69 million page views

The real islamic history

Reader comment on item: Predicting a Majority-Muslim Russia
in response to reader comment: history?

Submitted by Yunus Zamakda (United Kingdom), Jul 15, 2009 at 06:11

What history have you read ? . Your history is certainly non authentic so let me enlighten you. During the great islamic era both jews/christians flocked to Islamic dynasties knowing full well that they will be able to participate actively in society without the fear of being persecuted.

If you open your history books my dear friend you will find that Islamic rule in Andalucia Spain clearly epitomised this. Islam is certainly not a government it is much more bigger. It is in fact a guidance for mankind which is devine.

You note that the conquered were charged fees to live in Islamic lands, the exact term you are referring to was called jizya. To clarify this point i would like to note that the percentage paid by non muslim communities was minimal.Moreover muslims also had to contribute via zakat contributions which was in fact based on earning thus in many cases it was alot more. The money which was collected was rather like a welfare state. A safety net for the poor & for those who were in absolute need, also it was distributed for those in need & not based on which religion the vulnerable people belonged to. We all pay taxes dont we ? & we certainly dont have the choice to opt out.

Please compare Islamic conquest to european slavery whereby slaves were forcibly uprooted from their homes in Africa, shackled & placed on slaveships destined for the new world. They were in fact dehumanised & coerced to give up their religion for christianity.Furthermore they were brutally beaten whilst they worked on the plantations.Did they have a choice & who actually benefitted from the huge sums of money made from slavery ? Islam has never pursued such an aggressive approach in its entire history.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (97) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Why Islamic Influences in Russia Matter in the Middle East [157 words]M ToveyJan 2, 2022 15:02277948
Good news: Central Asian Muslims tend to be moderate [189 words]DaveJan 1, 2022 14:22277928
Regarding Muslim Russia: Let us judging Islam with secular standards [359 words]PrashantOct 10, 2019 06:00255317
President Trump's Adversaries, including Establishment Conservative Republicans, Should be "Eating Crow" [73 words]LudvikusDec 20, 2017 12:51241629
6Part of the problem is with the non-Muslims [731 words]PrashantDec 31, 2016 02:43234996
Maybe Putin thinks an undemocratic Russia can always keep Muslims in check [29 words]AnonDec 13, 2015 23:11227045
2Putin Has Moral Values Of A Terrorist Tyrant [113 words]Lujack SkylarkSep 18, 2014 05:03218003
3COMPLACENCY & FOOLISHLY ARROGANT SCHOLARS DESTROY CHRISTIANITY [200 words]Nur el Masih ben HaqSep 16, 2014 14:01217941
It is Written - Search the Scriptures - Obedience to the WORD is Required [591 words]M. ToveySep 19, 2014 17:56217941
1The New Testament speaks against the "Trinity" doctrine [746 words]Michael S.Sep 22, 2014 19:57217941
New Testament Speaks to the Authentication of the Old Testament [217 words]M. ToveySep 23, 2014 15:40217941
Dear Mr. Tovey [107 words]Debanjan BanerjeeOct 4, 2014 00:16217941
Homosexuality in the church [776 words]Michael SFeb 6, 2015 10:10217941
I am sorry [114 words]DebanjanAug 5, 2015 04:27217941
1Allah, the ayatollahs, gays and al-Qada' wa al-qadr (pre-destination) [389 words]dhimmi no moreAug 7, 2015 06:49217941
God bless Israel. The US and Russia are on their own. [327 words]Michael SAug 7, 2015 16:39217941
Smirnov has hit upon something [314 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Michael S.Sep 14, 2014 21:19217884
Religion is not politics. [178 words]Michael S.Sep 19, 2014 02:47217884
Russia Working With Muslims Whom Will Turn On Them [78 words]Lujack SkylarkMar 19, 2014 11:40213882
1The Haunting [63 words]Tom DundeeOct 26, 2013 19:22210988
2Persecution: the way of life [38 words]Michael S.Sep 24, 2014 03:11210988
3Sounds familiar [50 words]JeffOct 14, 2013 13:05210447
4Do anti-Muslim sentiments in Russia really count? [68 words]Meyse KapeyrOct 13, 2013 16:36210431
2Islamization [19 words]steven lOct 21, 2013 18:19210431
You're An Excellent Reporter on Middle-East Affairs [174 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Tom SkylarkOct 9, 2013 11:43210353
Really saddens me [31 words]Diana WellsAug 4, 2012 11:09197663
3the demographic transformation [158 words]ManavAug 27, 2012 04:38197663
21The Myth of Muslim Population Growth in Russia [1208 words]babaMar 7, 2012 13:56194098
all other things being equal [89 words]DougJan 1, 2013 16:09194098
Terrorism and Al-Qaeda obey to Al-Qur'an instructed. [104 words]SunartyAug 21, 2013 00:02194098
Interesting comments [198 words]Kepha HorNov 3, 2013 19:38194098
What are white ethnic groups? [36 words]EdoMay 27, 2018 20:24194098
