69 million page views

ISLAM, Terror "Ghulam Nabi" , The Prophet's truth

Reader comment on item: Debate: Islam and Democracy
in response to reader comment: Mohammed 's rule by consent and consultation

Submitted by No-american (Germany), Dec 13, 2007 at 10:19

Terrible !!! (referring to the murder of "Ghulam Nabi")

The Qur'an was written approximately 20 years after Mahommed's death by some manipulating arabian early politicians. The prophet was illiterate. Very talented person mixed the prophecies of the prophet with political claims of the early religious community.
Mahommed hadn't nominated himself as prohpet but one christian did it. (when a cloud is one the sky above the boy with a dromedar caravan ... it will be the sign for a new prophet - he will be the prophet)
So all muslim's should be proud of the christians and the christian culture. Without them, they would never have had their prophet.

Further I don't understand the hate of the jewish culture. Muslims and Jews are almost the same. There are so many parallels even the sacrifice....

The obligation to pray or the islamic confession seems to me the people cannot have their own opinion. Shari'a is primitive without respect of humanity, it was modern 1500 years ago, when there were no laws and no constitution in these countries. But nowadays it seems quite pervert.

Almost 80% of the muslims have a misinterpretating false pretence about the prophet's words.
He said you should... and not you ought to...
For example the prohibition of alcohol.
He dind't want to see drunken man on the streets vomiting and hanging around. So he said don't drink wine (He didn't know alcohol - just wine !!!) but the Qur'an was manipulated, and now all alcohol is forbidden.
Or the pork meat.
In hot climates the pork must be cared attentively. If you don't do it, they will soon be full of bacteria that causes illness.
They didn't care. He just wanted to avoid sickness. He had no idea of diseases. But eating pork is legal if it is clean and healthy.
The prophet always had problems with his perspiration - but now all divine muslims do it like him, even if they have no problems.
It's just aping his manner I think.

Jews need all food to be kasher - muslims too , halal !!!

The ISLAM is just like a copy and mixture of christianism and zionism, with some adds of arabian history and superstition.

In Qur'an formely you could find the prophet prayed and thanked other gods for their fertility. But the manipulators of the Qur'an delete these entries.

I think almost the 60% of the Qur'an is influenced by the first arabian ruling powers. To abuse their privilege they put all in the holy book and made it law. The arabians base a claim on the godlike and holy land. And to give reason for the muslim expansion.

The Islam is not a religion, it's a cult of eastern superstition.

If the germans had rationalized Hitler was just doing what god told him in his visions - the Nazi's would be now famous as the Islam today. That is no joke - it's pure arabian purpose !!!!

All is God (Allah) !!! I think the word "Allah" should be exchanged with the word "conscience" !!! And all the things get clearer.

God doesn't exist anyone - but a god called "conscience" lives in everyone of us. It's like a cloud - you can't see it or touch it, but it's everywhere.

All you radical muslims please be sure the words you read in the Qur'an are authentic from Mahommed. Most of it it's just ugly artfully poemic propaganda. I believe in the peaceful and primordial mohammedanic Islam.

Just keep in mind the fact that the original Mosque of the prophet, a simple and small building of bricks of clay was torn off in Makkah. The bulid up a collosal Mosque but without any real mohammedanic elements.

And further evidence of no godlike origin of the Qur'an -
20 years after Mahommed's death they think now it's time to write down the words of God. Isn't it strange.

If I would hear the words of god, and be illiterate, I quickly would go to someone who's able to write down the words I heard. Isn't it normal ? Why do waiting so long ? I just want to mention (Chinese whispers) if you know waht I mean.

So all you radical muslims, please be peaceful. We western people have our law - you got the Shari'a.
I don't believe in god - I believe in my daily work and in my family to enjoy my life as long as I live, and when I'm dead I'm dead - Finito - but I had my life.

