A reply to Jaladhi

Submitted by Debanjan Banerjee (India), Apr 1, 2010 at 06:02

Hi,

"US gives 2B$ to Israel and not 5B$ a year."

My Answer >>>>> Rhetoric wo'nt do for me , Jaladhi. Show me the actual figures. Bye the bye have you counted those money that men like John Hagee give to Israel ? If you add them then the count goes up to 10B$ probably.

"For that we get a democratic government in the middle east which is friendly to US."

My Answer >>>>> You do not have a friendly govt. in Israel rather what you have a master who are pulling you around. Read Steve Walt , man.

"At the same time US has given Egypt 1B$ a year since the peace accord with Israel( which has totaled more than 20B$ to date) and what have we gotten in return from Egypt. Those ingrate Egyptians still hate us."

My Answer >>>>> The Egyptian people do not hate the US for American values they hate US for supporting that brutal tyrant Mubarak , get it man. You say that you are a democracy in one hand and in the other hand you support tyrants like Mubarak , in the end some people are going to wake up to your hypocracy.

"USA has helped Muslims and so many Islamic countries on this planet and still doing it but do they even acknowledge that help. NOoooo!!! If we count all the aid given by US to Muslim countries, it will far exceed the aid given to Israel!!"

My Answer >>>>> Yes you have helped the Muslims by murdering in cold blood 1 million children in Iraq through economic sanctions from 1990-2003!!!!! Now since 2003 you have killed millions in Iraq in a brutal war. You have interfered in Muslim countries from Iran , Somalia , Afghanistan , Libya and so on from last 50-60 years and you are also responsible for the deaths of innocent Muslims in the so-called surgical strikes from UAV-s.

"Now Pakistan is getting billions per year and already has gotten more than 20B$ or so and what have we gotten in return so far"

MyAnswer >>>>> It seems to me that you do not read newspapers or probably do not have any touch with history. Remember Zia Ul Haq ? This is the Pakistani leader who fought on behalf of US to drove the Soviets out of Afghanistan which enabled you to win the cold war. So next time you brag that you won the cold war remember it was a Pakistani Muslim who won it for your behalf.

Coming to the most recent histroy , Pakistan is the country which has arrested most number of Al-Qaeda or Taliabn millitants and handed them over to the US. Do you know the names of Abu-Jubeida , Ramzi bin al-shibh or Khalid Sheikh Mohammad ? These are the people who were caught by Pakistan and handed over to the US.

Now tell me how many people do Israel has caught so far in the "War on Terrorism" ?

"Lot of the armaments that Pakistan is receiving will to fight against India"

My Answer >>>>> Lots of armaments that US or Israel is offering to India will end up being used against China or Pakistan. So what is the big deal here ?

"It's beyond anybody that as an Indian citizen why would you hate Israel - Israel being a good friend to India."

My Answer >>>>> I believe in Justice and truth. The Israeli state is becoming an apartheidic regime , day by day. Even men like Ehud Barack are acknowledging it. So Please do not blindly support Israeli actions for the sake of Israel.

...

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".