Different situation

Submitted by Lady (Indonesia), Jan 18, 2010 at 23:56

Eventhough I do not know much about history, but I admire historians and their findings. Historians are like a modern fortune teller, who can predict the future base on the events'd data in the past.

I guess Laurence story in the movie was a hearthrobing blue eyed British's soldier in WW1, which happened in real in 19th century, then changed in 21 century to be a fiction story of 007 James bond story.

I guess Laurent, on behalf of British's vested interest, he tried to build up Arab's tribes into a union force of Arab nationalist, against their Turkish master (Ottoman empire). He used his individual personality to win the heart of Arab tribe's leaders and gained trust. So arab leaders followed his advises then decided to revolt againt the Ottoman empire.

I only can guess, probably during that time historians saw the future, that Ottoman empire, the biggest islamic chaliphate emperium, the master of all muslims in the world (in the past including Aceh muslims in Indonesia), with their islamic way of life, soon or after, might oneday invaded or influented Europe. Then probably British historians advised the British generals, to ask someone (Laurent) to do his assignment, to influence and encuraged the Arab tribes leaders, to feel their nationalist pride of Arabia. Probably, before Laurent, those Arabs still thinking that Ottoman chaliphate was their frontier to defend or to spread islam. I do not know, I am so sorry if this is only my own imagination which may wrong. Turkish are not Arab, so Laurent in the end succeded to create Arab nationalist force againts the master of muslims (Ottoman emperium). Arabs tribes splitted the religion of islam as their boundage to Ottoman. So it was much easier for Laurent to influence The Arab tribes.

Now, US Army under Petreus is in a war in the land of Arabia, where Arabs against Arabs against kurd against persian. Sunni agains shie against wahabi (Al-Qaeda), against seculerism, against the west!!! There is no nationalist anymore, because the sect of islam is not devided base on nationalist anymore but by religion sect or tribes doctrines. I guess that is the differences between the Laurent strategy in the past and current Patreus strategy. So, Patreus probably will not be able to win all Arab tribes leader heart and trust as what Laurent got in the past.

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".