69 million page views

notrelated to this article

Reader comment on item: The End of American Jewry's Golden Era

Submitted by bob buck (United States), May 3, 2004 at 09:33

hi,

enjoy your web site very much. i do have 2 questions not related to this article posed by someone to whom i forwarded an article written by lev navrozov for the washington times. i am not a writer and this question and your comments are not intended for publication on the web site. i'd like to know if this article is accurate.

if it is, then it certainly appears that the solution to the problem is not ostensibly what's being addressed as one by any government, unless i'm missing something(which is possible)?

and #2, if this is accurate and the suicide bombers achieve martyrdom and the benefits thereof as described in the article, e.g. specifically the 'eternal virgin'. how does the koran, the iman/mullah address this situation with regards to women. is their intended benefit the same, a 'reverse' eternal male virgin. can the crux of the problem be fundamentally as simple as described in the last couple of paragraphs of the article and these folks are being used by the powers that be as well as their religious institutions....

the article is below.

in August 2001, shortly before 9/11, the well-known CBS documentary program "60 Minutes" interviewed an Islamic (Palestinian) terrorist about the motives of those who blow themselves up in order to kill infidels (Israelis in
the present case).

What prompted Islamic suicidal terrorists to sacrifice their lives? The great future of Palestine? How unlikely! "Palestine" is not even an Arab word. The word is Latin and was given by the Roman Empire to their Jewish colony when no one had heard of Arabs there, and Islam originated many centuries later. Is the motive the destruction of Israel? How can the destruction of Israel be worth the destruction of the ONE AND ONLY LIFE a Moslem (a human being) has?

However, the great future of Palestine and/or destruction of Israel are at least historically imaginable.
But what was the motivation of 19 Moslems, including 15 Saudis, in the killing of about 3,000
Americans? The great future of Saudi Arabia cannot be thus created in North America, and the destruction of the United States does not come
closer as a result of decrease of its population in 2001 by one-thousandth of one percent.
The Western officials, including the Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, dealing with Islamic suicidal
terrorism, refuse to understand even its motivation. They have assumed that it is political — like meetings or demonstrations in the West.
They have also regarded suicidal terrorists as tools of an organization, such as "the Islamic organization Hamas, which has claimed
responsibility for dozens of suicide bombings
against Israel," as a report of Aug. 23, 2001, put
it, describing the "60 Minutes" interview.

The phrase "has claimed responsibility" is
noteworthy. A suicidal terrorist carries out a
terrorist act in which he sacrifices his ONE AND
ONLY LIFE. Hamas "claims responsibility," that is,
brags of it. Accordingly, Sharon bombs Hamas in
2004 and kills its two top officials. Well, next time
Hamas officials will not brag, or, if they do, they
will hide like Osama bin Laden.

Similarly, the United States got rid of the Taliban,
"captured" the living corpse of Saddam Hussein,
and is trying to capture or kill Osama bin Laden,
who "claimed responsibility" for the death of about
3,000 Americans on 9/11/01 and has also been
bragging that he will kill all Jews and Crusaders
(Christians). If all Westerners are killed (by
Chinese molecular nano weapons), Osama will
"claim responsibility" for their deaths.

Actually, a suicidal terrorist (to say nothing of 19
suicidal terrorists) may plan and carry out a
suicidal terrorist act without any Hamas or
al-Qaeda, claiming responsibility. HE will be wholly
responsible for his terrorist suicide. Period.

An organization, be it a criminal mafia or a
democratic government, can control a person in
two ways: rewards and penalties. A suicidal
terrorist is impervious to either way. He is to die
at his own will. Hence he may seize Osama by the
scruff of his neck, and despite the boastful
coward's piteous pleas for mercy, smash him
against the wall.

Members of organizations like Hamas or al-Qaeda
may run into millions and be absolutely harmless.
One suicidal terrorist is a mortal danger on his
fearless own and without any organization.

Instead of making an expected political speech,
denouncing Israel, the terrorist explained on "60
Minutes" in 2001 that the Islamic suicidal terrorists
are motivated by their wish to go to the Islamic
paradise, where each of them would deflower 70
houris — beautiful virgins whose virginity is
renewable, that is, while a former suicidal terrorist
deflowers, say, the seventh houri, the first
becomes a virgin again, and thus the deflowering
may go on eternally, since the former terrorist's
ability to deflower a virgin will be as renewable as
her virginity.

Those who have read "The Arabian Nights" will
recall that its main protagonist was rich and
powerful enough to have a new wife (a virgin, of
course) every night, and the paradise rationalizes,
sublimates, and ennobles this historical aspect of
Islamic life "at the top"— harems.

