| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
Why not?
Reader comment on item: A Madrasa Grows in Brooklyn
in response to reader comment: What about Christian Madrasas?
Submitted by Rodni E. Chalet (United States), May 1, 2007 at 00:40
If Jews have Yeshivas and rightfully would like their children to learn Hebrew and keep their ancient traditions alive, why can't Muslim immigrants teach their children their traditions and language? This is a multi cultural and open society that is based on tolerance and I see no big deal with Muslims wanting to open their own schools.
Besides, Jebran khalil Jebran was an Arab Christian like so many law abiding citizens in this country! So why the outright bigotry and finger pointing of some posters? The Arab minorities of Israel have similar schools and it's tolerated within Israeli society with no problems, so why should we in the most diverse city in the world deprive minorities from exercising their freedoms?
Nonetheless, I do understand the fear of radicals who often use Madrasas to their own ends...
Respectfully
Rodni E. Chalet
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (179) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Point of Disagreement [38 words] | RobertDC | Mar 29, 2012 16:15 | 194857 | ||
| 1 | Why not enroll your Jewish & Christian children? [288 words] | AWB | Aug 14, 2007 15:23 | 106211 | |
| this idea could help america [127 words] | shaif yahya | Jun 6, 2007 17:00 | 96286 | ||
 Communication [14 words] | DennisOS2 | Jul 24, 2007 22:03 | 96286 | ||
| Yaya....Why not offer Arabic in any public school. [27 words] | Froike | Jan 27, 2009 13:06 | 96286 | ||
| Whom to believe ? Pipes or ADL ? [142 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Gershon Goldsteen | May 26, 2007 22:58 | 94710 | ||
| You are afraid of people converting to Islam [145 words] | Generation of Tomorrow | May 19, 2007 18:05 | 93656 | ||
| 1 | To Generation of Tomorrow (GoT): Islam brings me out in a cold sweat [502 words] | Plato | May 21, 2007 06:34 | 93656 | |
| 2 | Afraid of Islam! [293 words] | Guy Leven-Torres (Agricola) | May 23, 2007 16:47 | 93656 | |
| support arab liberalism [56 words] | samy | Jun 1, 2007 10:02 | 93656 | ||
| 1 | Converting [150 words] | joeyindc | Jun 7, 2007 20:36 | 93656 | |
| about islam [182 words] | alvin | Aug 26, 2007 23:12 | 93656 | ||
| It looks like you are afraid of Islam, maybe because it's the truth? [75 words] | plusaf | Jan 23, 2008 02:02 | 93656 | ||
| Afraid of Christianity and people like you ! [229 words] | zasho | Apr 24, 2010 06:19 | 93656 | ||
| You are afraid of people converting to Islam [3 words] | mm | Jul 3, 2012 11:33 | 93656 | ||
| Jelousies and poisonous by nature [155 words] | Kalam | Jun 25, 2018 06:21 | 93656 | ||
| Madrasa grown in Brooklyn [91 words] | Lorie Newcomb | May 16, 2007 13:28 | 93248 | ||
| the tolerance is the best drug [18 words] | samy | Jun 1, 2007 10:05 | 93248 | ||
| 1 | What could be more un-American than a culture-specific school? [221 words] | James A. Bridge | May 16, 2007 12:16 | 93216 | |
| Debbie seems genuine and right [224 words] | Manav | May 5, 2007 03:21 | 91690 | ||
| reply to "debbie seems genuine and right". [112 words] | romain | May 7, 2007 04:49 | 91690 | ||
| THE ISLAMIST MODEL [353 words] | Robert Thomas | May 8, 2007 11:53 | 91690 | ||
| muslims want to take over [13 words] | tabingins911 | May 13, 2007 01:13 | 91690 | ||
| Division not necessary [70 words] | Anthony Perez | May 16, 2007 09:02 | 91690 | ||
| The Truth behind Madrassas ! An eye opener for all ! [128 words] | Veer | May 4, 2007 10:38 | 91642 | ||
