Better vet than dead :: Reader comments at Daniel Pipes

Submitted by Virginia Thogersen (United States), Oct 2, 2003 at 13:05

Why is it necessary to have Muslim chaplains at Gitmo for the prisoners? Talk about molly-coddling! At our state women's prison, there is one chaplain who serves all prisoners of all faiths. Giving the Gitmo prisoners a Muslim chaplain was like giving booze to an alcoholic.

That said, the army certainly dropped the ball with the interpreters.

Like Dislike

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>

Reader comments (52) on this item

	Title	Commenter	Date	Thread
	From Immigrant To US Marine [27 words]	Lt. Col. Dominik George Nargele USMC (Ret) ( Author)	Sep 6, 2005 00:36	25505
	Swimming in half truths [34 words]	MArco Machiavelli	Jan 24, 2004 17:55	13523
	Why God in the military? [263 words]	Travis Workman	Nov 16, 2003 23:59	12201
	The Guantanamo Arrests, Oct. 1,2003 [78 words]	S.C.Panda	Nov 6, 2003 15:46	12094
	How Is This Not Terrorism? [146 words]	Mary Ann Meier	Oct 7, 2003 13:09	11725
	islam is the problem [11 words]	Jo	May 1, 2009 04:28	11725
	Stastical Analysis: The Correct way to look at it [196 words]	Leonard Applebaum	Oct 7, 2003 10:28	11715
	sarah (?) eltanawi [84 words]	Joyena Abraham	Oct 5, 2003 17:57	11696
	Military/PC [74 words]	zeph ruziah	Oct 5, 2003 13:07	11692
	Percentages [125 words]	Gershon Y. Perry, M.D., F.A.C.C.	Oct 4, 2003 16:47	11685
	Has O'Reilly Really lost his mind? [47 words]	Howard Mirkin	Oct 4, 2003 14:06	11683
1	Militant Islam - We must destroy it [166 words]	Pete Dumas	Oct 3, 2003 17:51	11680
	Convert them [43 words]	elijah jay clark	Feb 26, 2006 19:16	11680
	Militant Islam [43 words]	S Singh	Aug 11, 2006 08:23	11680
	Ants [73 words]	Michael Arian	Oct 3, 2003 15:22	11679
	Have You Noticed... [158 words]	J. Spiro	Oct 3, 2003 14:30	11677
1	Japanese Internment and Muslims [1197 words]	Bob Price	Oct 3, 2003 12:15	11676
	Regarding your comments [61 words]	Austin Sato	Jun 4, 2007 13:07	11676
	Just a 'comment' [84 words]	A lover of the English language (Amanda)	Nov 3, 2009 18:55	11676
	PC too far? [81 words]	Ivan Barna	Oct 2, 2003 21:58	11674
	Daniel, You sure know more than Sarah Eltantawi [14 words]	Gary	Oct 2, 2003 18:15	11669
	Islamists need extra vetting [101 words]	A. Ahmed	Oct 2, 2003 18:01	11668
	People like Daniel Pipes [86 words]	Jeff Bercovitch	Oct 2, 2003 17:30	11667
	In complete agreement [230 words]	Mariana Harari Froment	Oct 2, 2003 16:01	11665
	Eltantawi and her comments [122 words]	Shahin Shadmer	Oct 2, 2003 13:32	11664
	Facts v Lies [10 words]	Charles Christine	Oct 2, 2003 13:27	11663
	Better vet than dead [56 words]	Virginia Thogersen	Oct 2, 2003 13:05	11662
	The numbers are insignificant... [87 words]	Lucile	Oct 2, 2003 12:29	11661
	Similarities in treason during World War II, the Cold War, and now. [234 words]	Dr. William E. Watson	Oct 2, 2003 11:02	11660
	On your O'Reilly Factor appearance. [32 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes	Sol Levitin	Oct 2, 2003 10:49	11657
1	Muslim clerics [126 words]	Dov Sussman, Esq.	Oct 2, 2003 10:35	11656
	9 out of > 4,000 isn't many. [433 words]	Peter J. Herz	Oct 2, 2003 10:21	11655
	Chasing our tails [96 words]	John Maloney	Oct 2, 2003 08:56	11652
	The Real Enemy [579 words]	Kyle Gosnell	Oct 2, 2003 07:30	11650
	Eltantawi More Interested in Dissing Dr. Pipes [238 words]	Dan Bobinski	Oct 2, 2003 05:03	11649
	u.s.military chaplains in particular muslims [148 words]	robert fink	Oct 2, 2003 01:53	11647
	Muslems involved in the military's war on terror [131 words]	Dennis Brown	Oct 2, 2003 01:51	11646
	Muslims in the Army [38 words]	Walter E. Wallis	Oct 2, 2003 01:36	11645
	Assimilation [206 words]	Robert Hicks	Oct 2, 2003 00:39	11644
	Sarah Eltantawi [241 words]	Nora Amrani	Oct 2, 2003 02:05	11642
	Appearance on O'Reilly Sept. 30 [109 words]	harold fox	Oct 2, 2003 01:45	11639
	bush needs to say it [12 words]	pat forrestal	Oct 2, 2003 01:26	11638
	Eltantawi harms moderate Muslims [87 words]	Lori-Ann Bernath	Oct 2, 2003 00:19	11636
	Relative Likelihood of Terrorism Among Muslims and Non-Muslims [81 words]	P. G. Lubin	Oct 2, 2003 00:09	11635
	Sept. 30th O'Reilly Program [106 words]	Jean	Oct 1, 2003 23:43	11634
	No Answer [17 words]	Betty Matherne	Oct 1, 2003 23:00	11631
	Forthright [31 words]	Stephen Macht	Oct 1, 2003 22:53	11630
	Gitmo Arrests [218 words]	James Hellwig	Oct 1, 2003 22:35	11629
	muslim traitors? [77 words]	Y. B. David	Oct 1, 2003 21:53	11627
	What Muslim Clerics Preach [87 words]	Mike Ramirez	Oct 1, 2003 21:35	11625
	O'Reilly appearance [94 words]	Professor Matthew Yarczower	Oct 1, 2003 21:33	11624
	the o'reilly show. [72 words]	kevin card	Oct 1, 2003 21:04	11622