| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
reply ...
Reader comment on item: Why Newt Gingrich Was Right about Palestinian History
in response to reader comment: The Roman Destruction of Israel
Submitted by Amin Riaz (United Kingdom), Dec 19, 2011 at 04:52
But Israel was no longer Israel. And the assertion that Muslim took that land by force is false. Yes some Jews have always lived there. Even Arabs claim to be descendants mostly of Jewish tribes.
Most Jews of Arabia have has far more positive experience than European counterparts. Many were HAPPILY taken in Arabs after WW2 - that is why there was no initial uproar against Jews. But the destructive monopoly of Homeland came up afterwards.
Go back into reading the Old Testament. Wasn't the Biblical God promoting genocide of the Canaan. ... ?
Why do some of the most deeply religious end up looking like Same for Islam, Judaism, Christianity, Hinduism and etc.
Dislike
Submitting....
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (91) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Timeline for Progress is As Follows: [110 words] | Dallas | Feb 9, 2012 22:26 | 193259 | ||
| 1 | Newt's campaign [79 words] | sara | Jan 13, 2012 17:19 | 192563 | |
 Speaker Gingrich Understands What's at Issue - And That's the Problem For the Others [366 words] | M. Tovey | Jan 19, 2012 12:31 | 192563 | ||
| Newt seems too volatile and unpredicatble [200 words] | sara | Jan 20, 2012 17:03 | 192563 | ||
| Speaker Gingrich IS Volitile-Isn't That What it Will Take To Get the Government off the Dime; and its duff? [1103 words] | M. Tovey | Jan 23, 2012 12:15 | 192563 | ||
| All good points, Mr. Tovey [271 words] | sara | Jan 23, 2012 19:50 | 192563 | ||
| Points May Be Good For Debate - But Debates Never Solved Problems of Reality [610 words] | M. Tovey | Jan 24, 2012 14:02 | 192563 | ||
| OK--- who then? [59 words] | sara | Jan 24, 2012 21:32 | 192563 | ||
| Florida's Counting That Right Now-Spkr Gingrich's Electability To be Determined by Wall Street's Effectivity [673 words] | M. Tovey | Jan 31, 2012 19:23 | 192563 | ||
| Newt unfortunately buried himself [180 words] | sara | Feb 1, 2012 19:57 | 192563 | ||
| Speaker Gingrich Did Not Bury Himself - He is Finding That There is No Room Left for Gentlemen in Politics [484 words] | M. Tovey | Feb 6, 2012 11:37 | 192563 | ||
| All politicians are the same in the end [222 words] | sara | Feb 6, 2012 16:32 | 192563 | ||
| American Politics Requires a Warrior Political Mentality To Regain True Government [330 words] | M. Tovey | Feb 13, 2012 13:24 | 192563 | ||
| 3 | Israel has rights too [89 words] | steven | Jan 13, 2012 17:16 | 192562 | |
| 2 | History tells the tale [75 words] | sam | Jan 13, 2012 17:11 | 192561 | |
| So tired of this whole farce [21 words] | sargum | Jan 13, 2012 17:08 | 192560 | ||
| 2 | Dr Pipes talk on the Palestinian Myth [43 words] | Rose DeRenzo | Dec 17, 2011 00:37 | 191782 | |
| 11 | No Such thing as a Palestinian [4038 words] | Michael Bussio | Dec 16, 2011 02:25 | 191737 | |
| Thank you! [16 words] | sonny | Dec 16, 2011 17:52 | 191737 | ||
| Denying History. [81 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 16, 2011 19:34 | 191737 | ||
| 2 | Rights of Arab's over various lands [71 words] | Joe | Dec 17, 2011 00:35 | 191737 | |
| 1 | The Roman Destruction of Israel [97 words] | Steven | Dec 17, 2011 23:27 | 191737 | |
| Basic History [36 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 18, 2011 09:19 | 191737 | ||
 reply ... [114 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 19, 2011 04:52 | 191737 | ||
| 2 | same rule for all? [73 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Dec 20, 2011 01:51 | 191737 | |
| Great history [84 words] | Wilks | Dec 20, 2011 12:52 | 191737 | ||
| Right & Might [57 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 20, 2011 19:14 | 191737 | ||
| Palestine was Comprised of More Than an Arabic Presence - and More Than the Current State of Israel [15 words] | M. Tovey | Jan 4, 2012 19:29 | 191737 | ||
| 1 | Muslim Land [121 words] | sara | Jan 10, 2012 18:29 | 191737 | |
| Thanks for this detailed history [13 words] | sam | Jan 10, 2012 18:33 | 191737 | ||
| 8 | What is common between Nigeria and India? [183 words] | Prashant | Jan 11, 2012 02:01 | 191737 | |
| Re-transfering the name Palestinian from Jews to Muslims is... [44 words] | IamJoseph | Dec 15, 2011 23:54 | 191733 | ||
| A question of Evidence [34 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 19, 2011 18:05 | 191733 | ||
| 1 | Evidence. [56 words] | IamJoseph | Dec 19, 2011 21:03 | 191733 | |
| What is Evidence? [37 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 20, 2011 20:11 | 191733 | ||
| 1 | Plenty of evidence from Roman and other historians of the time [968 words] | sara | Dec 20, 2011 20:26 | 191733 | |
| 3 | Stop parading lies with impudence. [167 words] | IamJoseph | Dec 20, 2011 20:32 | 191733 | |
| Where is the lie? Accusing without evidence... [164 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 21, 2011 09:55 | 191733 | ||
| Incorrect factors negating Israel's rights & History as a 4000 year nation. [127 words] | IamJoseph | Dec 21, 2011 19:52 | 191733 | ||
| Laying out an argument [71 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 21, 2011 20:11 | 191733 | ||
| A simple point [47 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 21, 2011 20:30 | 191733 | ||
| 3 | criticism = hatred [322 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Dec 21, 2011 21:24 | 191733 | |
