| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
When did "Palestine" exist?
Reader comment on item: Not Stealing Palestine but Purchasing Israel
Submitted by adeline (United States), Jun 21, 2011 at 12:51
My history of the Middle East is lax, since I don't really care, but I would argue the point that the British gave up on "Palestine" in 1948. According to my admittedly limited information (which I'm obviously not researching), there never was a Palestine. There were English colonies, French colonies, German colonies, Portuguese colonies across after. But where and when was there a "Palestine?"
Dislike
Submitting....
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
Daniel Pipes replies:
"Palestine" existed under the British mandate, 1923-48,
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (141) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Palestinian Authority's linked "Colonization & Wall Resistance Commission" made up of released terrorists [906 words] | Miri | Sep 22, 2022 04:46 | 286741 | ||
| 1 | A winner in a war does not give his land to a shattered enemy [154 words] | Mark Shor | Aug 4, 2020 08:24 | 259825 | |
| Modern Greeks and Ancient Greeks. [121 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Reynald de Chatillon | Aug 7, 2018 02:04 | 244123 | ||
| 2 |  The religious and linguistic landscape at the time of the Arab invasion [400 words] | dhimmi no more | Aug 7, 2018 15:03 | 244123 | |
| 3 | Palestine aka Greater Israel is Jewish territory according to International law and treaties, additionally incorporating the January 3, 1919 Faisal Weizmann agreement [507 words] | YJ Draiman | Aug 31, 2015 02:10 | 224875 | |
| Property Laws INVENTION making spoliation legal [102 words] | Blues Driver | Feb 7, 2014 20:50 | 213055 | ||
| On the contrary... [20 words] | Gary Katz | Nov 4, 2015 14:27 | 213055 | ||
| 1 | Missing Palestine percentages [58 words] | Keith | Aug 22, 2011 22:47 | 188664 | |
| correction no-Aryan invasion [87 words] | venu | Jul 24, 2011 15:10 | 187664 | ||
| 2 | God Almighty Gave Israel to the Hebrew Children! [173 words] | Marjie | Jul 19, 2011 17:38 | 187565 | |
| 6 | How Israel was really founded [141 words] | P. Schwartz | Jul 12, 2011 00:57 | 187192 | |
| 1 | stolen land [69 words] | realist | Jul 14, 2011 16:18 | 187192 | |
| 2 | This missed the facts that land purchases predate JNF [66 words] | Eric | Jul 25, 2011 02:04 | 187192 | |
| 2 | well written piece... [130 words] | Evan Mark | Jul 3, 2011 12:57 | 186995 | |
| 4 | In Need of Education... [355 words] | Sarah | Jul 6, 2011 08:46 | 186995 | |
| 6 | In Bad Need Indeed! [384 words] | Moshe | Jul 9, 2011 15:58 | 186995 | |
| You... [19 words] | Evan Mark | Jul 12, 2011 01:27 | 186995 | ||
| 2 | WHAT? [223 words] | Peter Hall | Aug 4, 2011 11:32 | 186995 | |
| 1 | You're wrong [42 words] | Bobmark | Jan 4, 2012 14:20 | 186995 | |
| If you read the 1917 Balfour Declaration (Which emulated Napoleons 1799 letter to the Jewish community in Palestine [234 words] | YJ Draiman | Sep 3, 2017 15:24 | 186995 | ||
| 2 | The promised land of the Semites [245 words] | Herman1943 | Jul 3, 2011 06:25 | 186990 | |
| 1 | Wrong Herman [79 words] | Moshe | Jul 5, 2011 03:59 | 186990 | |
| Palestines, Philistines and Sea People [53 words] | Albert | Jul 19, 2011 01:03 | 186990 | ||
| who says the Palestinians are descended from anyone? [127 words] | sara | Jul 19, 2011 17:32 | 186990 | ||
| The true story of the "Palestinian People" [249 words] | Moshe | Jul 20, 2011 10:05 | 186990 | ||
| 2 | Give the Jews back everything then! [82 words] | sarai | Jul 1, 2011 17:26 | 186952 | |
| 3 | Sarai, how generous you are! [260 words] | Moshe | Jul 2, 2011 16:40 | 186952 | |
| 1 | You read too much in to it, Moshe [95 words] | sarai | Jul 2, 2011 18:16 | 186952 | |