And Muslims just pray all your life - you got almost nothing, just your faith. When you're dead you will have your paradise - why don't you die right after your birth - so you could save a lot of pains. The pains of endure our western way of living. Just a joke ! ;) But I think you are even not open for jokes - have no joy in your life !!!

Stop killing people !!! The boy who killed the Ghulam Nabi should immediately go to a psychiatrist to get help !!! Did you see too much Action movies - Horror movies, boy ???

Thanks for your attention !!!

I am the friend of everyone !!! Be peaceful !!! Stop death penalty !! Save the nature !!! Save endangered animals !!!

As Salam' Aleykum !!
All you Muslims be peaceful - Jihad is the power to control yourself of doing things you should better do not. Is not meant "holy war".
So convince yourself to be friendly and peaceful - don't let the dark side of your mind win !!! Say "No" to war !!!

Greetings from "No-american" !!! الله أَكْبَ

Dislike
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (69) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
2Are Islam and democracy incompatible. How about Islam and ethics? [377 words]PrashantApr 12, 2013 00:39205107
third largest democratic country [5 words]antarApr 11, 2013 07:20205084
Democracy/secularism [130 words]KateSep 4, 2010 19:54177685
See the Reality, Women is still a commodity in Islamic Country by and large. [80 words]Sardar Ravi Ranjan Singh 'Bharat Panthi'Jul 20, 2010 11:49175804
The need for foreign intervention - Islam's incompatibility with democratic principles [157 words]AlexMar 11, 2010 22:11169999
Caliph was elected [30 words]bary soetoroJan 11, 2010 18:02167193
Indonesia: The third democratic country in the world [34 words]barry soetoroMar 28, 2009 23:11152919
Five minutes before twelve [84 words]Listiani LestariFeb 3, 2011 18:56152919
indonesia [10 words]b soetoroFeb 6, 2011 07:42152919
1Islamic 'Democracy' under Sharia Law? OXYMORON [281 words]TheWayItIsJul 3, 2006 17:3848804
2Islam and democracy [1168 words]Guy Leven-Torres (Agricola)May 30, 2007 15:0248804
Christian fanatics lack moral authority to criticize Islam [409 words]J. GuzmanApr 6, 2011 21:0348804
Security for US more important than spreading democracy [325 words]Saleem SiddiquiFeb 21, 2006 19:2636882
JIHAD IN ISLAM [56 words]I.N.F.Dec 1, 2005 17:1129272
1Sharia: DOA in Ontario [254 words]Mark-Alan WhittleSep 16, 2005 09:1725897
pkk ist doof [80 words]Sep 3, 2005 19:4025456
Plz read well about Islam first [28 words]someoneFeb 28, 2004 17:2514020
Later [126 words]truthMay 4, 2006 07:3714020
very good [12 words]lelekDec 14, 2003 08:4812647
Correction for Mike Ramirez [46 words]A.A.Sep 12, 2003 16:3111231
The question is on democracy. [52 words]Al-Zhoheir HajimSep 5, 2003 01:1211037
No reform Muslims [117 words]Hank RothAug 21, 2003 22:5510715
4Freedom, equality, justice & human dignity in islam [229 words]A.A.Aug 11, 2003 12:0010504
this is islam [234 words]FADWAApr 26, 2006 06:4410504
2Islamic Vs. Western Human Rights [677 words]CanadianChrisSep 29, 2010 16:0110504
1the information is not based on truth [69 words]hawwaJun 5, 2011 09:3110504
Equality For All in Islam??? [147 words]Mike RamirezAug 5, 2003 10:1410447