| NY Times suggests opening of the school will be postponed (5/4) [78 words] | R. Davidson | May 4, 2007 08:02 | 91629 | ||
| madrasa [39 words] | jon purizhansky | May 3, 2007 23:41 | 91584 | ||
| What about Christian Madrasas? [174 words] | Muhammad Jesus Moses | Apr 30, 2007 00:21 | 91087 | ||
| Apples and Oranges [22 words] | Constantine Kipnis | Apr 30, 2007 14:01 | 91087 | ||
| You are 100% wrong [155 words] | Bharat Khan | Apr 30, 2007 19:53 | 91087 | ||
 Why not? [140 words] | Rodni E. Chalet | May 1, 2007 00:40 | 91087 | ||
| 2 | boo hoo, you said it yourself [111 words] | susan | May 1, 2007 14:10 | 91087 | |
| I'm glad your curiousity was not punished. Some others aren't as lucky. [199 words] | Constantine Kipnis | May 1, 2007 17:15 | 91087 | ||
| Our dear Muhammad and his bogus Arabic [100 words] | dhimmi no more | May 2, 2007 18:24 | 91087 | ||
| Just one problem, Rodni [456 words] | Jeff | May 3, 2007 18:05 | 91087 | ||
| down with muslim madarsas [121 words] | surj | May 7, 2007 17:11 | 91087 | ||
| wake up. [63 words] | surjit | May 7, 2007 17:34 | 91087 | ||
| Madras in Brooklyn, NY [43 words] | Ed Melik, Esq. | May 14, 2007 12:10 | 91087 | ||
| My letter to Joel Klein, Chancellor of the New York Department of Education [704 words] | Constantine Kipnis | Apr 29, 2007 15:53 | 91054 | ||
| Are You Kidding? [71 words] | Marlene Barry | Apr 28, 2007 17:17 | 91028 | ||
| No break [43 words] | Terry | Apr 30, 2007 16:35 | 91028 | ||
| about madrasa [86 words] | sam | Apr 27, 2007 23:55 | 90998 | ||
| "Political Correctness" Gone Out of Control? [239 words] | Judith Carpet | Apr 27, 2007 23:05 | 90992 | ||
| A Mahadrasha Grows in Brooklyn [194 words] | Maurice | Apr 27, 2007 12:56 | 90925 | ||
| The opening of the Khalil Gibran International Academy [58 words] | Nili Biondi | Apr 27, 2007 10:13 | 90903 | ||
| A Madrasa Grows in Brooklyn Art.No. 4441 [59 words] | S.C.Panda | Apr 27, 2007 04:37 | 90870 | ||
| Are Americans naive! Is this a new Jihad training center, this time in USA! [212 words] | Egyptian Christian | Apr 26, 2007 10:56 | 90734 | ||
| Know Thine Enemy [590 words] | Abu Nuwas | Apr 26, 2007 09:53 | 90726 | ||
| dangerous [171 words] | Terry | Apr 30, 2007 16:50 | 90726 | ||
| A Madrasa Grows in Brooklyn [28 words] | David R.Groesbeck | Apr 26, 2007 04:32 | 90698 | ||
| Islam out of control [120 words] | G.Vishvas | Apr 26, 2007 01:39 | 90686 | ||
| Your vision & mission is to create friction and hate [163 words] | Ravi Jain | Apr 26, 2007 20:23 | 90686 | ||
| I agree with you 100%. [93 words] | Egyptian Christian | Apr 27, 2007 04:22 | 90686 | ||
| To Mr. "Jain" [294 words] | G.Vishvas | Apr 27, 2007 16:15 | 90686 | ||
| Venom [74 words] | Frahad Navkhoda | Apr 30, 2007 04:33 | 90686 | ||
| To Frahad Jain [215 words] | G.Vishvas | May 1, 2007 06:30 | 90686 | ||
| You are right - G. Vishvas [154 words] | Jaladhi | May 1, 2007 22:25 | 90686 | ||
| Face of an extremist is like a multi-headed God [344 words] | Frahad Navkhoda | May 2, 2007 05:29 | 90686 | ||
| Bravo Frahad [77 words] | G.Vishvas | May 3, 2007 03:47 | 90686 | ||
| 2 Farhad "Christian Fundies give headache while Islamics cut the Head" [303 words] | skmiller | May 3, 2007 10:33 | 90686 | ||
| Best commnets I ever seen! [70 words] | Judeo Chrislam | May 7, 2007 01:02 | 90686 | ||
| That's a simple one... [179 words] | Frahad Navkhoda | Jan 24, 2008 11:03 | 90686 | ||
| 1 | Scrutiny, Awareness, education and debate [2471 words] | Ibby | Sep 12, 2010 18:09 | 90686 | |
| stop the complaining [166 words] | Muslim | Apr 25, 2007 22:56 | 90679 | ||
