| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
Location, Location, Location
Reader comment on item: Immanuel Kant vs. Israel
Submitted by Caleb (United States), Aug 25, 2010 at 14:06
Even some Americans who favor the Zionist ideal of a homeland for the Jews have questioned the wisdom of establishing it in the middle of the Arab world. [Let's leave God and Old Testament out of it. Israel is a secular state, at least for now.] I believe Uganda was on offer.
Dislike
Submitting....
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
Daniel Pipes replies:
Surely you jest. Why not Birobijan?
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (113) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe" (OSCE) 57 countries) [386 words] | Robert | Sep 30, 2022 11:32 | 286982 | |
| 1 |  Cooperation by Coercion - Following When True Leadership is Usurped for Reasons of Ambitions of Empire [84 words] | M Tovey | Oct 1, 2022 16:31 | 286982 | |
| 1 | New World Order and the United Nations. [382 words] | Robert | Sep 30, 2022 07:45 | 286975 | |
| Current American Dollar Currency Demonstrates Changes in American Governance from Constitutionalist to Bureaucratic Authoritarian [321 words] | M Tovey | Sep 30, 2022 15:53 | 286975 | ||
| 1 | Let Muslims disambiguate among their subdivisions [169 words] | Prashant | Apr 2, 2021 14:32 | 265259 | |
| 2 | Prashant! What is Judaism and Christianity? [87 words] | Robert | Sep 29, 2022 15:09 | 265259 | |
| Judeo-Christianity in A More Basic Covenant Testament [210 words] | M Tovey | Sep 29, 2022 21:36 | 265259 | ||
| 1 | My view of Judaism and Christianity (and Islam) [199 words] | Prashant | Sep 30, 2022 13:48 | 265259 | |
| 5 | It's simple: Israel used to be the land of kibbutzes and socialism [43 words] | Base Maven | Sep 26, 2010 04:16 | 178702 | |
| 1 | religión e historia [242 words] | luciano tanto | Sep 13, 2010 10:11 | 178196 | |
| 1 | Reminds me of this quote, from Solzhenitsyn... [225 words] | The Sanity Inspector | Sep 10, 2010 12:16 | 178002 | |
| 1 | Kant...Shmant! [274 words] | Roque | Sep 2, 2010 00:29 | 177577 | |
| Paradigm Shifts [178 words] | Robert | Aug 31, 2010 19:00 | 177514 | ||
| Wrong [11 words] | Abu Nudnik | Oct 5, 2010 14:03 | 177514 | ||
| 1 | Re: Paradigm shift [82 words] | Robert Villegas | Oct 5, 2010 19:04 | 177514 | |
| 3 | Kant? A puppet of the Jesuit Order [2141 words] | alessandro albore | Aug 31, 2010 15:06 | 177508 | |
| coo-coo, coo-coo, coo-coo, coo-coo [8 words] | Abu Nudnik | Oct 5, 2010 13:58 | 177508 | ||
| Aged 55, Count Wladimir Ledochowski? [15 words] | D | Dec 24, 2021 13:39 | 177508 | ||
| 2 | The Left, David, and Goliath. [189 words] | Lynn | Aug 30, 2010 09:49 | 177456 | |
| IV Reich is behind us, TRUE Jews, true gentiles [251 words] | alessandro albore | Aug 29, 2010 19:01 | 177434 | ||
| the GOST Nation [2006 words] | alessandro albore | Aug 29, 2010 07:36 | 177417 | ||
| Open your eyes, everybody [908 words] | alessandro albore | Aug 29, 2010 07:06 | 177415 | ||
