69 million page views

European attitudes reflect a desire that power be shared

Reader comment on item: Europe vs. America

Submitted by Marian Hennings (United States), Jan 17, 2003 at 13:43

A poll of European attitudes released last year indicates that the Europeans, like Americans, believe their countries should exert leadership in world affairs. The statements made by Bush and others in his administration that the U.S. will not allow any other superpowers was viewed as arrogant by Europeans, especially by the French and Italians. The Germans, interestingly, are more hesitant about assuming military and economic superpower status, which is probably cause for relief among their neighbors.
Both Americans and Europeans view NATO as still important, but Europeans feel that common problems should be solved jointly, not unilaterally, and they believe that the U.S. should not be the only power making military decisions. Another sore point is the Bush administration's rejection of international agreements on global warming, population limitation, and the international court. The entire poll, a joint American and European project (one sponsor was the Chicago Council on Foreign Relations) makes very interesting reading, and it shows that Europeans and Americans see many issues similarly, but Europeans are not willing to always play second fiddle to the U.S.
Dislike
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (159) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
vacation [16 words]AdamFeb 10, 2012 23:24193284
2European union was a mistake [73 words]Judit SabaterFeb 23, 2008 23:52120925
2Grow up [141 words]VinnieJun 1, 2010 12:40120925
3America vs Europe? The basic difference. [483 words]Seth R BaileyJun 24, 2007 16:38100665
1Balls? [127 words]Joris GoosenAug 17, 2007 06:20100665
1Socialism is eating Europe alive [345 words]jennifer solisNov 15, 2007 16:37100665
1Europe v America 2008 [373 words]TerryDec 27, 2007 19:40100665
wow. this is why. [123 words]ChelseaApr 12, 2008 22:22100665
1wow, that was the least useful answer you could have given. [176 words]JorisApr 25, 2008 06:08100665
Least useful reply you...no anyone, could have given [112 words]ChelseaJun 10, 2008 20:55100665
Iraq did 9/11? [247 words]JorisJun 20, 2008 02:42100665
Joris- You are entirely missing the point - Radical Islam knows no sovereignty! [605 words]saraJun 20, 2008 17:24100665
Joris get your facts straight [659 words]ChelseaJun 21, 2008 03:44100665
Intimidation? [429 words]JorisJul 2, 2008 08:21100665
Attacked [37 words]LynnJul 2, 2008 15:37100665
2Absolutism is eating the United States alive [715 words]StephenAug 3, 2008 07:10100665
So Europeans have no balls huh? [258 words]StephenAug 3, 2008 08:10100665
Poverty, oil, WWII and the EU [618 words]jennifer solisAug 4, 2008 15:40100665
Typical American comment [87 words]RichardNov 19, 2008 15:47100665
Reply to Richard [90 words]jennifer solisNov 20, 2008 11:57100665
to Chelsea, [212 words]johnDec 9, 2008 04:48100665
The US should help themselves, instead of "helping" Iraq [47 words]dutchmanDec 9, 2008 10:26100665
U.S. actually helped? [128 words]ErikaMar 8, 2009 13:14100665
Myopia [32 words]jennifer solisMar 8, 2009 23:30100665
oh yeah? [49 words]ErikaMar 10, 2009 08:48100665
Sense. This makes none. [223 words]bushMar 18, 2009 14:07100665
What? [212 words]mediancaMar 18, 2009 14:27100665
BUSH [54 words]btillyMar 19, 2009 13:41100665