| to muslim [22 words] | me | Apr 26, 2007 17:19 | 90679 | ||
| ...more than 1400 years. [170 words] | Muslim | Apr 26, 2007 23:15 | 90679 | ||
| to muslim (II) [158 words] | G.Vishvas | Apr 27, 2007 04:03 | 90679 | ||
| mollah [111 words] | true believer | Apr 27, 2007 12:41 | 90679 | ||
| 6 | Mr. Muslim, Aya 33.50 convinced me the truth of Islam [211 words] | New muslim | Apr 27, 2007 17:16 | 90679 | |
| to muslim [69 words] | romain | Apr 27, 2007 22:15 | 90679 | ||
| Downfall of west. [114 words] | surj | Apr 28, 2007 19:05 | 90679 | ||
| to Muslim re: Stop the complaining [355 words] | Bill | Apr 29, 2007 16:42 | 90679 | ||
| yeah, sure!! [106 words] | Jaladhi | Apr 30, 2007 09:35 | 90679 | ||
| Who was the first muslim? [215 words] | morous | May 7, 2007 12:16 | 90679 | ||
| Education [172 words] | Sam Green | Aug 18, 2007 19:57 | 90679 | ||
| Wrong [26 words] | Rita | Aug 4, 2012 13:30 | 90679 | ||
| The Land of the Free? [368 words] | Avenger | Apr 25, 2007 21:32 | 90658 | ||
| Madrasa Grows In Brooklyn [73 words] | Anthony | Apr 25, 2007 19:09 | 90644 | ||
| My letter to Klein [193 words] | dan w. taliaferro | Apr 25, 2007 19:05 | 90642 | ||
| Islamic Accademy in Brooklyn [149 words] | Carol Solfronk | Apr 25, 2007 18:29 | 90639 | ||
| Don't Muslims pay Tax too? [26 words] | Frahad Navkhoda | Apr 26, 2007 06:50 | 90639 | ||
| Reply to 3 questions by Muslim writer [232 words] | Carol Solfronk | Apr 26, 2007 20:36 | 90639 | ||
| Reply to Frahad Navkhoda's questions [149 words] | Romesh Chander | Apr 26, 2007 22:22 | 90639 | ||
| Don't Catholics pay Tax too? [29 words] | Jeff | Apr 29, 2007 10:10 | 90639 | ||
| Dear J. K. Klein of New York City schools [152 words] | Colin | Apr 25, 2007 17:54 | 90634 | ||
| western politicians are fools! [135 words] | romain | Apr 25, 2007 19:35 | 90634 | ||
| One school out of many [38 words] | Frahad Navkhoda | Apr 26, 2007 06:53 | 90634 | ||
| a constitutional issue [217 words] | ajfest | Apr 25, 2007 15:31 | 90623 | ||
| ajfest [12 words] | Carol Solfronk | Apr 25, 2007 19:49 | 90623 | ||
| "Separate" equals "Unequal" [19 words] | James A. Bridge | May 16, 2007 12:31 | 90623 | ||
| My letter to Joel Klein [325 words] | James Vesce | Apr 25, 2007 15:15 | 90620 | ||
| Madrassas in America [17 words] | Cecil Donaho | Apr 25, 2007 14:58 | 90619 | ||
| When will the USA learn appeasement doesn't work [327 words] | Cheri Hunt | Apr 25, 2007 13:22 | 90608 | ||
| totally agree [95 words] | Terry | Apr 27, 2007 15:55 | 90608 | ||
| Madrasas have long been present in Canada... [356 words] | J.S. | Apr 25, 2007 13:19 | 90607 | ||
| So Many Questions [256 words] | Pat | Apr 25, 2007 11:41 | 90602 | ||
| Why Gibran? [31 words] | Pekka Surellat | Apr 25, 2007 10:46 | 90601 | ||
| Gibran background non Musim [119 words] | Dwight Brown | Apr 25, 2007 14:56 | 90601 | ||
| Dear Mr. Klein - Incomplete deNazification [93 words] | Norman Wand | Apr 25, 2007 08:48 | 90597 | ||
| Be efficient : be primitive. [177 words] | Raymond31 | Apr 25, 2007 07:13 | 90593 | ||
| Learn the Lessons of History [68 words] | Singha | Apr 25, 2007 01:27 | 90568 | ||
| Alarm bells are ringing [38 words] | Rajunov Singh | May 10, 2007 06:30 | 90568 | ||
| US Taxpayer Supported Madrasas.... [90 words] | Domenic Pepe | Apr 25, 2007 01:06 | 90566 | ||
| An Interesting (?) Name for this School ? [37 words] | Stevan Dweck, Ph.D. | Apr 25, 2007 01:02 | 90564 | ||
| No accident... [75 words] | donvan | Apr 26, 2007 16:04 | 90564 | ||
| Amen! [66 words] | Stevan Dweck, Ph.D. | Apr 26, 2007 19:51 | 90564 | ||
