69 million page views

probably a waste of time

Reader comment on item: How Many Muslims in the United States?
in response to reader comment: There is no place in Islam "Holy war" is mentioned. "Holy War" is not a muslim term by any means, but is Christian

Submitted by bos (United Kingdom), Mar 11, 2008 at 10:16

I did think that I would not engage in this anymore but im going to try something here

I'm stepping back from the rhetoric and would ask you to please read what i say very calmly as though i was saying it very amicably in the manner of a polite conversation/debate, perfectly happy to have you make reasoned disagreement with me. and in that vein i will respond to your points

1) the unity of christendom you describe is actully inacurate but to discuss the bretton code or cathars or celtic versions of christianity or north european paganism would be a tangent so i only note them and move on.:- The church under the pope was Catholic it means universal, they labeled themselves Catholic before papal authority was established, its why the popes part was still called Catholic when the byzantine churches split from the popes authority in 1054. As for the lutherian schisms, there was never a protestant 'Crusade' though there were crusades against protestants. Finally i'm not blaming any catholics for the crusades, everyone involved is dead, but it was an entirely catholic concept, nowadays as you highlight even the pope renounces the concept and it a has become a broad term used to refer to a personal struggle a bit like the greater jihad of sufism. So it confuses me when muslims get upset when public figures use the term. perhaps you could explain that to me?

PS. king richard of england was actually king of what has been called the Angevin empire/commonwealth, he didnt speak english and only came here for 10 months to consolidate authority and ensure taxation, england was a backwater of his empire by virtue of a battle his great great grandfather fought so his descendants wouldnt have been likely to be protestants, i include this only to illustrate that tiny slices of history are often picked up by those with an agenda and developed into huge myths that are eventually thought of as history.

2) I have tried to get you to asess the crusades in context. you highlight the popes apology for the excess's of the crusades. its a good point, so in that spirit i ask you when any significant muslim figure, or significant number of muslims will express regret for the excess's of there ancestors conquests, such as Omars order for mass murder when he invaded syria, and assess the history in context. in illustration i ask 'why are Couer de lion's executions at Acre terrorism while salah al din's executions at Hattin are no impediment to his righteous reputation.?

3)Jihad:- smiling and calm I must insist that Jihad means holy war. Sahih al-Bukhari, contains 199 references to jihad, and every one of them refers to it in the sense of armed warfare against non-Muslims"......."In the words of Majid Khadduri of Johns Hopkins University, writing in 1955 (before political correctness conquered the universities), jihad is "an instrument for both the universalization of [Islamic] religion and the establishment of an imperial world state" Forgeting the silly silly, very silly academic debate regarding the meaning of the word, common usage is much more pertinent and everyone engaged in what teh western anti islamist groups would call Jihad does in fact describe there military activity as jihad.

So please i'm being calm and honest with you, please think this through and decide what is relevent and what is accurate. islamists are killing innocent muslims and non muslims and calling it jihad and some people are arguing essentially about whether or not they have labelled their murder accurately? while you think perhaps you could read some of Mr Pipes comments on the subject here is one for starters

http://www.danielpipes.org/article/498

4) Spain; we cant just shout yeh it is, no it aint, yeh it is at each other. I have acknowledged a period of relative prosperity, i have denied that including as it did 'Dhimmitude' and being short lived and only on a small space it means what many have portrayed it as meaning, I would ask you if you can acknowledge, Almoravide and almohad persecutions, the massacre at Cordoba( check the Jewish virtual library of you like) the expulsions, the flight of miamondes the executions for blasphemy. I would also ask you even if the myth of spain were not a myth what relevence should it have to our perception of a chain of empires from spain to china across 1500 years of history?

Without conveying offence i would also suggest that when you cite the history of a place as evidence for yout opinion there is nothing strange in your audience percieving an intimation of some knowledge of that history otherwise you are just using soundbites to support an opinion born of something other than knowledge and evaluation.

