| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
Winning the Peace
Reader comment on item: Does Israel Need a [Peace] Plan?
Submitted by Ken Goldstein (United States), Feb 3, 2003 at 15:34
Thank you for a lucid, rational and expremely well-written piece. If I may inject just one quibble, may I respectfully suggest that you recommend the works of Victor Davis Hanson to your readers. This respected military historian explains in some detail why it is all well and good to win wars but to win the peace, it is necessary to thoroughly defeat one's opponent and leave no doubt as to which side actually won. Examples abound, many of which you correctly cited. And of course, this "defeat" may be military or it may be economic and political in nature. Thanks again.Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (67) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| "the right road to peace" [383 words] | shuki | Jul 5, 2007 18:53 | 103051 | ||
| I agree with the ONLY DEFINITION of "GENOCIDE BOMBERS" [212 words] | A | Dec 18, 2005 10:23 | 30138 | ||
| Two Nations, Two Walls [705 words] | Karel Sykora | Jun 4, 2005 11:57 | 22556 | ||
| A Plan [171 words] | Murray Smith | Mar 6, 2004 13:26 | 14104 | ||
| Close, but no cigar [449 words] | Ray Exley | Feb 3, 2004 05:50 | 13674 | ||
| Stated as it is [78 words] | Reniroberts | Feb 2, 2004 20:15 | 13671 | ||
| whos side is England on? [80 words] | Benjamin Curd {14 year old} | Jan 21, 2004 16:50 | 13474 | ||
| God bless Daniel Pipes [24 words] | Albert Pinto | Dec 29, 2003 16:22 | 12987 | ||
| My Take on the Israeli/Palestinian dilemma [1569 words] | Hector Fernandez | Nov 7, 2003 10:07 | 12102 | ||
| Thank God for Daniel Pipes. [5 words] | Christina Foltz | Jun 5, 2003 20:52 | 9406 | ||
| Transfer is still the only way [217 words] | Ray | May 30, 2003 03:47 | 9293 | ||
| Aren't we forgetting Islam [377 words] | Y Brandstetter MD | Apr 24, 2003 08:21 | 8650 | ||
| What the left demands [209 words] | Jonathan | Mar 4, 2003 17:16 | 7070 | ||
| Thank You [271 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Paula Kirby | Mar 4, 2003 11:15 | 7051 | ||
| difficult problem [175 words] | joyce | Feb 19, 2003 10:06 | 6771 | ||
| One question [153 words] | Charles | Feb 12, 2003 07:16 | 6582 | ||
| Your advocacy of "total victory" is misguided. [202 words] | Luke Takeuchi | Feb 8, 2003 04:59 | 6493 | ||
| Why not another idea? [240 words] | V. Thogersen | Feb 4, 2003 17:35 | 6394 | ||
| Strategic Thinking for Israel (by an Israeli) [1614 words] | Yirmeyahu Ben-David, Paqid 16 | Feb 4, 2003 11:34 | 6370 | ||
| Does Israel Need a Plan [61 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Val Widgren | Feb 4, 2003 10:51 | 6368 | ||
| The Arabs' mentality in a nut shell [190 words] | Jonathan Lipshutz | Feb 4, 2003 06:51 | 6347 | ||
| Does Israel has a plan? [56 words] | Muhammad Siddiqui | Feb 4, 2003 00:54 | 6343 | ||
| "Genocide Bombers" [213 words] | Jacob Wolfowicz | Feb 3, 2003 22:21 | 6339 | ||
 Winning the Peace [101 words] | Ken Goldstein | Feb 3, 2003 15:34 | 6332 | ||
| The Palestinian State of Terror [555 words] | Arlinda DeAngelis | Feb 3, 2003 14:46 | 6331 | ||
| Anti- Zionism in Western Euope [57 words] | M. Nadler | Feb 3, 2003 14:03 | 6329 | ||
| The Impossible Dream [103 words] | J. Spiro | Feb 3, 2003 13:39 | 6328 | ||
| Train of thought ran off the Track [273 words] | Isaiah520 | Feb 3, 2003 13:39 | 6327 | ||
| plan !!! [60 words] | plainolcitizen | Feb 3, 2003 12:28 | 6320 | ||