| What did you expect -- call it Bin Laden Academy [71 words] | Romesh Chander | Apr 26, 2007 22:07 | 90564 | ||
| Embracing the best culture, not "multiculturalism" [321 words] | Caesar M. Arevalo | Apr 25, 2007 00:53 | 90563 | ||
| Love the title of this article... [167 words] | Richard House | Apr 25, 2007 00:42 | 90562 | ||
| Vouchers: another casualty in the war on terror [253 words] | Stuart Fagin | Apr 24, 2007 23:31 | 90559 | ||
| Who abuses madrasas? [434 words] | Bharat Khan | Apr 24, 2007 23:16 | 90558 | ||
| Turkish solution [62 words] | David W. Lincoln | Apr 24, 2007 22:58 | 90557 | ||
| and in spite of this [87 words] | susan | May 1, 2007 14:48 | 90557 | ||
| Lighting a candle [105 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 1, 2007 19:27 | 90557 | ||
| a totally different story [160 words] | susan | May 2, 2007 16:26 | 90557 | ||
| What can be redeemed? [184 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 2, 2007 19:12 | 90557 | ||
| what you greatly miss [233 words] | susan | May 3, 2007 18:12 | 90557 | ||
| Working with what is [65 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 5, 2007 12:04 | 90557 | ||
| progress and turkey should not be placed in the same sentence [197 words] | susan | May 5, 2007 18:20 | 90557 | ||
| Where we need to go to from here [237 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 6, 2007 20:15 | 90557 | ||
| not the smartest starting point [274 words] | susan | May 7, 2007 17:18 | 90557 | ||
| Once more, from the beginning [167 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 8, 2007 10:34 | 90557 | ||
| you're taking the longest path [217 words] | susan | May 9, 2007 06:06 | 90557 | ||
| Limited vision [180 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 9, 2007 19:06 | 90557 | ||
| 4 | china is a great civilization, no matter what [161 words] | susan | May 11, 2007 06:02 | 90557 | |
| Perspective [254 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 11, 2007 23:58 | 90557 | ||
| again ignorance of the basics of history [384 words] | susan | May 13, 2007 08:52 | 90557 | ||
| Touchy aren't we... [107 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 14, 2007 10:39 | 90557 | ||
| Some observations [163 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 14, 2007 12:23 | 90557 | ||
| no idea of what real politik is [127 words] | susan | May 15, 2007 15:44 | 90557 | ||
| Why do you look at the speck ... [184 words] | susan | May 15, 2007 15:50 | 90557 | ||
| Cui bono? [54 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 16, 2007 08:52 | 90557 | ||
| Papist-Caesaroism in other words? [187 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 16, 2007 09:07 | 90557 | ||
| who is doing more brigandage? [101 words] | susan | May 16, 2007 16:20 | 90557 | ||
| relativism never works [78 words] | susan | May 16, 2007 16:41 | 90557 | ||
| A different path [61 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 17, 2007 14:19 | 90557 | ||
| Combatting evil [35 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 17, 2007 14:22 | 90557 | ||
| that's an entirely different situation [123 words] | susan | May 17, 2007 17:20 | 90557 | ||
| wishful thinking [60 words] | susan | May 17, 2007 17:21 | 90557 | ||
| Stick to script [172 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 19, 2007 12:47 | 90557 | ||
| Clarification [72 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 19, 2007 12:50 | 90557 | ||
| what if? [80 words] | susan | May 21, 2007 08:15 | 90557 | ||
| not a smart comparison [55 words] | susan | May 21, 2007 08:19 | 90557 | ||