5) The antichrist- the concept of the antichrist is not unique, i'm sure you are aware of the concept of ad dajjal who will come from syria/iraq, does that make them all enemies of islam for all time? of course it doesnt, nor does the believe in some people that the anti christ will come from the same region make its inhabitants enemies of christendom for all time. that was clearly my point. I just dont understand the need for victimhood, i recognise it as a tool of propoganda and recruitment, but why so many seemingly rational people are clutching to it bemuses me?

Also you should read the passages you cite, not many christians are going to exegitically disect them and decide that the anti christ is coming from assyria, also it is the old testament not the new and while christians revere it I thought muslims did to? al kittab isnt just the Quran? right? so even if it did say that, thats up to Allah right? no sarcasm, your a muslim so i'm asking you?

6) It was not the first mosque in greece, it was the first official mosque planned for athens.

The orthodox church leadership has backed a new mosque and interfaith dialogue, the greek governement is paying for i, the objections to the previous mosque were over location, i.e. It would be the first large structure people flying into Athens would see as they landed and left airport, Greece was busy selling a nationally proud classical history to the world via its Olympics (although i am sure there were some prejudiced objectors as well, after all greeks are only people as well). There are many 'unnoficial mosques' in athens with de facto official protection and cooperation, there are also many mosques in thrace were traditionally most muslim immigrants lived, there are more than 300 mosques in greece, all of this can be established in five minutes on a computer, using sites such as the bbc or abc I wont list sights as i am allready being verbose and if you arent interested enough to look you wont believe it just because i spoon feed it.

but finally i would again emphasise that Greece has been criticised regarding religious rights, by america and europe, but islamic criticism is hypocritical and no assessment should ignore the relatively recent historical factors, after all your still fairly angry about the crusades.

but I must state that the ottoman mosques were not shut down by the government, they were shut down by the rebelion that freed greece, and the flight of the occupiers.

7) The saudi clergy are whahabi, that should be enough said, even many muslims reject the ferocity of there doctrine. They are idealogically commited to the notion that it is not only there duty, but there privelage to to work towards the inevitable removal of all other forms of religion other than Whahabi or whahabi like groups. They like many muslims see christianity as a distortion of revelation making all christians Dhimmi ( it also means guilty). I dont pretend to know how people feel, i listen to them and reads what they say, I also read analysis of there positions by people I consider better informed than myself, in that vein i recomend you start getting translations of meccan sermons and read "two faces of islam" (by a muslim called Schwartz (go figure))

8) iraq, there are many things i could cite as evidence but it isnt that that would convince you, only a personal epiphany (for want of a better term) will do that. So to encourage that i ask ; are muslim militants killing up to two thousand muslims a month in iraq? are they bombing muslim pilgrims and blowing up pet markets? are they using mentally disabled women as human bombs? I havent asked if america is a good guy or bad, i havent asked you to support the original invasion,!

I am asking you, as a muslim are these people irelevant to you? how far will the militants go with murder torture, rape (and that is also well evidenced) before you decide they are responsible for there own actions? or at least before you think they should stop and denounce them? so very calmly I ask with sincerity, do you not fear allah brother?

9) with regard to my murdered nun comment, i was trying to illustrate the hypocrisy and silliness i saw in you antichrist comments. i think marginalised religious nonsense less relevent to peace than murder. somali muslims muredered a charity working nun by shooting her in the back while she cared for muslims, this was openly in response to the academic lecture by the pope in which he quoted charlegmane. You responded by raising the issue of the nazi's (genarally allied to muslims by the way), this is what i called obscurantist comedy. you cant respond to curent murder by stating the nazi's were bad and expect it to be a serious debate that ensues.

10) You wish peace upon me, so I will ask you a favour. I dont believe in Allah but i assume you do, so just in case you are right will you intercede for me and wish peace and an end to islamist violence against the iraqi people. Will you denounce the insurgency, solely because of there tactics and the irationality of fighting an enemy who will leave when you stop?

