"The novelty and magnitude of Europe's predicament make it difficult to understand, tempting to overlook, and nearly impossible to predict. Europe marches us all into terra incognita." That's how I closed an article ten years ago on the topic of Islam's future in Europe. Now, thanks to elections in France and Austria, an answer is emerging; Europeans appear not ready to "go gentle into that good night" but will "rage, rage against the dying of the light."
True, the elites, as symbolized by Germany's Chancellor Angela Merkel, remain in deep denial about the issues of immigration, Islamism, and identity. What I call the 6 Ps (politicians, press, police, prosecutors, professors and priests) refuse to acknowledge the fundamental societal changes and enormous tensions their policies are creating. But – and this is the news to report – the masses are starting to make their views heard not just in futile protest but dramatically to change their countries' direction.
The French center-right political party, the Republicans, just held its first-ever U.S.-style primary for the position of president of the country. In the first of two rounds, seven candidates, including a former president (Nicholas Sarkozy) and two former prime ministers (Alain Juppé and François Fillon), vied to place in the top two slots.
For months, Juppé and Sarkozy ran one-two in the polls, with Fillon a distant third. Fillon was so invisible that, for example, a commentary on the French primaries by the excellent Christopher Caldwell ignored him completely.
 Juppé and Sarkozy led for months, with Fillon a distant third - until the last few days. |
But, as has happened often in recent years (Benjamin Netanyahu and David Cameron in 2015, Brexit and Donald Trump in 2016), the more conservative option did far better than expected. In a stunning surprise, Fillon won 44 percent of the vote, way ahead of Juppé with 29 percent and Sarkozy with 21 percent. (The other four candidates won 7 percent.)
Fillon went on to crush Juppé in the second round, 66-34 percent. Fillon will likely win the first round of the general election and then win the run-off against either the Socialist Party candidate or Marine Le Pen of the National Front. He will have offered a way forward between the silly notion of a "happy identity" (really!) forwarded by Juppé and the insurgency of le Pen, which seeks "temporarily" to nationalize the banks.
Assuming Fillon stays true to his platform, his becoming president has epochal importance for Europe. For the first time, a centrist politician espouses a traditionally patriotic outlook, standing up for indigenous European culture and mores while opposing further large-scale immigration and accommodation to Islamism. This greatly damages the insurgent National Front, an inexperienced party replete with eccentric and often left-wing views.
 The generally staid François Fillon has a taste for flamboyantly fast cars. |
Fillon has broken the Europe-wide taboo against a legacy party stealing the thunder of an insurgent party. If he rides this tactic to victory, he will chart a course for politicians of the center-right from Greece to Norway; already, Merkel has followed his lead by with a dramatic course change, calling for the burqa "to be forbidden."
The timing of these events is not fortuitous but follows on two developments: repeated major acts of jihadi violence in France and Merkel's 2015 decision to allow in uncounted numbers of unvetted migrants. Merkel's decision, which will likely be seen as a turning point in European history, also helped fuel the spectacular rise of Norbert Hofer of the Freedom Party of Austria (FPÖ) nearly to the presidency of that country, winning 49.7 percent of the vote in May and then 46.2 percent in December, both times running against the Green Party's former leader.
 Alexander van der Bellen and Norbert Hofer, candidates for Austria's presidency, debated face to face. |
Granted, Austria has minor importance and its presidency is largely ceremonial, but the fact that an insurgent party, the FPÖ, two times almost reached the 50 percent mark shatters the consensus view that insurgent parties cannot gather more than one-third of the vote. They can. Hofer's near-victory has immense implications, suggesting that if legacy parties do not steal the insurgents' thunder in time, those insurgents will eventually reach power on their own.
Together, then, the French and Austrian elections suggest Europeans have two alternate paths to reject multi-culturalism, Islamism, and unceasing immigration: either by transforming legacy parties or supporting insurgent parties.
Whether they will do so in turn depends mainly on two key developments: the willingness of legacy center-right parties to adopt insurgent party ideas; and the frequency and death toll of jihadi attacks.
The terra is becoming more cognita.
Mr. Pipes (DanielPipes.org, @DanielPipes) is president of the Middle East Forum. © 2016 by Daniel Pipes. All rights reserved.
Dec. 7, 2016 addendum: Other candidates to add to the 6Ps include parents, philanthropists, and producers. Non-Ps include immigration officers and librarians.
Jan. 12, 2017 update: Thunder-stealing has also just occurred in a big way in Austria: Wary of the FPÖ's strength (it is first in the polls, with support from 30 percent of the electorate), the shaky center-left government of Chancellor Christian Kern has proposed a 10-year plan that, among other steps, gives priority to citizens for jobs, migrants being eligible only if no citizens apply or are competent. In Kern's words: "Only if there is no suitable unemployed person in the country can a job be given to new arrivals without restriction." This directly contradicts European Union regulations.
Jan. 23, 2017 update: Prime Minister Mark Rutte of the Netherlands has followed suit, seeking to steal Geert Wilders' voters in anticipation of national elections on March 15. The Associated Press reports:
In a full-page newspaper message, Rutte said "we have to actively defend our values" against people who refuse to integrate or act antisocially. "Behave normally or go away." ... Rutte, leader of the center-right People's Party for Freedom and Democracy, said he understands calls for people who don't integrate to leave the Netherlands. "I have that feeling, too," he said. But he also appeared to criticize Wilders' anti-immigration stance. "The solution is not to tar people with the same brush," Rutte said.
Comment: Thunder-stealing seems to be infectious now. I could not be more pleased.
Oct. 15, 2017 update: The expectations I had for Fillon – that a conservative legacy party would adopt the key ideas from an insurgent party – obviously came to nothing, thanks to his unfortunate taste for money. But they appear to have succeeded for Sebastian Kurz of Austria, who moved the Austrian People's Party (ÖVP) from third place in the polls in June to first in the elections today by appropriating policies on economics, immigration, and Islamism from the insurgent Freedom Party of Austria (FPÖ).
Anton Pelinka, a professor of political science at Budapest's Central European University, comments: "His formula has consisted of stealing talking points from the FPÖ and presenting them in more moderate garments and with better manners."
Feb. 11, 2018 update: Perhaps Laurent Wauquiez, 42, the new leader of Les Républicains, the legacy French conservative party, is the right-wing answer to Emanuel Macron who is moving the legacy party further toward anti-immigration policies in an attempt to fend off the challenge from the National Front. The Washington Post reports, for example, that he has called for interning everyone on terrorism watch lists in camps. Comment: This is a good example of what I hope will emerge all over Europe – invigorated conservative parties talking about the real issues facing their countries.