| 1 | purchasing by 'merchants' [58 words] | sara | Jul 1, 2011 16:54 | 186948 | |
| No one is better ! [31 words] | Anne-Marie Delcambre | Jun 29, 2011 10:10 | 186897 | ||
| they purchased ALL the land?? [143 words] | mike | Jun 27, 2011 14:57 | 186843 | ||
| 1 | Not stealing Palestine but purchasing Israel [271 words] | Judith Davies | Jun 28, 2011 13:19 | 186843 | |
| 4 | Mike, you can't be serious! [175 words] | Moshe | Jun 29, 2011 08:49 | 186843 | |
| 4 | Not supported by history [108 words] | Brian | Jul 3, 2011 04:45 | 186843 | |
| 1 | Thank you, Daniel Pipes [52 words] | Donna Paschal | Jun 26, 2011 19:38 | 186817 | |
| Pray for Israel [60 words] | roy in calgary | Jun 26, 2011 12:14 | 186807 | ||
| 3 | Not stealing Palestine but purchasing Israel [251 words] | Judith Davies | Jun 26, 2011 11:55 | 186804 | |
| 2 | Dr Pipes, your article is priceless [129 words] | Anne-Marie Delcambre | Jun 26, 2011 05:47 | 186795 | |
| 14 | 'occupation' of Muslim land [58 words] | Joe Six-Pack | Jun 25, 2011 08:25 | 186775 | |
| 1 | Judge Islam using neutral secular ethics [58 words] | Prashant | Jun 26, 2011 12:47 | 186775 | |
| 1 | Joe Six-Pack [41 words] | Jaime | Jul 17, 2011 16:20 | 186775 | |
| 1 | Israel is much more than a jewish possession [73 words] | Anne-Marie Delcambre | Jun 25, 2011 05:11 | 186769 | |
| 2 | Arabs hanged for selling land to Jews [78 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Ianus | Jun 24, 2011 17:01 | 186751 | |
| The Arab countries expelled over a million Jewish families and confiscated all their assets [218 words] | YJ Draiman | Jul 13, 2015 16:02 | 186751 | ||
| 1 | Sri. Rajiv Malhotra's article on Huffington Post [132 words] | K P Ganesh | Jun 24, 2011 11:20 | 186742 | |
| Thank you for this article [30 words] | Anne-Marie Delcambre | Jun 24, 2011 09:56 | 186740 | ||
| 1 | Thank You, Prof. Pipes [38 words] | Jon Jones | Jun 23, 2011 22:41 | 186718 | |
| 1 | Thank you. [163 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Sara Frooman | Jun 23, 2011 22:33 | 186717 | |
| The Arab Countries expelled over a million Jewish families to date - The Arab refugees amounted to half that number [270 words] | YJ Draiman | Sep 3, 2017 15:35 | 186717 | ||
| There is enough land for every nation [99 words] | stephen | Jun 23, 2011 17:57 | 186701 | ||
| 2 | in support of aryan invasion theory [144 words] | fighterclass | Jun 23, 2011 17:19 | 186699 | |
| Did Aryans invade India? [73 words] | Sagar | Jun 24, 2011 00:34 | 186699 | ||
| Reaction to "Not Stealing Palestine but Purchasing Israel" [267 words] | Prashant | Jun 23, 2011 12:28 | 186681 | ||
| Thank you Daniel Pipes, so true and so real that people have forgotten who this country. [89 words] | beautyful israel | Jun 23, 2011 11:50 | 186679 | ||
| 9 | Aryan myth-- politics, not science [137 words] | N.S. Rajaram | Jun 23, 2011 10:34 | 186673 | |
| Aryan Invasion Theory or its opposition is not the main topic of this forum [129 words] | Prashant | Jun 25, 2011 03:23 | 186673 | ||
| 1 | Prashant on the Aryan myth [105 words] | N.S. Rajaram | Jun 26, 2011 20:27 | 186673 | |
| 1 | Debunking Aryan Invasion Theory [21 words] | K P Ganesh | Jun 23, 2011 09:58 | 186672 | |
| Purchasing not once but multiple times [137 words] | yuval Brandstetter MD | Jun 23, 2011 08:34 | 186664 | ||
| True name of the so called Palestinians [69 words] | Watts L.W. ( Mr ) | Jun 23, 2011 04:42 | 186649 | ||
| 1 | Then where did the refugees come from? [48 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Happyirish | Jun 23, 2011 04:14 | 186648 | |
| 2 | Timeline [110 words] | Lila | Jun 28, 2011 03:49 | 186648 | |
| Leave Israel out of this story. [155 words] | batya dagan | Jun 22, 2011 22:49 | 186639 | ||