I have done what you have yet to do, i have made a reasoned response to more or less everything you said, i have not cherry picked or moved the goalposts, i have endeavoured to clarify what it is i would hope to inspire reflection upon (which is surely the point of peaceful debate). I have not offered in depth academic citation because i dont think that is where we are in this 'conversation' but neither have I mentioned anything obscure that you would have difficulty verifying.

there are points that have been raised and ignored but i have not sought to resurect this issue.

I dont think you will respond, and if you do i dont think it will be in kind. I hope i am wrong, i would enjoy it.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (120) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
How Haaretz twists facts. Reporting on racist Arab-Islamic "Palestinian" attackers eliminated [657 words]Nava GMay 26, 2022 10:22281869
Leftists should be encouraged to visit Muslim enclaves in Europe [27 words]AnonDec 25, 2016 11:02234881
Not only they should visit enclaves but also they should give speeches [139 words]PrashantDec 26, 2016 03:38234881
Voting percentages [88 words]StasJun 30, 2012 17:23196855
Canada's expected to reach 10% by 2041. [118 words]DougJan 7, 2016 00:36196855
Avoid countries that are not genuine democracies [84 words]PrashantJan 8, 2016 23:12196855
2Numbers Game [327 words]Dawud Abu BakrSep 19, 2010 11:23178426
4Islam - Why is it still a protected religious group? [278 words]JimSep 8, 2010 01:56177852
2Islam is a political party hiding under a religious banner, [60 words]PrashantDec 27, 2016 01:47177852
is there a 2010 count? [5 words]owiejgiojawoieSep 7, 2010 19:23177828
1muslim in the US military [9 words]richard margaritJun 25, 2010 16:53174839
2Proposed islamic holidays in the US [290 words]AlexanderJul 29, 2009 04:32159395
5MM to 7MM is probably about right. [418 words]GWKJun 8, 2009 15:40157028
0.4% of Americans are Muslim [88 words]Jim in TexasJun 4, 2009 09:46156704
Math for Population Estimates [123 words]GWKJun 9, 2009 22:02156704
fudging numbers... [143 words]TajJun 10, 2009 17:44156704
1Haj - Podge [23 words]Melvin SherwoodJun 3, 2008 12:07130993
3Islamic fraud [211 words]LarryApr 20, 2008 20:11126294
2The estimates made by muslim organizations is most accurate [138 words]MohammedMar 2, 2008 12:32121549
1Re: Mohammed [37 words]Straight_Talk_LuigiApr 24, 2008 02:53121549
Less than 1% it seems [46 words]KlewFeb 26, 2008 10:48121124
5Muslims: Our numbers MUST be bigger ...... [92 words]warren raymondDec 25, 2006 17:2870511
2Medieval Dark Ages still haunt the west [193 words]Mohamed YoussifJul 2, 2007 09:3070511
1Condemning Hate Makes Me A Hateful Person? [440 words]warren raymondJul 2, 2007 17:4070511
2Response to Mohammed [418 words]gary fouseJul 3, 2007 14:0970511
1Find the Truth [628 words]Mohamed YoussifJul 4, 2007 19:0870511
response to Mohammad Youssif [250 words]gary fouseJul 7, 2007 12:5770511
1Same Dark and repetitive Argument [606 words]Mohamed YoussifJul 16, 2007 19:0970511
Response to Mohammed Youssef [290 words]gary fouseJul 21, 2007 17:4970511
Message Delivered [488 words]Mohamed YoussifJul 22, 2007 13:5770511
Good Bye to Mohammed Youssef. [13 words]gary fouseJul 23, 2007 19:3070511
Our dear Mohamed: Of Popes and neo-cons and the blame the dog defense [86 words]dhimmi no moreFeb 27, 2008 06:3470511
9-11 and 7-7 were the work of CIA and M15? [178 words]jennifer solisFeb 28, 2008 01:1270511