| Here is a similar assessment. [23 words] | ITZIG | Aug 29, 2010 04:15 | 177414 | ||
| Kant vs Israel [97 words] | Amo Fuchs | Aug 27, 2010 04:32 | 177347 | ||
 Location, Location, Location [52 words]w/response from Daniel Pipes | Caleb | Aug 25, 2010 14:06 | 177268 | ||
| Utopia is nowhere! On Mr. Pipes´ addendum dated August 17 concerning the Left. [213 words] | Isaac Haskiya | Aug 25, 2010 12:06 | 177265 | ||
| 1 | I do agree [54 words] | Vladimir | Aug 25, 2010 10:12 | 177262 | |
| 5 | Anti-Israel polemics are rooting for the UN as the new emerging power structure as opposed to nation states. [428 words] | Tarnow | Aug 24, 2010 09:44 | 177197 | |
| I dissent from Hazony's view [102 words] | Peter Herz | Aug 23, 2010 22:01 | 177173 | ||
| over-sophistication [119 words] | yuval Brandstetter MD | Aug 23, 2010 10:46 | 177143 | ||
| American means freedom from or for Religion [41 words] | RON | Aug 24, 2010 00:23 | 177143 | ||
| 1 | This analysis is true in the case of left thinkers and intellectuals [42 words] | Yael F. | Aug 22, 2010 06:52 | 177085 | |
| 3 | Oversophistication. [60 words] | Menchem Chazan | Aug 21, 2010 15:03 | 177049 | |
| Oversimplification [4 words] | Penstarrs | Aug 26, 2010 21:19 | 177049 | ||
| 8 | The flaw in Hazony's thesis [400 words] | Alex Safian | Aug 21, 2010 12:15 | 177045 | |
| 1 | "Immanuel Kant vs. Israel" [203 words] | norine krasnogor | Aug 20, 2010 22:47 | 177034 | |
| 2 | KANT VS. ISRAEL [281 words] | Rafi | Aug 20, 2010 16:54 | 177024 | |
| Paradigm shift not worth a dime [137 words] | Bernie | Aug 19, 2010 17:05 | 176987 | ||
| Cosmopolis by Stephen Toulmin [19 words] | Hillel S. | Aug 19, 2010 16:41 | 176986 | ||
| 1 | putting Kuhn and Kant in some context [374 words] | myth | Aug 19, 2010 09:54 | 176971 | |
| 6 | Immanuel Kant vs. Israel [1785 words] | Morry Markovitz | Aug 19, 2010 01:49 | 176950 |
| Immanuel Kant vs. Israel [40 words] | Morry Markovitz | Aug 22, 2010 03:40 | 176950 | ||
| 1 | some recent facts about the national idea [189 words] | myth | Aug 22, 2010 06:28 | 176950 | |
| Kant vs Israel [142 words] | Morry Markovitz | Aug 22, 2010 23:05 | 176950 | ||
| Kant vs Israel [489 words] | Morry Markovitz | Aug 22, 2010 23:33 | 176950 | ||
| my response to "some recent facts about the national idea" [183 words] | Morry Markovitz | Aug 24, 2010 00:17 | 176950 | ||
| almost contentless [90 words] | myth | Aug 24, 2010 12:29 | 176950 | ||
| 4 | Science, facts, truth [391 words] | Morry | Aug 26, 2010 19:19 | 176950 | |
| 4 | Science, facts, truth #2 [1866 words] | Morry | Aug 26, 2010 19:24 | 176950 | |
| "myth" is right: fact and truth are not the same [79 words] | Abu Nudnik | Oct 5, 2010 14:23 | 176950 | ||
| Don't be too hard on Kant [276 words] | Peter Herz | Dec 18, 2010 22:02 | 176950 | ||
| Immanuel Kant vs. Israel , reply to Peter Herz's reply [2267 words] | Morry Markovitz | Dec 20, 2010 02:21 | 176950 | ||
| Rejoinder to a pecksniffian [133 words] | Honoring Teachers | Jun 7, 2011 02:41 | 176950 | ||
