69 million page views

Please read.. -correction-

Reader comment on item: [Michael Oren's] "Six Days of War"
in response to reader comment: Reply to Waleed Abd El Rahman - Egypt "victory" in 1973

Submitted by Amroo (Israel), Apr 24, 2007 at 05:15

Shmuel Ben Zvi, with all due respect, I highly suggest you revise your facts about certain parts of your article/reply..

I would like to remind you, or maybe tell you, that Egypt reached much further than 10 km from the East bank, in fact some soldiers even reached Tel-Aviv although they did not have to fight their way through. Syria occupied the entire north of Israel in just three days, that includes the entire Golan heights taken by Israel in 1967. However, the Egyptian army did stop and the Syrian army was brought back when the United Nations intervened.

I would also like to correct you. In your article/reply, you've said "The Soviet Union, the USSR intervened and threatened to join the war if Israel would not halt its progress on Arab Capitols."

You said that in a way that sounded like America did not, in any way whatsoever support Israel economically, politically, and especially in that specific war, militarily. I'm afraid that's very incorrect. In your article you made it sound like it was Egypt and the USSR attacking Israel, who just like in a fairy tale managed to beat the both (and I would like to emphasize the fact that the USSR was one of the, if not THE most powerful nation in the world at the time, and Egypt was also one of the most powerful nations in the Arab peninsula). All that about Israel beating both alone is false and incorrect; an easy example to give would be the America "Phantom". Many of these powerful planes were given to Israel during that war, not to mention the 1.6 trillion dollars America spent on aids for Israel since 1973.

Dislike (1)
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (44) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
2Why Six Days? [30 words]M. GreenbergJun 6, 2007 10:3096247
1Praise the Lord!! [60 words]Anurag EdwardsDec 13, 2008 12:1396247
1Go Israel [129 words]Aaron KinneyAug 1, 2005 20:0024197
I admire Israel. [202 words]C.Pe.MakheshMay 8, 2005 12:1722025
10THE SANDSTORM THAT UNCOVERED A MINE FIELD [148 words]Sam AurilioDec 2, 2004 16:3518827
How the Egyptians learned the lesson [210 words]Waleed Abd El RahmanAug 2, 2003 15:5710416
1Reply to Waleed Abd El Rahman - Egypt "victory" in 1973 [274 words]Shmuel Ben ZviApr 9, 2004 11:0710416
Well said Shmuel Ben Zvi [25 words]Levy SolomanJul 23, 2006 08:5810416
Please read.. -correction- [282 words]AmrooApr 24, 2007 05:1510416
Reply to Amroo [461 words]cliffJun 23, 2007 10:5910416
Actually, Egypt won (strategically) [61 words]Oren GreenAug 12, 2008 12:5210416
Ezekiel [240 words]Joe MalanioJun 11, 2009 10:2710416
The Prophets [43 words]Rebecca MouldsOct 26, 2009 22:2310416
Victory? [38 words]El JohnNov 18, 2009 07:1510416
Right [22 words]ElNov 18, 2009 07:1810416
Who is the one learned the lesson?!!! [194 words]Nader M.Aug 20, 2010 14:3910416
Need more history info [83 words]ZyloJul 29, 2003 19:3710303
Six Days War Is Unavoidable [296 words]PK LowJun 29, 2003 22:299769
Six Days War. [28 words]MohammedApr 5, 2003 19:468078
There isn't any need [100 words]Phil CollinsMar 11, 2003 12:147191
Why? [37 words]HenryOct 24, 2002 23:473258
Brilliantly Written! [91 words]Neal R. HellerJun 24, 2002 11:09917
No Accident [1088 words]David M. DastychJun 8, 2002 12:41610
It is all Israel's fault [128 words]Nadir AhmedJun 7, 2002 15:48598
2Israel's fault? [554 words]HenJun 7, 2003 05:33598
NOT IN OUR INTERESTS [86 words]marc melchioriFeb 15, 2006 12:32598
Had the Arabs Won the 6th Day War, Then What? [494 words]Joe LeviJun 6, 2002 14:53576
Israel's determination to survive [69 words]Stan RoseJun 5, 2002 17:26556
1Israel was under Gods Leadership [55 words]Janet NgowiFeb 8, 2006 07:59556
The Six Day War [299 words]LukeDec 20, 2007 21:30556
ISRAEL - GOD IS MY DEFENDER [57 words]SUSIGARANJun 16, 2009 03:12556
Fire Power Demonstration [193 words]Michael SheridanJun 5, 2002 15:47555
Historical Parallels [209 words]Charles DaggsJun 5, 2002 15:34554
1A Modern-Day Miracle [89 words]Bill SweeneyJun 5, 2002 11:00551
1Israel deserves to exist in security [302 words]Bruce ColemanJun 5, 2002 10:59550
Israel Must Repeat the Six Days of War [131 words]Charles LauderJun 5, 2002 02:47548
SecDef was not alone [208 words]Robert H. SternJun 5, 2002 00:31545
Friendly Clarification Suggested [64 words]Adam BurczykJun 4, 2002 19:47544
In agreement [51 words]Etta HellerJun 4, 2002 17:40542
Kudos with a question [136 words]Stan RoseJun 4, 2002 15:18540
1Is this book available in Egypt? [85 words]Boris GalinskyJun 4, 2002 10:30536
Won't be a bestseller in the Arab world [71 words]Salvador Vargas-RiveraJun 5, 2002 19:22536
1Not Even Six Days! [143 words]Samy MikhailJun 4, 2002 09:16535
Timely Book [112 words]William J. SturmJun 4, 2002 08:01534

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)