| Thank you! [73 words] | Phyllis Robinson | Jun 22, 2011 13:19 | 186601 | ||
| 2 | the antisemitic appeal of purchasing and my argument [223 words] | myth | Jun 22, 2011 11:47 | 186597 | |
| 2 | More than a "mercantile" project, Israel was reconstituted by "right" under internationational law [306 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Salomon Benzimra | Jun 21, 2011 19:07 | 186566 | |
| 4 | Stealing Palestian [47 words] | steven L | Jun 21, 2011 18:24 | 186564 | |
| 1 | Purchasing Israel [150 words] | Nelson D'Silva | Jun 21, 2011 17:17 | 186562 | |
| 6% constitutes buying the land of Israel? [133 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Ivan Pope | Jul 25, 2011 06:49 | 186562 | ||
| 2 | Much more than "only a tenuous connection" [403 words] | Ianus | Jun 21, 2011 17:11 | 186561 | |
| In fact, Land of Israel remained a Jewish possession during the last 2000 years [116 words] | Larry Feldman | Jun 21, 2011 16:47 | 186559 | ||
| 4 | HOW DID THE ISLAMIC ARABS GET THEIR VERY LARGE EXPANSE OF LAND? [529 words] | Nur el Masih Ben Haq | Jun 21, 2011 16:23 | 186557 | |
| Islam [56 words] | Moshe | Jun 22, 2011 10:23 | 186557 | ||
| Moshe, I HAVE PROVED VARIOUSLY THAT EVEN ACCORDING TO ISLAMIC SCRIPTURES, PALESTINE BELONGS TO JEWS [75 words] | Nur el Masih Ben Haq | Jun 22, 2011 21:49 | 186557 | ||
| 2 | The Unholy Land - ancient and modern [209 words] | Ianus | Jun 21, 2011 16:06 | 186555 | |
| Unholy people and the Holy Land [32 words] | Moshe | Jun 23, 2011 05:06 | 186555 | ||
| Israel - ancient and modern [246 words] | Ianus | Jun 24, 2011 07:06 | 186555 | ||
| Ancient Israel [126 words] | Moshe | Jun 26, 2011 08:14 | 186555 | ||
| 1 | Ancient Israel - "the kingdom of priests" [1294 words] | Ianus | Jun 28, 2011 17:03 | 186555 | |
| "Wars against Reality?" [120 words] | Moshe | Jun 29, 2011 09:26 | 186555 | ||
| 1 | All wars waged against reality are lost wars [1141 words] | Ianus | Jun 30, 2011 10:30 | 186555 | |
| Ancient or Modern - Israel's Almighty Eternal Sovereign Reigns and His WORD Rules [933 words] | M. Tovey | Jun 30, 2011 19:31 | 186555 | ||
| No, not all of them! [108 words] | Moshe | Jul 1, 2011 10:27 | 186555 | ||
| 1 | "Implausible" doesn'tt mean "impossible" [317 words] | Ianus | Jul 1, 2011 18:59 | 186555 | |
| Definitions [124 words] | Moshe | Jul 3, 2011 08:08 | 186555 | ||
| 2 | Defintions elucidate things and so help our understanding of them. [536 words] | Ianus | Jul 5, 2011 03:25 | 186555 | |
| Once in the Land by Ezekiel's Reference - Always in the Land - Against All the World's Odds [342 words] | M. Tovey | Jul 5, 2011 19:32 | 186555 | ||
| Let's elucidate something [77 words] | Moshe | Jul 6, 2011 05:20 | 186555 | ||
| Where to Shine the Light of Enlightenment [1239 words] | M. Tovey | Jul 7, 2011 14:00 | 186555 | ||
| Religion???? [82 words] | Moshe | Jul 8, 2011 04:51 | 186555 | ||
| 2 | Let's do it by all means ! [1441 words] | Ianus | Jul 14, 2011 09:44 | 186555 | |
| 2 | Religion [235 words] | Ianus | Jul 14, 2011 10:06 | 186555 | |
| By all means.... [495 words] | Moshe | Jul 17, 2011 08:36 | 186555 | ||
| Israel's Past Laid the Foundation for Its Future - The Coming Theocracy in Messianic Prophecy [9 words] | M. Tovey | Jul 28, 2011 15:53 | 186555 | ||
| The Jebusites [77 words] | ann farmer | Jun 21, 2011 14:47 | 186553 | ||
| 1 | Zionism and Zionists versus wandering Arabs with no place where to go [259 words] | Nenette Grunberg | Jun 21, 2011 14:32 | 186552 | |
| 2 | Well said Dr. Pipes [44 words] | Yoven | Jun 21, 2011 14:20 | 186551 | |
 When did "Palestine" exist? [64 words]w/response from Daniel Pipes | adeline | Jun 21, 2011 12:51 | 186543 | ||
| You can't be a Canaanite and offspring of Ishmael too: you're one or the other [60 words] | Abu Nudnik | Jun 21, 2011 12:03 | 186539 | ||
