [39 words] | Abu Nudnik | Dec 29, 2009 12:47 | 9591 | ||
| Comment on Alex Cross Post [89 words] | N. Khan | Apr 30, 2003 15:43 | 8804 | ||
| NY Post [294 words] | Ali Khan | Apr 24, 2003 16:34 | 8653 | ||
| Islam and the blame game. [287 words] | Sheikh Ahmed | Apr 16, 2003 12:45 | 8397 | ||
| Islamic Clerics Shoot Down Your Argument [288 words] | Lisa | Mar 28, 2006 22:02 | 8397 | ||
| In response to commenter Wendy Crews [227 words] | Dale Crawford | Apr 11, 2003 22:47 | 8276 | ||
| 2 | Muslims and U.S. Citizenship [96 words] | Nadia K. | Apr 11, 2003 13:43 | 8268 | |
| 1 | All Muslims are not the same!!!! [699 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Adeel | Apr 11, 2003 04:12 | 8260 | |
| 1 | No such thing as a true Muslim who is peaceful, according to Muslim texts [121 words] | Lisa | Mar 28, 2006 11:32 | 8260 | |
| appreciation [58 words] | Pastor Max Jackson | Sep 10, 2010 09:49 | 8260 | ||
| Prove it to me. [302 words] | howard | Sep 21, 2015 20:29 | 8260 | ||
| 1 | Stop spread of militant Islam [41 words] | tb303 | Apr 9, 2003 23:02 | 8229 | |
| Peace Pipe that 'Smokes' [85 words] | linda | Apr 7, 2003 23:44 | 8130 | ||
| 1 | From an American Muslim [267 words] | Thomas J Hamza Mohammed Haidon | Apr 6, 2003 05:12 | 8092 | |
| hasan akbar and murder [95 words] | btilly | Sep 1, 2008 17:08 | 8092 | ||
| Another one of Those People [226 words] | dgage | Apr 5, 2003 13:06 | 8067 | ||
| When will someone get it right? [302 words] | Ronald P. Jones | Apr 5, 2003 12:28 | 8066 | ||
| Are we still obtuse? [254 words] | MWhitton | Apr 4, 2003 21:28 | 8047 | ||
| Too much generalizing [327 words] | Miss Ruth | Apr 3, 2003 02:51 | 7984 | ||
| Conscientious Objectors, other excuses? [85 words] | Shawn O'nealy | Apr 2, 2003 22:56 | 7975 | ||
| The bad news... [65 words] | Walt | Apr 1, 2003 20:53 | 7906 | ||
| Overlooked Historical Event? [25 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Stuart Gang | Apr 1, 2003 18:09 | 7895 | ||
| Investigate Muslim Chaplains [249 words] | John Rudolph | Apr 1, 2003 14:39 | 7867 | ||
| Excuses, excuses! [88 words] | Linda Lee Jungblut | Mar 31, 2003 21:20 | 7827 | ||
| 1 | Protecting Muslims [124 words] | Avraham | Mar 31, 2003 19:32 | 7825 | |
| 1 | Islam is a System, not a religion, & is dangerous [231 words] | Alex Cross | Mar 31, 2003 15:01 | 7816 | |
| Islam is a religion of peace [117 words] | ahmad rashad jenkins | Jan 3, 2006 22:36 | 7816 | ||
| Spiritual Warfare [164 words] | Robert Hayes | Mar 30, 2003 12:20 | 7783 | ||
| Iraq War [253 words] | David Hart | Mar 29, 2003 07:43 | 7761 | ||
| Conscientious Objectors [187 words] | Mike Ramirez | Mar 28, 2003 22:39 | 7756 | ||
| Where will it end? [137 words] | Veronica | Mar 28, 2003 21:16 | 7753 | ||
| How many deaths and acts of terrorism will it take... [151 words] | Maryallene Otis | Mar 28, 2003 15:25 | 7748 | ||
| 18 | Dangers of Islam [633 words] | A Hindu | Mar 28, 2003 14:32 | 7746 | |
| Imagine if there was no religion. [60 words] | whitegoose | Dec 7, 2007 07:52 | 7746 | ||
| I think you are correct. [39 words] | guy hamilton | Jul 30, 2012 11:59 | 7746 | ||
| can't believe it [268 words] | alskdjfhg | Apr 7, 2015 19:31 | 7746 | ||
| Agree With Halim [151 words] | George K | Mar 28, 2003 14:14 | 7744 | ||
| Reply to Halim: Muslims and the melting pot [131 words] | Ayesha A. | Mar 28, 2003 11:08 | 7738 | ||
| murder in the airborne [96 words] | S.C.Panda | Mar 28, 2003 06:33 | 7733 | ||
| 1 | An Indian's point of view [100 words] | A Desi | Mar 28, 2003 01:53 | 7729 | |
| The Failure Of Islam To Police Itself [320 words] | Spytalk | Mar 27, 2003 22:33 | 7725 | ||
| Melting Pot? [62 words] | Halim | Mar 27, 2003 19:05 | 7722 | ||