This ... American [248 words]Vinnie Munoz CanoApr 1, 2009 13:17100665
Wrong [58 words]Erik PatchJul 29, 2009 12:33100665
fool [37 words]stanAug 17, 2009 02:07100665
sorry, no [72 words]mariaSep 5, 2009 14:19100665
WW2 has been over for a very long time, maam !!! [74 words]mariaSep 5, 2009 14:27100665
Europe has balls, they just keep them in pragmatic underwear [118 words]NielsMar 2, 2010 17:30100665
We think that? [93 words]JakobSep 19, 2010 22:30100665
1Shallow mis-dis-information and stereotyping . [2264 words]E. ViscontiSep 21, 2010 04:15100665
1Y'know? Someone should really clear this up for me! [203 words]KaylaJan 21, 2011 23:27100665
There are definitely reasons for America in Iraq... [65 words]JohnDec 20, 2011 21:25100665
Agreed [57 words]John (US)Dec 20, 2011 21:30100665
Oil [11 words]JorisFeb 10, 2012 12:20100665
1we all must stand up against evil [46 words]Phil GreendJun 2, 2007 13:2895788
Strong Government indeed [35 words]Ryan McGrealDec 16, 2005 12:0330073
1Europe vs. America [160 words]Kerri BeaudoinJan 17, 2006 15:0830073
We all have to be united [85 words]AlexNov 14, 2007 02:3730073
2Do Europeans hate themselves? [123 words]StephenAug 3, 2008 07:5030073
Dealing with Islamic Fundamentalism [42 words]Clifford IshiiJun 12, 2004 21:1915657
3Europe's Hatred of Americans [31 words]Jim WellsMay 11, 2004 16:0115128
Nobody deserves what the Americans got [62 words]DavidFeb 24, 2007 14:5015128
1Why do Europeans hate Americans? Be honest... [86 words]StephenAug 3, 2008 07:3515128
4European cultural chauvinism vs. American multiculturalism [258 words]D. WellsJan 22, 2004 13:3813490
2European cultural chauvinism vs. American multiculturalism by reader [194 words]MesoJun 5, 2006 04:5313490
Multiculturalism in America [209 words]blaize27Oct 9, 2006 01:0913490
imagine [65 words]guestApr 18, 2007 14:0613490
multicolored fracturation [86 words]guestApr 18, 2007 14:1413490
The American "Dream" is just that... a dream... [83 words]StephenAug 3, 2008 07:2513490
im sorry in real life this is the other way around. [121 words]aliOct 31, 2008 12:4413490
1History [300 words]MogensFeb 8, 2009 13:3513490
THE QUESTION IS....... [11 words]CharleneJan 28, 2010 06:0613490
you are wrong! [91 words]benJan 19, 2004 03:0113402
you are wrong! [53 words]MesoJun 5, 2006 04:5613402
1claims that US "deserved what they got" on 9/11 [153 words]REDec 12, 2003 10:2112637
Did the US really deserve what it got? [113 words]WarrenJun 1, 2006 00:2912637
America deserved all they got and so did we [581 words]Andrew MacLeodJul 19, 2006 15:2912637
reply [136 words]bernard morreyMay 2, 2007 07:1312637
The "Poor Things" [109 words]BarbaraAug 22, 2007 17:2912637
USA tries to rule the world [6 words]NorwegianSep 11, 2009 09:1912637
The Administration v The People! [903 words]E. ViscontiSep 14, 2010 09:0512637
Do you canucks know that some of you're own citizens we're killed in 9/11 [48 words]Luke MurphyMar 9, 2011 14:2912637
re:religious fundalmentalism [22 words]karaOct 9, 2003 19:5611768
U.S. NOT the Western Roman Empire (I hope) [169 words]JamesSep 15, 2003 23:5711262
Comment of the 'bureaucratic socialism' term of Mr.Pipes [685 words]Quentin HAug 9, 2003 23:1710488
This is exactly what is happening... [191 words]Peter VerkooijenJul 11, 2003 08:299973
News debates [415 words].AURELIO ZUÑIGA RAMIREZ from International and Environment Consulting Mallin LtdaMay 15, 2003 18:569093
