discussing with muslims

Submitted by G.Bisvas (Germany), May 23, 2006 at 05:23

to faisal

Muslims are fixated in their indoctrination of their own "glory and glorious past". Muslims answer questions without reading properly and thinking over their "logic" in its depth. One cannot repeat the same arguments again and again only to find that the muslims just do not have the training and the intelligence to understand them. Since we do not know each other nor see each other, it is very frustrating. We are questioing primarily the performance of islam - not of muslims. Many muslims have muslim names but their life is, fortunately, not determined by islam. Do not mix up these two species.

The questions are: What has ISLAM contributed to the welfare of MANKIND (not only of muslims, but whole of mankind), which scientific or cultural or political or social achievements come from ISLAM and ISLAM only, which of these achievements would not have taken place if ISLAM had not come on the scene, is it possible to criticise and reject ISLAM, MOHAMMAD andKURAN openly and publicly in an islam-dominated area or society, how does ISLAM treat ex-muslims and those who show signs of wanting to leave ISLAM, did scientists with muslim names take an idea from the kuran or hadith in order to make a clear scietntific discovery ...etc. (many such questions can be asked).

If ISLAM is criticised then do not try to answer back by pointing to the faults in other religions. We have to judge ISLAM according to its own boastful claims and declarations. Each religion has to be judged on the basis of its own declarations. No comparing and relativising can be allowed. If a religion is bad then it is bad - no matter whether other religons are better or worse.

You muslims must first learn how to discuss and debate properly, honestly, self-critically and decently using correct well-developed English (the Arabic langauge has been used as an instrument of islamic fascism and totalitarianism for so long, 1400 years, that it is useless for honest debates).

I repeat: ISLAM is a fascist-totalitarian and manipulative ideology and an instrument of arabic ethno-fascism and imperialism. The last 1400 years prove this repeatedly. ISLAM is the real cause of the sufferings of the muslims (especially muslim women) and the muslims, fanatically in love with their religion and their prophet as they are, are unwilling to and incapable of and forbidden from practising honest self-criticism. In islamic societies there is a terrible pressure and competition to show-off one's love for islam and Mohammmad. You muslims just do not realise how foolishly you behave because of this pressure, how difficult it is for non-muslims to reach your deeply indoctrinated minds.

Think over these lines respected Mr. Faisal. I guess you are decent friendly man - but unfortunately mentally imprisoned in islam (=submission = mental slavery). Overcome the fear and the narrow-minded-ness which islamic indoctrination has injected in you and look for yourself which destruction islam has caused and is causing on the earth.

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".