| Hatred of Israel [228 words] | Ilbert Phillips | Aug 19, 2010 00:43 | 176947 | ||
| don't accept the hazony thesis [67 words] | paul | Aug 18, 2010 15:44 | 176910 | ||
| 1 | Paradigm here, paradigm there, paradigm everywhere. [235 words] | Isaac Haskiya | Aug 18, 2010 14:03 | 176901 | |
| 4 | Fort Apache, The Middle East. [472 words] | Cherif El-Ayouty | Aug 18, 2010 05:27 | 176884 | |
| 8 | Fort Europe [211 words] | Bert Tate | Aug 21, 2010 05:04 | 176884 | |
| It´s not shifting deelings towards the national state, but new realities [152 words] | Lars Nielsen | Aug 18, 2010 05:10 | 176882 | ||
| 3 | Israel a victim of the paradigm shift dieses [150 words] | Prakash Khatiwala | Aug 18, 2010 01:31 | 176878 | |
| 12 | Yoram Hazony's thesis is probably not correct [333 words] | Rajeev | Aug 17, 2010 23:55 | 176877 | |
| Great Minds Think Alike [103 words] | Stuart Fagin | Aug 17, 2010 23:53 | 176876 | ||
| Jew hatred to be precise [78 words] | Anne Julienne | Aug 18, 2010 16:55 | 176876 | ||
| Now I understand [38 words] | John W. McGinley | Aug 17, 2010 22:33 | 176873 | ||
| A victim of our own success [98 words] | Shepard Barbash | Aug 17, 2010 22:08 | 176870 | ||
| What's the difference? [170 words] | Yoel Lerner | Aug 17, 2010 21:39 | 176868 | ||
| 2 | Kant's Revolution [285 words] | J Kourlas | Aug 17, 2010 21:28 | 176867 |
| Revolution under Kant and under Islam [229 words] | Anne Julienne | Aug 18, 2010 17:42 | 176867 | ||
| 3 | Kant as "the founder of the counter-Enlightenment" in the light of his essay "What is Enlightement" [444 words] | Ianus | Aug 19, 2010 16:16 | 176867 | |
| Kant's not so universal universalism [348 words] | Elliott A Green | Aug 20, 2010 09:03 | 176867 | ||
| Comment on Green's Critique of Kant [167 words] | J Kourlas | Aug 21, 2010 21:23 | 176867 | ||
| Read the book [41 words] | J Kourlas | Aug 21, 2010 22:02 | 176867 | ||
| 3 | Reading Kant's Perpetual Peace [418 words] | J Kourlas | Aug 22, 2010 09:18 | 176867 | |
| response about Kant's Judeophobia [65 words] | Elliott A Green | Aug 22, 2010 17:48 | 176867 | ||
| 1 | Doubts as "dogmatic slumber" [123 words] | Ianus | Aug 22, 2010 18:05 | 176867 | |
| 1 | Kant's "single ruler" paradigm [336 words] | Anne Julienne | Aug 22, 2010 21:45 | 176867 | |
| 4 | Death to Israel Isn't a Theory [316 words] | Historyscoper | Aug 17, 2010 21:22 | 176866 | |
| 3 | Mohammed vs. Israel , not Kant ! [121 words] | Ianus | Aug 18, 2010 18:38 | 176866 | |
| 3 | Yoram Hazony is not so smart [233 words] | yonatan silverman | Aug 17, 2010 21:21 | 176865 | |
| Yonatan silverman on Yoram Hazony [69 words] | efraim Carlsen | Mar 4, 2013 15:12 | 176865 | ||
| Myopic Paradigm [140 words] | Marilyn Abramovitz | Aug 17, 2010 20:30 | 176861 | ||
| Explanation [14 words] | DennisWojciak | Aug 17, 2010 19:57 | 176857 | ||
| 3 | Israel vs. Kant - Following the True Paradigm - Israel is Not Immune - But Will Recover [816 words] | M. Tovey | Aug 17, 2010 19:33 | 176854 | |