RE Sanes misses the river and the boat [33 words]Simon DebusschereMay 5, 2003 10:148866
Anti-American Canukistan [403 words]Stephen BlogginsJan 21, 2003 03:577597
Liberal(aka Soviet)Canukistan becoming Islamic Canukistan [370 words]Rodney MooreMar 25, 2003 14:017597
Important distinction, but not new! [352 words]Alec RawlsFeb 1, 2003 22:256246
Your take on the Sanes insight in email #294 [295 words]J. Keen HollandJan 29, 2003 14:346105
Fundamentalist aspects in Europe? [233 words]Leo BruxJan 25, 2003 18:525979
Response to Mr. Brux.. [127 words]amiexpatJan 31, 2003 08:025979
RE comment "Sanes misses the river and the boat" [26 words]Ian DwyerJan 25, 2003 11:265974
US/European Differences [135 words]Robert StephensonJan 23, 2003 11:515909
No, it is only Zionists [84 words]Arun GuptaJan 22, 2003 22:385898
Sanes Misses the River and the Boat [132 words]Michoel ZeldisJan 22, 2003 20:405896
Selling one's soul [106 words]Bob FusfeldJan 21, 2003 21:595884
Common ground between liberals and Islamists? [447 words]Antonio ChavesJan 21, 2003 17:535882
1Yes, Iraq is all about oil [656 words]Calisse CansimeJan 21, 2003 11:335878
Response to Calisse Cansime : Yes, Iraq is all about oil 1/21/03 [742 words]Michael LangeJan 30, 2003 06:055878
Calisse, see my reply to Joris, I would be interested in your response as well [34 words]saraJun 20, 2008 18:405878
Are we serious? [1005 words]David WolfJan 20, 2003 15:515869
How can America oppose "bureaucratic leftism"? [184 words]François GuillaumatJan 19, 2003 09:565854
1Korea vs. America? [813 words]Joshua DavisJan 18, 2003 19:035848
From a Fundamentalist [36 words]John BucknerJan 18, 2003 13:375844
Not in my House [160 words]Jack AjzenbergJan 18, 2003 08:535839
Contrast American conservatism with the European Right [330 words]Arlinda DeAngelisJan 17, 2003 15:115836
European attitudes reflect a desire that power be shared [177 words]Marian HenningsJan 17, 2003 13:435831
The third system presupposes a strong American military [29 words]JeffJan 16, 2003 18:455812
Corporatacracy [210 words]Antonio ChavesJan 16, 2003 18:105811
More on Europe going its own way [71 words]Mel KusinJan 16, 2003 14:255810
Commenter Lindermayer mistates American religious life [160 words]Gail LammersJan 16, 2003 11:395808
1Who among us cares what Europe thinks? [372 words]Scott BrownJan 16, 2003 00:105800
Third Party Politics [93 words]Phil ValentiJan 15, 2003 23:195799
No More Money [43 words]Nancy BarnettJan 15, 2003 22:565798
That's what I said [12 words]Leo BauerJan 15, 2003 14:275790
Mr. Bush's rhetorical style--its impact in Britain and Europe [260 words]Elizabeth S.Jan 15, 2003 12:435787
The center of the universe? [283 words]Fred FieldJan 15, 2003 12:295786
Response to commenter Mr Stasse [1688 words]Graham SpenceJan 15, 2003 11:265782
Our Fault Etc. [121 words]N. PIllmanJan 15, 2003 09:595779
KUDOS to DANIEL PIPES [345 words]Julio DamJan 15, 2003 04:305772
EU's Immoral Foreign Policy: Economic Self Interest at any Cost [347 words]Shep FargotsteinJan 15, 2003 00:395765
Neo-communism [114 words]Peter EdgarJan 14, 2003 21:345762
outrage is subsiding [111 words]Owen CampJan 14, 2003 20:525759
Differing Conceptions of Nationalism Involved Too [461 words]Tom HolsingerJan 14, 2003 18:255755
Response to "Individualisti Liberalism?" [117 words]Rich LeonardiJan 14, 2003 18:095754
The world's views reduce to two. [1256 words]Robert CoppsJan 14, 2003 17:515753
