Now do not get nasty Slayhy

Submitted by Peter Hall (Australia), Dec 1, 2011 at 21:20

Now Slayhy, try as you might, your evidence really is pathetic.

The only ages ANYBODY gives is her being 6 or 7, and consummated at 9 or 10. NO OTHER AGES ARE GIVEN

Also the year of her death, and the age at her death do not correspond with any of the alternate ages you have given.

Therefore when the only, and I repeat; only ages given are the ones I state, and she was married to the dirty old man for 9 years when he died, and that she was 18 years old when he died, your truly pathetic attempts to hide the truth are laughable.

If these specific ages of married 6/7 consummated at 9/10 married for 9 years and Mohammed died when she was 18, and she died at age 67/68 are not correct, what are they in Muslim Texts. The reliable thing does not wash Slayhy, it you discount everything this guy writes why bother to record it for over 1200 years.. What you are doing is cherry picking the sources to suit the lie you want to tell.

No Islamic texts have EVER given alternate ages for Ayisha. Its only when exposed to Western Values do Muslims like you try and hide the fact he was a paedophile who at 54 has sex with a 9 yo girl..

Only a fool would be convinced by what you use as "evidence" it even confuses you! If what you said was true, your estimates would all arrive at the one alternate age, however, you used various sources and A LOT of guessing, you arrive at a number of alternate ages. Not one alternate age. Therefore your logic is flawed. You are the unreliable one here.

The 3 points which matter is that the ONLY ages cited in any Muslim texts for this poor child all correspond to her being 9 years old when Mohammed raped her.

The second thing is if it was incorrect, why has it been repeated for 1400 years?

The third factor is that you have not been able to provide one source that gives a specific alternate age, NOT ONE.

Saying if A follows B and someone else says they saw B, then maybe C had to leave A and B to get past C to arrive at D just does not wash in the face of numerous Islamic texts all attributing a certain age to this poor rape victim young girl.

You are typical of the average ignorant Muslim male, if you were talking with other Muslim Arab males you would be boasting about how Mohammed raped his wives and slaves every night and how young Ayisha was.

But to Westerners you lie and cry and say, NO WE DO NOT UNDERSTAND. I understand you and your type.

You lie, threaten and assume you are smarter than we westerners and that we will believe the nonsense you come up with.

So do not try and threaten me, I have enough things to laugh at as it is.

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".