| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
Only native states can win counterinsurgency
Reader comment on item: Must Counterinsurgency Wars Fail?
Submitted by Romesh Chander (United States), Sep 14, 2008 at 16:20
Outside powers like US cannot win insurgency in Iraq, Afghanistan, etc. But Iraqis can fight their own insurgents to win; and so can Afghanis fight their insurgents and win. Israel can win insurgents in its territory; and so can Sri Lanka. And so can India in Kashmir and Northeastern India.
Dislike
Submitting....
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (87) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The gap between Tribal Culture and the way that the West Thinks About Counterinsurgency [233 words] | Sam Stolzoff | May 23, 2009 15:08 | 156053 | ||
| Must counter insurgency wars fail? [44 words] | joe | Nov 7, 2008 09:03 | 142357 | ||
| British experience. [221 words] | Dixon | Oct 25, 2008 22:45 | 141009 | ||
| This is a Truth Regarding the Insurgencies [557 words] | M. Tovey | Oct 7, 2008 19:44 | 139699 | ||
 What provocation? [344 words] | Nura | Oct 11, 2008 19:42 | 139699 | ||
| Misdirected Comments Cannot Hide the Truth - the Provocation is Already There [655 words] | M. Tovey | Oct 13, 2008 19:02 | 139699 | ||
| Nura fails to present the truth [354 words] | Infidel | Oct 13, 2008 19:37 | 139699 | ||
| Re: Misdirected comments [2843 words] | Nura | Oct 16, 2008 19:00 | 139699 | ||
| The Righteous Branch - Yeshua HaMashiach [325 words] | M. Tovey | Oct 20, 2008 12:02 | 139699 | ||
| No truth!!! [180 words] | Mansoor | Oct 1, 2008 22:45 | 139447 | ||
| Ask Jesus to save you ... [37 words] | PDM | Oct 3, 2008 19:59 | 139447 | ||
| islam=submission (and that is not for me) [118 words] | j. turner | Oct 4, 2008 11:19 | 139447 | ||
| Karzai calling Mullah Omar "his Brother" [96 words] | Mark Blackman | Oct 5, 2008 00:02 | 139447 | ||
| Mansoor, the fools pond [39 words] | Infidel | Oct 5, 2008 15:08 | 139447 | ||
| Turning the table!! [117 words] | Mansoor | Oct 6, 2008 08:01 | 139447 | ||
| I am happy!! [10 words] | Mansoor | Oct 6, 2008 08:04 | 139447 | ||
| Mansoor in Pakistan [119 words] | Kafir911 | Oct 7, 2008 09:56 | 139447 | ||
| Drama unfolds!!! [230 words] | Mansoor | Oct 7, 2008 23:53 | 139447 | ||
| no comment [134 words] | real | Jan 15, 2009 16:39 | 139447 | ||
| legitimacy wins such a war [211 words] | the libertine | Oct 1, 2008 17:48 | 139430 | ||
| Insurgencies are the Precursors - It Takes World Power to Dominate the World [665 words] | M. Tovey | Sep 23, 2008 16:48 | 139070 | ||
| Re Must counterinsurgencies wars fail [124 words] | Gabby (from Australia) | Sep 23, 2008 00:48 | 139046 | ||
| Make 'em stand up [72 words] | Joe Six-Pack | Sep 19, 2008 12:28 | 138856 | ||
| Joe 36-Pack [52 words] | adnan khan | Oct 5, 2008 00:08 | 138856 | ||
| adnan khan [73 words] | btilly | Oct 6, 2008 14:51 | 138856 | ||
| Its very hard to compare different insurgencies... [194 words] | Cadwallon | Sep 18, 2008 20:23 | 138834 | ||
| Two can play at that game. [16 words] | Monty | Sep 18, 2008 18:11 | 138828 | ||