| If the truth be known ... [25 words] | Anne Julienne | Aug 17, 2010 20:17 | 176854 | ||
| one thing always seems left out [78 words] | Nora | Aug 18, 2010 04:49 | 176854 | ||
| 3 | One thing is sure [201 words] | Solomon Taragano | Aug 18, 2010 11:33 | 176854 | |
| Shape Shifting Paradigms Always Leave Out One Thing - Truth [409 words] | M. Tovey | Aug 18, 2010 17:36 | 176854 | ||
| Perpetual Peace in Human Terms Cannot Compare to the Peace That Passes All 'Human' Understanding. [27 words] | M. Tovey | Aug 18, 2010 18:09 | 176854 | ||
| 1 | One Thing Even More Sure [867 words] | M. Tovey | Aug 23, 2010 12:29 | 176854 | |
| Irony - The More Things Seem to Change- the More They Seem the Same [168 words] | M Tovey | Mar 31, 2021 20:01 | 176854 | ||
| Let us double check Biden's executive orders. [55 words] | Prashant | Apr 1, 2021 19:15 | 176854 | ||
| Exectuve Decisions - Whose Orders Should Be Observed - The Holy or Unholy [225 words] | M Tovey | Apr 4, 2021 15:49 | 176854 | ||
| New 'Paradigm': You've Got to Be Kidding! [448 words] | Joe | Aug 17, 2010 18:57 | 176851 | ||
| Ironic [78 words] | Abu Nudnik | Aug 17, 2010 18:38 | 176850 | ||
| 4 | But something central is Overlooked [687 words] | Ron Thompson | Aug 17, 2010 18:27 | 176849 | |
| 1 | the new pardigm [469 words] | gingersnap | Aug 17, 2010 20:34 | 176849 | |
| 1 | The new paradigm doesn't explain enough [221 words] | Erich Wieger | Aug 17, 2010 18:12 | 176847 | |
| 1 | Why the anti-Israel hostility? [90 words] | Tarnow | Aug 17, 2010 17:29 | 176845 | |
| 1 | Kant and Kuhn misunderstood [145 words] | Anne Julienne | Aug 17, 2010 17:26 | 176844 | |
| Can't Use Kant to Describe Israel's Dilemma with the World Governments [388 words] | M. Tovey | Aug 19, 2010 18:56 | 176844 | ||
| Nation states don't need supra-national entities to control themselves [44 words] | Abu Nudnik | Oct 5, 2010 14:15 | 176844 | ||
| What's Holding Us Back? [119 words] | Kim Bruce | Aug 17, 2010 17:20 | 176843 | ||
| Kant's antisemitism [75 words] | Paul Lawrence Rose | Aug 17, 2010 17:06 | 176842 | ||
| 2 | Kant's antisemitism ? [192 words] | Ianus | Aug 18, 2010 15:41 | 176842 | |
| Kant and German Antisemitism [144 words] | PLRose | Aug 27, 2010 21:04 | 176842 | ||
| 3 | Is criticizing Judaism or Jews ipso facto anti-Semitism ? [429 words] | Ianus | Aug 30, 2010 10:31 | 176842 | |
| 1 | DEJA VU in 2010.... how frightening [178 words] | sara | Aug 30, 2010 17:15 | 176842 | |
| Interesting point of view [71 words] | Mike Shapiro | Aug 17, 2010 17:06 | 176841 | ||
| 2 | Kant and Islam [105 words] | Anne Julienne | Aug 17, 2010 19:46 | 176841 | |
| 4 | Avraham Burg - don't waste your proverbial ink on him. [198 words] | Yehuda, Ottawa, Canada | Aug 17, 2010 17:00 | 176840 | |
| 1 | burg [60 words] | solemnman | Aug 18, 2010 05:15 | 176840 | |
| 1 | Burg - utter scum [86 words] | Eliyahu | Aug 23, 2010 04:57 | 176840 | |
| burg has no principles [63 words] | Eliyahu | Aug 23, 2010 05:01 | 176840 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)