| Arab fantasies [125 words] | Moshe | Jul 5, 2011 10:27 | 186539 | ||
| There is no evidence of this [55 words] | Abu Nudnik | Jul 11, 2011 21:36 | 186539 | ||
| Arab degradation [63 words] | sara | Jul 12, 2011 17:28 | 186539 | ||
| Not the point, Sara [52 words] | Abu Nudnik | Jul 14, 2011 00:33 | 186539 | ||
| It's All About ISLAM [676 words] | Historyscoper | Jun 21, 2011 10:23 | 186535 | ||
| Stoning of a Dog [16 words] | MarjorieR | Jun 22, 2011 21:42 | 186535 | ||
| 2 | Ben Gurion quote [241 words] | Chris D | Jun 21, 2011 10:21 | 186534 | |
| Nahum Goldman [331 words] | Moshe | Jun 22, 2011 16:53 | 186534 | ||
| Gurion/Goldmann [31 words] | Chris D. | Jun 23, 2011 06:56 | 186534 | ||
| A Secular Israel Will Give Way to A Prophetical Israel [697 words] | M. Tovey | Jul 1, 2011 16:18 | 186534 | ||
| 1 | The Quote of Chris D from Goldmann/Ben-Gurion is PHONY [7 words] | abu afak | Aug 24, 2013 02:03 | 186534 | |
| Ben Gurion quote [270 words] | Yaakov A Sternberg | Jul 20, 2014 17:32 | 186534 | ||
| No Jew has the right to yield the rights of the Jewish People in Israel - David Ben Gurion [213 words] | YJ Draiman | Sep 3, 2017 16:05 | 186534 | ||
| Placing his statement in context [131 words] | Robert F. | Apr 18, 2020 21:41 | 186534 | ||
| Trying to rationalize the irrational [82 words] | Robert F. | Apr 20, 2020 15:10 | 186534 | ||
| "Israelis should hold their heads high . . ." [65 words] | Carl Sesar | Jun 21, 2011 10:20 | 186533 | ||
| Wish it were that simple [188 words] | Dean M. | Jun 21, 2011 10:18 | 186532 | ||
| "when Messiah comes" [100 words] | Moshe | Jun 22, 2011 10:12 | 186532 | ||
| Simplicity of the Promise - Redemption by His Holy WORD [437 words] | M. Tovey | Jun 23, 2011 11:40 | 186532 | ||
| 1 | Forced nomadism and religiosity [281 words] | Ianus | Jun 24, 2011 06:29 | 186532 | |
| Redemption of Israel [158 words] | Dean M. | Jun 25, 2011 01:43 | 186532 | ||
| Moses did not redeem [126 words] | Moshe | Jun 26, 2011 04:39 | 186532 | ||
| I pray you are right [359 words] | Dean M. | Jun 26, 2011 19:44 | 186532 | ||
| Blind ex-slaves [113 words] | Moshe | Jun 29, 2011 10:40 | 186532 | ||
| Gandhi on Israel [113 words] | M.A.Sastry | Jun 21, 2011 10:11 | 186530 | ||
| Gandhi [43 words] | Moshe | Jun 22, 2011 09:52 | 186530 | ||
| holocaust [124 words] | M.A.Sastry | Jun 23, 2011 10:48 | 186530 | ||
| Another view [219 words] | Rebecca Moulds | Jun 21, 2011 10:09 | 186529 | ||
| 2 | Not stealing palestine, but buying Israel [23 words] | Veronique | Jun 21, 2011 09:09 | 186525 | |
| well done [173 words] | John W McGinley | Jun 21, 2011 09:07 | 186524 | ||
| Life-cycles. [37 words] | Naushad Omar | Jun 22, 2011 14:35 | 186524 | ||
| 2 | Islamic drivel [139 words] | dhimmi no more | Jun 23, 2011 06:39 | 186524 | |
| Israel Not About Cycles-But Beginnings and Endings [802 words] | M. Tovey | Jun 23, 2011 16:05 | 186524 | ||
| Educating about Israel [58 words] | John Schwartz | Jun 21, 2011 08:43 | 186522 | ||
| 1 | It's not stealing when you buy the land. [100 words] | Kim Bruce | Jun 21, 2011 08:39 | 186521 | |
| 1 | Aryans did not invade India [64 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Sankar | Jun 21, 2011 08:20 | 186519 | |
| 2 | Aryans also invaded India [110 words] | Purshottam Lal Arya | Jun 22, 2011 06:10 | 186519 | |
| 1 | This is not the place [82 words] | sankar | Jun 23, 2011 01:59 | 186519 | |
| 3 | Aryan Invasion Theory [218 words] | K P Ganesh | Jun 23, 2011 09:53 | 186519 | |
| 4 | Did Aryans invade India? [80 words] | Sagar | Jun 23, 2011 14:19 | 186519 | |
| lets base history on findings not prior leanings [120 words] | venu | Jul 24, 2011 15:23 | 186519 | ||
| 1 | Nation state [37 words] | Bjoern | Jun 21, 2011 08:09 | 186518 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)