Yes, the difference: We don't want to rule the world [114 words]Straight_Talk_LuigiApr 24, 2008 02:5870511
In the interest of many [50 words]alJul 2, 2008 03:2170511
2Muslim justice [160 words]Dr.WalshMay 31, 2009 15:0270511
1A few verses [272 words]TrevorJun 5, 2009 18:5970511
@ warren raymond : Muslims cant excel in Science? Medicine? Arts? - hmmm are you sure ? [727 words]AhmadAug 9, 2009 20:0670511
1Muslim "Scientists" [113 words]sheik yer'mamiAug 9, 2009 21:4470511
Condemning hate is hateful! The first rule... [21 words]jayrenaudFeb 15, 2010 12:5070511
achievement IN SPITE of Islam [82 words]jayrenaudFeb 16, 2010 11:5770511
2Dark ages still exist in Middle east [46 words]ClaudiaSep 7, 2010 18:3270511
America Citizen [149 words]PEGGY BASSINGERSep 24, 2012 00:3370511
number is too large and is increasing [102 words]steveDec 25, 2006 02:1970462
6Let's stop Arab and muslim immigration now! [35 words]HowardJun 8, 2009 15:5170462
Americans are stupid [186 words]stopnowOct 22, 2009 07:0070462
5Stop Muslim Immigration NOW [72 words]Go_America!Dec 17, 2009 02:1170462
Time for "Made in America Jackboots" [199 words]L FondaDec 28, 2010 06:5570462
1" YOU SAID IT " [7 words]lollyDec 8, 2006 21:5468842
1how many Muslims in the Uninted states? [147 words]concernedAug 12, 2006 21:1652534
Hatred [434 words]DiscouragedJun 1, 2007 14:1352534
Heard what is happening in Gaza? [70 words]George BruceJun 19, 2007 18:5352534
wonderful discouraged [212 words]truth_finderJun 23, 2007 04:1652534
Think before you speak... [527 words]DiscouragedJun 23, 2007 19:2252534
truly discouraged ! [396 words]truth_finderJun 25, 2007 07:4652534
2Don't bother to reply unless you can stop googling [694 words]discouragedJun 25, 2007 17:1552534
Don't worry about the provencials [220 words]K.H. AhmedJun 26, 2007 16:4652534
hatred [521 words]gary fouseJul 4, 2007 01:0752534
1Read your words! [724 words]DiscouragedJul 5, 2007 09:3052534
To Gary Fouse- No hatred [253 words]YnnatchkahJul 6, 2007 02:3652534
Response to Discouraged [419 words]gary fouseJul 11, 2007 22:1952534
Still no satisfactory answers [391 words]DiscouragedJul 14, 2007 09:3052534
2Response to discouraged [264 words]gary fouseJul 21, 2007 18:0652534
Thinking outside the box [79 words]DiscouragedJul 22, 2007 15:1952534
Thinking outside the box (Continued) [228 words]DiscouragedJul 22, 2007 15:3652534
(Last) Response to discouraged [138 words]gary fouseJul 23, 2007 19:2552534
atom bombs [25 words]gary fouseJul 23, 2007 19:2752534
Blind enough to see [203 words]DiscouragedJul 25, 2007 14:4052534
1American author's blatant racism [215 words]ShirinMay 20, 2022 09:4852534
1Countering reader Shirin's views [743 words]PrashantMay 22, 2022 05:1852534
Life in the no genocide zone [222 words]JeffMay 23, 2022 23:5052534
1dont trust the followers of islam [72 words]how true VictorJun 27, 2006 09:3548203
Islamic Youth [313 words]robAug 13, 2006 00:3048203
how true Victor/safe airways [229 words]joe kaffirAug 13, 2006 03:2548203
Strong statement my friend; I must say you may be right! [475 words]Dan HawkinsSep 13, 2006 16:1148203
What is a "moslem speaking country"? [123 words]Just CuriousOct 18, 2006 18:0848203
moslem speaking countries [120 words]Joe KaffirOct 19, 2006 01:4648203
moslem speaking country [141 words]VijayOct 19, 2006 05:3748203
1Islam [301 words]BettyNov 26, 2006 16:2648203
1betty...you havent read enough. [290 words]ahmadzafireDec 26, 2006 22:1248203