| no cloudy, smokey apparitions here [24 words] | Bruce A. Birnberg | Feb 3, 2003 12:16 | 6319 | ||
| The Best Review, Yet [371 words] | Don Skupsky | Feb 3, 2003 12:04 | 6318 | ||
| Response to "Does Israel Need a Plan" [427 words] | robert goldstein | Feb 3, 2003 11:25 | 6317 | ||
| Who in the U.S. govt will move on this? [113 words] | Mel Kusin | Feb 3, 2003 11:21 | 6316 | ||
| Clarity at last [60 words] | Rivka Muskat | Feb 3, 2003 11:00 | 6314 | ||
| Victory [6 words] | Glenn Klotz | Feb 3, 2003 09:55 | 6313 | ||
| Plans are not the answer! [46 words] | Robert Abrams | Feb 3, 2003 09:05 | 6312 | ||
| Truths are recognizable... [49 words] | Kerry Anderson | Feb 3, 2003 05:41 | 6309 | ||
| Ignoring complicity. [279 words] | Timothy P. Brown | Feb 3, 2003 01:51 | 6307 | ||
| Dr. Pipes clearly defined the "problem" and the solution is obvious! [91 words] | Ivan Barna | Feb 3, 2003 01:49 | 6306 | ||
| Pipes = Genius [89 words] | steve frederick | Feb 3, 2003 00:14 | 6305 | ||
| Western assumptions may be false. [644 words] | A.F. | Feb 3, 2003 00:09 | 6304 | ||
| discussion on chatboard [84 words] | Joe Keysor | Feb 2, 2003 23:19 | 6302 | ||
| What's wrong with Jordan? [585 words] | Shahar | Feb 2, 2003 22:57 | 6300 | ||
| "Speak soft but carry a big stick"(T. Roosevelt) [293 words] | alex | Feb 2, 2003 22:46 | 6299 | ||
| Defining Motivation [219 words] | E. J. Blumberg | Feb 2, 2003 22:25 | 6297 | ||
| a question about Oslo [309 words] | Susan Krieger | Feb 2, 2003 22:18 | 6295 | ||
| Other Arab Nations?? [66 words] | A. J. | Feb 2, 2003 22:17 | 6294 | ||
| Underlying problem in Palestine [82 words] | Wallace L. Cooper | Feb 2, 2003 21:34 | 6292 | ||
| What comes first? [221 words] | Boris Frenkel | Feb 2, 2003 20:58 | 6291 | ||
| peace in the middle east [45 words] | robert mandresh | Feb 2, 2003 20:10 | 6289 | ||
| Should Israel be invited to join NATO? [739 words] | Sam Lewis | Feb 2, 2003 16:53 | 6284 | ||
| Does Israel Need a Plan [39 words] | Yale Richmoind | Feb 2, 2003 16:43 | 6283 | ||
| For how long can TRUTH be ignored? [88 words] | Salomon Benzimra | Feb 2, 2003 16:21 | 6281 | ||
| Brilliant! [75 words] | Mort Reichek | Feb 2, 2003 15:20 | 6280 | ||
| The Iron Fist is Not the Answer [471 words] | Ralph Winstanley | Feb 2, 2003 14:07 | 6278 | ||
| Religious fanaticism [185 words] | Glenn Klotz | Feb 2, 2003 13:38 | 6277 | ||
| excellent analysis [199 words] | Alfred Dukesz | Feb 2, 2003 13:37 | 6276 | ||
| Excellent analysis [131 words] | martin kessler | Feb 2, 2003 13:18 | 6274 | ||
| Query [57 words] | David Fawcett | Feb 2, 2003 13:05 | 6272 | ||
| Kahanne was too late and too early [44 words] | Norman Wand | Feb 2, 2003 12:48 | 6271 | ||
| well-conceived analysis [108 words] | Michelle Tuchman | Feb 2, 2003 12:02 | 6268 | ||
| Israel's "plan" [150 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | David Schechter | Feb 2, 2003 11:43 | 6266 | ||
| The only solution for peace in Israel [134 words] | Jordan Holtz | Feb 2, 2003 11:21 | 6264 | ||
| The Unobviousness and Uncommoness of Obvious Common Sense [108 words] | S. Matthew Prastein | Feb 2, 2003 11:21 | 6263 | ||
| A Clear Vision [40 words] | Thea (Tzippi) Riise | Feb 2, 2003 11:12 | 6262 | ||
| Thanks for posting it! [31 words] | Cookit | Feb 2, 2003 11:09 | 6260 | ||
| Tough problems require tough solutions! [109 words] | Kevin Handley | Feb 2, 2003 10:49 | 6259 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)