Debanjan Banerjee I have told you there is no need to further demonstrate ...

Submitted by Peter Hall (Australia), Nov 6, 2011 at 20:26

Well Debanjan Banerjee, you really do have a knack of comparing apples to tree frogs don't you?????

There is a big difference to ceremonially cutting someone's throat and cutting out their heart for their Gods, as opposed to individuals, groups or Governments working people to death out of greed. It is sad your lack of moral development limits your thought processes so. They are all wrong, but in different ways!

As to the Holocaust, again I find that your grasp of even your own arguments is astounding ! At least you are one of the Muslims who do admit what happened to the Jews, however can you not see the difference between a Invasion?? One is called a war, one is called genocide.

Now I am glad you brought this up because do you know what model the Germans were acting upon? The Germans wanted to wipe Jews from Europe. They Failed.

How ever, how many Jews are now in Saudi Arabia?

How many are in The UAE?

The Muslims successfully murdered and stole the property of the Jews. Mohammed virually lived off the proceeds of theift and his slave trading.

If this isn't so my poor ignorant Debanjee, where are all the Jews of Medina? and Mecca? Why are there no Jews in Medina and Mecca? There were lots of them at the time of Mohammed ! Answer me?

So will you admit the Holocast of Mohammed in the Arabian Penninsula? And the genocide of the Armenians by the Turks? Or the murder of 90 million Hindus?

Or are you only a finger pointer?

I admit the Catholic Church is responsible for many many evil deeds, and that the German People and the Nazis murdered millions of Jews, that the US Government allowed wholesale slaughter of the American Indians, and that Australia systematically tried to wipe out the Aborigines.

I can admit all that and I can so how each and every one of these institutions have tried to reform and improve. They have admitted guilt and tried to prevent the same from happening again.

However, Jews, even Zionists, do not want to go out and kill Germans for what happened 70 years ago. They want people to remember what happened and for it not to happen again.

However, YOU and most Muslims cannot admit the evil deeds of Islam and Mohammed, because you are in denial. Islam and Muslims will continue to repeat the evils and mistakes of the past because you cannot reform, you cannot admit your mistakes and you are brainwashed into thinking the rest of the world is in denial.

I am not proud of what Christians have done in the past, or the many misdeeds of the US and even my own Government.

However, I am not shocked or ashamed when you bring up past events from the distant and recent past. Do you know why my poor ignorant Debanjee? It is because we, and I use that term collectively, have taken responsibility for the past, we have learnt.

You demonstrate you lack of moral development by not seeing the difference between wars and genocide, between greed of an individuals and Governments and the evil acts done in the name of religion.

You cannot admit or own your own faults, nor the faults in Islam or your Mohammed. All you can do is try and play the victim, and in playing the victim you relegate yourself to not being a equal. but a victim trapped in your own ideology.

Islam was for a few centuries a progressive force in a backward part of the world, but the inability of Islam and Muslims to truly adapt will always be its limitation. Communism was a good idea but did not work well in execution. However Communism did bring about many positive things even though it allowed itself to be continually hijacked but evil dictators. Islam is the same, the same problems that allowed Communism to promote evil men is inherent in Islam. That is why Muslim majority countries have the leaders they do.

The USSR at least did not blame the US for Starlin, but Muslim majority countries always seem to go from one despotic and murderous leader to the next. They either blame the US, or in the past the Bristish or the French. Yet Muslim men never seem to be able to man up and admit there is a problem of their own doing, they always have to find someone to blame.

You are yet another sad and pathetic example of this Debanjee Banerjee. ... And the only reason is YOU DO NOT WANT TO BE, otherwise how can you play the victim???

As long as you remain trapped in you ideological prison, you will always be a self imposed 2nd class citizen. It is easy to remain a failure when that is what you want to be.

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".