| Heads in the sand. [61 words] | A. Berlin | Mar 27, 2003 17:19 | 7720 | ||
| What does it take for us to get the message? [76 words] | Steven Hess | Mar 27, 2003 17:10 | 7719 | ||
| Not exactly a religon [132 words] | Mark Garretson | Mar 27, 2003 15:43 | 7717 | ||
| Too many excuses [39 words] | Jo Combs | Mar 27, 2003 15:36 | 7716 | ||
| Murder in the 101st Airborne--Coming to a Workplace Near You [179 words] | DMarquis | Mar 27, 2003 11:54 | 7710 | ||
| Very much to the point [109 words] | Another freethinker | Mar 27, 2003 11:43 | 7709 | ||
| Support of Wendy Crews [184 words] | yaron | Mar 27, 2003 11:35 | 7707 | ||
| Any students of Comparative Religion? [7 words] | James Solbakken | Mar 26, 2003 23:57 | 7702 | ||
| clash of values [142 words] | Charn Deol | Mar 26, 2003 19:39 | 7698 | ||
| Who can best help? [56 words] | Gene Behl | Mar 26, 2003 17:49 | 7694 | ||
| It's the people, not the religion. [313 words] | Simon | Mar 26, 2003 17:43 | 7693 | ||
| Muslim-American [196 words] | Raymond Low | Mar 26, 2003 16:59 | 7691 | ||
| Now Showing: UN Crocodile Tears – Episode #2 [363 words] | Shep Fargotstein | Mar 26, 2003 16:44 | 7690 | ||
| 1 | Apologizing for muslim religion [81 words] | Nazia K | Mar 26, 2003 15:29 | 7686 | |
| fall of islam [153 words] | mouservias | Sep 22, 2007 08:30 | 7686 | ||
| What makes an American Muslim carry out such an act? [197 words] | Rob Riedijk | Mar 26, 2003 13:54 | 7682 | ||
| Loyalty to the Muslim umma trumps all else [445 words] | Jean-Jacques Furet | Mar 26, 2003 13:29 | 7681 | ||
| Muslim Chaplains - Highly Suspect [434 words] | John Rudolph | Mar 26, 2003 12:48 | 7680 | ||
| Doesn't surprise me [89 words] | Brian | Mar 26, 2003 11:17 | 7676 | ||
| Dictates of reason [753 words] | Blake Butterworth | Mar 26, 2003 11:17 | 7675 | ||
| Need some serious thinking [308 words] | ProudToBeAMuslim | Feb 7, 2008 13:41 | 7675 | ||
| 1 | Effective and Necessary Profiling [64 words] | kala | Mar 26, 2003 10:51 | 7674 | |
| ignorance gone to seed [192 words] | Stella | Mar 26, 2003 09:20 | 7671 | ||
| Suspecting loyalty at the front [156 words] | Richard Davis | Mar 26, 2003 09:16 | 7670 | ||
| A tragedy [19 words] | Alexander | Mar 26, 2003 08:53 | 7667 | ||
| Is It Already Too Late? [282 words] | M. J. Greene | Mar 26, 2003 08:52 | 7666 | ||
| questions [74 words] | uyk7 | Mar 26, 2003 07:31 | 7662 | ||
| S.O.S [163 words] | Bob Morrison | Mar 26, 2003 07:06 | 7661 | ||
| 1 | Stop political correctness! [151 words] | Joel M. Weiner | Mar 26, 2003 02:43 | 7657 | |
| 1 | Weak leadership in America has opened the door to disaster [292 words] | TOM | Apr 11, 2008 16:24 | 7657 | |
| Murder in the 101st Airborne [53 words] | Lawrence Smith | Mar 26, 2003 01:00 | 7654 | ||
| 2 | Political correctness will lead to the death of America [144 words] | lea burns | Mar 26, 2003 00:08 | 7653 | |
| Sometimes the knee-jerk conclusion is right. [183 words] | SallyVee | Mar 26, 2003 00:07 | 7652 | ||
| Amazing Awareness [84 words] | John Sharpe | Mar 25, 2003 22:37 | 7646 | ||
| I agree! [42 words] | penny | Mar 25, 2003 22:28 | 7644 | ||
| Disingenuity of thinking now is different from the Middle Ages [473 words] | Walt O'Brien | Mar 25, 2003 22:25 | 7643 | ||
| When only will non-Muslims and Americans see? [465 words] | Al-Mansur | Mar 25, 2003 22:07 | 7642 | ||
| Trust But Verify [122 words] | William Ford | Mar 25, 2003 21:29 | 7640 | ||
| Running out of Cheeks [106 words] | Erik Paulson | Mar 25, 2003 20:29 | 7636 | ||
| Playing the "race" card - and knowing when to fold [127 words] | Yonason | Mar 25, 2003 19:47 | 7635 | ||
 Wahabi Imams [134 words]w/response from Daniel Pipes | Howard S. Smigel | Mar 25, 2003 19:42 | 7633 | ||
