69 million page views

there's only one Islam

Reader comment on item: Hamza Yusuf Fails My "Test"

Submitted by Khalil (United Kingdom), Sep 14, 2006 at 10:07

I would like to mention a few notices I had on your questions, I won't take too much of your time. there's only one Islam, there is no Sunni, shia, Sufi or goofies!. these are but names that people have incorporated to their opinions, the only criteria to be a Muslim is as follows: The shahada (declaration): la ilaha illa Allah, Muhammad rasul Allah (theres no God but Allah and Muhmmad is his Messenger. to believe without a doubt: in Allah, his Angels, Prophets, books and the Final day and in pre-destined fate.

To establish Salat (commonly known as prayer but the Arabic word is taken from the Root Sillah "Connection" and it is the very bacbone of the worship. alot of English words are used in describing Muslim ritual but we have inherited that so in English terms alot of Muslim practices have been Christianized in Language, for instance "Deen" today we call it religion but it really means "way of life", without it there can be no Islam, it is not only a religion but a complete way of life and without establishing these and living them how can one be a muslim?. payment of Zakat "Alms giving", and performing the Hajj "pilgrimage" atl east once in our lives. that is basically Islam, but there are other degrees that are never apparent they are hidden and between the servant "worshipper" and his lord, how?

I will explain: Muslim: one who has made the declaration. Mu'min: one who has firm belief in his/her heart. Muhsin: one who has reach a high ettiquette in his worshipping Allah. Not every Muslim is a Mu'min and not every Mu'min is a Muhsin. I agree theres a lot of problems the muslim's face today, extremism is one of them! but should the price to pay be letting go of our very fabric and ideals? ceartainly not! thats the whole reason we are Muslim, to establish what Allah has tought us and revealed to us through his prophet and messenger but ofcourse within the rights and limitations of his devine law not by our whims and desires. yes! we must treat everyone fairly, we must seek peace, justice and prosperity, but when our very way of life is threatned we must defend it to the last, this is a basic human right!, did you learn nothing from history?

the muslim's once rised to the highest of standards in humanity, arts, science, and ofcourse militaria, In Andalusia there where Colleges, universities, hospitals, public baths, light lit streets and libraries for all (christian, jews and muslims), when the chatholics took control they showed no mercy to jews nor muslims the inquisition drove all out, where did alot of jews go to? the Ottoman empire, which welcomed them with open arms, gave them equal rights, lands and oppertunity, but sadly this proud and glorious history is forgotten on both-sides of the fence, I'm not extremist but I have a culture and a way of life and it's my right to live it as God intended. for no civilisation can survive without these things, why? look at the U.S.A. thy are in a position of power yes! but I fear they are becoming Haughty and arroggant! and for that there is no cure.

I do not hate the U.S. i know there are alot of good and God fearing people there but their civilazation is going down a dark and dangerous path, as did the Greeks, Romans, Persians, British, Spanish, Chinese, Egyptians, Nazi's and soviets, the remnants of these civilizations are all around us, but what of their empires? nothing but ruins, do not be so foolish to be bias my friend, theres good and bad on both-sides, we have to look deeply between the dirt to dig-out the treasures of all civilization, only then will we put aside our differences and true progress can be made!, only then will we be able to go to the next level, and achieve great things together. all the organizations you mentioned are fighting for something greater than land, greater than thmselves, true I disagree with alot of their methods especially terrorism, but why have they turned to it I wonder? it is simply because they found no other way!

the die is cast unfortunately but we must not dispair, we can bring them back to the light, but the west must also change its policies and respect peoples rights and live-up to it's so called ideals, and practice what they preach or else the future looks very dark indeed for everyone. moreover, the west and the east must change theyre ways, they are willingly paying a very high price, for somethings under the vail and slogans of freedom and democracy, but they are no more than an abuse of freedom and democracy, just take a look if your are sound of logic and reason, to the statistics of crime, murder, aids, poverty, unemployment, racism, alchoholism, sodomism, prostitution, gun-running, drug-dealing, all these you are sustaining their existance but nothing is free and nothing is done but with it a price to pay weather immediatly realized or further down the line, fine b my guest and carry-on, you will see these plagues all are destorying your civilization from within but I fear you will not take this good advice and you will suffer the consicuences so be it, I am talking here both as a Muslim and a Human being, we are destroying our children, our homes, our counrties and our earth with our own hands, wala hawala wala quwata illa billah.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (33) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
1Passing Daniel Pipes' test should be mandatory to be called a decent modern person [87 words]PrashantJan 24, 2017 04:28235748
What "failed" means [136 words]FwazApr 21, 2013 09:49205368
1You must fail...or you aren't a Muslim [55 words]MarcusAug 21, 2010 09:12177043
I failed the test as well...Al Hamdulillah [6 words]Islam Will PrevailAug 5, 2010 01:09176357
I failed :D [40 words]JasmineMay 7, 2009 09:18155068
1how can I take the test, I wanna fail it too! [11 words]murhafJan 16, 2010 16:23155068
Hamza Yusuf a patsy? [46 words]graemeJul 25, 2010 07:43155068
Defining Islam [29 words]JCSep 9, 2008 10:54138177
4I like Hamza Yusuf, from an Orthodox Christian [75 words]EliasJun 28, 2008 11:33133689
I Failed, Yessss!!!! [26 words]SaqibJun 1, 2009 17:48133689
my high model [23 words]adnanJan 24, 2008 19:50118917
brother hamza i think you are doing a great job out there. [79 words]amal hassanDec 29, 2007 21:03117094
Hi Hamza, I have some further questions [650 words]ArchimedesApr 16, 2007 13:2189401
Takfir is not the solution [206 words]JohanNov 19, 2011 11:5289401
2zaytuna.org [275 words]SubriahOct 25, 2006 23:0364509
Hamza [162 words]DavidOct 26, 2006 22:3164509
Read this. [755 words]SubriahOct 27, 2006 21:5064509
1Thanks for your comments Subriah [1365 words]Archimedes2Apr 17, 2007 11:0064509
Interesting. [351 words]Anoy.Apr 21, 2007 07:3264509
Stick to breakfast cereal; it's more nutritious [608 words]Archimedes2Apr 22, 2007 23:3764509
Shorter response [141 words]Archimedes2Apr 23, 2007 09:4464509
2Hamza is not Islam [221 words]NisreinApr 26, 2007 20:5764509
there's only one Islam [930 words]KhalilSep 14, 2006 10:0755920
Hamza Yusuf in NPR glowpiece [43 words]Charlie QuidnuncSep 11, 2006 15:1555564
unfair test [9 words]randyAug 21, 2006 19:5453648
test..proves what??so hamza yusuf didnt pass daniels test...big deal he is not a perfect person.. [133 words]aliAug 9, 2006 00:2352150
Failed the test! [84 words]Harald Yahya KöppingApr 20, 2006 03:1243634
may God bless your efforts [60 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
EimadApr 18, 2006 22:2343534
What Exactly Does This Test Measure? [38 words]UC Berkeley Political ScientistMar 10, 2006 19:2139679
1Reply from a fellow Professor with PhD [470 words]archimedes2Apr 16, 2007 13:4839679
Not getting it [141 words]Khuram HussainJan 5, 2006 18:1631141
l love you Hamza Yusuf one [51 words]khalooApr 15, 2007 06:0131141
respect note [29 words]leen al_masriJun 2, 2009 08:2931141

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)