| Peace or Rebellion - Rule of Law or Anarchy - Which is Necessary for Survival of Societies [619 words] | M. Tovey | Sep 18, 2008 13:28 | 138815 | ||
| NO CLEAR VICTORY BUT MORE DEFEAT WITH WRONG STRATEGIES ! [965 words] | TTS | Sep 17, 2008 21:54 | 138776 | ||
| TTS [14 words] | Infidel | Sep 25, 2008 15:22 | 138776 | ||
| In order to defeat any enemy, we have to understand its ideology [694 words] | Howard | Sep 17, 2008 18:40 | 138761 | ||
| Islam [134 words] | Kunda | Dec 9, 2009 17:38 | 138761 | ||
| Extremism in the Cause of Liberty is No Vice [54 words] | Pennsy Dutch | Jun 5, 2010 15:04 | 138761 | ||
| winning against islamic terrorists. [29 words] | hari | Sep 17, 2008 02:22 | 138711 | ||
| The main war is not militarily [190 words] | Shial Inquilab | Sep 16, 2008 16:22 | 138682 | ||
| O.K., NOW I'M MAD [123 words] | jennifer solis | Sep 17, 2008 23:29 | 138682 | ||
| Take Knowledge in the Truth of Why People Hate the United States - [574 words] | M. Tovey | Sep 29, 2008 13:36 | 138682 | ||
| Jenn- Talibans are winning? What in the h--- [747 words] | ah ha | Oct 6, 2008 00:11 | 138682 | ||
| God gives time but never neglects [95 words] | sTs | Oct 17, 2008 16:30 | 138682 | ||
| Samer is back: and Allah created the mountains as a protection against earth quakes! really? [177 words] | dhimmi no more | Oct 18, 2008 08:51 | 138682 | ||
| Faith in Yeshua HaMashiach Prepares the Believer for Eternity, and All the Time One Wants with His Savior [89 words] | M. Tovey | Oct 20, 2008 12:31 | 138682 | ||
| We believe in the unseen [174 words] | sTs | Oct 21, 2008 06:22 | 138682 | ||
| Worship Of Almighty God is Worshipped in Spirit and in Truth - Holy Bible is Written Evidence of the Truth in Yeshua HaMashiach [645 words] | M. Tovey | Oct 22, 2008 14:19 | 138682 | ||
| rituals of Hajj [1116 words] | sTs | Oct 28, 2008 02:52 | 138682 | ||
| 1 | Understanding the Holy Bible is an Act of Faith Necessary to Understand its Truths [1192 words] | M. Tovey | Oct 29, 2008 18:27 | 138682 | |
| Great resource for passages [13 words] | BRandy F. Brooks | Mar 20, 2010 01:11 | 138682 | ||
| The Hebrew Holy Bible is the ONLY Resource for These Difficult Times. [108 words] | M. Tovey | Mar 22, 2010 11:15 | 138682 | ||
| "Holding our postion" never wins wars - against state, as well as non-state enemies [109 words] | jennifer solis | Sep 16, 2008 15:16 | 138678 | ||
| What type of war we should win?! [274 words] | Khaled Aly | Sep 16, 2008 11:33 | 138673 | ||
| Managing between winning and losing [106 words] | Jay | Sep 16, 2008 05:27 | 138660 | ||
| PC rears its ugly head again [207 words] | Y Brandstetter MD | Sep 16, 2008 04:07 | 138658 | ||
| Must counterinsurgency wars fail [185 words] | kim segar | Sep 15, 2008 13:29 | 138633 | ||
| counter insurgency? [152 words] | trans-parere | Sep 15, 2008 11:06 | 138620 | ||
| Not with a sword [163 words] | michael | Sep 15, 2008 09:31 | 138617 | ||
| To win or to loose, a question of objectives. [177 words] | Jon, a Brit in Euroland | Sep 15, 2008 08:42 | 138615 | ||