Very eloquently put Victor [71 words]Frahad NavkhodaApr 20, 2007 08:3648203
Love vs Hate [76 words]MansurpuriJun 20, 2007 14:1448203
Be careful what you wish for Victor [339 words]Frahad NavkhodaJun 22, 2007 09:5148203
Victor you should be ashamed ! [99 words]Shilpa PopadumJun 25, 2007 10:5548203
Response to Shilpa Popadum [129 words]BerryJun 26, 2007 08:5748203
Victor, you should be proud [134 words]Michael KocianJun 26, 2007 18:0048203
1The Dark Ages and the Christian Church [101 words]Shilpa PopadumJun 27, 2007 07:0348203
1Building Trust [88 words]Shilpa PopadumJun 27, 2007 07:1048203
Victor, you should be proud [75 words]Michael KocianJun 27, 2007 19:5448203
The Dark Ages Continue To This Day in Islam [68 words]Michael KocianJun 27, 2007 19:5948203
Shilpa, snap out of the islamist propaganda. [271 words]True IndianJun 27, 2007 22:0248203
Berry Berry Naughty [313 words]Frahad NavkhodaJun 28, 2007 05:5248203
'True Indian Rope-Trick' [89 words]Frahad NavkhodaJun 29, 2007 05:2348203
And how Objective are you? [68 words]Frahad NavkhodaJun 29, 2007 05:3048203
About "Tricks and Exclusivism". [553 words]True IndianJun 29, 2007 19:0148203
The Dark Ages Continue To This Day in Islam [355 words]Michael KocianJun 29, 2007 19:5148203
'True Indian' should care about the level of Poverty in India and the outdated Caste System [101 words]Frahad NavkhodaJul 2, 2007 09:5448203
What about muslim poverty and islamic system which were never justified! [383 words]True IndianJul 2, 2007 20:0548203
'true Indian' [455 words]Frahad NavkhodaJul 5, 2007 09:4848203
Response to Shilpa Popadum [19 words]BerryJul 22, 2007 22:1448203
There are no chuches in Saudi Arabia [23 words]Shilpa PopadumJul 24, 2007 06:5548203
Living in a world of hatred [685 words]AnonymousFeb 27, 2008 17:4548203
1how many mosques are there in Greace? [45 words]MohammedMar 2, 2008 12:5348203
The greek clergy and government supports greek mosques, whats the stand of their saudi counterparts [322 words]bosMar 3, 2008 16:0648203
1al andalus the utopian myth [99 words]bosMar 3, 2008 16:1848203
Is antichrist a reality or a joke? [332 words]MohammedMar 4, 2008 21:5248203
false comments? [585 words]bosMar 5, 2008 20:4548203
Is 'freedom of Speech' a good excuse to insult religions? [540 words]MohammedMar 7, 2008 05:0448203
Freedom of speech isnt an excuse to insult religions, its the right to say what you believe even if a religion is going to choose to be offended. [866 words]bosMar 7, 2008 21:5048203
ammendment to my last comment [50 words]bosMar 7, 2008 23:5048203
There is no place in Islam "Holy war" is mentioned. "Holy War" is not a muslim term by any means, but is Christian [865 words]MohammedMar 9, 2008 22:0748203
the final figure and the equation that made it [83 words]bosMar 10, 2008 08:4348203
probably a waste of time [1836 words]bosMar 11, 2008 10:1648203
1Muslims Liberated the oppressed nations, thats why Islam expanded quickly [420 words]MohammedMar 15, 2008 18:3048203
dissapointing [150 words]bosMar 16, 2008 04:3348203
Some Scientific Miracles in the Koran [330 words]MohammedMar 22, 2008 15:5448203
rain drops and moonpie [466 words]bosMar 22, 2008 20:5548203
False comments again [266 words]MohammedMar 28, 2008 02:4948203
A little knowledge can be a dangerous thing,......... but here it might help [443 words]bosMar 29, 2008 08:3748203
andalucian myth [112 words]harry boyleAug 16, 2011 20:4848203

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)