9So what's wrong with Muslims being a majority? [136 words]TahaOct 26, 2011 19:28190429
3What is wrong in Islamic majority in Russia? [53 words]JoshOct 27, 2011 02:56190429
4What is wrong in Islamic majority in Russia? [116 words]ArnesDec 11, 2011 14:38190429
4Muslims are violent against people like me. This is why I have a problem with Muslims. [56 words]GregSep 11, 2012 02:19190429
What we can learn from survivors [15 words]Januk36Oct 17, 2013 07:29190429
1Clear view from Finnish muslim "convert" [186 words]kaitsu80Oct 17, 2011 11:17190100
6Let us unite. [105 words]Nazneen O. SaherwalaJul 13, 2010 09:27175512
2RE: The "Nashi" youth movement in Russia. [246 words]Mysil BergsprekkenFeb 4, 2010 22:53168480
3DUTCHMAN WITHOUT FEAR OR FAVOUR [295 words]Michelle5publish.Aug 12, 2009 14:18160113
1Islam [55 words]Dan the ManJul 3, 2009 12:38158444
1Maybe I missed it, but... [187 words]Fay VoshellFeb 16, 2009 12:26150583
2Not to get spiritual - but Ezekiel 38 cleary depicts an Islamic invasion of Israel - led by Russia [149 words]RobWFeb 12, 2009 15:03150325
Russian Muslim Army in Ezekiel 38:2-6 [47 words]Lujack SkylarkOct 8, 2013 14:39150325
9Why fear islam ? Islam will unify & liberate Russia [134 words]Yunus ZamakdaJan 27, 2009 06:12149212
history? [68 words]ButtonGreenJul 8, 2009 18:34149212
8The real islamic history [298 words]Yunus ZamakdaJul 15, 2009 06:11149212
4History [132 words]Yunus ZamakdaSep 15, 2009 07:59149212
5answer to mr. button green [383 words]ismael abdul azizOct 25, 2009 04:31149212
2GREAT DECEPTION [70 words]AlexDec 12, 2009 00:14149212
6Alex lets learn to love each other & to live in peace. [191 words]Yunus ZamakdaDec 12, 2009 10:58149212
Slavery in Islam. [38 words]NaliniOct 9, 2013 03:55149212
Consistency of the message [232 words]Sudeep PathakJan 22, 2009 05:05148734
4Islam [118 words]MansoorJan 24, 2009 04:47148734
With Allah's help this religion will spread like wild fire...Hummmmm...Jungle Jehad in Australia [44 words]BabushaFeb 11, 2009 13:29148734
It is a fight for the turf. [359 words]Sudeep PathakFeb 15, 2009 18:30148734
1Islam in Russia [110 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Debanjan BanerjeeDec 25, 2008 13:46145862
1I like russia with muslim majirity [20 words]idris adamDec 10, 2008 08:34144797
2What ...? [81 words]TelldatruthDec 12, 2009 00:24144797
1watch up [110 words]basDec 22, 2009 12:25144797
you are wrong [99 words]idris adamMay 15, 2011 06:58144797
Idris Adam from Nigeria needs to be corrected [136 words]PrashantMay 17, 2011 11:33144797
2Did Muslim forced Islam on anyone? [138 words]SayedMar 16, 2012 15:54144797
Re: Islamic Conversion [137 words]TihorNov 30, 2012 03:46144797
2What is there to worry about [121 words]RizAug 17, 2008 01:02136870
2Truth Religion [38 words]mahadiMay 1, 2008 10:27127348
not religion of peace [53 words]TdubJun 23, 2008 03:53127348
3Don't be fair Islam will bring Peace and prosperity in Russia [60 words]Mohd. Rizwan KhanJan 26, 2008 13:43119033
2Oh, really? [98 words]sd1Mar 31, 2008 13:48119033
arrogant [14 words]D. LennonAug 9, 2008 20:33119033
What? [65 words]AlexDec 12, 2009 00:32119033
Islam's time has past. [87 words]RickOct 11, 2010 11:15119033
2Islam is Truth [95 words]Nazneen O. SaherwalaApr 2, 2013 09:24119033
Wahhabite Russia [45 words]NobodyJan 23, 2008 13:57118830
With a little help from the US and Europe [50 words]Aly aus AegyptenJan 1, 2008 22:31117308
"How the West Could Lose" [130 words]William J. AbbottDec 26, 2006 10:5070598
1allah is great [25 words]muhammad irfan syedApr 25, 2006 13:4444119
1Numbers don't add up [19 words]SadatAug 26, 2006 21:1244119
Not [64 words]KatApr 25, 2007 03:2844119
He he [68 words]KatApr 25, 2007 03:3144119
2Islam is not a religion which says about peace. [119 words]Mohammend YasirDec 3, 2009 07:4444119
Reply to G. Bisvas [78 words]MarkMar 17, 2006 21:5240563
1rate and direction of change are important [305 words]G.BisvasMar 21, 2006 06:1040563
someone should have stopped him. [181 words]KatApr 25, 2007 03:3940563
Disappointing Russia [146 words]MarkMar 17, 2006 13:3040561
what's important: the truth [354 words]mikeNov 1, 2006 08:0440561
1Hinduism and reply to Mike [40 words]Sam JayDec 10, 2006 13:3040561
islam and russia [36 words]kumarMar 4, 2007 12:4940561
conversion,,again ? [83 words]KatApr 25, 2007 03:5140561
1reply to Jay walker [58 words]kimbaMay 4, 2007 05:3140561
5LOL - bunch of scared non-muslims.... [184 words]Abdul-Rehman KhanApr 18, 2008 12:1440561
Hinduism and reply to Sam [58 words]KshamaJan 22, 2009 11:5140561
1Not going anywhere [25 words]Straight_Talk_LuigiFeb 7, 2009 16:5640561
1Stahn in Sanskrit and stan in persian [32 words]dancanMar 7, 2009 09:4740561
Russian Protestants undercounted [60 words]ElamBendMar 17, 2006 13:1940559
Maybe the Russian Evangelicals will face a better future at home [65 words]Kepha HorNov 3, 2013 19:4140559

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)