The "60 Minutes" interview produced a storm of
indignation among some American Moslems. Dr.
Maher Hathout, an American Moslem specialist in
Islam, declared that "there is nothing in the Koran
or in any Islamic teachings about 70 virgins or sex
in paradise. This is ridiculous."

Many Western Moslem specialists in Islam have
assumed that anything in the Koran differing from
the Bible or from the United Nations Charter would
"defame" Moslems since it would suggest that they
are different from Judeo-Christian and
agnostic-atheistic Westerners. After the suicidal
terrorist act of 9/11/01, American Moslem
specialists in Islam kept saying in the U.S. media
that the word "Islam" means not "submission," as
the Arabic-English dictionaries indicate, but
"peace," as in the relevant Geneva conventions of
the past 150 years.

Ignorant as the West has been re the Islamic
world, the Western Moslem specialists in Islam
have constituted a solid wall, preserving that
ignorance.

Fortunately, there are copies of the Koran in
English in the branch libraries of the New York
Public Library, and so there is no need to believe
the Western Moslem specialists in Islam that
houris, deflowered by male paradise-dwellers, is a
"60 Minutes" invention, intended to defame
Moslems.

The word "houri," which my Webster's defines as
"one of the voluptuously beautiful virgins that in
Muslim belief lives with the blessed in paradise,"
came into English from Arabic in 1737. The word
exists in all languages. Is this an international
conspiracy of many centuries to defame
Moslems?

The Judeo-Christian paradise is spiritual (recall
Dante), fleshless, and certainly asexual. On the
contrary, Adam and Eve were banished from it;
you know what for. Voluntary celibacy was
widespread even in earthly Christian life — the
celibacy of monks, nuns, and Roman Catholic
priests. The Islamic paradise offers in
mind-boggling abundance what the poor do not
have in their earthly life:

Wealth, such as precious stones and other items
of luxury,

Water in springs, fountains, and swimming pools
(there was a dearth of water in Arabia).

Wine in "rivers of wine," "delicious to those who
drink it." Yet "it will neither dull their senses nor
befuddle them" (Koran 37:40-48).

Fruits. This is another
dream-in-an-Arabian-desert of the Islamic poor in
their earthly life.

The deflowering of houris, beautiful virgins. This
is in response to the kind of poverty — mass
sexual starvation — that does not exist in
Christendom with its monogamy: one husband –
one wife. The Islamic rich can have up to four
wives. Hence the poor often have none. Imagine
the resulting male sexual starvation and the
maniacal vision of the deflowering of houris — a
kind of eternal bridal night.

Let us now take a sample year, say, 1997, and
see that 3,559 American males from 15 to 24
years old and only 627 American females of the
same age committed suicide in that year. This
does not mean that American males from 15 to 24
years old are worse off than Americans females of
the same age. This means that suicide is genetic.
Women are, genetically, more attached to the
family, children, procreation, and human life.

In the Islamic world, whose statistics I will not
quote because I do not trust it, the proportion of
males wishing to commit suicide can well be
expected to be much greater than in the United
States since the males unable to marry because
the rich have up to four wives are less attached to
life than married men.

But a genetically suicidal Islamic male can enact
his suicide as martyrdom for Islam and thus
ascend to the Paradise of super-earthly wealth
and other super-earthly splendors, and first and
foremost, of beautiful virgins to be deflowered in
an eternal bridal night.

Those of us who have encountered a virgin in their sexual biography know that the encounter may be psychologically moving, but sensually it is next to nothing for a man and an acute pain for a woman. But owing to the inability of the Islamic
poor to have a wife, the sexually starving section of the Moslem population have sexual-hunger
visions close to maniacal mental states.

In Christendom, universal school education undermined the universal belief (of Dante, for example) in the physical or material existence of
Paradise. An Islamic terrorist explained to "60 Minutes" in 2001 that Islamic suicidal terrorists
are motivated by the Paradise of super-earthly splendors they were deprived of in their earthly
life, and, above all, of those super-earthly beauties, "top-breasted," "black-eyed," and virginal
again and again in the eternal bridal night.