10Why is a man allowed to have more than one wife in Islam? i.e. why is polygamy allowed in Islam? [1263 words]Mohammed Rizwan MemonNov 27, 2009 12:2310447
RE: Why is a man allowed to have more than one wife in Islam? i.e. why is polygamy allowed in Islam? [601 words]SoManyContradictionSoLittleTimeJul 30, 2010 21:0910447
1Just answer the question [116 words]rational thinkerFeb 15, 2014 18:0810447
equality for all [25 words]coolknOct 20, 2014 08:1510447
Understand first. [18 words]SalihuMay 12, 2017 03:5010447
Answer [49 words]Manish guptaAug 21, 2017 22:5910447
Islam-Double talk [155 words]hari iyerAug 1, 2003 11:5210385
Discrimination? [77 words]S.C.PandaJul 30, 2003 07:3310324
1Sharia Law and Turkey [131 words]M. LeviJul 28, 2003 23:1710286
3Sharia Law and Turkey [131 words]M. LeviJul 28, 2003 23:1410283
Mohammed 's rule by consent and consultation [77 words]N.K.Jul 28, 2003 10:5610275
1ISLAM, Terror "Ghulam Nabi" , The Prophet's truth [939 words]No-americanDec 13, 2007 10:1910275
The Enlightenment can be evil, too [97 words]Peter J. HerzJul 25, 2003 23:5010244
It's a matter of time [182 words]Tim EarlJul 25, 2003 09:5310237
2Dr. Khan's ignorance [101 words]A. A.Jul 24, 2003 14:0710214
1conquest by the womb and sword [109 words]Y Brandstetter MDJul 24, 2003 08:3810198
Some important points [1515 words]Linas KondratasJul 24, 2003 05:0110191
Islam and Democracy [107 words]Nozrul HussainJul 23, 2003 18:1310185
3Muslim Women Prime Ministers [263 words]Peggy RapierJul 23, 2003 11:5410179
Tansu Ciller / Muslim Women Prime Ministers [99 words]Jan OOct 19, 2007 09:0510179
Female political leaders in Islam and in Muslim-majority countries [35 words]Dr. Fawzy SaadJul 27, 2011 11:2010179
Muqtedar! You are utterly WRONG! [231 words]Lakshmi NarayainJul 23, 2003 02:0510165
religion and democracy: can islam do it? [1285 words]Peter J. HerzJul 22, 2003 23:3810154
1Islam & democracy [874 words]SaankhyaJul 21, 2003 03:1010095
Islam is better than democracy and Muslim women have all the rights and freedom since 1400 yrs ago [176 words]Nur IbrahimFeb 16, 2011 10:4810095
A Leopard Can't Change Its Spots [126 words]James CartwellJul 20, 2003 11:2210093
Our is the best society? [149 words]JafetyJul 19, 2003 13:5410087
What is the real problem? [469 words]Dennis WheelerJul 18, 2003 22:3810086
PEW Report [119 words]Julian WassermanJul 18, 2003 17:5010085
Islam and Democracy [671 words]Vijay DandapaniJul 18, 2003 15:2410084
Dr. Muqtedar Khan [26 words]Dan GurtaJul 18, 2003 13:4710083
Islam itself [36 words]Regan HuffmanJul 18, 2003 13:1410082
Muqtedar Khan is wrong [118 words]Malolan CadambiJul 18, 2003 04:1310080
The real question [72 words]William PapkeJul 17, 2003 17:4710075
1Biblical criticism & the truth about stoning in Islam. [388 words]Richard BurdJul 17, 2003 17:4110074
Appreciaton for #1167 article [29 words]Mike HeibergJul 17, 2003 12:4610066
Khan misses several key points [222 words]Jane AdlerJul 17, 2003 12:3810065
Debate: Islam and Democracy [1434 words]Gabriele (Gila) KleinJul 17, 2003 12:0210064
Debate: Islam and Democracy [48 words]Mike RamirezJul 17, 2003 12:0210063
What others have said about this topic [601 words]Karl EricsonJul 17, 2003 11:4310061
Different perspectives [214 words]Kenneth BesigJul 17, 2003 11:2610059
Islam's "civil war" [43 words]Glenn KlotzJul 17, 2003 08:4310055

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)