| Victory against insurgents [116 words] | Rafi | Sep 15, 2008 06:25 | 138608 | ||
| Economical way to beat terror. [119 words] | Radovan | Sep 14, 2008 23:32 | 138588 | ||
| different and clever ways to beat Terror [174 words] | Radovan | Sep 14, 2008 23:13 | 138584 | ||
| Pakistan backed Insurgency was defeated Indian Punjab [155 words] | Singha | Sep 14, 2008 22:51 | 138581 | ||
| Very Interesting Question for Dr. Pipes [195 words] | Alex | Sep 14, 2008 22:16 | 138577 | ||
| Must counter.wars fail? [220 words] | Miani, Elie | Sep 14, 2008 17:45 | 138564 | ||
| Sleuths, Poets, Boots and Persistence [596 words] | J. S. Oppenheim | Sep 15, 2008 09:47 | 138564 | ||
| Much simpler [155 words] | Stuart Teich | Sep 14, 2008 17:08 | 138562 | ||
| Counterinsurgency wars are winnable, provided... [49 words] | M.D'Souza | Sep 14, 2008 17:01 | 138561 | ||
| I have a news for Hindus and Jews [92 words] | Aseel Abdul | Oct 5, 2008 00:17 | 138561 | ||
| No amount of olive branches waved at Islamists will pacify them! [30 words] | M.D'Souza | Dec 2, 2008 17:12 | 138561 | ||
| "fighting terrorism" [99 words] | Ben Z | Sep 14, 2008 16:55 | 138560 | ||
 Only native states can win counterinsurgency [50 words] | Romesh Chander | Sep 14, 2008 16:20 | 138556 | ||
| counterinsurgency [199 words] | stafford | Sep 14, 2008 16:12 | 138555 | ||
| Wrong examples [449 words] | Ianus | Sep 14, 2008 14:55 | 138549 | ||
| Leadership winning over FARC insurgency [171 words] | Dan Schwartz | Sep 14, 2008 14:20 | 138547 | ||
| Winning the war against Islamic extremists [119 words] | Ahmad | Sep 14, 2008 14:03 | 138546 | ||
| Act like Putin did in Chechnya [273 words] | Romesh Chander | Sep 14, 2008 21:59 | 138546 | ||
| Ahmad [16 words] | Terrorists | Sep 15, 2008 07:38 | 138546 | ||
| Ahmed: Thanks but NO thanks [13 words] | Khan Bulzar | Sep 21, 2008 17:39 | 138546 | ||
| yes, that's the way to win [27 words] | Tulio | Sep 14, 2008 13:10 | 138543 | ||
| Counterinsurgency wars are winnable, but require a paradigm shift in the population [326 words] | Dr-RJP | Sep 14, 2008 13:08 | 138542 | ||
| Reply to Dr-RJP [88 words] | jennifer solis | Sep 16, 2008 15:37 | 138542 | ||
| All wars are one (sic) [51 words] | DrRJP | Sep 18, 2008 13:37 | 138542 | ||
| Hammer and nails [234 words] | Ghulam Muhammed, Mumbai | Sep 14, 2008 12:31 | 138538 | ||
| Winnable or accepting the inevitable? [246 words] | Rebecca Moulds | Sep 14, 2008 12:05 | 138535 | ||
| Justice/Mercy is the answer: suicide/murder are false gods [98 words] | Moshebaer ben Yoseflevi | Sep 14, 2008 11:51 | 138534 | ||
| Winning hearts and minds [78 words] | hyman peskin | Sep 14, 2008 11:08 | 138532 | ||
| War: Its nature cause and end. [242 words] | Ralph C Whaley MD | Sep 14, 2008 10:15 | 138528 | ||
| A realistic answer. [95 words] | Anne-Marie Delcambre | Sep 14, 2008 07:26 | 138515 | ||
| THE FINANCING OF TERROR [763 words] | TIRDAD GHARIB | Sep 14, 2008 07:02 | 138512 | ||
| Win or not win [46 words] | Francesco Mangascià | Sep 14, 2008 06:14 | 138510 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)