69 million page views

RESPONSE TO IRA LEVINE

Reader comment on item: Michael Mukasey: No to Islamic Law in the United States
in response to reader comment: don't forget eruvs

Submitted by DANIEL REDMOND (United States), Oct 29, 2007 at 20:23

I read with interest your comment regarding the placement of eruvs in public areas. For those not familiar with this somewhat comical expression of religious ..., an eruv is, in essence, a calculated attempt by members of the Jewish faith to circumvent a totally unnecessary and silly religious edict regarding leaving their homes on certain days of the week. Here's how it works. If you are an Orthodox Jew you are forbidden to leave your domicile on certain days---every Saturday, I believe, but there may be other days as well---or presumably some punishment will fall upon you.

Now, needless to say, this is a pointless inconvenience that should have been dispensed with by rational people years ago. But since when was religious belief based upon reason? So, finding this inconvenience cumbersome when, let's say, one has run out of groceries and needs a trip to the corner store, the faithful decided to devise a means of avoiding the inconvenience. Enter the eruv. It is nothing but a thin wire that is strung from the home to one utility pole (or other stationary object) after another until it connects with the desired location---let's say, the supermarket where the food is. I know, you're scratching your head and wondering, 'huh'? And this is where it gets really weird. The pretense is that the eruv has now connected the home to the supermarket and that therefore when one leaves the home and walks around the block to buy food, or whatever, that they aren't really leaving their domicile as long as they walk under the wire. Only religion could cause otherwise rational people to create a silly rule and then an even more ridiculous means of getting around it.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (38) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Iran, Relegion, free trade policies, all in a mess not econmics??? [349 words]Firozali A Mulla MBA PhDFeb 17, 2008 02:17120386
One Day freedom But it is a bliss YES SIR I need this type of news [114 words]Firozali A Mulla MBA PhDJan 25, 2008 12:21118967
Islam and selling to them the right way? [196 words]Firozali A Mulla MBA PhDJan 15, 2008 11:44118248
#811: Pipes on "Annapolis Blues" in the Jerusalem Post [95 words]Suren SukhtankarNov 2, 2007 10:44112908
2DO WE HAVE A TRUE "DEMOCRACY" IN AMERICA? [749 words]DANIEL REDMONDNov 3, 2007 10:29112908
Is this democracy? [444 words]Firozali A Mulla MBA PhDJan 15, 2008 23:58112908
Firozali, do not complain [170 words]AngelMar 31, 2009 13:43112908
THE REPUBLIC [83 words]Dennis PattersonFeb 5, 2011 19:29112908
1DO WE HAVE A TRUE "DEMOCRACY" IN AMERICA? [4250 words]---Feb 21, 2011 14:52112908
RATHER LONG-WINDED [43 words]DANIEL REDMONDFeb 21, 2011 18:28112908
Legacy of monotheism [41 words]David W. LincolnOct 28, 2007 04:41112487
Muslim Heretics [1005 words]gary fouseOct 24, 2007 01:01112226
WE SHOULD ALL BE HERETICS [282 words]DANIEL REDMONDOct 25, 2007 22:25112226
Heretics [284 words]gary fouseOct 26, 2007 22:12112226
THE LUNACY OF RELIGION [293 words]DANIEL REDMONDOct 27, 2007 18:41112226
RESPONSE TO MR. FOUSE [459 words]DANIEL REDMONDOct 28, 2007 17:29112226
Heretics [130 words]gary fouseOct 28, 2007 20:45112226
DEAR MR. FOUSE [256 words]DANIEL REDMONDOct 30, 2007 00:39112226
Heretics [15 words]gary fouseOct 30, 2007 20:27112226
YES, MR. FOUSE, CHRISTIANS ARE "NOT INVOLVED" [152 words]DANIEL REDMONDNov 1, 2007 18:45112226
not really.... [290 words]donvanNov 2, 2007 17:01112226
heretics [111 words]gary fouseNov 2, 2007 21:18112226
FOLLOW-UP COMMENTS TO MR. FOUSE [203 words]DANIEL REDMONDNov 4, 2007 07:41112226
REPLY TO DONVAN RE: WE SHOULD ALL BE HERETICS [729 words]DANIEL REDMONDNov 4, 2007 08:39112226
Dismissive [197 words]donvanNov 5, 2007 09:41112226
The HOLY book of Islam is Quran, with Q hard in Queensland [106 words]Firozali A MullaJan 25, 2008 20:10112226
Islamic Law in the United States? [121 words]Firozali A.Mulla MBA PhDOct 23, 2007 05:20112181
Comment on Islamic Law in the United States? [159 words]Firozali A.MullaNov 1, 2007 05:37112181
committee hearings and demonstrations? [61 words]greykangarooOct 23, 2007 01:33112171
Squirm Factor [58 words]AthosOct 21, 2007 18:45112112
Laws of Personal Status [306 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Fred SchlomkaOct 21, 2007 09:58112077
don't forget eruvs [38 words]ira levineOct 21, 2007 17:19112077
RESPONSE TO IRA LEVINE [286 words]DANIEL REDMONDOct 29, 2007 20:23112077
shari'a law at odds with humanity [64 words]Phil GreendOct 20, 2007 10:34111997
and 2 women... [303 words]TajOct 28, 2007 03:49111997
RESPONSE TO MR. PHIL GREEND ON SHARIA LAW [555 words]DANIEL REDMONDOct 31, 2007 03:07111997
THE BROWNBACK / MUKASEY DIALOGUE [253 words]DANIEL REDMONDOct 20, 2007 01:18111989
He who holds the votes, makes the rules [64 words]jennifer solisOct 19, 2007 14:39111932

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)