| His family comments - more was sai [137 words] | Dave Krasnow | Mar 25, 2003 19:40 | 7632 | ||
| Rattlesnakes in the house [27 words] | John Hansen | Mar 25, 2003 19:36 | 7631 | ||
| Only Dr. Pipes... [169 words] | Arlinda DeAngelis | Mar 25, 2003 19:19 | 7629 | ||
| Why can't we as a people see this is a real danger. US Rep Virgil Goode is so right but will catch real trouble for saying it [4 words] | Cecil Yeatts | Jan 5, 2007 20:19 | 7629 | ||
| The Only Solution [68 words] | Eber Haddad | Mar 25, 2003 18:17 | 7628 | ||
| In order to win the War quickly [87 words] | Wendy Crews | Mar 25, 2003 18:03 | 7627 | ||
| When will we wake up? [36 words] | R. Whiteley | Mar 25, 2003 17:55 | 7626 | ||
| Traitor! [7 words] | Javier Soprano | Mar 25, 2003 17:45 | 7625 | ||
| No more apologizing [17 words] | Edward P. Welsh | Mar 25, 2003 17:38 | 7624 | ||
| What Sect is Akbar a member of? [16 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Bill Dillon | Mar 25, 2003 17:31 | 7623 | ||
| Bravo - it's about time the facts are faced. [38 words] | Richard Zuma | Mar 25, 2003 17:07 | 7621 | ||
| Hard Lessons [127 words] | Boris Frenkel | Mar 25, 2003 16:42 | 7619 | ||
| You are right on! [80 words] | Thomas Beachum | Mar 25, 2003 16:35 | 7618 | ||
| Great Job! [8 words] | Tom Brown | Mar 25, 2003 16:26 | 7617 | ||
| I wondered the same? [263 words] | Sheerahkahn | Mar 25, 2003 16:22 | 7616 | ||
| Why Was This Soldier Deployed? [42 words] | William Steimel | Mar 25, 2003 16:22 | 7615 | ||
| Our alien nationals [101 words] | Gymnast | Mar 25, 2003 16:20 | 7614 | ||
| THANKS [5 words] | Richard Haar | Mar 25, 2003 16:05 | 7612 | ||
| What a dangerous stance... [242 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Mysterie | Mar 25, 2003 15:25 | 7610 | ||
| The enemy will strike again [79 words] | Terry | Mar 25, 2003 15:24 | 7609 | ||
| "AMERICAN" MUSLIMS [161 words] | Mike Davis | Mar 25, 2003 15:19 | 7608 | ||
| Muslim Forthrightness [146 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Bayers | Mar 25, 2003 15:19 | 7607 | ||
| What is racism? Depends upon whose ox is being gored. [154 words] | Ethan Corey | Mar 25, 2003 15:14 | 7606 | ||
| The real threat of PC- the enemy [267 words] | Martin H. Green | Mar 25, 2003 15:06 | 7605 | ||
| See no evil, hear no evil. [33 words] | A Canadian named Lenn | Mar 25, 2003 15:05 | 7604 | ||
| Muslims; anywhere [237 words] | Lisa Michelson | Mar 25, 2003 14:32 | 7602 | ||
| Please do more to get this article's facts promulgated [56 words] | M. Nemko, Ph.D. | Mar 25, 2003 14:20 | 7601 | ||
| Excellent, unflinching piece [25 words] | diana west | Mar 25, 2003 14:16 | 7600 | ||
| Senseless acts of violence. [160 words] | Bill Hadney | Mar 25, 2003 14:02 | 7598 | ||
| Have we the courage to confront our enemies? [144 words] | Kevin M. | Mar 25, 2003 13:51 | 7593 | ||
| 5th column [120 words] | Glenn Klotz | Mar 25, 2003 13:49 | 7592 | ||
| Overlooking The Obvious? [69 words] | John T Voisey | Mar 25, 2003 13:39 | 7590 | ||
| USA SOLDIER WHO THREW GRENADES [24 words] | C. E. Hammond | Mar 25, 2003 13:07 | 7587 | ||
| 101st & real tradegy [116 words] | thomas w. olds | Mar 25, 2003 13:00 | 7586 | ||
| No peaceful Muslim [57 words] | Dan | Mar 25, 2003 12:35 | 7584 | ||
| Disappointed with this one [124 words] | Gerald Shapiro | Mar 25, 2003 12:32 | 7580 | ||
| Is anyone surprised? [121 words] | Stan Lutz | Mar 25, 2003 12:31 | 7579 | ||
| P.C= Political Correctness? P.C. = Positively Crazy! [114 words] | Carol | Mar 25, 2003 12:26 | 7576 | ||
| Sensitive jobs and islamists [72 words] | A. Ahmed | Mar 25, 2003 12:22 | 7575 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)