| 1 | A LIE BY OMISSION IS A LIE. [70 words] | IamJoseph | Dec 22, 2011 18:29 | 191733 | |
| 2 | A Simple Point is ----- You have no proof ! [330 words] | sara | Dec 22, 2011 18:31 | 191733 | |
| 1 | quite simple [99 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Dec 22, 2011 19:01 | 191733 | |
| Which proof have you given? [357 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 22, 2011 19:11 | 191733 | ||
| What Prejudice Does to you [97 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 22, 2011 19:17 | 191733 | ||
| Got Cha! Answer for Dhimmi ... [605 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 22, 2011 19:46 | 191733 | ||
| 5 | Blame it on the Soviets [1033 words] | Wallace Edward Brand | Dec 23, 2011 16:38 | 191733 | |
| Objection! [47 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 23, 2011 20:48 | 191733 | ||
| Great historical details! [94 words] | sara | Dec 24, 2011 18:01 | 191733 | ||
| wrong target [180 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Dec 24, 2011 20:38 | 191733 | ||
| 1 | AR Is obviously very handsome! [139 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 25, 2011 20:03 | 191733 | |
| 2 | self-evaluation - rarely accurate [351 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Dec 25, 2011 22:33 | 191733 | |
| A pot calls the kettle black [909 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 26, 2011 20:05 | 191733 | ||
| 2 | a bigger issue goes unaddressed [316 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Dec 26, 2011 21:20 | 191733 | |
| 1 | requested examples [638 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Dec 27, 2011 23:10 | 191733 | |
| Tit for Tat [705 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 28, 2011 17:51 | 191733 | ||
| 1 | questions ignored [283 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Dec 28, 2011 20:06 | 191733 | |
| Dancing [586 words] | Amin Riaz | Dec 29, 2011 19:11 | 191733 | ||
| ... INCAPABLE OF UTTERING A SINGLE TRUTH - THANKS TO TAQIYAH. [152 words] | IamJoseph | Jan 2, 2012 19:54 | 191733 | ||
| Denying the Old Testament? [272 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 4, 2012 18:19 | 191733 | ||
| 4 | beliefs [1005 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Jan 4, 2012 21:11 | 191733 | |
| 2 | To All Muslims, Christians, Jews and Hindu [434 words] | Abdul Rahman | Jan 5, 2012 03:00 | 191733 | |
| Testing theories [193 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 5, 2012 20:13 | 191733 | ||
| Dhimmi DOES NOT know Arabic. [235 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 5, 2012 20:23 | 191733 | ||
| 6 | Let's help Muslims to reprogram their heads [572 words] | Abdul Rahman | Jan 5, 2012 22:00 | 191733 | |
| 2 | 22 ISLAMIC REGIMES ARE ILLEGALLY OCCUPYING LANDS [195 words] | IamJoseph | Jan 6, 2012 01:41 | 191733 | |
| You do tickle me so! [37 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 6, 2012 19:10 | 191733 | ||
| Still Denying Old Testament [151 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 6, 2012 19:11 | 191733 | ||
| 5 | Any spiritual remedy which must be fearfully and angrily defended is no remedy at all. [435 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Jan 6, 2012 20:33 | 191733 | |
| 1 | Dhimmi does not know any Arabic! [304 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 7, 2012 21:20 | 191733 | |
| 1 | ISRAEL IS ARABIA'S MOST HISTORICALLY AND LEGALLY LEGITIMATE COUNTRY. [156 words] | IamJoseph | Jan 8, 2012 00:11 | 191733 | |
| 5 | Amin Riaz ran away from my logic [134 words] | Abdul Rahman | Jan 8, 2012 22:25 | 191733 | |
| Deduction. [58 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 9, 2012 22:50 | 191733 | ||
| Result - showing hand. [119 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 9, 2012 22:57 | 191733 | ||
| 4 | an example please [255 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Jan 10, 2012 19:40 | 191733 | |
| GAZA IS NOT OCCUPIED BUT DISPUTED TERRITORY. [225 words] | IamJoseph | Jan 10, 2012 20:04 | 191733 | ||
| Dhmmi Not even Aware of Basics of Arabic! [279 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 11, 2012 19:28 | 191733 | ||
| 5 | Deduction? [240 words] | Abdul Rahman | Jan 11, 2012 20:27 | 191733 | |
| Answer or go away... [77 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 12, 2012 21:33 | 191733 | ||
| 3 | examples not given [275 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Jan 13, 2012 19:51 | 191733 | |
| 1 | Dhmmi Not even Aware of Basics of Arabic! [245 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 15, 2012 00:48 | 191733 | |
| 6 | acts of omission [962 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Jan 15, 2012 21:24 | 191733 | |
| Old Testament Tells Why Gingrich is More Right - If One Truly Wants to Understand [555 words] | M. Tovey | Jan 17, 2012 13:14 | 191733 | ||
| 1 | Geography [397 words] | Wahine | Jan 20, 2012 22:13 | 191733 | |
| Jews/Israel/Zionists are the savior of Muslims. [429 words] | IamJoseph | Jan 21, 2012 18:31 | 191733 | ||
| Cannot be bothered [17 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 24, 2012 17:54 | 191733 | ||
| Too Bad - Cannot Help You with That [98 words] | M. Tovey | Jan 25, 2012 10:44 | 191733 | ||
| huh? [126 words] | Amin Riaz | Jan 25, 2012 19:17 | 191733 | ||
| The Point No One is Getting - Gingrich will Not Solve the Middle East Land Issue [642 words] | M. Tovey | Jan 27, 2012 14:34 | 191733 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)