| With clarity and more words [316 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 22, 2007 10:50 | 90557 | ||
| The differences make the difference [318 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 22, 2007 11:05 | 90557 | ||
| whatever you think you have made clearer [51 words] | susan | May 24, 2007 04:42 | 90557 | ||
| Clarity and resolve [90 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 25, 2007 23:06 | 90557 | ||
| I hope there doesn't become a need for High School and Grammar School Campus Watch! [140 words] | larry | Apr 24, 2007 22:13 | 90551 | ||
| bravo for Multicultural curriculum! [28 words] | Elizabeth Ross, MD | Apr 24, 2007 21:13 | 90547 | ||
| A Madrasa in Brooklyn [114 words] | Roberto Vicencio | Apr 24, 2007 21:08 | 90546 | ||
| Muslim Schools in America [125 words] | Iftikhar Ahmad | May 16, 2007 10:49 | 90546 | ||
| Schools not for terrorist [85 words] | Kalam | Jun 25, 2018 08:49 | 90546 | ||
| Muslim Schools in America [727 words] | Iftikhar Ahmad | Jun 25, 2018 17:08 | 90546 | ||
| Questions for our dear Iftikhar Ahmad (PBUH aka صلى الله عليه وسلم) [272 words] | dhimmi no more | Jun 27, 2018 06:02 | 90546 | ||
| More questions for our dear Iftikhar Ahma صلى الله عليه وسلم and the "Muslim rapes of non Muslim girls and women" [114 words] | dhimmi no more | Jun 27, 2018 06:21 | 90546 | ||
| More questions for our dear Iftikhar Ahma صلى الله عليه وسلم and "Farting" in Islam! No I'm not joking! [122 words] | dhimmi no more | Jun 27, 2018 06:34 | 90546 | ||
| Our dear Iftikhar Ahmad صلى الله عليه وسلم why not move to Saudi Arabia? [252 words] | dhimmi no more | Jun 27, 2018 07:55 | 90546 | ||
| The victory of Arabs in America [75 words] | f.sha | Apr 24, 2007 20:29 | 90543 | ||
| Abandoning Arabic in favour of English [79 words] | R K Iyer | May 12, 2007 11:22 | 90543 | ||
| great that you have a plan but [15 words] | susan | May 14, 2007 14:55 | 90543 | ||
| Time to put cameras in classrooms. [125 words] | paratisi | Apr 24, 2007 20:23 | 90541 | ||
| Dear Mayor Bloomberg [604 words] | Irene Alter | Apr 24, 2007 19:13 | 90538 | |
| Written well [17 words] | Kat | Jun 11, 2007 09:17 | 90538 | ||
| Arabic Schools in US pose danger [82 words] | Tennisman | Apr 24, 2007 18:17 | 90534 | ||
| State Education Requirements [162 words] | Frank K. Hoover | Apr 24, 2007 17:33 | 90522 | ||
| Jihad Factory in New York!!! [172 words] | Romesh Chander | Apr 24, 2007 16:09 | 90514 | ||
| Love them "Hand Outs" [26 words] | Joe Schmoe USA | Apr 24, 2007 14:33 | 90510 | ||
| Arabic and anti-Semitism [215 words] | R K Iyer | Apr 25, 2007 02:22 | 90510 | ||
| A Jewish teacher meeting their standards [24 words] | O. Felmanova | Apr 25, 2007 11:58 | 90510 | ||
| shout from the tallest building [63 words] | syed mohammad ali | Apr 29, 2007 13:26 | 90510 | ||
| 2 | racism and communication [275 words] | moderate Muslim 1 | May 5, 2007 13:12 | 90510 | |
| some clarifications [349 words] | susan | May 5, 2007 18:33 | 90510 | ||
| Arabs and Arabic have an image problem [292 words] | Ramakrishnan | May 6, 2007 06:05 | 90510 | ||
| To Moderate muslim1: Lucky you! [971 words] | Plato | May 9, 2007 07:24 | 90510 | ||
| Too much detail [91 words] | DennisOS2 | Jul 24, 2007 22:33 | 90510 | ||
| Arabs are Semitic people too [9 words] | tuxedo | Jul 27, 2008 23:35 | 90510 | ||
| A doomed mission [62 words] | Yuval Brandstetter MD | Apr 24, 2007 12:47 | 90503 | ||
| Exactly [59 words] | Blackspeare | Apr 24, 2007 19:54 | 90503 | ||
| Brava Irene Alter. [86 words] | Maura Collins | Apr 27, 2007 20:27 | 90503 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)