Europe's dilemma [172 words]J.ShearerJan 14, 2003 17:455752
In response to Stephen's question [432 words]nickieJan 14, 2003 16:395748
Response to Mr. Spence [365 words]Garrett StasseJan 14, 2003 16:105747
Truths and generalizations on "anti-americanism" [610 words]nickieJan 14, 2003 15:245745
Blunderous numskullery... [316 words]David JohnsonJan 14, 2003 15:245744
Europe vs. America - a different view? [252 words]sid amsterJan 14, 2003 15:115743
It's about time! [166 words]Captain B.SpiveyJan 18, 2006 19:555743
Fundamentalist? [68 words]Frank VoslerJan 14, 2003 15:045742
1US/European differences [72 words]Ken BesigJan 14, 2003 14:275739
Ignorance [103 words]StephenAug 3, 2008 07:485739
Reply [80 words]LdAug 22, 2010 20:575739
You are a bit defensive [58 words]saraAug 23, 2010 16:155739
America is preeminently dominant by default and not by design [219 words]David ThomsonJan 14, 2003 13:435738
Asians ? [8 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
B. WeissJan 14, 2003 13:425737
Ken Sanes on unAmerican Europe [92 words]Frank VoslerJan 14, 2003 13:235736
Interesting variant of Gorchakovism [59 words]David W. LincolnJan 14, 2003 13:215735
We're not all in this together [301 words]RichardJan 14, 2003 13:185733
Anti-Americanism: spontaneous reaction or ideology? [122 words]Alessandra NucciJan 14, 2003 13:105731
On Again, Off Again; Maybe Yes, Maybe No. [140 words]Joe Wood ("Havoc")Jan 14, 2003 12:575730
What about China? [117 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Jason EpsteinJan 14, 2003 12:415729
Get your facts straight [74 words]GuestJan 3, 2008 17:245729
Oil? Look at the costs and benefits.. [184 words]Juris KazaJan 14, 2003 12:305727
Fundamentalist Christianity??? [205 words]Matthew SchirosJan 14, 2003 11:355724
1Anti-Americanism: spontaneous reaction or ideology? [277 words]StephenJan 14, 2003 11:335723
Individualistic Liberalism? [387 words]Calisse CansimeJan 14, 2003 11:225722
response to Calisse: Greed? Hardly [309 words]T.S.Jan 14, 2003 16:005722
Oriana Fallaci is not Daniel Pipes [42 words]Gabriel GrossoJan 14, 2003 11:085721
Europe [196 words]jamescaplan@hotmail.comJan 14, 2003 10:275719
Fall of the American Empire [284 words]PhillipJan 14, 2003 10:155718
Yes, & for a beautiful example...... [130 words]Alo KievalarJan 14, 2003 08:275717
As usual : France and Europe against the USA [113 words]Prof. Richard MillmanJan 14, 2003 08:095715
France and Europe against the USA by reader Prof. Richard Millman [131 words]MesoJun 5, 2006 04:415715
Attitudes in Europe. [606 words]Graham SpenceJan 14, 2003 07:315714
Response to commenter Graham Spence [103 words]Jeff P.Jan 14, 2003 11:395714
Response to Jeff P [593 words]Graham SpenceJan 15, 2003 13:305714
EU [214 words]Ante GranićFeb 26, 2006 08:185714
EU by reader Ante Granic [167 words]MesoJun 5, 2006 05:415714
We're all in this together [108 words]Richard RiceJan 14, 2003 07:185713
We're all in this together [101 words]MesoJun 5, 2006 05:485713
As an Italian, I apologize to the United States [82 words]Gabriel GrossoJan 14, 2003 07:055711
RE [173 words]Francesco Mario AzzenaAug 28, 2006 00:595711
A fourth "super-system" with global aspirations [170 words]Dennisw-usaJan 14, 2003 06:095708
Religious 'fundamentalism' is an American phenomenon [81 words]Orestis LindermayerJan 14, 2003 05:375707
Commenter Lindermayer is classic [222 words]RichardJan 14, 2003 13:105707

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)