For information about the Center for the Survival of Western Democracy, Inc., including how you can help, please e-mail me at
navlev@cloud9.net.

your thoughts and comments would be appreciated.

thanks and regards,
bob
Dislike
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (52) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Jews in Denial of the Dark Days coming: Attracted to two scoundrels: 1) Obama & 2) Madoff [66 words]james burkeMay 26, 2009 08:24156167
Listen to those who have gone before us... [370 words]Veronique CarewFeb 18, 2008 01:54120435
Jew v. Jew [282 words]Jeff BurkeFeb 1, 2007 09:1075391
America HAS to be the World's Policeman [523 words]Dr RJPJul 1, 2006 12:4648665
america doesnt HAVE to be the worlds policeman [140 words]r.o.Apr 16, 2009 18:3948665
Militant religions [79 words]Gary NewmanSep 18, 2005 09:1925997
"Politically Correct" American fools..... [205 words]Vicki MorganSep 7, 2005 10:4225556
"Politically Correct" American fools [148 words]OlieJan 25, 2007 16:4425556
A Rebuttal [380 words]A ThinkerJan 7, 2011 16:0525556
The existence of "moderate" Muslims [75 words]Avigdor Ben-DovSep 7, 2005 02:0325544
response to Avi the Zionist [66 words]Abdulfattah BudayrNov 22, 2009 09:5525544
Reader's Observation [94 words]MordechaiAug 12, 2005 13:3524601
Defend It or lose it-Your heritage [89 words]SanmiFeb 16, 2005 15:1220399
Wake up America...When? [148 words]Chris ShivnerFeb 15, 2005 23:1920374
Americans won't allow an Islamic State in US [75 words]Kevin LoudonFeb 15, 2005 22:2520373
Islam [5 words]DadJul 20, 2006 14:1420373
Americans and the world converting to Islam. [118 words]LulwaNov 25, 2009 05:1320373
Good Article [14 words]StaceyFeb 15, 2005 14:2920364
My concerns are confirmed [186 words]Anne LeonardiMay 15, 2004 22:2915236
agree with you [89 words]Helen GordonMay 15, 2004 12:2815229
Face the truth - not the teachings.. [101 words]Anatoly GoldbergMay 10, 2004 15:2915105
Face the truth - not the teachings.. [98 words]Anatoly GoldbergMay 10, 2004 15:2715104
The end of American Jewry? [90 words]Elaine NugentMay 10, 2004 11:3615102
Excellent [87 words]SPMay 7, 2004 03:5015075
Militant Islam and jehadis+ [59 words]S.C.PandaMay 5, 2004 06:0715056
scary but true [84 words]yuval BrandstetterMay 4, 2004 13:0615033
detail mistake [13 words]ron thompsonMay 3, 2004 17:4915024
The End of American Jewry's Golden Era-Daniel Pipes Comments [82 words]NormanMay 3, 2004 15:0015023
The Koran vs The Bible [24 words]Alan TrombettaMay 3, 2004 11:3315021
notrelated to this article [1615 words]bob buckMay 3, 2004 09:3315018
Homegrown terrorism in the US will become reality unless .... [126 words]C FreedMay 3, 2004 00:4215015
Religion vs Religion or Religion vs Secularity? [531 words]A.Hamilton MencherMay 2, 2004 22:0515013
curious [117 words]AlinaJan 10, 2011 08:4515013
makes one think [169 words]yvette martinMay 2, 2004 16:5015011
Excellent!! [100 words]Darwin BarrettMay 2, 2004 16:3515009
Thailand: Killing other people is God's will in Islamic religion? [227 words]PraornMay 2, 2004 08:3215005
How can I help?? [148 words]cindy connerMay 2, 2004 08:2515004
As The Islamist Trogan Horse Grows [87 words]Major Peter St, Jean USAF retMay 2, 2004 07:1315002
Winston Churchill and the Fall of France [302 words]Uzi Amit-KohnMay 2, 2004 06:5215001
3"We await the verdict of honest men " [3623 words]Daniel WyboApr 2, 2006 11:2715001
Can we take off the Union Jacked glasses for a minute... [843 words]ArmyDickedNov 25, 2012 03:5915001
Michael C. Goncalves [394 words]ArmyDickedJan 30, 2013 05:5515001
Finally someone has assimilated Pipes concepts [79 words]Shimon PerlmutterMay 2, 2004 06:5015000
Food for Thought [454 words]Peter J. HerzMay 2, 2004 05:2914999
It is painfull to face reality. [66 words]Esther ElbazMay 1, 2004 21:3814995
The same in Europe [76 words]annemarie cherletApr 30, 2004 04:1614955
Islamist vs. Jew [91 words]Timothy B. RobertsApr 29, 2004 00:1114941
Islamic Canada [18 words]L. McClainApr 28, 2004 16:2314927
will pass this on - but the date? [35 words]roshApr 27, 2004 14:5214893
appeasement and censorship in Europe [940 words]marc jorisApr 27, 2004 09:3714880
ANOTHER wake up call [38 words]RichierichApr 27, 2004 09:0114879
It could be worse [338 words]Kenneth BesigApr 27, 2004 06:4614878

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)